Browse Topic: Injury classification

Items (42)
Currently, adult anthropomorphic test devices used in regulatory and consumer information crash testing in the United States are targeted to represent a small female (5th percentile) and an average male (50th percentile). The anthropometry determined previously might not represent the current population, or as investigated in the current study, those that are at least moderately injured during a motor vehicle crash. The objective of this study was to use field data to determine if the current frontal anthropomorphic test devices are representative. Data from the National Automotive Sampling System–Crashworthiness Data System (2010-2015) and Crash Investigation Sampling System (2017–2023) were queried for sex, age, size, and injury information for front seat occupants in frontal crashes. Additional datasets used were from the National Trauma Data Bank and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. According to field data, the most frequently injured female and male is approximately 164 cm tall, weighing 72 kg and approximately 177 cm tall, weighing 81 kg, respectively. The distribution of those injured in frontal crashes aligns with all crash types and the current United States population. Differences between anthropomorphic test device specifications and recent data (particularly weight) should be the focus of future work.
McNeil, ElizabethAtwood, JonathanRudd, RodneyCraig, Matthew
Research Question/Methods The study examined abdominal injuries of 87 belted occupants in CIREN frontal crashes for sex-based differences in abdominal injury patterns. It introduced a more anatomically detailed method for identifying injury locations in an abdominal-pelvic region that includes skeletal structures. The study introduces and applies a novel Abdominal New Injury Severity Score (AbNISS) to address limitations of traditional AIS coding in capturing sex-based differences in injury patterns. The operative reports/EDR/imaging data in CIREN cases enabled identification of sex-specific crash outcomes. The dominant analytical motif is Bertrand Russell’s knowledge by acquaintance and definite descriptions. Results Females had a higher rate of moderate to severe abdominal injuries than males: Only females sustained AIS 5 injuries, lumbar Chance fractures, posterior pelvic arch injuries, and more AIS 2, 3, and 4 injuries, with more injuries in superior-mid, left-superior, and medial-mid-abdominal zones. Males had more in the medial-inferior zone. 13 females had muscle ruptures. Four had combined muscle and Morel–Lavallée injuries, and four had Morel–Lavallée injuries alone. 13 of 14 males had muscle ruptures only. Pelvic morphology: Statistically significant (p < 0.05) sex-based difference in pelvic aspect ratios: Females: 1.37 ± 0.053, with the male ratio of 1.28 ± 0.079. By incorporating anatomical precision and enhanced injury mapping, it supports the development of more representative ATD/human body models. Discussion and Limitations Limitations of the study include its retrospective design, possible inconsistencies in clinical documentation, and challenges in applying AbNISS coding to non-CIREN datasets due to specificity constraints.
Halloway, DaleCurry, WilliamSomasundaram, KarthikPintar, Frank
Background. Road safety is a major public concern, as road traffic accidents result in numerous casualties and significant economic losses. In traffic collisions, the pattern of injuries sustained by drivers often varies depending on various accident factors. The interactions between safety device use, alcohol consumption status, and injury locations can reveal important association patterns and insights. Therefore, we examine patterns in injury locations, accounting for safety device use and alcohol consumption. Method. In this study, we applied two complementary graphical approaches, including multiple correspondence (MCA) analyses and mosaic plots (MPs). Results. The MPs reveal the existence of meaningful patterns between injury location, alcohol consumption, and safety device. Likewise, the MCA reveals that head/neck injuries are more likely to be associated with alcohol impairment. In particular, sober status and safety device used tend to be associated with all injury locations, excepted head/neck injuries. Furthermore, the chi-square statistic with p < 0.05 rejects the null hypothesis ( H 0 ) of non-association between injury location, safety devices, and alcohol consumption factors. By providing concrete evidence and insights, these findings can inspire policymakers and safety device manufacturers to improve the effectiveness of safety devices.
Chen, Ching-FuWa Lukusa, Martin Tshishimbi
Wrap around distance (WAD) is an important index to evaluate the contact position between pedestrian head and vehicle, and is also one of the key parameters of pedestrian accident reconstruction. The purpose of this paper is to explore whether the pedestrian headform testcan reflect the distribution of head injury in the real world. Firstly, in order to study the distribution of pedestrian head WAD in road accidents in China, a head WAD prediction model was established using logistic regression based on pedestrian height and vehicle collision speed. Secondly, in order to study the distribution of the risk of severe head injuries among pedestrians in accidents, the frequency of pedestrian head impact and the proportion of pedestrian head injury were counted respectively for sedans and SUVs. Subsequently, a risk curve for severe head injuries was constructed based on the head impact frequency and the proportion of severe injuries, utilizing a method that incorporates joint probability. Finally, to investigate the relationship between the headform test results and the distribution of severe head injury risks among pedestrians in road traffic accidents in China, a meticulous regional division of the head WAD was conducted based on the vehicle's front structure. A qualitative comparison was made between the distribution of headform test results in that area and the distribution of pedestrian injuries in the real world within that specific region. The results indicate that the location of pedestrian head impacts is primarily concentrated within the range of WAD 1500 mm to WAD 2300 mm. When pedestrians collide with sedans, the peak frequency of head impact occurs at WAD 1900 mm, whereas in collisions with SUVs, this peak occurs at WAD 1700 mm. In the areas of sedan windshields and A-pillars, as well as the rear portion of SUV hoods and windshield wiper regions, pedestrians' heads are most susceptible to severe injuries. It is noteworthy that within the WAD1000-WAD1500 mm range, the risk of severe head injuries for pedestrians is nearly zero. This study, through the analysis of severe head injury distribution among pedestrians in China, assessed the effectiveness and applicability of The China Insurance Automotive Safety Index (C-IASI) headform test. It provides targeted recommendations for the enhancement of the C-IASI pedestrian assessment protocol and offers crucial reference for optimizing the design of vehicle front structures.
