Browse Topic: Crash statistics

Items (105)
This study aims to analyze the impact of spatial and aspatial factors on the safety driving behavior of motorcycle couriers in East Jakarta within the context of the gig economy. Both factors are integrated to clarify how spatial conditions and individual characteristics jointly shape couriers’ safety driving behavior. The Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) method was employed to examine the relationship between spatial and aspatial factors on safety driving behavior. Data were collected through questionnaires from 253 motorcycle couriers operating in three subdistricts in East Jakarta, namely Cakung, Pasar Rebo, and Pulo Gadung. The results show that safety driving behavior is significantly influenced by aspatial factors, particularly socioeconomic characteristics and personality traits. In contrast, spatial factors such as road conditions and daily activity patterns do not directly influence safety driving behavior, but exert indirect effects through the couriers’ personality traits.
Wahyuddin, YasserSitorus, Paldibo AlfriramsonPutri, KharuniaMaharani, Garnierita
This research examined the performance of SAE Level 2 (L2) advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) in crash-imminent scenarios (CIS), with particular attention to how vehicle configuration like body style and powertrain (internal combustion engine, plug-in hybrid, electric vehicle) influences vehicle system performance. The objectives were to (1) identify CIS relevant to L2-equipped vehicles using crash databases and naturalistic driving studies (NDSs), (2) develop scenario-based test procedures and test matrices, and (3) evaluate system and vehicle responses across configurations and conditions. Multiple crash data sources were analyzed, including NHTSA’s Standing General Order dataset of L2-related crashes, the Fatality Analysis Reporting System, the Crash Report Sampling System, and NDS data from the Second Strategic Highway Research Program and the Virginia Tech Transportation Institute L2 NDS. Coded variable analyses from the datasets identified three common CIS: lane and road departures, rear-end striking events, and intersection conflicts. Supporting variables such as speed, roadway condition, and driver actions were also extracted to characterize scenarios and inform test development. Tests were executed at a closed-track testing facility using four vehicles selected for diversity of L2 systems, body types, and powertrains. Phase 0 exploratory testing assessed vehicle kinematics and L2 responses to refine the test matrix. Phases 1 and 2 conducted controlled evaluations of selected CIS, with expansion factors reflecting real-world crash variability. The testing highlighted interactions between L2 features and active safety systems. For example, results showed that all four vehicles employed distinct hand-off strategies between L2 longitudinal control and active safety systems during rear-end striking crash scenarios, and AEB engagement was strongly correlated with TTC at the moment the vehicle identified the crash partner. This work contributes novel insights into vehicle L2 and ADAS behavior in CIS events across multiple factors and provides a structured framework to evaluate system behavior for those crash-imminent scenarios.
Beale, GregoryKefauver, KevinVenegas, MichaelLi, EricChen, JayHuggins, StevenGuduri, BalachandarLlaneras, Eddy
Road Traffic crash statistics highlight the importance of reducing fatalities among Powered-Two-Wheeler (PTW) riders, and suggest the necessity of a robust method to evaluate PTW crashworthiness performance. The objective of this study is to clarify the relationship between impact conditions and the Head Injury Criterion (HIC) to establish a fundamental basis for determining representative crash configurations for safety. A total of 1,272 PTW-front to car-side impact simulations were conducted by using production car and PTW models. HIC was used as a metric indicating likelihood of head injury. Velocities, impact angle, and impact locations were varied to create response surfaces. The surfaces were evaluated in terms of their accuracy in identifying the representative impact conditions. In addition, head trajectories were analyzed to clarify the kinematics until head impact. The Finite Element (FE) simulations produced the following findings. The HIC distribution by Head Impact Target can be categorized into 2 groups by the height of the car roof. Some of the low-roof car group results show a phenomenon of partial helmet removal, causing large variation in HIC. High HIC values are observed when the Y-direction displacement at the head impact is small. Structural stiffness and roof height may need to be considered when investigating a future test method that provides stable safety evaluation. These findings establish a fundamental basis for determining the representative crash scenario through an analysis of the relationship between crash conditions and the HIC.
Yanaoka, ToshiyukiGunji, YasuakiZulkipli, Zarir HafizMatsushita, TetsuyaCarroll, JolyonPuthan, PradeepMohd Faudzi, Siti AtiqahD-Wing, KakMiyazaki, Yusuke
This article presents crash rate benchmarks for evaluating US-based automated driving systems (ADSs) for multiple urban areas, distinguishing between freeway and surface street crash rates, and breaking them down by crash severity and type. The purpose of this study was to extend prior benchmarks focused only on surface streets to additionally capture freeway crash risk for future ADS safety performance assessments. Using publicly available police-reported crash and vehicle miles traveled (VMT) data from Arizona, California, Georgia, and Texas, the methodology details the isolation of in-transport passenger vehicles, road type classification, and crash typology. Key findings revealed that freeway crash rates exhibit large geographic dependence variations with any-injury-reported crash rates being approximately three times higher in Atlanta (2.3 IPMM; the highest) when compared to San Diego (0.7 IPMM; the lowest). The results show the critical need for location-specific benchmarks to avoid biased safety evaluations and provide insights into the VMT required to achieve statistical significance for various safety impact levels. The distribution of crash types depended on the outcome severity level. Higher severity outcomes (e.g., fatal crashes) had a larger proportion of single-vehicle, vulnerable road users (VRUs) and opposite-direction collisions compared to lower severity (police-reported) crashes. Given heterogeneity in crash types by severity, performance in low-severity scenarios may not be predictive of high-severity outcomes. These benchmarks are additionally used to quantify at the required mileage to show statistically significant deviations from human performance. Future work investigating the underlying factors influencing crash rates in each geographical area will further enhance future benchmarking efforts (by identifying potential confounders to account for when matching exposure between baseline and ADS data). This is the first article to generate freeway-specific benchmarks for ADS evaluation and provides a foundational framework for future ADS benchmarking by evaluators and developers.
Scanlon, John M.McMurry, Timothy L.Chen, Yin-HsiuKusano, Kristofer D.Victor, Trent
This paper investigates the current state of road safety for female occupants in India, with a particular focus on road accident statistics and the gaps in safety regulations. According to the Road Accident in India 2022 report by the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH), female occupants constitute 16% of passenger car fatalities. Using a extensive dataset of 596 passenger car accidents involving at least one female occupant from the Road Accident Sampling System – India (RASSI), this study evalu the severity and patterns of injuries sustained by female drivers and passengers. The analysis identifies critical shortcomings in existing safety measures, particularly in addressing anatomical differences and male-centric safety designs. Gender-sorted injury trends reveal heightened vulnerabilities for women in crash scenarios. Current regulatory frameworks bank on crash test dummies developed on average male anthropometry, neglecting female-specific biomechanical needs in seatbelt fit, airbag deployment, and injury mitigation. Key gaps include the absence of standardized female-representative crash test dummies and insufficient anthropometric data on Indian women, which compromise the effectiveness of safety systems. To address these issues, the paper advocates for systematic gender-sorted data collection and integration of female-centric dummies in crash testing protocols. Policy recommendations emphasize the urgent need for gender-sensitive regulations and targeted anthropometric research to align safety measures with the physiological diversity of occupants. These steps are vital to reducing disparities in injury outcomes and promoting equitable road safety for women in India.
Ayyagari, ChandrashekharG, Santhosh KumarRao, Guruprakash
Curtain airbags are the most effective protective systems to prevent severe/fatal head injuries in side collisions with narrow objects such as poles or trees. One of the important parameters of curtain airbags is the inflated zone i.e. the coverage area of the airbag, which decides the extent of head protection for occupants with different anthropometries in different seating rows. EuroNCAP first introduced the concept of Head Protection Device Assessment (HPDA) in 2015., In addition to the performance requirements in the dynamic test, EuroNCAP started assessing the deployed curtain airbag/s for its area coverage and verification of inflated zones for various anthropometries over occupant rows. In India, there is now a near total adoption of curtain airbags as standard fitment by the OEMs. Further, introduction of Bharat NCAP (BNCAP), a Perpendicular Pole Side Impact test is conducted for assessing the effectiveness of curtain airbags in a dynamic test, but currently, does not perform the HPD assessment. The paper studies the Head Protection Device/Curtain Airbags offered in Passenger Vehicles in India w.r.t. the Head Protection Device Geometric Assessment (HPDA). This assessment analyses the effectiveness of curtain airbags present in Indian passenger vehicles for protection of occupants of different anthropometries. The study is conducted on the vehicles that have been tested at ARAI and are also currently under sale in the Indian market.
