Browse Topic: Injury causation

Items (102)
This study investigated sex-specific differences in thoracic injury prevalence, causation, and rib fracture patterns among seriously injured occupants in frontal motor vehicle collisions. Crash Injury Research and Engineering Network (CIREN) data from 2005 to 2022 included 793 front-seat occupants aged 16 years and older with Abbreviated Injury Scale 2+ thorax injury, representing 1802 thoracic injuries. Injuries were grouped as rib fracture, sternum fracture, hemo/pneumothorax, lung injury, heart injury, and other. A weighted scoring system captured contributions of involved physical components to each injury. Logistic and linear regression with generalized estimating equations assessed sex associations with injury presence and causation. Two models were estimated: a comprehensively adjusted model including demographic, crash, vehicle, restraint, and airbag deployment, and a simplified model adjusting for age, body mass index, delta-V, and occupant role. Among occupants with AIS 2+ thoracic injuries, sex-specific differences were observed in injury patterns and causation. Females were less likely than males to sustain lung injuries (OR = 0.70, p = 0.038) and more likely to sustain rib fractures (OR = 1.25, p = 0.006). Females had higher odds of rib fractures attributed to seatbelt loading in both models (Full: OR = 2.20, p = 0.005; Simplified: OR = 1.55, p = 0.021). Females were less likely than males to sustain lung injuries (OR = 0.17, p = 0.042) and hemo/pneumothoraces (OR = 0.15, p = 0.044) from instrument panel loading. Steering wheel, airbag, and other components showed no significant sex-specific associations with thoracic injury. Rib fracture patterns showed clusters along the seatbelt path in belted occupants and a more diffuse pattern in unbelted occupants, with minimal significant findings of differences between sexes. These findings contribute to the growing evidence of sex-specific injury patterns and may inform future research on injury prediction and prevention strategies. However, this dataset includes only occupants with AIS 2+ thoracic injuries and therefore cannot be extrapolated to the general population or to collisions outside those represented in the sample.
Armstrong, WilliamDevane, KaranHsu, Fang-ChiHeilmann, NinaSink, JoelMiller, Anna N.Kiani, BahramMartin, R. ShaynStitzel, Joel D.Weaver, Ashley
Research Question/Methods The study examined abdominal injuries of 87 belted occupants in CIREN frontal crashes for sex-based differences in abdominal injury patterns. It introduced a more anatomically detailed method for identifying injury locations in an abdominal-pelvic region that includes skeletal structures. The study introduces and applies a novel Abdominal New Injury Severity Score (AbNISS) to address limitations of traditional AIS coding in capturing sex-based differences in injury patterns. The operative reports/EDR/imaging data in CIREN cases enabled identification of sex-specific crash outcomes. The dominant analytical motif is Bertrand Russell’s knowledge by acquaintance and definite descriptions. Results Females had a higher rate of moderate to severe abdominal injuries than males: Only females sustained AIS 5 injuries, lumbar Chance fractures, posterior pelvic arch injuries, and more AIS 2, 3, and 4 injuries, with more injuries in superior-mid, left-superior, and medial-mid-abdominal zones. Males had more in the medial-inferior zone. 13 females had muscle ruptures. Four had combined muscle and Morel–Lavallée injuries, and four had Morel–Lavallée injuries alone. 13 of 14 males had muscle ruptures only. Pelvic morphology: Statistically significant (p < 0.05) sex-based difference in pelvic aspect ratios: Females: 1.37 ± 0.053, with the male ratio of 1.28 ± 0.079. By incorporating anatomical precision and enhanced injury mapping, it supports the development of more representative ATD/human body models. Discussion and Limitations Limitations of the study include its retrospective design, possible inconsistencies in clinical documentation, and challenges in applying AbNISS coding to non-CIREN datasets due to specificity constraints.
Halloway, DaleCurry, WilliamSomasundaram, KarthikPintar, Frank
Objective The objective of this study was to examine the Large Omnidirectional Child (LODC) anthropomorphic test device (ATD) neck and spine responses in reclined seating configurations with and without a backless belt-positioning booster (BPB) in far-side lateral oblique impacts. Methods The LODC was seated on a production passenger seat with an integrated seatbelt and tested in nine lateral oblique impact (80° from frontal) sled tests (31.3 km/h). A condition with a nominal seatback angle (~25°) with a backless BPB and two conditions with reclined seatback angles (~45° and ~60°) with and without a BPB were compared. Each condition was repeated, except for the 60° without BPB. Peak upper neck tension force and lateral moment, T1, T6, and T12 lateral rotation, lumbar axial and lateral shear forces, and lumbar axial moment (Mz) were extracted. Results With noBPB, upper neck tension (45° noBPB: 2.0 ± 0.1 kN; 60° noBPB: 1.8 kN) and lateral moment (45° noBPB: 31.7 ± 2.3 Nm; 60° noBPB: 29.2 Nm) were greater than with the BPB in all seatback angles (25° BPB: 1.3 ± 0.04 kN; 21.6 ± 0.1 Nm; 45° BPB: 1.2 ± 0.1 kN, 22.5 ± 2.3 Nm; 60° BPB: 1.2 ± 0.03 kN, 17.6 ± 0.7 Nm). Thoracic spine rotation was smaller in reclined conditions with noBPB (41°–59°) than with BPB (63°–80°). Lumbar axial forces decreased with increasing seatback angle with the BPB (from 2.2 to 1.2 kN). Lumbar Mz showed increasing unbelted shoulder rotation toward the seatback with increasing seatback angle (from 29.8 to 37.8 Nm) with the BPB but not without. Discussion The presence of the BPB may improve neck and spine coupled motion during far-side lateral impacts. However, increased lumbar Mz with the BPB in recline seatbacks requires further understanding.
Graci, ValentinaHumm, JohnHauschild, Hans
The skull-brain interface is structurally complex, and various simplification methods have been employed in existing head models to simulate the interaction between the skull and the brain. The modeling approach of the skull-brain interface determines how loads are transmitted to the interior, which is critical for accurately simulating head injuries. Thus, understanding the impact of current skull-brain interface modeling approaches on intracranial simulation results is significant. This study aims to explore the influence of different skull-brain interface modeling methods on the results of finite element models during the development of Advanced Chinese Human Body Models (AC-HUMs) based on the LS-DYNA solver. By comparing the responses of rigidly bonded connections (tied Contact), failure-allowing bonded contacts (tiebreak Contact), shared nodes, and arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian (ALE) methods under the Nahum 37 test load conditions, the study analyzes the effects of different modeling methods on pressure and deformation trends. Additionally, varying the failure values of tiebreak contact allows for the calculation of intracranial pressure responses under the same load conditions, revealing the influence of failure values on intracranial pressure responses. The results indicate that only the tiebreak model can simulate the transition from negative to positive pressure observed in experimental results, with significant variations in simulation outcomes corresponding to changes in failure values. This research provides a reference for the selection and optimization of finite element head modeling methods. Tiebreak contact is a better choice if the interface tearing effect needs to be modelled under linear impact conditions; Tied contact and shared nodes methods provide better computational stability and are more considered at the early stage of modelling; the ALE method is more common in studies for specific injuries and should be used in conjunction with the previously mentioned methods.