Ye, BinLiu, YuLong, YongchengShi, LiangliangXinming, Wan
Boosting Algorithms for the Accident Severity ClassificationSAE-PP-003904/7/2024
Background: Road accident severity estimation is a critical aspect of road safety analysis and traffic management. Accurate severity estimation contributes to the formulation of effective road safety policies. Knowledge of the potential consequences of certain behaviors or conditions can contribute to safer driving practices. Identifying patterns of high-severity accidents allows for targeted improvements in terms of overall road safety. Objective: This study focuses on analyzing road accidents by utilizing real data i.e., US road accidents open database called “CRSS”. It employs advanced machine learning models like Boosting algorithms such as LGBM, XGBoost and CatBoost to predict accident severity classification based on various parameters. The study also aims to contribute to road safety by providing predictive insights for stakeholders, functional safety engineering community and policymakers using KABCO classification systems. The article includes sections covering theoretical methodology, data analysis, model development, evaluation, performance metrics and implications for improving road safety measures by comparing the performance of different Boosting algorithms on the CRSS dataset. Results and Conclusions: This study addresses challenges in evaluating performance metrics for different severity classes within unbalanced datasets, emphasizing the impact of dominant classes like Class O on overall accuracy. The investigation reveals the limitations and conservatism associated with balanced data in boosting models, hinting at a potential ceiling in their performance. Comparative analysis of algorithms, including CatBoost, XGBoost, and LGBM, demonstrates CatBoost’s superiority in various metrics, especially in ROC-AUC and PR-AUC for all severity classes. The study introduces novel metrics, including PR-AUC, for the first time in an accident analysis case study. Future work directions involve extending the application of CatBoost and XGBoost to diverse datasets, exploring the capabilities of deep neural networks, refining dataset preparation for accuracy improvement, and creating unified tools for hazard analysis and risk assessment.
Babaev, IslamMozolin, IgorGarikapati, Divya
A research program has been launched in Iran to develop an evaluation method for comparing the safety performance of vehicles in real-world collisions with crash test results. The goal of this research program is to flag vehicle models whose safety performance in real-world accidents does not match their crash test results. As part of this research program, a metric is needed to evaluate the severity of side impacts in crash tests and real-world accidents. In this work, several vehicle-based metrics were analyzed and calculated for a dataset of more than 500 side impact tests from the NHTSA crash test database. The correlation between the metric values and the dummy injury criteria was studied to find the most appropriate metric with the strongest correlation coefficient values with the dummy injury criteria. Delta-V and a newly created metric T K 200 Y , which is an indicator of the kinetic energy transferred to occupants in a 200 ms time interval and in the lateral direction, were found to be the most appropriate metric for assessing the crash severity of side impacts with strong correlation coefficients with head injury criteria such as HIC36 and HIC15, resultant spinal acceleration, and moderate correlation coefficients with average rib deflection and abdominal forces. Due to the need to calculate the metric based on EDR measurements, T K 200 Y was chosen as the side impact severity metric for the research program.
Sadeghipour, Emad
This study compares statistical models for frontal crash injuries based on delta-v data reported by the vehicle event data recorder (EDR) with injury probability models based on delta-v reconstructed by Crash Investigation Sampling System (CISS) investigators. Injury probabilities and their follow-on use in advanced automatic crash notification (AACN) systems have traditionally been based on delta-v obtained through accident reconstruction of field crashes in the National Automotive Sampling System Crash Data System (NASS-CDS) database. Field delta-v from EDRs in the CISS database is an alternative source of information for crash injury probability modeling. In this study, frontal impact injury risk probabilities computed from EDR and reconstructed delta-v were compared. All data came from the years 2017–2021 of the CISS database, which contains EDR downloads and also reconstructed delta-v using crush measurements and NHTSA’s WinSmash software. On average, CISS reconstructions overestimated delta-v below 16 kph and underestimated delta-v above 16 kph when compared to EDR delta-v. CISS also records detailed injury data using the 2015 Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) developed by the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). Statistical analysis was performed using logistic regression to calculate MAIS 1+, MAIS 2+, MAIS 3+, and ISS 16+ injury probabilities. EDR-derived injury probabilities showed a lower risk for serious injury at delta-v above 48 kph when compared to probabilities based on CISS reconstructed delta-v. AACN algorithms are currently based on reconstructed delta-v but are triggered by EDR delta-v in the field. An analysis performed to determine the effect of the difference between the source of delta-v on the AACN notification threshold showed differences for AACN algorithms trained on EDR delta-v compared to reconstructed delta-v. The results of this study showed that the trigger threshold for AACN notification will differ by delta-v source, and this difference leads to variation in injury prediction.
Watson, Richard A.Bonugli, EnriqueGreenston, Mathew
Sitting Position Contributions to Injury Distributions Among Aviators Involved in Apache Mishaps Between 1990 and 2018.
Johnson, BlakeSous, ShelbyRhodes, DanielleBukowska, MariaGanz, GregoryBrozoski, FrederickMcEntire, Joseph
With growing environmental concerns associated with gas-powered vehicles and busier city streets, micro-mobility modes, including traditional bicycles and new technologies, such as electric scooters (e-scooters), are becoming solutions. In 2018, e-scooter usage overtook other shared micro-mobility modes with over 38 million e-scooter trips taken. Concurrently, the societal concern regarding the safety of these devices is also increasing. To examine the types of injuries associated with e-scooters and bicycles, the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System (NEISS), a probability sample of US hospitals that collects information from emergency room (ER) visits related to consumer products, was utilized. Records from September 2017 to December 2018 were extracted, and those associated with powered scooters were identified. Injury distributions by age, sex, race, treatment, diagnosis, and location on the body were explored. The number of person-trips was obtained to perform a risk analysis. An estimated 17,772 injuries were associated with powered scooters. Nearly 45% of injuries occurred in persons aged 10-29 years. Almost 87% of ER visits consisted of patients being treated and released, whereas nearly 11% were hospitalized (the remaining 2% either received no treatment or the disposition was unknown). Common injuries included contusions/abrasions, fractures, and lacerations. Almost 15% of the injuries associated with powered scooters occurred to the face; the head, ankle, lower leg, and knee were other common body parts injured. An estimated 51 million person-trips were taken during this time period, resulting in an injury rate of 346 injuries/million trips. In comparison, 4.7 billion person-trips were taken on bicycles, resulting in an injury rate of 114 injuries/million trips.