Jaju, DivyanKulkarni, DileepMahajan, Rahul
This study is conducted to analyse the significance of the Bharat NCAP crash test protocol in real road crashes in India. Accident data from on-the-spot investigation (Road Accident Sampling System India) and Government of India’s, Ministry of Road Transport and Highways official road accident statistics 2023 is used together to understand the real road accidents in India. The current Bharat NCAP crash test protocol is compared against the real road accidents and the frequency of the same in discussed in this paper. A seven-step calculation method is developed to analyse real accidents together with existing crash tests by using similar crash characteristics like impact area, overlap and direction of force. This method makes the real accident comparable with the corresponding crash test by calculating the impact energy during the collision between the real accident and a collision under crash test conditions. Relevant parameters in real accidents that significantly influence the test scenario, such as the opposing vehicle mass or the resulting collision speed, are analysed in detail and compared with existing test conditions. The analysis shows that more than 26% of car collisions in India with seriously or fatally injured car occupants could be attributed to the current existing Bharat crash test scenarios. In addition to quantifying the proportion of real-world accidents reflected in current testing scenarios, the results also reveal typical accident scenarios that are not currently addressed by any test. Furthermore, the results indicate whether the test configuration approximately corresponds to actual accident conditions. The results can therefore inspire the adaptation of existing or the development of new test scenarios to further increase safety for car occupants.
Moennich, JoergLich, ThomasKumaresh, Girikumar
PU foam shows a excellent energy absorbing dissipation properties during impact load so it commonly used in car seats, cabin and crash protection system. Specifically, in vehicle seats PU foams play a critical role in protecting occupants during crash scenarios by absorbing energy, distributing forces, and improving seatbelt performance, additionally providing countermeasures for head impact protection. The movement of the seat and the direction of the force during crash testing are highly unpredictable. The material behaviour of PU foam is captured using an isotropic, hyper-elasticity-based constitutive model available in LS-DYNA through MAT_083. This model is designed to take into account the foam's compressibility, sensitivity to strain rates, low Poisson's ratio, and hysteresis. The characterization of a PU foam with a nominal density of 65 kg/m3 was performed using quasi-static compressive testing of 0.01/s and dynamic compressive testing of 1/s,13/s, 120/s, as well as a quasi-static tensile test of 0.01/s. The material response data were used to calibrate the LS-DYNA foam model MAT-FU CHANG FOAM MAT-083. Calibration of the LS-DYNA material card (*MAT_FU_CHAN_FOAM MAT-083) was performed using coupon-level test data. The goal was to accurately simulate the foam's behaviour under varying strain rate conditions and extract the deformation pattern. Finally, the simulations were conducted with the same geometry and loading conditions as the experimental setup. The performance of the material card was validated by comparing simulation results with experimental data, demonstrating its ability to replicate foam behaviour under crash conditions.
Gaurav, Ashish KumarKrishnamoorthy, KunjuVaratharajan, Senthilkumaran
Single motorcycle accidents are common in Nagano Prefecture where is mountainous areas in Japan. In a previous study, analysis of traffic accident statistics data suggested that the fatality and serious injury rates for uphill right curves and downhill left curves are high, however the true causes of these accidents remain unclear. In this study, a motorcycle simulator was used to evaluate the driving characteristics due to these road alignments. Evaluation courses based on combinations of uphill/downhill slopes and left/right curves were created, and experiments were conducted. The subjects of the study were expert riders and novice riders. The results showed that right curves are even more difficult to see near the entrance of the curve when accompanied by an uphill slope, making it easier to delay recognition and judgment of the curve. Expert riders recognized curves faster than novice riders. Additionally, expert riders take a large lean of the vehicle body, actively attempted to ride on the inside corner, while that of novice riders was less. On the other hand, for downhill left curves, there was a tendency for delayed judgment of sharp curves, and riders were more likely to increase their speed. Also, the expert riders recognized curve curvature earlier and had a greater lean angle of the vehicle body than the novice riders, but there was no significant difference. From these results, the road alignment combination of uphill/downhill slopes and left/right curve has a significant impact on the risk of motorcycle accidents.
Kuniyuki, HiroshiKatayama, YutaKitagawa, TaiseiNumao, Yusuke
To address the issue of high accident rates in road traffic due to dangerous driving behaviors, this paper proposes a recognition algorithm for dangerous driving behaviors based on Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks. Compared with traditional methods, this algorithm innovatively integrates high-frequency trajectory data, historical accident data, weather data, and features of the road network to accurately extract key temporal features that influence driving behavior. By modeling the behavioral data of high-accident-prone road sections, a comprehensive risk factor is consistent with historical accident-related driving conditions, and assess risks of current driving state. The study indicates that the model, in the conditions of movement track, weather, road network and conditions with other features, can accurately predict the consistent driving states in current and historical with accidents, to achieve an accuracy rate of 85% and F1 score of 0.82. It means the model can effectively detect the consistency of driving states in current and hazardous driving behaviors in historical, such as aggressive acceleration, abrupt deceleration, and speeding. It contributes to provide timely risk warnings for drivers, effectively reducing the occurrence of traffic accidents, and adherence to driving safety.
Huang, YinuoZhang, MiaomiaoXue, MingJin, Xin
Background. In 2022, vulnerable road user (VRU) deaths in the United States increased to their highest level in more than 40 years. At the same time, increasing vehicle size and taller front ends may contribute to larger forward blind zones, but little is known about the role that visual occlusion may play in this trend. Goal. Researchers measured the blind zones of six top-selling light-duty vehicle models (one pickup truck, three SUVs, and two passenger cars) across multiple redesign cycles (1997–2023) to determine whether the blind zones were getting larger. Method. To quantify the blind zones, the markerless method developed by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety was used to calculate the occluded and visible areas at ground level in the forward 180° arc around the driver at ranges of 10 m and 20 m. Results. In the 10-m forward radius nearest the vehicle, outward visibility declined in all six vehicle models measured across time. The SUV models showed up to a 58% reduction in visibility within a 10 m radius. Other vehicles exhibited smaller (7%–19%) reductions. At longer distances (10 m–20 m), vehicles demonstrated both increases and decreases in visibility. Conclusion. The markerless method provides a straightforward and replicable assessment of driver visibility. The observed decrease in direct outward visibility near the vehicles points to the need for further study regarding this trend, including analysis of the repeatability and viability of the measurement technique.
Epstein, Alexander K.Brodeur, AlyssaDrake, JuwonEnglin, EricFisher, Donald L.Zoepf, StephenMueller, Becky C.Bragg, Haden
This paper aims to forecast and examine traffic conflicts by integrating Random Forest (RF) alongside Long Short-Term Memory Network (LSTM). The paper begins with the Random Forest method, pinpointing essential elements affecting traffic conflicts, revealing that the speed difference between interacting vehicles and their leaders, as well as the average headway and distance have significant effects on the occurrence of traffic conflicts. The forecasted Time to Collision (TTC) metric demonstrates extraordinary accuracy, confirming the creation of a precise traffic conflict forecast model. The model expertly predicts the vehicle's trajectory. This model skillfully anticipates vehicle paths and potential traffic conflict, demonstrating strong alignment with actual traffic patterns and offering support for traffic management by highlighting imminent risks. Merging RF with feature selection and LSTM for temporal dynamics enhances the forecasting capability. Furthermore, it also illuminates changes in traffic interaction patterns. Considering both fixed and shifting elements, this extensive process leads to a deep understanding of the subtle mechanisms driving traffic conflicts. The suggested platform serves as a robust device for traffic engineers and policymakers, enabling them to make informed decisions and implement effective strategies for managing traffic.