Gan, Qiuyujiang, YejieJunpeng, XuZhou, RunzhouZhang, LiyingJiang, Binhui
Real-world data show that abdominal loading due to a poor pelvis-belt restraint interaction is one of the primary causes of injury in belted rear-seat occupants, highlighting the importance of being able to assess it in crash tests. This study analyzes the phenomenon of submarining using video, time histories, and statistical analysis of data from a Hybrid III 5th female dummy seated in the rear seat of passenger vehicles in moderate overlap frontal crash tests. This study also proposes different metrics that can be used for detecting submarining in full-scale crash tests. The results show that apart from the high-speed videos, when comparing time-series graphs of various metrics, using a combination of iliac and lap belt loads was the most reliable method for detecting submarining. Five metrics from the dynamic sensors (the maximum iliac moment, maximum iliac force drop in 1 ms, time for 80% drop from peak iliac force, maximum pelvis rotation, and lumbar shear force) were all statistically significant predictors of submarining, but the presence of a rear seat-belt pretensioner was not significant. Though no one metric was able to provide accurate submarining judgement in all the cases, a combination of these significant metrics can be used along with video to gain more confidence in submarining judgement.
Jagtap, Sushant RJermakian, Jessica SEdwards, Marcy A
This paper investigates a novel seating arrangement where occupants face each other, focusing on occupant safety during a 56 km/h frontal impact, a standard test condition for assessing crashworthiness. A preliminary study was carried out, examining three distinct cases: a forward-facing 50th percentile occupant in third row seat, a rear-facing 50th percentile occupant in second row seat, and the interaction between these two occupant orientations. The study utilized both elastic flexible and rigid seat designs to analyze the impact on occupant kinematics and injury outcomes. The results demonstrate that the seating position has a significant influence on occupant injuries. Rear-facing occupants are primarily at risk due to seat design, whereas forward-facing occupants face a higher risk of injury from the increased space between occupants, lacking a reactive surface to mitigate impact forces. Notably, direct interaction between occupants did not result in severe injuries. However, interactions with the opposite seat structure did lead to lower extremity injuries. The study employed the Human Body Model developed by Humanetics to simulate and assess injuries for both rear-facing and forward-facing occupants. Additionally, the relationship between rear-facing seats and the front seat was explored in the context of vehicle environment and its impact on occupant safety. This research underscores the need for careful consideration of seating arrangements in intelligent cockpit design, particularly in face-to-face configurations. Our findings suggest that, while face-to-face seating, occupant interaction and seat design are critical factors that must be addressed to ensure occupant safety.
Liu, ChongLi, KunLiu, YutaoLv, XiaojiangWang, YonghuiZhou, DayongYang, Heping
Mitigating both neck and head injuries in the pediatric population relies heavily on improving our understanding of the underlying biomechanics of the pediatric cervical spine. The tensile response for individual motion segments and the whole cervical spine (WCS) has been reported, but there is no data characterizing the intersegmental kinematics of pediatric WCS under axial loading conditions. The structural response of motion segments and WCS provide valuable data for the design and validation of biofidelic physical and computational models for the pediatric population. However, the use of motion segment data to construct WCS response or the use of WCS axial response to accurately characterize intersegmental response may present limitations to accurately modeling the pediatric cervical spine response. In this secondary analysis of the work of Luck et al. (2008, 2013), the fixed-fixed, low load, quasi-static tensile response of the WCS and individual motion segments (O-C2, C4-C5, and C6-C7) of a six-year-old postmortem human surrogate (PMHS) was investigated to quantify and compare the intersegmental kinematics under both conditions. In the whole spine, O-C2, C3-C4, C6-C7, and C7-T1 exhibited a tensile response, C2-C3 and C5-C6 exhibited a compressive response, and C4-C5 did not exhibit an appreciable response in the axial loading direction. Furthermore, when compared to the tensile behavior of the individual motion segment load-controlled tests, C6-C7 exhibited reduced axial displacement and an increased stiffness at higher loads (≥13.5 N), suggesting the recruitment of more superficial ligamentous layers that span multiple vertebrae in the whole spine. Regarding vertical displacement and rotation, O-C2 exhibited the largest amount of rotation of 5.57 degrees in flexion and all segments exhibited some amount of anterior–posterior (AP) displacement. The intersegmental kinematics provide biomechanical response data that may support both physical and computational surrogate design and validation as well as data for comparison to isolated FSU testing conditions.
Liu, MirandaLuck, Jason F.
The goal of this study was to gather and compare kinematic response and injury data on both female and male whole-body Post-mortem Human Surrogates (PMHS) responses to Underbody Blast (UBB) loading. Midsized males (50th percentile, MM) have historically been most used in biomechanical testing and were the focus of the Warrior Injury Assessment Manikin (WIAMan) program, thus this population subgroup was selected to be the baseline for female comparison. Both small female (5th percentile, SF) and large female (75th percentile, LF) PMHS were included in the test series to attempt to discern whether differences between male and female responses were predominantly driven by sex or size. Eleven tests, using 20 whole-body PMHS, were conducted by the research team. Preparation of the rig and execution of the tests took place at the Aberdeen Proving Grounds (APG) in Aberdeen, MD. Two PMHS were used in each test. The Accelerative Loading Fixture (ALF) version 2, located at APG’s Bear Point range was used for all male and female whole-body tests in this series. The ALF was an outdoor test rig that was driven by a buried explosive charge, to accelerate a platform holding two symmetrically mounted seats. The platform was designed as a large, rigid frame with a deformable center section that could be tuned to simulate the floor deformation of a vehicle during a UBB event. PMHS were restrained with a 5-point harness, common in military vehicle seats. Six-degree-of-freedom motion blocks were fixed to L3, the sacrum, and the left and right iliac wings. A three-degree-of freedom block was fixed to T12. Strain gages were placed on L4 and multiple locations on the pelvis. Accelerometers on the floor and seat of the ALF provided input data for each PMHS’ feet and pelvis. Time histories and mean peak responses in z-axis acceleration were similar among the three PMHS groups in this body region. Injury outcomes were different and seemed to be influenced by both sex and size contributions. Small females incurred pelvis injuries in absence of lumbar injures. Midsized males had lumbar vertebral body fractures without pelvis injuries. And large females with injuries had both pelvis and lumbar VB fractures. This study provides evidence supporting the need for female biomechanical testing to generate female response and injury thresholds. Without the inclusion of female PMHS, the differences in the injury patterns between the small female and midsized male groups would not have been recognized. Standard scaling methods assume equivalent injury patterns between the experimental and scaled data. In this study, small female damage occurred in a different anatomical structure than for the midsized males. This is an important discovery for the development of anthropomorphic test devices, injury criteria, and injury mitigating technologies. The clear separation of small female damage results, in combination with seat speeds, suggest that the small female pelvis injury threshold in UBB events lies between 4 – 5 m/s seat speed. No inference can be made about the small female lumbar threshold, other than it is likely at higher speeds and/or over longer duration. Male lumbar spine damage occurred in both the higher- and lower lower-rate tests, indicating the injury threshold would be below the seat pulses tested in these experiments. Large females exhibited injury patterns that reflected both the small female and midsized male groups – with damaged PMHS having fractures in both pelvis and lumbar, and in both higher- and lower- rate tests. The difference in damage patterns between the sex and size groups should be considered in the development of injury mitigation strategies to protect across the full population.