Watson, Heather NGarman, Christina MRWishart, JeffreyZimmermann, Jacqueline
Taking the pedestrian-vehicle accidents in the China in-Depth Accident Study (CIDAS) database as a sample case, 13 accidents morphological parameters were selected from three aspects: human, vehicle and environmental factors, and their depth analysis was carried out to obtain their distribution law through the card. The chi-square test and logistic regression method are used to analyze the correlation between the injury severity of pedestrians and other accidental morphological parameters in pedestrian-vehicle accidents. The results show that there is no significant correlation between gender/season and injury severity of pedestrians. The age of pedestrians and the collision speed is the strongest correlation with injury severity of pedestrians. When a pedestrian is over 65 years old, the pedestrian height is in the range of 160-170cm, the collision speed is greater than 60 kilometers per hour, and the pedestrian speed is greater than 8 kilometers per hour, the probability of pedestrian injury is significantly increased.
Lian, XiaoweiDeng, JiaLi, XudongCui, Fujun
Lower extremities are easily injured in traffic accidents. During pedestrian-vehicle crashes, pedestrian lower extremities are subjected to the influence of combined shear force and bending force, which could bring about ligament tear and bone fracture. According to 2018 China New Car Assessment Program (C-NCAP) pedestrian testing protocol, where the flexible pedestrian legform impactor (FLEX-PLI) is struck from the right lateral by vehicle, the injuries of the ipsilateral side leg are taken into account for assessing the performance of lower extremities. However, the contralateral leg injuries and deformation are neglected in the current testing protocol and the pedestrian walking gaits and the e-bike riding scenario have been little consideration. The purpose of this study is to investigate the injury characteristics of the contralateral lower extremities in pedestrian-vehicle and bicyclist-vehicle crashes. Impact simulations were conducted by the Total Human Model for Safety (THUMS) biomechanical dummy, which the testing vehicle struck the pedestrian of the standing and walking postures as well as the bicyclist at the speed of 40 km/h. The femur, fibula, tibia stress, the stretching ratio of ligaments, and the bending angle of the knee joints for the contralateral side legs were measured. Meanwhile, a comparison of the injuries and motions between the two legs was analyzed. The results show that the walking gait increased the injury risk of long bone fracture and ligation rupture, and the e-bike riding posture enlarged the injury risk of long bone fracture and reduced the ligation stretching ratio compared the standing case. Moreover, the stretching ratio of the contralateral LCL was larger than that of the ipsilateral MCL for all scenarios.
Chen, ChaoFang, Ruiwang, Longliang
Injury distributions of belted drivers in 1998-2013 model-year light passenger cars/trucks in various types of real-world frontal crashes were studied. The basis of the analysis was field data from the National Automotive Sampling System (NASS). The studied variables were injury severity (n=2), occupant body region (n=8), and crash type (n=8). The two levels of injury were moderate-to-fatal (AIS2+) and serious-to-fatal (AIS3+). The eight body regions ranged from head/face to foot/ankle. The eight crash types were based on a previously-published Frontal Impact Taxonomy (FIT). The results of the study provided insights into the field data. For example, for the AIS2+ upper-body-injured drivers, (a) head and chest injury yield similar contributions, and (b) about 60% of all the upper-body injured drivers were from the combination of the Full-Engagement and Offset crashes. For the AIS2+ lower-body-injured drivers, (a) knee/thigh/hip and foot/ankle injury yield similar contributions, and (b) about 60% of all lower-body-injured drivers were from the combination of the Full-Engagement and Offset crashes. This analysis may help engineers inform their assessments of candidate countermeasures (e.g., quantification of real-world weighting factors for related optimization studies). Moreover, the analysis may help provide context for regulatory and public-domain considerations - both existing and proposed.
Laituri, Tony R.Henry, ScottSullivan, Kaye
Globally, road traffic crashes kill about 1.24 million people each year. Pedestrians constitute 22% of all road deaths, and in some countries this is as high as 60%. The capacity to respond to pedestrian safety is an important component of efforts to prevent road traffic injuries. Pedestrian collisions, like other road traffic crashes, should not be accepted as inevitable because they are, in fact, both predictable and preventable. Examination of pedestrian injury distribution reveals that given an impact speed, the probability of fatal injuries is substantially greater when the striking vehicle is a pick-up rather than a passenger car. Given their utility areas, pickup vehicles require negotiating rough terrains and are therefore engineered with higher ground clearance and larger approach angle. The challenge is to optimize these design parameters and also style the vehicle for pedestrian safety while maintaining a low design cost at the same time. This document presents methodology and a set of solutions to meet pedestrian impact safety for pickup vehicles as per the guidelines recommended by Regulation (EC) No 78/2009, of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 January, 2009. Pedestrian lower leg simulation is performed on LS DYNA with an Impactor propelled at a speed of 40Km/h towards the front end of the pickup vehicle. Head injury risk is assessed separately for adults and for children by identifying Head Impact Zones for both in CAD software CAVA CATIA. Head impact simulation is then performed in the relevant parts of the bonnet top area using LS DYNA software. The results thus obtained are used to optimize vehicle's front end to meet pedestrian safety requirements.