Cui, XinYuanShi, XiaomengShao, Yichang
Driving speed affects road safety, impacting crash severity and the likelihood of involvement in accidents on highway bridges. However, their impacts remain unclear due to inconsistent topography and consideration of crash types. This study aimed to identify the status of accidents and factors associated with accidents occurring on bridges along the Mugling to Narayanghat highway segment in Nepal. The study area involves the selected highway segment stretching from Aptari junction (CH: 2+42) to Mugling junction (CH: 35+677). Spanning 33.25 km, the road traverses through both hilly and Terai regions. The study employs descriptive and correlation statistics to analyze crash data from 2018 to 2023, aiming to achieve its research objectives. The study reveals overspeeding as the primary cause of crashes, notably head-on and rear-end collisions. Two-wheelers frequently exceed the speed limit of 40 km/h limit (29–88 km/h), and four-wheelers do similarly (18–81 km/h), leading to overspeeding crashes. Trucks are most involved in incidents, followed by microbuses and cars. Head-on collisions dominate at bridges, followed by rear-end, sideswipe, and runoff collisions. Multivehicle incidents outnumber single-vehicle ones. Damaged railings, barriers, and guardrails significantly contribute to severe accidents, necessitating urgent repairs and new installations for improved bridge safety. Poor road conditions and roadside hazards also worsened dangers, highlighting the importance of road infrastructure maintenance and speed limit enforcement.
Giri, Om PrakashShahi, Padma BahadurKunwar, Deepak Bahadur
Secondary crashes, including struck-by incidents are a leading cause of line-of-duty deaths among emergency responders, such as firefighters, law enforcement officers, and emergency medical service providers. The introduction of light-emitting diode (LED) sources and advanced lighting control systems provides a wide range of options for emergency lighting configurations. This study investigated the impact of lighting color, intensity, modulation, and flash rate on driver behavior while traversing a traffic incident scene at night. The impact of retroreflective chevron markings in combination with lighting configurations, as well as the measurement of “moth-to-flame” effects of emergency lighting on drivers was also investigated. This human factors study recruited volunteers to drive a closed course traffic incident scene, at night under various experimental conditions. The simulated traffic incident was designed to replicate a fire apparatus in the center-block position. The incident scene was complemented with a cone taper extending from the driver-side buffer to the edge of the roadway. The results indicate that higher-intensity lights were judged consistently as more glaring, but were only rated as marginally more visible. The rated visibility of the lights appears to be related to the perceived saturation of the color, while discomfort glare is related to the amount of short-wavelength spectral content. The results also suggest that the presence of highly reflective markings may decrease drivers’ ability to see first responders working adjacent to their vehicles.
Bullough, John D.Parr, ScottHiebner, EmilySblendorio, Alec
Wet pavement conditions during rainfall present significant challenges to traffic safety by reducing tire–road friction and increasing the risk of hydroplaning. During high-intensity rain events, the roadway pavement tends to accumulate water, forming a film that can have serious implications for vehicle control. As the longitudinal speed of the vehicle increases, a water wedge forms in front of the tire, leading to partial loss of contact with the road. At critical hydroplaning speed, a complete water layer forms between the tire and the road. Although less common, dynamic hydroplaning poses severe risks when high-intensity rainfall coincides with high vehicle traveling speed, leading to a complete loss of control over vehicle steering capabilities. This study advances hydroplaning research by integrating real-world data from the Road Weather Information System (RWIS) with an existing hydroplaning model. This approach provides more accurate hydroplaning risk assessments, emphasizing the importance of adapting predictive models to real-world conditions. Measurements of water film thickness from two Maryland locations over a year showed values of the water film heights up to 1.9 mm, with significant hydroplaning risk for vehicles with worn tires traveling at highway speeds. Using models such as Gengenbach and Gallaway, the study computes critical hydroplaning speeds, highlighting the importance of tire tread depth, inflation pressure, and pavement texture. Results indicate that the critical hydroplaning speed varies significantly based on these factors, emphasizing the need for safe driving practices during heavy rainfall. The findings underscore also the importance of developing new hydroplaning models in the context of future autonomous vehicles that needs robust algorithms for operating in wet conditions.
Vilsan, AlexandruSandu, CorinaAnghelache, Gabriel
The rapid advancement of new energy vehicle technology has led to the widespread placement of battery packs at the bottom of vehicles. However, there is a lack of corresponding regulations and standards to guide aspects related to vehicle bottom safety. This lack of guidance obscures the relative importance of various parameters impacting the structural safety of battery packs under dynamic impact conditions. Consequently, research on battery pack bottom collisions holds practical significance and offers valuable reference material. This study proposed a method based on the first collision point to examine the impact of bottom collisions on the mechanical safety performance of battery pack bottoms. A finite element model of the battery pack was established to investigate the effects of different impact types. During the collision event, the first collision point on the battery pack absorbed the most energy, resulting in the most severe damage and the formation of a distinct dent at the first collision point. The results indicated that bottom collisions exert a substantial impact on the structural safety of battery packs, with stress concentration primarily occurring near the impact point. The analysis of the first collision point emerged as a critical aspect of the bottom collision process, offering insights into the safety performance of battery packs under bottom impact and revealing the damage mechanisms that transpire during such collisions. Additionally, This study offered essential data support for design, verification testing, and optimization of battery packs.
Yan, PengfeiWang, FangMa, TianyiGao, YanHan, Ce
Two major steps involved in SOTIF analysis are defining acceptance criteria and estimating the validation target. While acceptance criteria aids in determining if we have an acceptable residual risk corresponding to a hazardous scenario, the validation target specifies the amount of testing effort (in hours or representative miles) that is needed to ensure that the acceptance criteria are met. The current approaches for defining acceptance criteria heavily rely on existing fatality databases or naturalistic driving study data sets. The criterion is selected based on average number of fatalities or crashes per mile or per one hour of operation. The validation target is then calculated based on acceptance criteria. However respective validation targets., are these values really reflecting the acceptable risk criteria and targets? According to statistics, for a given data set and a random sample derived from the dataset, only the mean of population of the data set and the sample can be considered equal. In the case of autonomous vehicles, this implies we can only generalize the mean of crash statistics of all vehicles in a country to a mean of crash statistics of a sample fleet of vehicles. However, the current acceptance criteria consider arithmetic mean across states but not vehicles, and often do not take into account the operational design domain (ODD) factors, the driver characteristics, and justifications behind their selection. Similarly, while the validation target is defined from the acceptance criteria there are no minimal requirements with respect to scenarios that are stated which needs be met within the target. To overcome these limitations, in this paper, we discuss the various factors that need to be weighed in for defining acceptance criteria and validation target. We illustrate with an example how the results can vary drastically when the factors we defined are considered and compare our results with the currently adopted methods.
Madala, KaushikKrishnamoorthy, JayalekshmiAvalos Gonzalez, CarlosShivkumar, AbhishekSolmaz, Mert
Analyses of driver response time studies and fatal crash statistics were examined to determine: 1. whether all rear-end crash types can be analyzed as one crash type, 2. average braking thresholds for drivers, and 3. the influence cell phone usage has on drivers’ response times when responding to a lead vehicle. The goal of this research is to recommend protocols for investigating LV crashes that is supported by the literature. Two distinct lead vehicle [LV] response time events emerged: LV platoon (two vehicles traveling together in close proximity) and LV looming (a vehicle approaching a stopped or much slower LV). In normal driving, platoon LV events were very common but resulted in very few crashes per exposure. Young drivers were over-represented when they did occur. Onset of the hazardous event was when the LV decelerated, and drivers began braking roughly 3 to 5 seconds before impact. These results were consistent with the braking thresholds by naturalistic drivers in congested traffic, as well as the GM-Ford Crash Avoidance Metrics Partnership [CAMP] test-track research. Conversely, LV looming crashes were rare, had much greater crash risk, involved drivers of all ages, and accounted for most fatal rear-end crashes. In this type of crash, drivers typically applied the brake less than 1.4 seconds before impact. These results were consistent with the braking thresholds by naturalistic drivers in smooth traffic and was nearly 3 times later than the braking thresholds by the 77th and 85th percentile responders in the CAMP tests. Hands-free and hand-held calling was not associated with an increase in brake response times when responding to a lead vehicle. However, visual and manual tasks, such as texting and dialing caused drivers to respond slower than approximately 93% of other drivers when responding to a lead vehicle. Based upon these results, a refined definition of driver distraction was offered.