Pietsch, HollieCristino, DanielleDanelson, KerryBolte, JohnMason, MatthewKemper, AndrewCavanaugh, JohnHardy, Warren
Most of the skin injuries caused by traffic accidents, sports, falls, etc. are in the intermediate strain rate range (1-100s-1), and the injuries may occur at different sites, impact velocities, and orientations. To investigate the multifactorial mechanical properties of rat skin at intermediate strain rates, a three-factor, three-level experimental protocol was established using the standard orthogonal table L9(34), which includes site (upper dorsal, lower dorsal, and ventral side), strain rate (1s-1, 10s-1, and 100 s-1), and sampling orientation (0°, 45°, and 90° relative to the spine). Uniaxial tensile tests were performed on rat skin samples according to the protocol to obtain stress-stretch ratio curves. Failure strain energy was selected as the index, and the influence of each factor on these indexes, the differences between levels of each factor, and the influence of errors on the results were quantified by analysis of variance (ANOVA). The results show that the site factor has the greatest influence on the skin’s mechanical properties within the intermediate strain rate range, followed by the strain rate factor, and the sampling orientation factor has the least influence. The mechanical properties of the lower dorsal and ventral skin differ significantly, but there is no apparent difference in the mechanical properties between the upper dorsal and ventral skin. As the strain rate increases, the failure strain energy of the skin increases significantly. There are no significant differences in the mechanical properties of skin samples in the three sampling orientations.
Yang, ShuaijunSong, XueweiZhao, HuiQiu, JinlongWang, NanYu, Tianming
Oblique motor vehicle crashes can cause serious head or brain injuries due to contact with interior vehicle structures even with the deployment of air bags, as they are not yet completely successful in preventing traumatic brain injury. Rotational head velocity is strongly correlated to the risk of brain injury, and this head motion is potentially related to the tangential friction force developed during contact between the head and air bags. Although crash test dummy head skins are designed with appropriate mass properties and anthropometry to simulate the normal direction impact response of the human head, it is not known whether they accurately represent the frictional properties of human skin during air bag interaction. This study experimentally characterized the dynamic friction coefficient between human/dummy skins and air bag fabrics using a pin-on-disc tribometer. Human skin samples were harvested from five locations (left and right forehead, left and right cheek, and chin) from male and female postmortem human subjects (PMHSs); some samples had previously been frozen and some were fresh. Crash dummy head skin samples were obtained from Hybrid III, ES-2re, and THOR-50M 50th-percentile male anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs) and were characterized in both chalked and unchalked conditions. Fabric samples were obtained from five different air bags spanning various vehicle manufacturers and interior mounting locations. Neither sex, linear speed, nor the harvested skin location on the head played a significant role on the dynamic friction between PMHS skin samples and air bag fabrics, while PMHS skin samples that had not been previously frozen had a higher coefficient of friction than those that had. Further, increasing normal load reduced the dynamic friction coefficient between PMHS skin samples and air bag fabrics. Unchalked ATD head skins exhibited significantly higher dynamic friction coefficients than PMHS skins for the air bag fabrics tested. The presence of a thin chalk layer on ATD skins reduced friction and produced dynamic friction coefficients with air bag fabrics that were not significantly different from those of PMHS skins; however, neither unchalked nor chalked ATD head skins differentiated the air bag fabric dynamic friction coefficients in the same pattern as the PMHS skin samples.
Noll, ScottDong, ShengKang, Yun-SeokBolte, JohnStammen, JasonMoorhouse, Kevin
This SAE Information Report attempts to provide a list of potential digital data recording devices that may be interrogated for forensic purposes. This list may not be exhaustive, but it lists sources of data that may be useful in the investigation of incidents such as motor vehicle collisions. This list is not intended to give instruction on how to access and preserve the data. This list is only to inform investigators that these known data sources may contain important information and should, if applicable, be searched for and queried. It is recognized that as the state of technology advances there may be additional data sources that become available.
Crash Data Collection and Analysis Standards Committee
The research on connected vehicles has attracted much interest of governments and research institutions in these days. As researchers who have been deeply intrigued, we are particularly interested in investigating the lane changing issues of connected buses when exiting bus stops. In order to examine the utilities of both the buses and social vehicles in a connected environment, we employ the game theory to analyze the interactions between them. A two-player, non-cooperative, non-zero-sum game model was built in this paper. We analyzed 5 different scenarios for bus exiting at bus bay stops and curbside bus stops. The payoffs considered in the game model were mainly from the perspective of safety and time. Besides the commonly studied safety issues caused by collisions, we supplement the existing literature by adding on non-collision injuries caused by improper driving behaviors (e.g. excessive acceleration). Moreover, unlike the lane changing game between two social vehicles, bus, as one of the dominant players in the game, carry more passengers and its impact on traffic delays cannot be neglected in the payoff of the time. According to the payoff functions, we deduced the Nash equilibrium solutions for the game between the connected bus and the connected social vehicle. The Nash equilibria in different conditions are analyzed. It is verified that the Nash equilibrium solutions obtained with the changes in parameters in the model is in accordance with the logic of rational players. The model proposed in this paper can provide reliable supports in terms of the lane changing behaviors for bus exiting in a connected environment.
Du, XiaojingYao, Ronghan
Lower extremity injuries caused by floor plate impacts through the axis of the lower leg are a major source of injury and disability for civilian and military vehicle occupants. A collection of PMHS pendulum impacts was revisited to obtain data for paired booted/unbooted test on the same leg. Five sets of paired pendulum impacts (10 experiments in total) were found using four lower legs from two PMHS. The PMHS size and age was representative of an average young adult male. In these tests, a PMHS leg was impacted by a 3.4 or 5.8 kg pendulum with an initial velocity of 5, 7, or 10 m/s (42-288 J). A matching LS-DYNA finite element model was developed to replicate the experiments and provide additional energy, strain, and stress data. Simulation results matched the PMHS data using peak values and CORA curve correlations. Experimental forces ranged between 1.9 and 12.1 kN experimentally and 2.0 and 11.7 kN in simulation. Combat boot usage reduced the peak force by 36% experimentally (32% in simulation) by compressing the sole and insole with similar mitigations for calcaneus strain. The simulated Von Mises stress contours showed the boot both mitigating and shifting stress concentrations from the calcaneus in unbooted impacts to the talus-tibia joint in the booted impacts, which may explain why some previous studies have observed shifts to tibia injuries with boot or padding usage.
Hampton, Carolyn E.Kleinberger, MichaelSchlick, MichaelYoganandan, NarayanPintar, Frank A.
Unmanned aircraft systems (UAS), commonly known as drones, are part of a new and budding industry in the United States. Economic and public benefits associated with UAS use across multiple commercial sectors are driving new regulations which alter the stringent laws currently restricting UAS flights over people. As new regulations are enacted and more UAS populate the national airspace, there is a need to both understand and quantify the risk associated with UAS impacts with the uninvolved public. The purpose of this study was to investigate the biomechanical response and injury outcomes of Post Mortem Human Surrogates (PMHS) subjected to UAS head impacts. For this work, PMHS were tested with differing UAS vehicles at multiple impact angles, locations and speeds. Using a custom designed launching device, UAS vehicles were accelerated into the frontal, parietal, or vertex portions of subjects’ craniums at speeds up to 22 m/s. Of the 35 UAS impacts carried out, one AIS 2+ injury was observed: a 13 cm linear skull fracture resulting from a Phantom 3 impact. Additionally, injury risk curves used in automotive testing were found to over predict the risk of injury in UAS impact scenarios. Finally, localized skull deformation was observed during severe impacts; the effect that this deformation had on measured kinematics should be further evaluated. Overall, the study found that AIS 2+ head injuries may occur as a result of UAS impacts and that automotive injury metrics may not be able to accurately predict head injury risk in UAS impact scenarios.