Pathak, Amit KamalakarRajke, MayurMadiyan, Anupama
Three years of data from the Large Truck Crash Causation Study (LTCCS) were analyzed to identify accidents involving heavy trucks (GVWR >10,000 lbs.). Risk of rollover and ejection was determined as well as belt usage rates. Risk of ejection was also analyzed based on rollover status and belt use. The Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) was used as an injury rating system for the involved vehicle occupants. These data were further analyzed to determine injury distribution based on factors such as crash type, ejection, and restraint system use. The maximum AIS score (MAIS) was analyzed and each body region (head, face, spine, thorax, abdomen, upper extremity, and lower extremity) was considered for an AIS score of three or greater (AIS 3+). The majority of heavy truck occupants in this study were belted (71%), only 2.5% of occupants were completely or partially ejected, and 28% experienced a rollover event. In the analyzed data set, none of the belted occupants experienced a complete ejection while 4.4% of unbelted occupants did experience a complete ejection. There was a higher, but not statistically significant, risk of complete and of partial ejection for occupants of heavy trucks that experienced a rollover than for occupants of heavy trucks that did not experience a rollover. An MAIS score of one or two (minor or moderate injury, respectively) accounted for 85% of the injuries to the heavy truck occupants. The MAIS score shifted towards greater injury severity in the cases of rollover, ejection, and unbelted occupants. The head, thorax, and lower extremities contained the highest percentages of AIS 3+ injuries. The head was the most commonly injured body region of ejected occupants, while injuries of belted occupants were most commonly found to the thorax.
Zabala, Michael E.Yang, NicholasImler, StacyZhao, KeRay, Rose
Road traffic accidents are major cause of fatalities and losing property. In many big cities, many common fatal accidents are involved buses and pedestrians. In order to increase safety for pedestrians, it is necessary to understand pedestrian-vehicle collisions and injury mechanisms. Injury characteristics and mechanisms depend on post-crash kinematics. It is obvious that post-crash kinematics resulting from passenger car-pedestrian crash is much different from bus-pedestrian crash. Bus-pedestrian collision study can be done through costly full scale crash tests. An alternative approach to these actual tests is finite element simulations which have been widely employed for vehicle components design and optimisation. This paper has addressed the development of bus-to-pedestrian collision finite element model. The model has been used to study influences of impact speed and impact angle on post-crash kinematics and injury mechanisms of a pedestrian. Relations between the injury risk, the impact speeds and the impact angles have been discussed. The analysis information will assist better design of the bus front structure.
Charoenthong, SujeepaphaCarmai, Julaluk
An overview NASS study of US frontal crashes was performed to investigate crash involvement, driver injury distributions and rates in airbag equipped vehicles by vehicle class and structural engagement. Frontal crash bins were based on taxonomy of structural engagement, i.e., Full Engagement, Offset, Between Rails and Corner impact crashes. A new classification of Corner impacts included frontal small overlap impacts with side damage as coded by NASS CDS. Belted drivers of two age groups, between 16 and 50 and over 50 years old, were considered. Vehicles were grouped into light and heavy passenger cars and lights trucks, and vans. A method to identify and address overly influential NASS weights was developed based on considerations of weighting factor statistics. The new taxonomy, with an expanded definition of corner impacts, allowed a more comprehensive classification of frontal crash modes. Results highlight the need to address upper extremities injuries and to better address lower extremities injuries for both the younger and older drivers. For all body regions studied, the vast majority of all serious and moderate injuries occurred in Full Engagement and Offset crash modes for both the younger and older drivers. Corner impacts, which have been the focus of recent research and testing programs, are the smallest contributors to serious and moderate injuries in frontal crashes. Greater opportunities to mitigate injuries in frontal crashes for vehicles have been shown to exist in lower speed full frontal and offset crash modes.
Samaha, Randa RadwanPrasad, PriyaNix, Lilly
An updated evaluation of the effects on predicted injuries of an example crush protective device (CPD) proposed for application to All-Terrain Vehicles (ATVs) is described. As in previous evaluations, this involved extending and applying the test and analysis methods defined in ISO 13232 (2005) for motorcycle impacts, to evaluate the effects of the example CPD in a sample of simulated ATV overturn events. Updated modeling refinements included lowering the energy levels of the simulated overturn events; accounting for potential mechanical/ traumatic (compressive) asphyxia mechanisms; refining and calibrating the force-deflection characteristics of helmet, head, legs and soil so as to reduce potential over-prediction of head and leg injuries; and calibrating the simulation against aggregated injury distributions from actual accidents. Approximately 3,080 computer simulations were run, and the results indicated that, for the simulation sample and in comparison to the helmeted baseline ATV, addition of the example CPD created injury and fatality risks that were greater than its injury and fatality benefits. This study also confirmed results of other research indicating that helmet wearing has substantial net injury benefits, and a low risk/benefit percentage, confirming the importance, effectiveness and low additional injury risk of helmet wearing.
Zellner, John W.Kebschull, Scott A.Van Auken, R. Michael
Lumbar Injury BiomechanicsPT-1538/1/2013
The amount of load that can be borne by the different components of the lumbar region is fairly well understood, as are resulting injuries from overloading. Less severe lumbar injuries involve a wide range of factors, including: heredity, obesity, age, occupation, sports, cardiovascular risk factors, and depression. Some of the most painful conditions that require high levels of care involve lumbar spine fracture or soft tissue injury from falls, contact sports, vehicle collisions, aircraft ejection, and underbody blasts from roadway explosions (military injuries). Each of these injury scenarios elicits a different kinematic response of the spine as a result of load direction, magnitude, and duration. Updated from a popular earlier volume, this new compendium includes landmark papers from 1994 through 2013 that focus exclusively on lumbar injuries. It also features an introductory chapter, “Blunt Lumbar Trauma” that provides an overview of the anatomy of the lumbar region, injury, and injury mechanisms, as well as an extensive literature update. This edition is the third in a series of biomechanics compendia edited by Mr. Pike. Earlier editions covered injuries of the neck and head. For this volume, Mr. Pike and the advisory panel selected 15 of the best papers from a variety of sources including SAE International, IRCOBI, Stapp, NHTSA, ESV, and the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine. The book will be helpful to those studying lumbar injury from a broad range of causes, including transportation, falls, sports, personal violence, and blast-related. Professionals from a variety of disciplines will find the book useful: biomechanics, accident reconstruction, medical and rehabilitation, insurance, legal, and law enforcement.