Muttart, JeffreyDinakar, SwaroopEdewaard, Darlene
The Promise of Advanced Technologies in Future Total Safety DeliverySAE-PP-000963/7/2021
The motivation for this paper grew out of several years of observations related to the progress or lack thereof in safety, particularly in active safety. Further, many advanced technologies have brought forward new opportunities for further improvement in safety; at the same time, the promise of technologies, if taken too far, could also possibly result in diminishing safety returns unless a cautious approach based on safety research and testing, is undertaken. The recent increases in traffic deaths in the United States in spite of the many advanced driver assistance systems that have come into the fleet in the last several years is surprising. The changing composition of the vehicle fleet, the rapid development and the sudden interest in even more advanced technologies as the solution to many of our safety problems without adequate research, test and evaluation, is therefore, even a major concern. Passive safety systems that are in vehicles of today were generally phased in by the Government over a period of three or four years from the date of its implementation of regulations by the National Highway Safety Administration (NHTSA), or through New Car Assessment Programs (NCAP). Along with this, other consumer information and rating programs such as those by Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, may have been the main drivers for safety enhancement. However, NHTSA or others have not yet found an effective method by which active-safety countermeasures that have proven safety performance and metrics, to proliferate them in vehicles through regulations or other means. During the last several years, vehicle manufacturers have marketed many such Advanced Driver Assistance (ADAS) features in their vehicles. However, it is not clear to what extent these driver assistance systems and other active safety technologies may have impacted overall safety. If there was a clear, beneficial impact of these, it is not evident from the overall crash statistics. Under these circumstances, a clear strategy is essential with regard to the deployment of all safety technologies that are likely to come forward in the near future, especially the most advanced technologies such as those found in fully and partially autonomous vehicles. This paper is based on an oral presentation (with power point slides) I made virtually at a conference of Traffic Safety Scientists and Engineers In Nagoya, Japan during the last week of November, 2020.
Kanianthra, Joseph
The National Automotive Sampling System (NASS) Crashworthiness Data System (CDS) contains an abundance of field crash data. As technology advances and the database continues to grow over the years, the statistical significance of the data increases and trends can be observed. The purpose of this paper is to provide a broad-based, up-to-date, reference resource with respect to commonly sought-after crash statistics. Charts include up-to-date crash distributions by Delta-V and impact direction with corresponding injury severity rates. Rollover data is also analyzed, as well as historical trends for injury severity, belt usage, air bag availability, and the availability of vehicle safety technology.
Yaek, Jennifer L.Brown, ThomasGoertz, Alan
Accident statistics have shown that older and obese occupants are less adaptable to existing vehicle occupant restraint systems than ordinary middle-aged male occupants, and tend to have higher injury risk in vehicle crashes. However, the current research on injury mechanism of aging and obese occupants in vehicle frontal impacts is scarce. This paper focuses on the optimization design method of occupant restraint system parameters for specific body type characteristics. Three parameters, namely the force limit value of the force limiter in the seat belt, pretensioner preload of the seat belt and the proportionality coefficient of mass flow rate of the inflator were used for optimization. The objective was to minimize the injury risk probability subjected to constraints of occupant injury indicator values for various body regions as specified in US-NCAP frontal impact tests requirements. The approximate model was established and the optimal combination of parameters was selected by NSGA-II genetic algorithm. The optimization results were verified via the finite element simulation model, showing that when the key parameters of the occupant restraint system were optimized, the joint injury risk probabilities of the senior women with a BMI of 24.5, 33.4 and 36.3 were reduced by 7.73%, 7.45%, and 9.48 %, respectively.
Lin, GuanZhan, ZhenfeiChou, CliffordXu, HuijieFu, YueJiang, LingYin, YunleiChen, Ruyi
This paper examines the trends in rotorcraft accident statistics, particularly regarding Loss of Control In-flight accidents (LOC-I), with the aim of stimulating interest in new research relevant to this area. Despite recent safety initiatives, LOC-I rotorcraft accidents have been identified as a significant and growing contribution to accident rates. The fixed-wing commercial airline community faced a similar situation starting in the late 1990s and, through a coordinated international effort, developed a new training program to help reduce accident rates. Lessons learned from the fixed-wing work are presented to highlight the need for improved rotorcraft modeling tools to reduce rotorcraft accidents through higher-quality, simulator-based training programs. The findings from previous and ongoing rotorcraft modeling and simulation research are presented, and areas for further research are identified. A proposal is made in the paper for a workshop to bring together the key rotorcraft stakeholders to develop future steps in tackling rotorcraft LOC-I accidents.
White, MarkLu, LinghaiAdvani, SunjooCameron, NeilPadfield, Gareth
Intersection collisions currently account for approximately one-fifth of all crashes and one-sixth of all fatal crashes in the United States. One promising method of mitigating these crashes and fatalities is to develop and install Intersection Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (I-ADAS) on vehicles. When an intersection crash is imminent, the I-ADAS system can either warn the driver or apply automated braking. The potential safety benefit of I-ADAS has been previously examined based on real-world cases drawn from the National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey (NMVCCS). However, these studies made the idealized assumption of full installation in all vehicles of a future fleet. The objective of this work was to predict the reduction in Straight Crossing Path (SCP) crashes due to I-ADAS systems in the United States over time. The proportion of new vehicles with I-ADAS was modeled using Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI) fleet penetration predictions. The number of potential SCP conflicts was modeled as increasing year over year due to a predicted increase in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) each year. Finally, the combined effect of these changes was used to predict the number of SCP crashes each year from 2019 to 2045.
Bareiss, MaxGabler, H.Sherony, Rini
Road accident between pedestrian and motor vehicle causes severe injuries and even death of pedestrian. The accident statistics show that the possibility of injury to pedestrian is higher in case of collision with car on busy roads. In car and pedestrian collisions, the pedestrian’s head hits with car bonnet and suffer from multiple injuries such as skull fractures and brain injury. The role of car bonnet structural strength plays an important role in pedestrian head injury level. To provide enough structural strength the high bonnet thickness is provided with under bonnet stiffeners, however thick bonnet and stiffeners reduces deformation of the bonnet during collision and increases injury level to pedestrian. Hence optimum bonnet thickness, least number and geometry of stiffeners and enough structural strength is important for bonnet to reduce injury level. The aim of this study is to analyse the effect of car bonnet thickness, number and arrangement of under bonnet stiffeners on head injury levels with the help of head injury criteria (HIC). Head Injury Criteria (HIC) is a measure of the likelihood of head injury arising from an impact during a car crash. It indicatesthe level of injury caused during a particular crash. A typical modern car bonnet is selected for investigation with variety of bonnet material thickness and different configurations of under bonnet stiffeners and head injury criteria (HIC) is computed with the help of computer modelling. Further, head linear velocity, acceleration and head injury risk are predicted for probability of skull fracture. The geometry of bonnet is optimized with the help of optimization technique and optimized bonnet geometry is validated experimentally by designing a bonnet test facility and head form imparter.
Thombare, Dr. Dhananjay G
Transportation surveys illustrate that one of the most significant deterrents to bicycles as a form of conveyance is the concern with safety. Moreover, crash statistics also indicate that motor vehicles pose a severe risk to bicycles. As a result, this paper focuses on the development of a bicycle-mounted traffic monitoring system with the potential of providing early crash warnings to bicyclists. The system designed has a low monetary cost ($280.84) and is small enough to mount on a bicycle (94 mm × 56 mm × 89 mm). Moreover, it has sufficient range to track cars before they get dangerously close to the bike. The foundation of the system includes a Light Detection and Ranging (LIDAR) module that includes direct compatibility with microcontrollers. This LIDAR module interacts with a camera, stepper motor, and small computers through interfacing hardware and software. While robust, one limitation of the system is processing power. Specifically, its ability to detect cars is contingent on the performance of the computer that processes a video stream from the camera. With increased computing power, the system is capable of detecting lanes aiding in the search for cars, subsequently eliminating most false positives. Hence, augmenting processing capabilities of the current system would allow the vehicle recognition software to be more sensitive, ensuring that an automobile on the road is always detected.