Stark, David B.Willis, Arrianna K.Eshelman, ZachKang, Yun-SeokRamachandra, RakshitBolte IV, John H.McCrink, Matthew
An anatomically detailed rhesus monkey brain FE model was developed to simulate in vivo responses of the brain of sub-human primates subjected to rotational accelerations resulting in diffuse axonal injury (DAI). The material properties used in the monkey model are those in the GHBMC 50th percentile male head model (Global Human Body Model Consortium). The angular loading simulations consisted of coronal, oblique and sagittal plane rotations with the center of rotation in neck to duplicate experimental conditions. Maximum principal strain (MPS) and Cumulative strain damage measure (CSDM) were analyzed for various white matter structures such as the cerebrum subcortical white matter, corpus callosum and brainstem. The MPS in coronal rotation were 45% to 54% higher in the brainstem, 8% to 48% higher in the corpus callosum, 13% to 22% higher in the white matter when compared to those in oblique and sagittal rotations, suggesting that more severe DAI was expected from coronal and oblique rotations as compared to that from sagittal rotation. The level 1+ DAI was associated with 1.3 to 1.42 MPS and 50% CSDM (0.5) responses in the brainstem, corpus callosum and cerebral white matter. The mass scaling method, sometimes referred to as Holbourn's inverse 2/3 power law, used for development of human brain injury criterion was evaluated to understand the effect of geometrical and anatomical differences between human and animal head. Based on simulations conducted with the animal and human models in three different planes - sagittal, coronal and horizontal - the scaling from animal to human models are not supported due to lack of geometrical similitude between the animal and human brains. Thus, the scaling method used in the development of brain injury criterion for rotational acceleration/velocity is unreliable.
Arora, TusharZhang, LiyingPrasad, Priya
Crash safety researchers have an increased concern regarding the decreased thoracic deflection and the contributing injury causation factors among the elderly population. Sternum fractures are categorized as moderate severity injuries, but can have long term effects depending on the fragility and frailty of the occupant. Current research has provided detail on rib morphology, but very little information on sternum morphology, sternum fracture locations, and mechanisms of injury. The objective of this study is two-fold (1) quantify sternum morphology and (2) document sternum fracture locations using computed tomography (CT) scans and crash data. Thoracic CT scans from the University of Michigan Hospital database were used to measure thoracic depth, manubriosternal joint, sternum thickness and bone density. The sternum fracture locations and descriptions were extracted from 63 International Center for Automotive Medicine (ICAM) crash cases, of which 22 cases had corresponding CT scans. The University of Michigan Internal Review Board (HUM00043599 and HUM00041441) approved the use of crash cases and CT scan data. The sternum morphomics data showed the thoracic depth increased, except for the 60-74-year-old age group. The average sternum thickness was greater in the older age groups. The sternum bone density decreased from youngest to oldest age groups. The angle between the manubrium and the sternum body decreased by 5.6° between the youngest and oldest age groups. The frequency of sternum fractures increased after age 45. Fractures were most frequent in the sternum body. The seat belt webbing was coded as the source of 54% of the sternum fractures.
Bunn, BarbaraJohannson, SuzanneKohoyda-Inglis, CarlaWang, StewartParenteau, ChantalHolcombe, Sven
Road accident between pedestrian and motor vehicle causes severe injuries and even death of pedestrian. The accident statistics show that the possibility of injury to pedestrian is higher in case of collision with car on busy roads. In car and pedestrian collisions, the pedestrian’s head hits with car bonnet and suffer from multiple injuries such as skull fractures and brain injury. The role of car bonnet structural strength plays an important role in pedestrian head injury level. To provide enough structural strength the high bonnet thickness is provided with under bonnet stiffeners, however thick bonnet and stiffeners reduces deformation of the bonnet during collision and increases injury level to pedestrian. Hence optimum bonnet thickness, least number and geometry of stiffeners and enough structural strength is important for bonnet to reduce injury level. The aim of this study is to analyse the effect of car bonnet thickness, number and arrangement of under bonnet stiffeners on head injury levels with the help of head injury criteria (HIC). Head Injury Criteria (HIC) is a measure of the likelihood of head injury arising from an impact during a car crash. It indicatesthe level of injury caused during a particular crash. A typical modern car bonnet is selected for investigation with variety of bonnet material thickness and different configurations of under bonnet stiffeners and head injury criteria (HIC) is computed with the help of computer modelling. Further, head linear velocity, acceleration and head injury risk are predicted for probability of skull fracture. The geometry of bonnet is optimized with the help of optimization technique and optimized bonnet geometry is validated experimentally by designing a bonnet test facility and head form imparter.
Thombare, Dr. Dhananjay G
The interior components of a passenger vehicle are designed to provide comfort and safety to its occupants. In the event of accident, vehicle interiors are primary source of injuries when occupants interact with them. Vehicle interiors consists of Instrument panel (IP), center console, seats and controls in front of seating position etc. Severity of the injuries depends on the energy dissipating characteristics, profiles, projections of different interior components. These are assessed by ECE R21 and IS12553 head form impact tests. To evaluate the Head form impact performance on Interior components, Computer Aided Engineering (CAE) simulations are extensively used during the vehicle development. In order to predict failure of plastic components and snap joints which might lead to expose sharp edges, it is critical to model plastic material and snap joint. Vehicle interiors are certified for head form impact requirements based on physical testing where dashboard samples from productions tools are used. At this stage of development, if any failure occurs then changes in interior design becomes very expensive and time consuming. To avoid this situation, CAE based failure predictions and injury performance evaluations are done during initial design phase of product development when changes are easily implemented without time and cost penalties. This paper describes the development of vehicle interior using CAE based head form impact simulations and predicting the failures like sharp edges exposure, structural integrity or joint failures. For accurate prediction of these failures in CAE based vehicle interior development, plastic material characterization and snap joint failure characterization are done.
Suryawanshi, YuvrajJoshi, KedarLambate, SachinJadhav, Vilas
A strong local initiative in Campinas - Brazil is studying how to be more effective in the improvement of road safety in order to align to other worldwide initiatives with similar goals. This paper describes the Brazilian initiative’s approach to the challenge of being aligned with iGLAD (Initiative for the Global Harmonization of Accident Data, starting as a project in 2011 and collecting data since 2007) on the delivery of its first set of accident cases from 2016. The Brazilian source of data started as a pilot project collecting local data with the aim of extending it within the next years to a larger region. In fact, a consistent method for the development of strategies and measures to prevent accidents and mitigate injury severity comes from accident database analysis. Although databases such as national statistics are available for many countries for assessing accident situations, examining trends, or carrying out similar analysis; the identification of accident and injury causation and the evaluation of countermeasures require a higher level of detail. Comparison with other regions or countries in terms of that analysis has been an aim for many researchers. For this reason, several in-depth accident data collection projects have emerged worldwide in recent years. Unfortunately, comparative analysis of in-depth data from different countries is difficult or even impossible due to different standards for data collection and coding. For that purpose, Brazil needs to join the methods used in iGLAD, i.e. to process and merge the different data samples describing and overviewing the current status in terms of case counts, marginal distributions as is done by the countries participating from Europe, Asia, Australia and North and South America (currently only Brazil) providing data for iGLAD. As an application example, the iGLAD dataset from 2007 to 2015 was used to analyze the distributions of accident types, presence of safety systems, characteristics of collision deformation and injury severity for each country and to provide country comparisons. The status of Brazil can be assessed in that frame and also capabilities for pre-crash analysis can be assessed. Exemplary statistical assessment of injury probability and descriptive statistics for comparison between different countries were given as a result of the analysis and for the Brazilian sample will give the first trends. This paper gives an overview of the Brazilian data in the framework of the iGLAD initiative as a new field crash data set and shows its unique opportunities for road accident analysis in a global scope, which are not provided by any other accident data source and will give stronger support for efficient and consistent traffic policies. The analysis according to the harmonized data helps to address challenges of road safety on a global level, whether through the identification of country-specific issues and measures to address them or the harmonization of legislation and ratings.