Pike, Jeffrey A.
Biomechanical Response of the Pediatric Abdomen, Part 2: Injuries and Their Correlation with Engineering Parameters2008-22-000611/3/2008
This paper describes the injuries generated during dynamic belt loading to a porcine model of the 6-year-old human abdomen, and correlates injury outcomes with measurable parameters. The test fixture produced transverse, dynamic belt loading on the abdomen of 47 immediately post-mortem juvenile swine at two locations (upper/lower), with penetration magnitudes ranging from 23% – 65% of the undeformed abdominal depth, with and without muscle tensing, and over a belt penetration rate range of 2.9 m/s – 7.8 m/s. All thoracoabdominal injuries were documented in detail and then coded according to the Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS). Observed injuries ranged from AIS 1 to AIS 4. The injury distribution matched well the pattern of injuries observed in a large sample of children exposed to seatbelt loading in the field, with most of the injuries in the lower abdomen. Univariate and multiple regression models were used to assess mechanical predictors as injury criteria for maximum AIS 2+ and 3+ outcomes, including peak belt tension and posterior reaction force, abdominal penetration, penetration rate, the viscous criterion, and a newly proposed criterion, ḞCmax, which is the maximum of the instantaneous product of loading rate and normalized penetration. The Goodman-Kruskal Gamma (γ) was used to assess each parameter’s ability to discriminate between injurious and non-injurious tests. Injury risk functions were generated for both outcomes by fitting a 2-parameter Weibull distribution to the injury data using survival analysis. The best discriminators were peak belt tension (γ=0.86 and 0.83, p<0.01), the work done by the deforming thorax (γ=0.86 and 0.74, p<0.01), and abdominal penetration (γ=0.89 and 0.66, p≤0.02). Penetration rate was not a good discriminator (γ=0.34 and 0.52), and the consideration of penetration rate decreased the discrimination of the viscous criterion (γ=0.67 and 0.58) relative to penetration alone. ḞCmax was a better discriminator of injury than the viscous criterion (γ=0.70 and 0.76, p<0.01), indicating that the loading rate may be more related to injury outcome than the penetration rate.
Kent, RichardStacey, StephenKindig, MatthewWoods, WilliamEvans, JayRouhana, Stephen W.Higuchi, KazuoTanji, HiromasaLawrence, Schuyler St.Arbogast, Kristy B.
Influence of Vehicle Body Type on Pedestrian Injury Distribution2005-01-18764/11/2005
Pedestrian impact protection has been a growing area of research over the past twenty or more years. The results from many studies have shown the importance of providing protection to vulnerable road users as a means of reducing roadway fatalities. Most of this research has focused on the vehicle fleet as a whole in datasets that are dominated by passenger cars (cars). Historically, the influence of vehicle body type on injury distribution patterns for pedestrians has not been a primary research focus. In this study we used the Pedestrian Crash Data Study (PCDS) database of detailed pedestrian crash investigations to identify how injury patterns differ for pedestrians struck by light trucks, vans, and sport utility vehicles (LTVs) from those struck by cars. AIS 2+ and 3+ injuries for each segment of vehicles were mapped back to both the body region of the pedestrian injured and the vehicle source linked to that injury in the PCDS database. The findings indicate that the head is the most frequently injured body region for both vehicle segments, but the lower extremity is second for cars, whereas the torso is second for LTVs. Mapping the injuries back to the vehicles we find that the most frequent sources of injury for cars are the windshield and bumper, while for the LTVs it is the hood and hood leading edge.
Longhitano, DouglasHenary, BasemBhalla, KaviIvarsson, JohanCrandall, Jeff
Below Knee Impact Responses using Cadaveric Specimens2004-22-000411/1/2004
Knee injuries represent about 10% of all injuries suffered during car crashes. Efforts to assess the injury risk to the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) have been based on a study available in the literature (Viano et al., 1978), in which only two of the five knees tested had PCL ruptures. The aims of the current study were to repeat the study with a higher number of samples, study the effects of other soft tissues on knee response, and assess the adequacy of the experimental setup for the identification of a PCL tolerance. A total of 14 knees were tested using a high-speed materials testing machine. Eight were intact knees (with the patella and all the muscular and ligamentous structures), three were PCL-only knees (patella and all the muscular and ligamentous structures other than the PCL removed), and the last three were PCL-only knees with the tibia protected from bending fracture. Of the eight intact knees tested, only one had PCL mid substance rupture, one had a partial articular fracture of the tibia below the plateau, and six had simple transverse fracture of the tibial metaphysis. Of the three PCL-only knees without tibial protection, one had PCL mid substance rupture, one had avulsion at the posterior intercondylar attachment point, and the last one had a simple oblique fracture of the tibial metaphysis. Of the three PCL only knees with tibia protection, two had PCL mid-substance ruptures and the third one had an avulsion at the tibial insertion site with partial articular fracture of the lateral plateau. Overall, the results of the current study were similar to those observed by Viano et al. (1978). The average displacement at failure for all PCL related injuries was 17.2±2.8 mm for the current study (n=6) and 16.2±3.9 mm for Viano et al. (1978) (n=4). This value is higher than the Injury Assessment Reference Value of 15 mm proposed by Mertz (1984) and used in various regulations. Both studies suggest that the existence of the soft tissues other than the PCL affect the injury outcome and that the intact knee would suffer predominantly tibial metaphyseal fractures possibly due to bending. Consequently, it is concluded that the current experimental setup can produce isolated PCL injuries but the data available are inadequate to characterize PCL tolerance. A Hybrid III knee equipped with a ball bearing knee slider was also tested using a pendulum setup. Apart from the initial higher stiffness, the overall response of this knee lies within the force-deflection corridors defined using the response of the cadaver knees with PCL mid-substance failure.