Blankenau, IsaacZolotor, DanielChoate, MatthewJorns, AlecHomann, QuailanDepcik, Christopher
The official Indian accident statistics show that the number of road accidents and fatalities are one of the highest worldwide. These official statistics provide important facts about the current accident situation. It is suspected that for various reasons not all accidents are reported to the official statistic. This study estimates the degree of underreporting of traffic accidents with casualties in India. In order to get a national overview of the traffic accident situation it is necessary to improve the knowledge about underreported accidents. Therefore, the in-depth accident database of “Road Accident Sampling System India” (RASSI) was analyzed [1]. This project is organized by a consortium that has collected traffic accidents scientifically in four different regions since 2011 on the spot which have been reported either by police or by local hospitals and own patrol by RASSI engineers. Thus, the level of underreporting is researched by comparing data from hospital records and police records in order to estimate the number of accidents which are not documented in official statistics. Based on a number of around 1 635 accidents mainly in rural area it was found that 32% of all documented cases are not recorded by the national police. Based on these findings it is assumed that the national statistics cover only about two-third of all rural crashes in India. Various characteristics of accidents can influence the percentage of underreported cases. Accident scenarios - e.g. classified by Accident Type - have different shares of underreported cases. RASSI data shows that every 2nd single vehicle accident (including pedestrian cases) is not notified in the official statistics. In the study the accident data is analyzed in detail concerning: Accident scenarios Road user category Injury severity Road conditions Infrastructural details Result of this study is an overview of the accident situation in rural area and point out the frequency of underreported accidents depending of typical accident characteristics. This information can be used to identify main causes of this phenomen.
Joerg, MoennichKumaresh, GirikumarLich, ThomasGeorgi, Andreas
Traffic injuries are an important public health issue. To prevent these injuries, safety systems in a vehicle are recognized as valuable tools. These safety systems are active before and during a crash event. Passive safety is one such safety tool which comprises of occupant restraint systems to prevent fatal injuries during an event of a crash. To improve the real life safety further, active safety systems plays an important role in mitigating the real world accidents. Moreover, effective integration of active and passive safety systems has a potential to further reduce car occupant fatalities. However, in the recent developments in India towards road safety, vehicle safety standards are oriented more towards passive safety. In the present work, road accidents data from India between 2005 and 2014 are studied, to estimate the major mode of accidents and factors influencing the fatal injuries. Technological and human factor interventions are derived from these accidents statistics. The data collected can be an important input in developing the active safety systems representing the real world scenario. The human errors and injury severities associated with above accidents, emphasize the need of both active and passive safety systems in a vehicle to avoid accidents and mitigate injuries. This paper signifies the need of a robust regulatory system combining both active and passive safety systems to reduce the proportion of road accidents and the fatalities.
Udugu, KumaraswamySaddala, Viswanatha ReddyLingan, Sridhar
Automotive OEMs, insurance agencies and regulatory bodies are continuously looking at various accident statistics and proper ways of evaluating unaccounted (as per current regulations and safety ratings) accident scenarios to improve the safety standards of cars. Small overlap and oblique impacts during which a corner of a car hits a tree or the corner of another vehicle are two such situations. Most of the vehicles that are on road scored low when tested for these impact scenarios. This paper focuses on development of energy-absorbing members, using engineering thermoplastics materials, which can be mounted on the BIW of a vehicle, as countermeasures to small overlap impact. Various design and material configurations options, including metal plastic and composite plastic structural members mounted on the BIW are evaluated through CAE studies, against small overlap/oblique impact scenarios. Different approaches of impact energy absorption and energy transfer have been studied to improve crashworthiness of vehicle. Vehicles with and without these structural members are evaluated for small overlap impact using CAE tools like Ls-Dyna. It is observed that vehicles mounted with these additional structural members perform significantly better in small overlap impact (SOI) scenarios than vehicles without these members.
Munjurulimana, DineshNagwanshi, DhanendraMarks, Matthew
Japanese accident statistics show that despite the decreasing trend of the overall traffic fatalities, more than 1,000 pedestrians are still killed annually in Japan. One way to develop further understanding of real-world pedestrian accidents is to reconstruct a variety of accident scenarios dynamically using computational models. Some of the past studies done by the authors' group have used a simplified vehicle model to investigate pedestrian lower limb injuries. However, loadings to the upper body also need to be reproduced to predict damage to the full body of a pedestrian. As a step toward this goal, this study aimed to develop a simplified vehicle model capable of reproducing pedestrian full-body kinematics and pelvis and lower limb injury measures. The simplified vehicle model was comprised of four parts: windshield, hood, bumper and lower part of the bumper. Several different models were developed using different combinations of geometric and stiffness representation. A unique model called a multi-layer model developed in this study represented each of the hood and the windshield with a stack of the panel representing the entire area of these components, while applying localized stiffness characteristics and contact definition with a particular pedestrian body region that contacts with the layer represented by the stiffness characteristics. These models were made to collide with the human FE model, and pelvis and lower limb injury measures and full-body kinematics were compared with those from the simplified vehicle models. The results of the comparisons showed that the multi-layer model provided a more realistic contact interaction between the pedestrian body and the vehicle by eliminating the gap between adjacent panels due to geometric division of a large vehicle body panel.
Asanuma, HiroyukiTakahashi, YukouIkeda, MiwakoYanaoka, Toshiyuki
Modeling of a 6×4 Tractor and Trailers for Use in Real Time Hardware in the Loop Simulation for ESC Testing2013-01-06934/8/2013
According to NHTSA's 2011 Traffic Safety Facts [1], passenger vehicle occupant fatalities continued the strong decline that has been occurring recently. In 2011, there were 21,253 passenger vehicles fatalities compared to 22,273 in 2010, and that was a 4.6% decrease. However; large-truck occupant fatalities increased from 530 in 2010 to 635 in 2011, which is a 20% increase. This was a second consecutive year in which large truck fatalities have increased (9% increase from 2009 to 2010). There was also a 15% increase in large truck occupant injuries from 2010. Moreover, the fatal crashes involving large trucks increased by 1.9%, in contrast to other-vehicle-occupant fatalities that declined by 3.6% from 2010. The 2010 accident statistics NHTSA's report reveals that large trucks have a fatal accident involvement rate of 1.22 vehicles per 100 million vehicle miles traveled compared to 1.53 for light trucks and 1.18 for passenger cars. This translates to a fatal accident involvement rate of 32.35 vehicles per 100,000 registered large trucks compared to 17.02 for light trucks and 13.09 for passenger cars. These statistics indicate that large trucks account for a disproportionately large number of fatal crashes compared to any other type of vehicle (excluding motorcycles) even though they account for only a small fraction of registered vehicles. However, testing tractor trailer combinations on the test track is a cumbersome, potentially dangerous, and expensive process. An alternate means to test such vehicles is to use Hardware-in-the-Loop (HIL) simulation technologies to test Electronic Stability Control (ESC) and other emerging advanced technologies intended for highway safety. The HIL simulation environment incorporates multiple software environments interacting with actual hardware. In such a simulation, the accuracy of the software models is critical to the accuracy of the simulation results. This paper outlines the modeling of a Volvo tractor and two trailers in TruckSim, used by the HIL system at NHTSA.