Longton, AlejandroSchulze, OliverBakker, JörgParera, NuriaLeitao, Joel
This user’s manual covers the instrumented arm for the Hybrid III 5th Percentile Small Female dummy as well as the SID –IIs dummy. It is intended for technicians and engineers who have an interest in assessing arm injury from the use of frontal and side impact airbags. It covers the construction, disassembly and reassembly, available instrumentation, and segment masses.
Dummy Testing and Equipment Committee
This study used finite element (FE) simulations to analyze the injury mechanisms of driver spine fracture during frontal crashes in the World Endurance Championship (WEC) series and possible countermeasures are suggested to help reduce spine fracture risk. This FE model incorporated the Total Human Model for Safety (THUMS) scaled to a driver, a model of the detailed racecar cockpit and a model of the seat/restraint systems. A frontal impact deceleration pulse was applied to the cockpit model. In the simulation, the driver chest moved forward under the shoulder belt and the pelvis was restrained by the crotch belt and the leg hump. The simulation predicted spine fracture at T11 and T12. It was found that a combination of axial compression force and bending moment at the spine caused the fractures. The axial compression force and bending moment were generated by the shoulder belt down force as the driver’s chest moved forward. The axial compression force at the spine was also induced by the forces from the crotch belt and the leg hump. Based on these mechanisms, the modifications were made to help reduce the spine fracture risk. The seat back angle was raised, the shoulder belt anchor was lifted, the crotch belt anchor was moved forward, the seat pad thickness was increased and the seat pad stiffness was reduced. These modifications allowed more forward motion of the pelvis and reduced the shoulder belt down force, and generated no spine fracture.
Katsuhara, TadasukeTakahira, YoshikiHayashi, ShigekiKitagawa, YuichiYasuki, Tsuyoshi
In 2010, the UN General Assembly proclaimed the period 2011-2020 as the Decade of Action for Road Safety, with a goal to stabilize and then reduce the forecast level of road traffic fatalities around the world. Road traffic accidents are the 8th cause of death in Brazil, according to World Health Rankings. There are few studies around the world with respect to cost due to traffic accidents, however a study performed in 2011 estimates that were spent R$ 44.6 billion in Brazil. So, the recent Brazilian regulations updates have enforced the automakers to develop vehicles safer to passengers and pedestrians. These regulations focus on prevent, reduce or minimize the traumas and injuries caused by different types of vehicular accidents. The present work was developed to optimize the driver restraint system, while focusing on minimizing the trauma during a vehicle frontal impact. The driver restraint system was optimized considering the complex interaction between the ATD and the different components that assemble the restraint system, like airbag, safety belts with/without pre-tensioners, seatbelt load limiting devices and steering column stroke. The numerical computational simulations were performed based on Design of Experiments (DOE), which is a powerful tool that allows for multiple input factors to be manipulated determining their effect on a desired output. The numerical computational model created was initially correlated with a physical test, and then 36 numerical simulations were performed in order to create the optimization matrix. The optimized parameters provided by the analysis of the DOE orthogonal matrix were simulated and showed a significant reduction at probability of injuries due to vehicle frontal impact. The computational numerical optimization tool helped to reduce the cost and time development of a safer vehicle that satisfies the current Brazilian regulations, focusing on driver performance. The results presented excellent correlation and the goals of the optimization were achieved showing that this tool is reliable and helpful for current and future developments.
de Lima, AndersonAlmeida, Eduardo L.Gouvea, Marco A.
ABSTRACT A full-scale crash test of a USMC CH-46 helicopter airframe was conducted at NASA-Langley Research Center. One of the internal experiments was an assessment of mobile aircrew restraint concepts. Two Hybrid III Pedestrian Anthropomorphic Test Devices (ATD's) were positioned in a standing position, just aft of the crew door. On the left side, a traditional gunner's belt was employed. On the right side, the Mobile Aircrew Restraint System (MARS) was employed with the Aircrew Endurance vest. The motivation behind this experiment was based on several mishap-based injuries of mobile aircrew that were using traditional gunner's belts. However, correlation of presumed injury causes with equipment deficiencies was difficult because of a near total void of mobile aircrew restraint testing data in a system-level environment. For the condition tested, the measured results for the two ATD's indicated a dramatic reduction in injury probability when employing the MARS. In contrast, the ATD equipped with the gunner's belt experienced accelerations and forces that could generally be considered lethal.
Bark, Lindley
This work is based on a current project funded by the United States Army Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) Program and is being conducted with the Tank Automotive Research, Development and Engineering Center (TARDEC) Ground Systems Survivability (GSS) Team and Paradigm Research and Engineering. The focus of this project is to develop an advanced and novel sensing and activation strategy for Pyrotechnic Restraint Systems, Air Bags and other systems that may require activation. The overriding technical challenge is to activate these systems to effectively protect the Soldier during blast events in addition to Crash, Rollover and Other Injury Causing events. These activations of Pyrotechnic systems must occur in fractions of milliseconds as compared to typical automotive crashes. By investigating systems outside of typical accelerometer based applications and activations, the potential exists to exploit systems that require little power, are self-contained and provide the required output for the desired result. As such Constant-Flux Magnetostrictive Sensors shall be evaluated in a self-contained environment to provide the output during these events. By activating the Pyrotechnic Restraint Systems and Air Bag Systems early in Blast Events, the systems can Restrain the Occupant and provide flail protection from surfaces within the vehicle. As the system is developed various test scenarios will be introduced to activate these systems and design a robust sensing and activating strategy.
Karwaczynski, SebastianUras, Mehmet H.
A considerable number of victims in the traffic are originated by some kind of side collisions. Around 30% of the fatalities occur due to these kinds of accidents [1][2]. Due to this fact, the development of the occupant protection for this kind of load cases becomes indispensable. For this, different kinds of crash tests were and are being developed around the world according to the characteristics inherent of each market. Barrier weight, impact angle, barrier type (pole or movable deformable barrier) and dummy types are some of the variations observed. The severity of injuries caused by side crashes is very high as the occupant is very close to the impacting object and the crush space is almost nothing when compared to frontal impact. To decrease these injuries the following features of the vehicle must be developed: structure (high strength materials, reinforcements, etc), restraint system (side airbags, curtain airbags, pre-tensioners, seats, etc), design and package (distances between occupant and interior parts, flat surfaces, etc), high speed sensing systems (accelerometers, pressure sensors, etc). This paper will present a comparative analysis between these different types of tests and demonstrate future tendencies and the challenges for the Brazilian market and the technologies available during the vehicle development capable of making the products safer when it comes to side impact collisions.