Balasubramanian, SriramBeillas, PhilippeBelwadi, AdityaHardy, Warren N.Yang, King H.King, Albert I.Masuda, Mitsutoshi
US and UK Field Rollover Characteristics2001-01-01673/5/2001
In this study, US and UK accident data were analyzed to identify parameters that may influence rollover propensity to analyze driver injury rate. The US data was obtained from the weighted National Automotive Sampling System (NASS-CDS), calendar years 1992 to 1996. The UK pre-roll data was obtained from the national STATS 19 database for 1996, while the injury information was collected from the Co-operative Crash Injury Study (CCIS) database. In the US and UK databases, rollovers accounted for about 10% of all crashes with known crash directions. In the US and UK databases, most rollovers occurred when the vehicle was either going straight ahead or turning. The propensity for a rollover was more than 3 times higher when going around a bend than a non-rollover. In the UK, 74% of rollovers occurred on clear days with no high winds and 14% on rainy days with no high winds. In the US, 83% of rollovers took place in non-adverse weather conditions and 10% with rain. In the US and the UK, more than 50% of rollovers happened during daylight. However, compared with non-rollover incidents, US and UK rollovers had a higher propensity to occur with sleet/fog or snow and in the dark without streetlights. In the UK, 76% of rollovers took place on roads with a speed limit of 50 mph (80 kph) and above, while in the US, the rate was 51%. In the US, drivers were most often distracted by people inside and outside their vehicle or when eating and/or drinking, and falling asleep. The results indicate that pre-rollover characteristics are somewhat similar in the US and in the UK. Rollovers were more likely to occur with sleet/fog or snow and in the dark than non-rollover crashes. Vehicles that were traveling straight on a highway or going around a curve were most likely to roll. In this study, the overall injury distribution was similar in US and UK drivers. For belted and unbelted drivers, serious injuries were most frequent in the head and in the thorax, emphasizing the need to provide protection in both these areas. The pre-rollover and injury information obtained in this study may thus be useful for the development of global preventive measures.
Parenteau, ChantalThomas, PeteLenarda, James
In this study, U.S. accident data was analyzed to determine interior contacts and injuries for front-seated occupants in rollovers. The injury distribution for belted and unbelted, non-ejected drivers and right front passengers (RFP) was assessed for single-event accidents where the leading side of the vehicle rollover was either on the driver or passenger door. Drivers in a roll-left and RFP in roll-right rollovers were defined as near-side occupants, while drivers in roll-right and RFP in roll-left rollovers were defined as far-side occupants. Serious injuries (AIS 3+) were most common to the head and thorax for both the near and far-side occupants. However, serious spinal injuries were more frequent for the far-side occupants, where the source was most often coded as roof, windshield and interior. Based on the injury sources for both situations, head injuries seem to occur from contact with the roof, windshield (in particular for unbelted occupants) and pillars, while thoracic injuries resulted from contact with steering assembly and the interior. The field injury data was compared with the Hybrid III responses obtained from simulated mathematical rollovers to better understand occupant kinematics and injury biomechanics. These simulations were validated using laboratory tests. The laboratory tests included the FMVSS 208 dolly rollover, the ADAC corkscrew, curb and soil-trips, bounce-overs and fall-overs. Based on the mathematical simulations, the kinematics of the front far-side occupant differed from that of the near-side. For the belted far-side occupant, the torso often slipped out of the belt which allows excursion towards the near-side occupant. For the belted near-side occupant, the shoulder belt remained on the upper body during the initial roll phase. The occupant nonetheless moved up and outwards and the head could contact the roof-rail and header areas depending on the rollover condition simulated. The near-side occupant's head crossed the window plane more frequently than the head of the far-side occupant. Dummy kinematics from the simulation help explain the frequency of serious head and thorax injuries reported in the field. Field data analysis and mathematical simulations are useful in understanding injury biomechanics and providing guidance for future testing.
Parenteau, ChantalGopal, MadanaViano, David C.
Shoulder Response Characteristics and Injury Due to Lateral Glenohumeral Joint Impacts2000-01-SC1811/1/2000
The objective of this study was to determine response characteristics and injury of the shoulder due to lateral impacts. The need for this data was heightened in the 1990s with increasing interest in harmonization of side impact standards, and questions regarding the measurement capabilities of dummies used in evaluating side impacts. A pneumatic impacting ram was employed in carrying out twenty-two lateral impacts to eleven unembalmed human cadavers at the level of the glenohumeral joint. Velocity of the ram at the time of impact was varied throughout the impacts from 3.5 to 7.0 m/sec, in an attempt to determine injury threshold. The cadavers were instrumented with tri-axial accelerometer blocks at ten locations in the shoulder region. Bony structures instrumented included the sternum, the first thoracic vertebra (T1), clavicles and scapulae. Output from the accelerometers was utilized to calculate impact forces and to examine the movement of the instrumented structures. Photographic target pins were inserted into the accelerometer blocks, thus permitting image analysis of the shoulder girdle displacement. Autopsies, radiographs, and magnetic resonance images (MRIs) were performed to document trauma that occurred as a result of the impact to the shoulder. Clavicles from the cadavers were subjected to bone density scans and three-point bending tests. Results from these evaluations were used to assess and compare properties of bones of the upper extremities. Observations from autopsy, MRI, and radiography have shown looseness of the sternoclavicular joint and fracture of the distal clavicle to be the most common injuries. Significant findings include normalized shoulder force-deflection curves and probability of injury distribution.
Bolte, John H.Hines, Margaret H.