Rao, Sughosh J.Salaani, Mohamed KamelHeydinger, Gary J.Guenther, Dennis A.Garrott, W. Riley
It is known that the collisions caused by lane departure events account for range of percentages among the countries studied. To help prevent such collisions, the Lane Departure Warning (LDW) system has started to be introduced in production vehicles, but there is little research on its benefits and limitations so far. In this paper we performed an in-depth analysis of the collisions and driver-related essential variables for the lane-departure collision scenarios and demonstrated the benefit estimation process. The benefit of the LDW system is estimated by comparing lane departure events when the vehicle has no LDW, and how they change with the addition of LDW. The event without LDW was modeled in 5 phases: (1) before departure, (2) starting of the departure, (3) departed the lane, (4) at the impact with an object, and, (5) after the impact. “An extensive analysis was conducted of traffic crash data compiled by the Institute for Traffic Accident Research and Data Analysis (ITARDA). The results of this analysis were used to create models of each phase of an LDW event. The Advanced Safety System & Traffic REaltime Evaluation Tool (ASSTREET), which is based on Monte-Carlo Simulation, was then used to simulate a variety of collision types. The results of these simulations were validated by comparing the distributions of fatality, serious injury, minor injury and no injury that they generated to crash statistics for Japan. Then, the effect of the LDW system was added to the lane departure events. The drivers' response delay to the LDW and the possible reactions were measured in a driving simulator test. The comparison between events with and without LDW clearly shows which cases could be prevented by the use of LDW and the ones that could not be avoided, thereby, providing us with important guidelines to improve the system performance.
Tanaka, ShinMochida, TsutomuAga, MasamiTajima, Jun
In Japan, the number of occupant fatalities has decreased at high ratio due to the development of passive and active safety technology in recent years. However, the pedestrian fatality is still the major proportion of fatalities according to the statistics of traffic accident. Therefore, it is important to study and develop active safety technologies which target to pedestrian. By analyzing the traffic accident statistics, narrow road in urban area is one of the dangerous parts for pedestrian. And the dangerous case that pedestrian often gets into an accident is while crossing road outside of crosswalk. This study focuses on accidents which are caused by pedestrians suddenly crossing narrow urban roads. In such cases, drivers need to drive carefully, preparing for sudden crossing or unexpected dangerous behavior of pedestrians. Therefore, it is important for drivers to predict the accident risk due to the crossing pedestrian behavior in such narrow roads. The final goal of this study is to find out the hazard anticipation mechanism in such scenes and to design a driving assistance system, such as, a warning or intervention system. To design such a driving assistance system it is necessary to describe a model of sudden crossing or unexpected dangerous behavior of pedestrian. To describe pedestrian behavior in urban area, near-miss incident database is analyzed which has been developed by JSAE. This database includes all kind of incidents collected by drive recorder, or black box, attached to Taxis in down town Tokyo. By using the database, we constructed a mathematical model for quantifying pedestrian behavior from camera image data, and verified the validity of the method by computer simulation.
Aoyagi, SoichiroHayashi, RyuzoNagai, Masao
Accident statistics shows pedestrian accident fatalities as one of the important concerns globally. In view of this, new test protocols for pedestrian safety have been drafted in regulation as well as in consumer group. Also as per new ENCAP requirements, pedestrian safety assessment is used as one of the four assessment criteria's (Adult protection, child safety, pedestrian safety, safety assist) in deciding the overall vehicle safety. Hence today importance of pedestrian safety is perceived as never before in vehicle development program. Basically pedestrian safety evaluation involves subsystem level (head form, upper leg form and lower leg form) impact tests representing human body parts, at specific region on test vehicle with injury limits to decide the severity of impact. In general these injuries are governed by vehicle styling, vehicle stiffness, hard points clearances from vehicle exterior like bonnet, bumper etc. For head impact, design parameter that mainly control the injury, like bonnet top stiffness design and under bonnet clearances remain valid for both passenger cars as well as for SUV's (Sport Utility Vehicles). Upper leg from impact test is not mandatory to be met in regulation and also difficult to meet in SUV class type vehicles as the location of impact is guided by bonnet leading edge which are quite high in case of SUV's because of vehicle stance. In case of lower leg test, injuries are mainly guided by front styling and bumper to hard point clearance. In SUV's as compared to passenger cars as the ground clearance from the ground is generally higher and vehicle styling is aggressive, controlling the injuries within the limits are quite challenging. This paper specifically discusses important design aspects on controlling the injuries of lower leg form for a SUV type vehicle to meet target requirements. This paper attempt to demonstrate the importance of vehicle front end styling, bumper system design, location of energy absorber, bumper profile, front end stiffness and limitation of bumper to hard point clearance in meeting the lower leg injuries.
Bhagat, MilindChalipat, SujitRanade, Amod
Plug-in electric vehicles are becoming increasingly popular as the U.S. and other nations look for ways to reduce the usage of petroleum fuels and reduce the carbon emission footprint. Though plug-in electric vehicles offer many advantages over conventional vehicles, they also present some unique potential hazards due to the presence of high voltage in the vehicle. Specifically, potential high voltage hazards can occur if the electric vehicle is crashed by another vehicle during its plug-in charging session. High voltage hazards include the possibility of electrical shock and thermal events as a result of electrical arcing that can cause injury or death to persons that operate or work around plug-in electric vehicles. Automotive Safety Integrity Level (ISO 26262), often abbreviated as ASIL, is used by the automotive industry for determining the ranking of safety hazards. The likelihood of exposure to a particular safety hazard that leads to a mishap is one of the factors used for ASIL rankings. Thus, it is necessary to understand the likelihood of a crash during a plug-in charging session in order to evaluate the ASIL ranking for hazards due to this particular scenario. This paper will analyze crash statistics in the United States and other factors to determine the likelihood of high voltage exposure due to a crash during a plug-in charging session.
Connolly, CotrinaGoodman, CalvinHo, Li-Pen
Developments in avionics, communications, and air-traffic management enable more affordable and better ways to fly and navigate. The tragic crash of the Polish-government-operated Tupolev Tu-154 on April 10, which came down after hitting trees on its approach to the airport runway at Smolensk, Russia, killed not only that nation's President and First Lady but also scores of Poland's military and civilian elite, including military and business leaders, ministers, and representatives of organizations ranging from war veterans to officials from the church and charities. National implications of this high-profile flying disaster can be imagined, but sadly, aircraft crashes on approach in poor weather, often involving small regional or general aviation aircraft, or business jets, are not yet a thing of the past.
Gardner, Richard
The National Automotive Sampling System (NASS) Crashworthiness Data System (CDS) contains a wealth of field accident data. As the size of the database continues to grow, the statistical significance of the data increases and trends can be observed. Numerous papers contain analysis and graphs of particular aspects of the data, but they are usually included in a supporting role to the main topic of the paper, and are extremely difficult to locate in a focused document search. The purpose of this paper is to provide an updated, comprehensive resource to reference when looking for commonly sought-after accident statistics. Charts include accident distributions by Delta-V and impact direction with corresponding injury severity rates. Rollover data is also analyzed, as well as historical trends for injury severity, belt usage, and air bag availability.
Goertz, AlanYaek, JenniferCompton, Charles
For occupant protection in vehicle crash, several kinds of ATDs (Anthropomorphic Test Devices) and associated injury criteria have been used to evaluate the performance of a vehicle body, restraint systems and other safety devices. Because of the lack of sufficiently validated injury criteria for the lumbar spine, it has been a concern that the effectiveness of some safety features for injury reduction based on the dummy and associated injury criteria may not be reasonably assessed. Therefore, in this study, a human FE model capable of evaluating lumbar spine skeletal injuries was developed. Considering an increasing percentage of the traffic accidents relating to elderly people due to extending span of human life and decreasing birthrate, not only an adult model but also a model that represents lowered tolerance of the elderly was developed. From traffic accident statistics, 35 and 75 years old (y.o.) were defined as the representative ages of adult and elderly populations. An existing human FE model for an adult male was adopted for the baseline. The material properties of the trabecular bone of the lumbar vertebra for 35 and 75 y.o. were determined using the compression characteristics from the literature. Because of the lack of published data, those of the cortical bone were estimated so that the maximum (fracture) forces of the whole vertebrae under static compression predicted by the models agree to those of the tests from the literature. The isolated vertebra FE models were validated against dynamic compression and endplate impact tests for respective generations from the literature, and the result showed good agreement in maximum (fracture) forces. Then the whole lumbar spine model was validated against dynamic flexion, extension and lateral bending tests from the literature for the overall kinematics.