Prado, Gustavo ImbriziPereira, Eduardo AlvesLacerda, Rogério Madrid
The FMVSS 208 advanced air bag rule has brought new technologies into the automotive industry. Low Risk Deployment, Suppression, or a combination of both, have prevailed in the industry to meet the right front passenger requirements for FMVSS 208 compliance. This rule provides the options to conduct low risk deployment (LRD) airbag tests with a 12-months-old infant dummy riding in a rear facing child seat and child dummies representing 3 years and 6 years old children. If the LRD tests do not meet the injury criteria set by NHTSA, vehicle manufacturers have to choose the another option for the suppressing airbag system when infants or children are present at the passenger seat. But this suppressing systems is not the cost effective method, also, contains potential quality problem such as misrecognition passenger age. Thus, the car makers start to choose LRD requirement option and develop new LRD passenger airbag system. A low risk deployment passenger airbag system has been developed to reduce the risk of injuries caused by airbag inflation to small size occupants and improve the restraint of adult occupants in high speed crashes as well. The new passenger airbag system has mounted on the instrument panel in such a way to reduce the inflator outputs. This paper presents a new methodology for improvement of airbag deployment using experimental and analytical research. The significant parameters were determined from screening process of the experiment data. As a result of the number of tests conducted at different conditions, this study was able to determine the range of relevant parameters. Additionally, using simulation model, a parametric study was done. It make to figure out main design factors of low risk deployment of the passenger airbag
Kim, Hyun
SMART RRS: Project Results2012-36-054810/2/2012
SMART RRS is an FP7 SST 2007 RTD1 European collaborative project funded by the EC with the participation of 10 institutions from 5 countries. The project aims to develop a new smart road restraint system that will reduce the number of deaths and injuries caused in road traffic accidents by integrating primary and tertiary sensor systems in it, providing greater protection to all road users, warning motorists and emergency services of danger for prevention purposes and alerting emergency teams of accidents as they happen to minimize response time to the exact location of the incident. This new smart restraint system will: Reduce the number of accidents through better information on the actual state of the road and traffic flow (climatic conditions, traffic flow, obstructions, hazards, accidents). Eliminate dangerous profiles from road restraint systems (crash barriers) that currently endanger vulnerable road users. Optimize road safety by providing exact information of where and when accidents happen in real-time. The project obtained interesting results from an in-depth review of motorcycle accidents, which shows that some of the most aggressive elements for riders are protection systems installed on roadsides. These systems may be continuous, punctual, and rigid or wire rope. It is also learnt that the accidents involving roadside protective systems include high speeds and the rider commonly impacts the barrier in an upward position, with severe outcome. Some of the most important injuries received by riders are blunt impacts to the head, member amputation and severe thoracic intrusion. Also, the dynamics of such accidents were researched, providing valuable information on where and how accidents take place and their outcome. Most of the accidents occur on rural roads, where a rider loses control and leaves the road, impacting some roadside obstacle. This impact is generally very severe, as actual roadside protection systems are not designed to absorb energy from the riders but from heavy vehicles instead. The next step was to analyze actual road restraint systems evaluation methods and to include simulation and testing phases for both systems and subsystems, providing a previous idea of how a barrier would behave in case of accident. All the previous steps have been completed and are now presented as a finished project during this year. The system includes primary and tertiary systems, followed by some evaluations of different designs of road barrier and energy absorbers. The project included barrier simulations and actual tests in specialized facilities, where the behavior of the system was analyzed.
Davila, ArturoMolina, ReneAlba, Juan Jose
ABSTRACT With US military casualties mounting due to Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs) and other roadside bombs, improving the protective capabilities of armored vehicles for service personnel is of paramount importance. Accurate numerical simulations of the blast event provide a means to quickly and economically evaluate the blast-protection performance of armored vehicles, and to develop improved blast countermeasures. This effort developed computational simulations of a system intended to mitigate blast accelerations to a level where the acceleration is no longer a lethal threat to the occupants of an armored vehicle. The hypothesis is that through the manipulation of the mass ratio, stiffness and damping properties of a dual-hull system, the capability of current Mine Resistant Ambush Protected (MRAP) vehicles can be greatly improved. The results show that, in comparison to the standard single-hull vehicle, the dual-hull vehicle reduces head injury criteria by 95.7%, neck compression by 78.3%, chest acceleration by 97.5% and leg forces by an average of 97%. Further work should focus on developing a realistic structural interface between the hulls and evaluating it using simulation, followed by fabrication and testing of limited test articles and full-vehicle systems.
Schaffner, GrantMiller, Adam
A large study of rear-end collisions was conducted for the neck injury indicators and test procedures. Neck injury in low-speed rear-end collisions is a big issue because there are a lot of patients despite low-speed rear-end collisions. Europe, Korea and Japan introduced the specific part in the New Car Assessment Program to reduce whiplash injury in low-speed rear-end collisions. From the legal point of view, to reduce the frequency and severity of injuries caused by rearward displacement of the head in rear-end collision, USA, EC, Korea, Japan and others internationally cooperated to make the global technical regulation (GTR) in UNECE/WP29. In 2008, after much meandering, GTR No. 7 head restraints were established. However the GTR No.7 is not a unique regulation because many countries had their own opinions and domestic regulations, and many questions related to injury criteria and biomechanical issues of dummy remain unresolved. The Biofidelic Rear Impact Dummy II (BioRIDII) is regarded as possessing the most similar characteristics to human volunteers and Post-mortem Human Subjects(PMHS) in terms of its response to low-speed rear impacts. Although a great amount of research was conducted for repeatability and reproducibility on the BioRIDII, the research results did not directly suggest the neck injury criteria and limit values for the regulation. The purpose of this research is to review the proper neck injury indicators for the BioRID-II through the low-rear sled test on the 3set BioRIDII ver-g. A series of sled tests were conducted to assess the adequacy of neck injury indicators for the repeatability and reproducibility of results obtained on the 3set BioRIDII. The sled tests were performed according to the test procedure proposed by the Korea New Car assessment Program (KNCAP). Neck injury indicators including NIC, Nkm, upper & lower Fx, upper & lower Fz, T1 X acc, Head X acc, were analysed for each dummy. The results show that some criteria, such as the neck shear force, exhibit coefficient variation (CV) up to 20.
Kim, Si-Wooshim, So-JungSuh, Myung-Won
Nerve Level Traumatic Brain Injury in in Vivo/in Vitro Experiments2010-22-001011/3/2010
The number of traffic deaths in Japan was 4,914 in 2009. Since the head was the most common site of injury in traffic accidents (2,302, 47%), traumatic brain injury causes the fatalities in these accidents. The aim of the present study was to quantify micro injuries in the animal brain for gaining insight and understanding of the human brain injury tolerance. Using porcine brain matter, in vitro stress relaxation experiments and in vivo impact experiments were conducted. In both experiments, the distribution of the damage ratio of the transverse to longitudinal length of cells, hereafter, referred to as an aspect ratio, in the brain matter under loading was examined. In the in vitro stress relaxation experiments, specimens were compressed vertically with a compression velocity of 1 mm/s, and the displacement was held for 140 sec when the compression strain reached the target strain. In the experiments, there were five categories of compression strain: 10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 percent. Regarding the aspect ratio of the cell body, it was 1.5 or less in a no-load condition. On the other hand, it was observed to be greater than 1.5 in the results from the experiments if the compression strain was 30% or more. The results from the experiments show that a compression strain between 20% and 30% corresponds to the threshold for the extremely deformed cell at the micro level. In the in vivo impact experiments, pigs in an unconscious state were exposed through craniotomy, and their exposed brains were hit with a ram at a low speed of 3.3 m/s and a high speed of 7.2 m/s, respectively. It was revealed that the number of cells in which the aspect ratio was greater than 1.5 increased if the impact is provided under the high speed. At the same time, the results indicated that cell deformation was dependent on the ram velocity in the brain matter. Thus, the compression strain on the entire brain from the direction of the force applied to the brain may be one criterion for assessment of brain damage.