The Dynamic Responses of the Cervical Spine: Buckling, End Conditions, and Tolerance in Compressive Impacts97334411/12/1997
This study explores the dynamics of head and cervical spine impact with the specific goals of determining the effects of head inertia and impact surface on injury risk. Head impact experiments were performed using unembalmed head and neck specimens from 22 cadavers. These included impacts onto compliant and a rigid surfaces with the surface oriented to produce both flexion and extension attitudes. Tests were conducted using a drop track system to produce impact velocities on the order of 3.2 m/s. Multiaxis transduction recorded the head impact forces, head accelerations, and the reactions at T1. The tests were also imaged at 1000 frames/sec. Injuries occurred 2 to 30 msec following head impact and prior to significant head motion. Head motions were not found to correlate with injury classification. Decoupling was observed between the head and T1, resulting in a lag in the force histories. Cervical spine loading due to head rebound constituted up to 54±16 percent of the total axial neck load for padded impacts and up to 38±30 percent for the rigid impacts. Dynamic buckling was also observed; including first order modes and transient higher order modes which shifted the structure from a primarily compressive mode of deformation to various bending modes. The average load at failure was 2243±572 N for males and 1061 ± 273 N for females. The difference between male and female tolerance was significant p = 0.0015). Impacts onto the padded surfaces produced significantly larger neck impulses (p = 0.00023) and a significantly greater frequency of cervical spine injuries than rigid impacts (p = 0.043). The impact angle was also correlated with injury risk (p < 0.00001). These experiments demonstrate that in the absence of head pocketing, the head mass can provide sufficient constraint to cause cervical spine injury. The buckling modes illustrate the kinematic complexity of cervical spine dynamics and may explain why injuries can occur at different vertebral levels and with widely varying mechanism in compressive head impacts. These experiments also suggest that highly deformable padded contact surfaces should be employed carefully in environments where there is the risk for cervical spine injury; however, the orientation of the head, neck, and torso relative to the impact surface is of greater significance.
Nightingale, Roger W.McElhaney, James H.Camacho, Daniel L.Kleinberger, MichaelWinkelstein, Beth A.Myers, Barry S.
A Study of Motor Vehicle Accidents Involving Children96243611/1/1996
This study utilizes a unique database that allows for the calculation of the correlation of injuries to child passengers involved in motor vehicle accidents with the restraint system and the accident characteristics. The database contains 4600 records of accidents involving children age 12 and under that occurred in 13 counties in western New York State during 1991 and 1992. Injured subjects and non-injured subjects were selected from data provided by the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles identifying reported accidents involving the target population in the time period and geographical area defined. The data sources included police accident reports, emergency medical team reports, hospital records and contact with the parents of children who were in child restraints. In child restraint cases, the type of child restraint in use is identified and misuse or equipment failure is noted. Injuries to child occupants are presented in Maximum Abbreviated Injury Scale (MAIS) and Injury Severity Score (ISS) formats, with each specific injury assigned Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS90) and International Classification of Diseases (ICD9) identifiers. Data presented include descriptive statistics concerning accident configurations and occupant and injury characteristics; no statistical comparisons are made. Analyses indicate that the risk of injury in this study is 58% for unrestrained children, 30% for children restrained by adult systems and 16% for those in properly used child restraints. The most severe injures to children in properly used child restraints included five children (2%) who sustained MAIS=3 injuries. MAIS ≥ 3 injuries were reported to 25 unrestrained children (6.5%, including 7 fatalities) and 13 children in adult restraints (2%, including 2 fatalities).
Walsh, Michael J.Kelleher-Walsh, BarbaraMcCullough, Catherine
Comparison of Occupant Restraints Based on Injury-Producing Contact Rates94221911/1/1994
The objective of this analysis is to evaluate the effectiveness of restraints in preventing injury-producing contacts of specific body regions, such as the head or chest, with specific interior components. In order to make comparisons by restraint use, an injury rate is calculated as the number of injury-producing contacts per hundred involved occupants. Data, including the Occupant Injury Classification (OIC), are from the 1988-92 National Accident Sampling System (NASS) Crashworthiness Data System (CDS). The analysis presented is limited to passenger vehicle drivers in towaway, frontal impacts. Injury-producing contact rates are compared for four restraint configurations: unrestrained, three-point belted, driver airbag alone, and driver airbag plus three-point belt. For each restraint configuration, contact rates are compared by three categories of injury severity, AIS 1, AIS 2, and AIS 3-6, body region injured, and contact area producing the injury. The three-point belt provides substantial reductions in driver injury rates for head/face and torso contacts with the glazing, pillar/rails, and steering assembly. The addition of the driver airbag to the three-point belt appears to offer further reductions in these injury rates. The driver airbag alone did not show similar reductions, although sample size was very limited. Also, the injury rate for airbag contacts is more than three times the rate for belt contacts. The effects of occupant age, gender, and stature are identified as areas for further study.
Blower, DanielCampbell, Kenneth L.
Safety Performance of Rear Seat Occupant Restraint Systems92252411/1/1992
Research was undertaken to determine the effectiveness of rear-seat outboard occupant restraint systems in passenger cars, focusing on the overall efficacy of two-point rear-seat occupant restraint systems and comparing the relative performance of two-and three-point rear-seat occupant restraint systems. While a significant body of literature exists comparing the safety performance of various types of front-seat occupant restraint systems, very little comprehensive accident data analysis (i.e., using large volumes of data) has been conducted to date comparing the safety performance of rear-seat occupant restraint systems. For the study, the motor vehicle accident databases from five states were examined to determine the reduction in rear-seat occupant injuries associated with two-point and three-point rear-seat occupant restraint systems. Confounding factors such as accident type and rear-seat occupant age were examined to identify differences between front-seat and rear-seat environments. The National Accident Sampling System (NASS) was also examined, to determine the injury distribution of occupants and belted occupants in front and rear seats. Two independent analysis approaches were used to assess the overall safety performance of rear-seat occupant restraint systems. Neither approach showed a measurable difference between the safety performance of two-point and three-point rear-seat occupant restraint systems.