Dokko, YasuhiroKanayama, YuIto, OsamuOhashi, Kazuki
Development of Human Lower Limb and Pelvis FE Models for Adult and the Elderly2009-01-03964/20/2009
It has been difficult to evaluate injuries to the elderly whose body tolerance is lowered due to aging. The objective of this study was to develop human FE models for evaluating skeletal injuries to the lower limb and pelvis of both adult and elderly people. From traffic accident statistics, 35 and 75 years old (y.o.) were defined as the representative ages of adult and elderly population. An existing human FE model for an adult male pedestrian was adopted for the baseline. Femur models were developed first, because there existed most sufficient data of material properties and geometry for the femur. Age-related changes in material properties and geometries of bone were investigated by literature survey, from which average values of Young’s modulus, yield stress/strain and ultimate stress/strain, section areas and cortical bone thicknesses for 35 and 75 y.o. were determined. As no age-related material data were found for the tibia and fibula, those of the femur were scaled with scale factors derived from some existing data. Using these parameters, the baseline model was modified to represent 35 or 75 y.o. male both in material properties and geometries. The femur, tibia and fibula models were validated against quasi-static and dynamic 3-point bending tests for force-deflection responses of respective generations, which resulted in good agreement. For the pelvic bones, as no material data were found in the literature, the parameters of the femur were initially used and then modified so that the force-deflection curves of the pelvic bone models fell within the corridors of those of side impact tests in several conditions. The validated part models were integrated into a lower body skeletal model, which was finally validated against a number of experiments with age information including knee impact and sole impact.
Dokko, YasuhiroIto, OsamuOhashi, Kazuki
Development of Adult and Elderly FE Thorax Skeletal Models2009-01-03814/20/2009
Accident statistics show that the thorax is one of the most frequently injured body regions in drivers who sustain severe injuries in frontal car crashes. Thoracic injuries are more significant for the elderly than for adults. However, there are no injury assessment tools accounting for differences in anatomical features and material properties between adults and the elderly. The current study developed adult and elderly FE thorax models for investigating thoracic injury mechanisms for each generation. The ages represented by these models were defined as 35 and 75 years old (y.o.), respectively, based on the age distribution from accident statistics. The FE meshes representing the external shapes of the thoracic skeleton were first created based on the thorax CT images of the individuals with approximately average body sizes of males in their 30’s and 70’s. Since the geometry of the created mesh of the 35 y.o. appeared significantly different from the average statistically generated in the literature while that of the 75 y.o. was very close, the mesh of the 35 y.o. was recreated by morphing the mesh of the 75 y.o. targeting the geometry of this average geometry of the 35 y.o. The cortical thickness of the sternum and other bones were determined from the literature supplemented by the CT data. The average material property of the ribs, clavicles, costal cartilages and sternum for each age was estimated from the literature. Due to the limited amount of available response data, the models for each age were validated by predicting the upper and lower limits of responses using individual variation of material parameters estimated from the literature. The average material parameters were considered valid when published response data fell within the predicted response limits. This procedure was applied to the validation of rib and thorax at the component level. Isolated rib models were validated against quasi-static and dynamic bending tests from the literature. Then, the thoracic skeleton model incorporating the ribs, clavicles, sternum, costal cartilages and thoracic spine was validated against dynamic chest loading tests from the literature which were performed by four different types of loading - hub loading, single diagonal belt loading, double diagonal belt loading, and distributed loading.
Ito, OsamuDokko, YasuhiroOhashi, Kazuki
Characteristics of Pole Impacts to Side of Passenger Cars in European Traffic Accidents and Assessment of Injury Mechanisms - Analysis of German and UK In-Depth Data2008-22-001411/3/2008
The national accident statistics demonstrate that the situation of passenger car side impacts is dominated by car-to-car accidents. Car side-to-pole impacts are relatively infrequent events but result in disproportionate rates of serious and fatal injuries when compared to those in car-to-car side impact. Hence their importance has been highlighted in recent studies. For the present study two approaches were undertaken to better understand the scenario of car-to-pole impacts in Germany. The German in-depth database GIDAS (German In-Depth-Accident Study) and the UK-based database CCIS (Co-operative Crash Injury Study) were used. The first part or the study is a statistical analysis of passenger car side-to-pole impacts to describe the characteristics and their importance relevant to other types of impact and to gain further knowledge about the main factors influencing the accident outcome. The second part contains a case-by-case review of passenger cars first registered 1998 and onwards to further investigate this type of impact, including regression analysis to assess the relationship between injury severity and pole impact relevant factors. The study uses a methodology that merges in-depth-accident data from different nations and shows how in-depth cases can be used for finding injury-related technical parameters like deformation pattern, load circumstances for impact locations, and directions on the vehicle for the assessment of current and prospective test regulations. Delta-v can be identified as the most significant influencing factor for MAIS, especially for injury severity for thr thorax and abdomen. The vast majority of severe and fatal injuries are in accidents involving damage to the passenger compartment. The depth of deformation has significant influence on the injury severity level of the extremities. The most frequent direction of impact in car side-to-pole impacts is perpendicular (90° ±15°).
Otte, DietmarHaasper, CarlEis, VolkerSchaefer, Roland
The Road/Lane Departure Warning System is a crash-avoidance technology which warns drivers if they are drifting (or have drifted) out of their lane or from the road. This warning system is designed to help prevent the possibility of a run-off-road crash. This system will not take control of the vehicle; it will only let the driver know that he/she needs to steer back into the lane. This warning system is not designed as a lane-change monitor, which addresses intentional lane changes, or a merging system which warns of other vehicles. This informational report applies to OEM and after-market Road/Lane Departure warning systems for light-duty vehicles on relatively straight roads with a radius of curvature of 500 m or more, and under good weather conditions. Future revisions should consider the implications of newer variations on the user experience.
Safety and Human Factors Standards Steering Committee
Child Side Impacts: Comparison of Vehicle Crush in Side Impacts from Field Investigations and U.S. Consumer Tests2005-01-02864/11/2005
A cooperative effort by multiple research organizations is being conducted in order to examine child occupants involved in vehicle side impacts. The overall goal of this study is to develop an understanding of how children are being injured in side impacts and what can be done to reduce the risk. This process involves an examination of three fundamental factors of side impacts. These include the behavior of vehicles involved in side impact, the risk and mechanism of injury to children, and the role of restraints or countermeasures. A comprehensive understanding of these three factors is needed prior to proposing and testing improvements that might reduce injury. Previous and ongoing research into accident statistics is framing the issue of side impact by identifying the risks to the pediatric population involved in side crashes. One initial factor being considered is the relationship between vehicle crash characteristics and injury risk to children. Review of field data has documented such points as vehicle type, vehicle deformation, and impact kinematics as influencing injury outcome. This report has initiated a multistage process to investigate vehicle crash parameters and characteristics to determine why the influence on injury risk exists. This report and future work will examine the performance of vehicles in side impact and to understand the crash environment that children are exposed to. The goal will be to identify crash characteristics that best represent the injury producing environment and translate this into a repeatable laboratory test condition. A comparison of the external crush of vehicles involved in real world side impacts with that of similar vehicles tested using conventional side impact procedures has been conducted. This effort has attempted to expand previous work by several research organizations that have investigated vehicle deformations in side impacts. Differences between the IIHS side impact test method and the US-Side NCAP tests are shown for mid-sized sedans. In addition, similarities between the IIHS side impact test method crush patterns and higher severity real world side impact crush patterns are provided. Additional work will be made using test reviews, case reviews, and computational analysis to better define the side impact environment for child occupants.