Matsui, YasuhiroNishimoto, Tetsuya
Worldwide, 1.2 million people die in road crashes yearly; 43,000 just in Europe. This implies a cost to the European society of approximately 160 billion euro, making use of 10% of all health care resources. Sharp objects like crash barriers may lead vulnerable road users into serious injuries. Different road restraint system designs have been developed in recent years to improve vulnerable road users' safety. SMART RRS is an FP7 SST 2007 RTD1 European collaborative project funded by the EC with the participation of 10 institutions from 5 countries. The project aims to develop a new smart road restraint system that will reduce the number of deaths and injuries caused in road traffic accidents by integrating primary and tertiary sensor systems in it, providing greater protection to all road users, warning motorists and emergency services of danger for prevention purposes and alerting emergency teams of accidents as they happen to minimize response time to the exact location of the incident. This new smart restraint system will: - Reduce the number of accidents through better information on the actual state of the road and traffic flow (climatic conditions, traffic flow, obstructions, hazards, accidents). - Eliminate dangerous profiles from road restraint systems (crash barriers) that currently endanger vulnerable road users. - Optimize road safety by providing exact information of where and when accidents happen in real time. The project obtained interesting results from an in-depth review of motorcycle accidents, showing that the most aggressive elements for riders are protection systems installed on roadsides (continuous, punctual, rigid, wire rope). Also the accidents involving roadside protective systems include high speeds and the rider commonly impacts the barrier in an upward position, with severe outcome. Some of the most important injuries received by riders are blunt impacts to the head, member amputation and severe thoracic intrusion.
Nombela, MarioDavila, ArturoAlba, Juan Josede Miguel, Juan Luis
Mechanisms of Traumatic Rupture of the Aorta and Associated Peri-isthmic Motion and Deformation2008-22-001011/3/2008
This study investigated the mechanisms of traumatic rupture of the aorta (TRA). Eight unembalmed human cadavers were tested using various dynamic blunt loading modes. Impacts were conducted using a 32-kg impactor with a 152-mm face, and high-speed seatbelt pretensioners. High-speed biplane x-ray was used to visualize aortic motion within the mediastinum, and to measure deformation of the aorta. An axillary thoracotomy approach was used to access the peri-isthmic region to place radiopaque markers on the aorta. The cadavers were inverted for testing. Clinically relevant TRA was observed in seven of the tests. Peak average longitudinal Lagrange strain was 0.644, with the average peak for all tests being 0.208 ± 0.216. Peak intraluminal pressure of 165 kPa was recorded. Longitudinal stretch of the aorta was found to be a principal component of injury causation. Stretch of the aorta was generated by thoracic deformation, which is required for injury to occur. The presence of atherosclerosis was demonstrated to promote injury. The isthmus of the aorta moved dorsocranially during frontal impact and submarining loading modes. The aortic isthmus moved medially and anteriorly during impact to the left side. The results of this study provide a better understanding of the mechanisms associated with TRA, and can be used for the validation of finite element models developed for the examination and prediction of TRA.
Hardy, Warren N.Shah, Chirag S.Mason, Matthew J.Kopacz, James M.Yang, King H.King, Albert I.Van Ee, Chris A.Bishop, Jennifer L.Banglmaier, Richard F.Bey, Michael J.Morgan, Richard M.Digges, Kennerly H.
Age and Gender Based Biomechanical Shape and Size Analysis of the Pediatric Brain2008-22-000311/3/2008
Injuries caused by motor vehicle crashes (MVCs) are the leading cause of head injury and death for children in the United States. This study aims to describe the shape and size (morphologic) changes of the cerebrum, cerebellum, brainstem, and ventricles of the pediatric occupant to better predict injury and assess how these changes affect finite element model (FEM) response. To quantify morphologic differences in the brain, a Generalized Procrustes Analysis (GPA) with a sliding landmark method was conducted to isolate morphologic changes using magnetic resonance images of 63 normal subjects. This type of geometric morphometric analysis was selected for its ability to identify homologous landmarks on structures with few true landmarks and isolate the shape and size of the individuals studied. From the resulting landmark coordinates, the shape and size changes were regressed against age to develop a model describing morphologic changes in the pediatric brain as a function of age. The most statistically significant shape change was in the cerebrum with p-values of 0.00346 for males and 0.00829 for females. The age-based model explains over 80% of the variation in size in the cerebrum. Using size and shape models, affine transformations were applied to the SIMon FEM to determine differences in response given differences in size and size plus shape. The geometric centroid of the elements exceeding 15% strain was calculated and compared to the geometric centroid of the entire structure. Given the same Haversine pulse, the centroid location, a metric for the spatial distribution of the elements exceeding an injury threshold, varied based on which transformation was applied to the model. To assess the overall response of the model, three injury metrics were examined to determine the magnitude of the metrics each element sustained and the overall volume of elements that experienced that value. These results suggested that the overall response of the model was driven by the variation in size, with little variation due to changes in shape. This study demonstrates a new methodology to quantify the shape and size variation of the brain from infancy to adulthood. The use of the changes in shape and size when applied to a FEM suggests that there are differences in the spatial distribution of the elements that exceed a specific threshold based on shape but the overall volume of elements experiencing the specified magnitude was more dependent on the changes in the size of the model with little change due to shape.
Danelson, Kerry A.Geer, Carol P.Stitzel, Joel D.Slice, Dennis E.Takhounts, Erik G.
Injury Causation Scenarios in Belt-Restrained Nearside Child Occupants2007-22-001310/29/2007
Successful development of side impact safety systems for rear row child occupants requires an understanding of injury causation and mitigation. However, data to guide the design of such safety systems for seat belt-restrained occupants is limited to injury risk assessments. Thus, we sought to elucidate Injury Causation Scenarios (ICS's) in children restrained by seat belts in nearside impacts. Included in the study were 4 to 15 year old children, involved in a side impact, seated on the nearside in the rear rows, restrained by a seat belt alone (no booster seats or side airbags) and who received an AIS 2+ injury. A Contact Point Map summarized the vehicle components that contribute to the injuries. The majority of head and face contacts points were found horizontally within the rear half of the window, and vertically from the window sill to the center of the window, and were a result of contact with both interior structures and structures on the crash partner. The most prevalent intracranial injuries included cerebral contusions, diffuse axonal injury (DAI), and subdural or subarachnoid hematoma/hemorrhage. The most common cause of torso and abdominal injury was contact with the side interior structure, and injuries included spleen lacerations or ruptures, liver lacerations and contusions, lung contusions, rib fractures, and clavicle fractures. Protuberances on the door interior, such as the armrest, were the most common source of abdominal injury in this dataset. These data provide important guidance for the development of rear row safety systems for belt-restrained children with no side airbags in nearside crashes.
Maltese, Matthew R.Locey, Caitlin M.Jermakian, Jessica S.Nance, Michael L.Arbogast, Kristy B.
Optical based sensor systems for vehicle based detection and warning systems are under development to reduce accidents and limit injuries caused by accidents. (1, 2, 3) In order to validate these types of detection systems, it is necessary to perform real world tests. In the case of pedestrian detection systems, this is very difficult in the field for safety reasons. Instead, simulated tests are more desirable. This paper describes work to understand the effectiveness of using virtual pedestrians as surrogates for real world pedestrian detection.