Padmanaban, JeyaRay, Rose M.
The Role of Skull Fractures in Short Duration Head Impacts8703212/23/1987
Head injuries are considered a significant safety problem for vehicle occupants involved in vehicle crashes. Although medical literature on the subject is extensive, the emphasis is mainly on the clinical and studies frequently involve data samples that are not representative to the vehicle occupant population. Also, research efforts on head injury have focused on the head rotational acceleration mechanism. The effect of head contact on brain injuries has not been adequately acknowledged and there has been disagreement regarding skull fracture and its relationship to brain injury. The human head, being an extremely complex structure, has many independent injury modes which cannot be described satisfactorily by a single brain injury mechanism. Many individual pathophysiological disturbances to the skull and its contents together comprise head injuries. Perhaps, a more practical method to study head injury problems is to divide prevailing occupant head injuries into subgroups having the same common injury characteristics and then study the individual problem based on impact dynamic theory. Head impacts with A-pillar/roof rail components may be a subgroup in the short duration impact category. A scientific study of the occupant head injury problem shows that skull fractures are a good indicator of severe brain injury for certain types of head impact. In many cases, skull fractures are directly or partly associated with severe and fatal brain injuries.
Fan, William R. S.
Accident and Injury Characteristics in Side-Collisions and Protection Criteria in Respect of Belted Occupants7709182/1/1977
In recent years recognition has been made of the important problem of car side collisions and some basic works concerning accident and injury characteristics have been published. In spite of this the relation between car damage and resulting injuries is not yet known to complete satisfaction. The injury criteria of belted occupants in particular, have until now only been known side collisions from individual cases. In this report the importance of side impacts is shown. The methodology of HUK-accident characteristics is presented. The accident characteristics as to impact area and intension type are analysed and related to the resultant occupant injuries on the basis of side collisions involving of 1.811 passenger cars with 3.064 unbelted occupants. Furthermore the significance of side collision involving passenger cars with other cars, trucks and objects and their proportion to all side collisions with serious/fatal injuries is indicated, showing priorities of safety requirements. The injury criteria of belted occupants were investigated on the basis of 163 collisions with car side damage involving 238 belted drivers and front seat passengers. The injuries of the belted occupants are discussed and the trends compared with injuries to unbelted occupants. Typical lesions to the different body areas and the influence the belt has on injuries to impact/opposite side passengers are indicated. Safety criteria concerning the structure and car interior characteristics and belt effectiveness in side impacts are discussed.
Danner, J. Maximilian
The Primate as a Model for Crash Injury7511752/1/1975
In this investigation, a number of anesthetized rhesus monkeys, baboons, and chimpanzees were subjected to a +Gz rectangular deceleration-time history. The parameters of deceleration versus average time duration were plotted as a function of spinal trauma to come up with a series of sensitivity curves based on spinal injury for three families of sub-human primates. The locus, distribution, type, and severity of vertebral body fracture was distinguished on post-impact roentgenographs. The primates were euthanized and the process of documenting and interpreting spinal trauma was repeated following necropsy and water maceration of the soft tissue. The mechanics of vertebral injury were identified. Normal skeletal geometry and proportionate torso kinesiology of the rhesus monkey, baboon, and chimpanzee and man were compared. The peculiarities and consistencies in injury distribution and their variations were interpreted in terms of distinctive vertebral morphology and functional kinesiology of each animal model. The distinguishing variations in injury patterns and their distribution was related to the scatter of human vertebral injury as reported in aircraft escape system accelerations, crash decelerations, and clinical statistics. THIS PAPER DEALS WITH spinal injury due to abrupt +Gz decelerative forces. Its purpose is to comparatively describe the biomechanical torso skeletal response of the rhesus monkey, baboon, and chimpanzee to a rectangular deceleration-time history in an attempt to establish a basis for a whole body interspecies scaling relationship among primates*. More specifically, this paper deals with the type, locus, and distribution of spinal injury as related to the vertebral bodies. It provides additional understanding and knowledge as to the comparative nature of torso skeletal geometry, kinesiology, and spinal injury among primates. These results are compared to human spinal column morphology, injury modes, severity and levels. The overall goal of this effort is to come up with a rational basis for using subhuman primates as a model to explain and predict human injury in biodynamic environments.
Kazarian, Leon E.
A comparative analysis of detailed road crash data from four different environments is presented. Three of the studies were on-scene investigations of crashes from Adelaide, Australia; Birmingham, and Worcestershire, England. The fourth set of data was taken from ACIR reports by Cornell Aeronautical Lab., Inc. of predominantly rural crashes in the United States. Where necessary the data were reanalyzed so that the variables being discussed were compatible. Comparisons are drawn between speeds at impact, areas of impact, vehicle damage severity, seated position, injury severity, anatomical injury distribution, and causes of injury for the four sets of data. The results show that there are considerable similarities between rural crashes in England and the United States, and urban crashes in Adelaide and Birmingham. Further, urban crashes have quite distinct characteristics from rural crashes. In urban collisions, speeds are low (22 mph), side impacts are frequent and lead to many injuries from the door structures. There are fewer injuries per person. In rural crashes impact speeds are higher, there are more frontal impacts and rollovers, and more injuries per person. The instrument panel, steering assembly, and windshield are the major causes of injury, regardless of whether the windshield is toughened or laminated glass, and ejection occurs with considerable frequency. The rank order of components which cause injury is discussed. The rank order changes when minor injuries are excluded. The research shows that the priorities for improvements vary with the environment, and a detailed knowledge of the crash circumstances in each country is required before design changes can have their maximum effect.
Ryan, G. AnthonyMackay, G. Murray
Items per page:
1 – 42 of 42