Tamborra, NicholasBahouth, George
Effects Causing Untripped Rollover of Light Passenger Vehicles in Evasive Maneuvers2004-01-10573/8/2004
Accident statistics show that rollover accidents contribute to a large proportion of fatal traffic accidents in the U.S.. In the past it has been documented that some light passenger cars showed tendencies to roll over in evasive lane change maneuvers. In 1997, a newly developed mini van rolled over in a severe double lane change test called “moose-test”. Recently (2001), a new SUV showed similar tendencies in the Consumers Union Short Course test. It is not immediately clear why these evasive test maneuvers are so strongly related to untripped rollover of light passenger vehicles. Therefore, the goal of current research is to understand the circumstances and effects causing modern passenger vehicles to roll over in evasive maneuvers on the road. This paper discusses research activities concerning the following questions: How do critical steering strategies lead to untripped rollover? Are resonant frequencies excited during maneuvers leading to rollover? What are the prerequisites for dynamic untripped rollover? To answer these questions, extensive testing with an instrumented test vehicle as well as simulations with a real-time capable vehicle dynamics simulation were performed. The results were validated with a near standard production SUV. Results show that rollover critical steering strategies are related to high differences in steering amplitudes and to high steering wheel angle rates. Critical steering frequencies are in the range of 0.3 to 0.8Hz. The time for counter steering during evasive maneuver tests is related to the maximum of roll rate and side slip angle. An excitation of the roll natural frequency does not play a roll in untripped rollover. The main conditions necessary for untripped rollover are to create high roll-rates and maximum side forces at both axles simultaneously. Therefore requisits are heavy side to side excitations of the body and dynamic, greatly increased wheel loads as well as a oversteering behavior of the vehicle.
Baumann, Frank W.Eckstein, Lutz
Rollover Crash Sensing and Safety Overview2004-01-03423/8/2004
This paper provides an overview of rollover crash safety, including field crash statistics, pre- and rollover dynamics, test procedures and dummy responses as well as a bibliography of pertinent literature. Based on the 2001 Traffic Safety Facts published by NHTSA, rollovers account for 10.5% of the first harmful events in fatal crashes; but, 19.5% of vehicles in fatal crashes had a rollover in the impact sequence. Based on an analysis of the 1993-2001 NASS for non-ejected occupants, 10.5% of occupants are exposed to rollovers, but these occupants experience a high proportion of AIS 3-6 injury (16.1% for belted and 23.9% for unbelted occupants). The head and thorax are the most seriously injured body regions in rollovers. This paper also describes a research program aimed at defining rollover sensing requirements to activate belt pretensioners, roof-rail airbags and convertible pop-up rollbars. The work required an understanding of the most relevant conditions for field rollovers, vehicle responses and occupant kinematics in the vehicle. The most common rollovers involve a soil trip, fall-over and curb trip. These conditions were simulated in laboratory tests where measurements were made with rate gyros, accelerometers and instrumented dummies. Cross-plots of vehicle roll rate and angle were used to consider triggering requirements for safety systems and to determine the timing of occupant motion in the vehicle. Some rollovers require triggering of safety systems when the vehicle has only a 10°-20° roll angle because roll angular velocities exceed 100°/s.
Viano, David C.Parenteau, Chantal S.
Analysis of Rollover Injuries for 125 Occupants at a Single Trauma Center With Special Focus on Head and Neck Injury2004-01-03213/8/2004
Analysis of the National Automotive Sampling System (NASS) data reveals that vehicle rollover accidents account for a relatively a small number of accidents, but the associated frequency of serious injury is high compared to frontal or side impact. These data demonstrate the apparently elevated probability of head and neck injury during rollover, with head injury occurring more frequently, injured 4.5 times more frequently than the neck when considering all injuries. Automotive industry researchers have performed numerous rollover tests with instrumented ATD's and have predicted an elevated probability of neck injury with little chance of head injury. This contradicts field data (NASS-CDS) which suggests a high frequency of head injury with little chance of neck injury. This difference may be explained in part, through the different volumes of data presented in the literature. For example, while government accident statistics represent a sample of all accidents (∼ 5000 cases per year) occurring within the United States, individual car crash experimental reproductions represent a small proportion of car crashes. As such, it would be helpful to analyze 100% of cases from a given region(s) to aid in our understanding of rollover injuries. The objective of the current study was to thoroughly analyze 125 cases collected from a trauma one hospital to elucidate the head and the neck injury profile for rollover victims. The resulting data demonstrate the prevalence of head injury supporting the government accident data thus suggesting reconsideration of either current rollover accident experimental protocols or the biofidelity of the dummy in rollover. It should be noted, however, that removing relatively minor head and neck injuries (AIS 1 and 2) from the analysis shows that there is very little difference in the frequency of head and neck injury.
Pate, Biren J.Atkinson, Patrick JSadowski, Jason B.Fernandez, David J.
Assessment of Pelvis and Upper Leg Injury Risk in Car-Pedestrian Collisions: Comparison of Accident Statistics, Impactor Tests and a Human Body Finite Element Model2003-22-001910/27/2003
In this study, we first present a comparison between pelvis/upper leg injuries observed in real-world accidents as recorded in the database of the Medical University of Hanover, and the EEVC test results of corresponding cars as published by EuroNCAP. The fact that modern cars with rounded hood edges cause very few pelvis/upper leg injuries is discussed against the findings of the EEVC tests, where these cars do not perform significantly better than their older counterparts with sharper hood leading edges. This discrepancy could be due to the fact that the radius of the hood edge is not accounted for in the current version of the test protocol. In a second step, various impacts against several different simplified hood shapes were simulated using a detailed finite element model of a 50th percentile male pedestrian. The finite element model (THUMS) has been extensively validated against PMHS experiments in previous studies. The validated model affords detailed insight into pelvic and femoral deformations and loading patterns, and reveals, as expected, that the shape of the hood leading edge plays a critical role in the resulting biomechanical loading patterns. Based upon the results of this study, recommendations are offered for a more appropriate characterization of the hood shape with regard to pelvis/upper leg injury risk.
Snedeker, Jess G.Muser, Markus H.Walz, Felix H.
The Effects of Occupant Age on Patterns of Rib Fractures to Belt-Restrained Drivers and Front Passengers in Frontal Crashes in Japan2003-22-001610/27/2003
The injuries sustained by elderly car occupants in traffic accidents are usually more severe than those of younger occupants. Accident statistics data show that injuries to elderly occupants frequently occur in the chest. Belted drivers and front seat passengers in cars involved in frontal collisions were investigated using detailed data on traffic accidents in Japan. From a total of 246 vehicle occupants, the total number of injuries among the 167 occupants listed as injured was 462. Most of the injuries to the chest were minor ones such as skin abrasions or contusions. However, 21 occupants sustained rib fractures and 7 persons even sustained internal organ injuries. Younger occupants appeared not to sustain rib fractures even in higher impact collisions. Conversely, elderly occupants frequently experienced rib fractures near the seat belt line even under lower impact severity. It was also typically observed that rib fractures in case of airbag deployment were more often found in the lower part of chest compared with those cases of seat belt restraint alone. Symptoms of these differences in injury are described in detail in consideration of the gender and age of occupants, airbag deployments, and accident severity. In addition, regression analysis was carried out to evaluate the influence of age on rib fractures. Results show that rib fractures in elderly occupants occur at a delta V 30 km/h lower than that of younger occupants.
Shimamura, MunemasaOhhashi, HideyukiYamazaki, Minora
Rear-End Collision Velocity Reduction System2003-01-05033/3/2003
In Japan, rear-end collisions occur at higher frequency than many other kinds of traffic accident. The causes of rear-end collisions were therefore investigated. Accident statistics was used to conduct a statistical traffic accident analysis and a questionnaire survey was used to conduct a detailed traffic accident analysis. Simulation was then used to perform an accident analysis on the basis of those studies. The results suggested that many of these accidents were caused by momentary inattention during daily driving. Research was therefore carried out to determine what kind of collision avoidance assist system would be effective for use at such times. Tests were carried out to measure the obstacle avoidance characteristics of drivers using actual cars, and control timing parameters were established. In this process, the warning timing was set so that it would not lose its impact as a warning and also so that it would not interfere with the driver. The system was configured to make up for delays in recognition and judgment by means of brake control. The method of brake operation to be used was studied using both computation and testing with actual vehicle. The brake operation timing was set not to interfere with ordinary driver operations, and the deceleration was set to assist the driver’s avoidance maneuvers. The result was creation of a system capable of contributing to the reduction of rear-end collisions.
Kodaka, KenjiOtabe, MakotoUrai, YoshihiroKoike, Hiroyuki
Items per page:
1 – 50 of 105