Cathey, LarrySteiger, ReidWallis, ChrisLopez, MikeBlommer, Mike
Spine Fractures in Open Cockpit Open Wheel Race Car Drivers2006-01-363012/5/2006
Spinal fractures in open cockpit open wheeled racecars have increased in frequency over the past 10 years (7.5% of all racing injuries in 1995 to 18.7% currently). In order to quantitate this and investigate potential causes we collected all fractures occurring in 5 open wheeled series from 1996 to 2005. The ultimate goal of the study is to identify causative factors that can be altered to lessen the fracture risk. This is a multipart study. These fractures were categorized as to fracture type and severity, and correlated to ADR-2 data from the race car. Also used in the analysis were data from a rearward impact barrier test, HYGE sled testing and development of a computer model. (Development of the model is reported in a separate submission) 38 incidents resulted in fractures in 36 different drivers (2 involved in 2 incidents). 54 spinal levels were injured with 9 drivers sustaining injury at more than one level. The thoracic and thoracolumbar spine was involved most frequently. Of the 38 injured drivers 26 sustained injury in a rearward directed impact 15 of which produced thoracic or thoracolumbar fractures. Fractures were classified according to Gertzbein's Comprehensive Classification System. All thoracic and thoracolumbar fractures sustained in rearward impacts were Type A axial compression fractures. We created a Fracture Severity Index to allow for analysis of the severity of these fractures which were similar in morphology. Fractures sustained in rearward impacts were less severe than fractures in frontal impacts. Rearward impacts accounted for 67% of the injuries, 63% of the levels injured and averaged 2.9 severity index (max 6.0). Rearward impact was investigated with a barrier test of a fully loaded Indy Car at an impact speed of 80kph. Occupant kinematics observed documented the ramping phenomena as well as a potential source of the vertical loading. Injured drivers ADR2 data was trended with fracture level, type, and severity. The ADR-2 is an Accident Data Recorder that is supplied by Delphi. It is secured to the chassis of the race car and is required equipment in the IRL and IPS as well as the other series included in this report. It senses and records key vehicle parameters at 1000 samples per second prior to, during and after a pre determined triggering event. Some of the parameters recorded include X,Y,Z axis accelerations, yaw rate, steering angle, throttle position, and wheel speed. Sled test using a 60g pulse (Indy Car pulse) and THOR ATD were carried out to verify and validate data from the ADR-2. Thoracic and thoracolumbar spine fractures are characterized by compressive loads; the ADR-2 data demonstrates vertical axis spikes which are reproducible on the sled in the T8 and T12 load cells. These data and literature review identified threshold loads predictive of spinal fracture in an open cockpit open wheeled race car. Continued investigation is focused on making alterations in the seat contour and foam material to help mitigate the impact loads, reducing the ramping phenomena and therefore compression loading on the spine.
Trammell, Terry R.Weaver, Christopher S.Bock, Henry
Exploring Pediatric Lower Extremity Injuries in Lateral Collisions with EDSMAC4 and GATB in HVE2006-01-14004/3/2006
This paper describes the application of the EDSMAC4 and GATB simulation modules of the Human Vehicle and Environment (HVE) software to analyze pediatric case occupants with fractures to the proximal part of the lower extremity due to lateral collisions. EDSMAC4 and GATB simulation results were compared with in-depth crash investigations for crash dynamics, injury mechanisms and occupant kinematics. These crash investigations were conducted as part of the Partners for Child Passenger Safety (PCPS) project at The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP). In-depth investigations of near side impact crashes involving children (8-15 years old) with proximal lower extremity fractures were conducted. EDSMAC4 module was used to simulate vehicle dynamics and damage. The vehicle acceleration pulse generated from EDSMAC4 was used in the GATB module to predict the child occupant kinematics in these crashes. The EDSMAC4 results were consistent with the vehicle dynamics and damage pattern as measured in the crash investigation. The GATB analysis of occupant kinematics suggests that the initial orientation and subsequent motion of the pelvis and the direction of force influence the likelihood of injury. Different boundary conditions were adopted in the respective cases to understand the initial orientation and subsequent motion of the occupant pelvis. The scenarios of two side impact cases with no-, mid-, and maximum-intrusion along with different vehicle seat contours were also simulated. The results from the study sample show that the seat contour, intrusion and point of impact on the vehicle influenced the severity of injury to the proximal lower extremity in side impacts. The study also illustrates the utility of EDSMAC4 and GATB simulation models in HVE for better understanding of occupant kinematics in real world crashes. Although this approach offers certain distinct advantages in studying the injury causing factors, further assessment of this approach and capabilities of the simulation modules in HVE is required.
Menon, Rajiv A.Ghati, YoganandMari-Gowda, Shresta
Children who are too large for harness restraints but too small to obtain good restraint from a vehicle seatbelt alone should be seated in a belt-positioning booster. Boosters have been shown to significantly reduce abdominal injuries caused by seatbelts. This effectiveness may be due in part to the fact that boosters reduce the effective seat cushion length, allowing children to sit more comfortably without slouching. NHTSA recommends that children who do not use harness restraints use boosters until they are at least 145 cm tall. In this paper, data from several sources were combined to assess how well children fit on rear seat cushions. Data from NASS-GES were analyzed to determine the age distribution of rear-seat occupants. Anthropometric data from several sources were analyzed to determine the distribution of buttock-popliteal length, a measure of thigh length that is a key determinant of seat fit, as a function of age and gender. Second- and third-row cushion lengths were measured on a convenience sample of 56 late-model vehicles. Comparing the distribution of body size for rear-seat occupants with the seat cushion lengths showed that most cushions are too long for most rear-seat occupants, using commonly applied standards of seat fit. Given that most rear-seat occupants in the U.S. are children, rear-seat design standards should consider the smaller body dimensions and different restraint needs of this population.
Huang, StephanieReed, Matthew P.
A Study on the Modelling Technique for the Passenger Out-Of-Position Simulation2005-01-12984/11/2005
There was a regulation to reduce injuries caused by airbags for OOP (Out-Of-Position) impact loading conditions. Also, many tests are needed to meet the regulation regarding design variation. And the main effect of airbag design variable has not been well known. Therefore, numerical simulation modelling method and technique were required to reduce the test numbers and recommend the airbag design guideline for OOP condition. To establish modelling procedure for OOP situations in this paper, simulation model was built and correlated with test. Also, the body block test for airbag cushion correlation, a pendulum test for opening stiffness correlation of airbag door and low risk deployment static test using 3-year-old dummy for OOP simulation correlation were performed. And, airbag door and folding condition were evaluated using full factorial DOE (Design of Experimental) technique. Finally, airbag inflator, vent hole, opening stiffness of door and friction coefficient were evaluated using orthogonal array (L9). From the DOE results, the airbag door modelling was insignificant for In-position situation whereas it was significant for OOP modelling. And the direct folded mesh shows a good correlation for OOP condition. Especially, the direct folded mesh by MOBIS folder was validated. The OOP simulation results had been mainly influenced by the inflator model and airbag door opening stiffness.
Park, WonsukHong, Soongu
The Role of Intrusion in Injury Causation in Frontal Crashes2005-01-13764/11/2005
In December 2003, fifteen participating Automobile Manufacturers announced the adoption of voluntary standards for geometric compatibility in frontal crashes. In an October 2003 report, Insurance Institute of Highway Safety (IIHS) estimated that an 8 to 28 percent fatality reduction might be achieved with better geometric and stiffness compatibility (O’Neill, 2003). This benefit was based on comparing the fatality risks of car occupants in car-to-car collisions and in car-to-SUV collisions. Reduced occupant compartment intrusion was cited as the principal advantage gained by compatibility improvements. However, the study did not actually examine the role that intrusion played in causing the fatalities. This study examines the magnitude of serious injuries in frontal crashes that could be addressed by reducing occupant compartment intrusion. Each frontal vehicle-to-vehicle case in William Lehman Injury Research Center (WLIRC) data was examined to determine the cause of each injury. The injury was attributed to intrusion when injury was caused by intruding components. The study examined the intrusion related injuries with variations in: the crash severity; the injury severity and the body region injured. The database contained 182 occupants with 339 unique AIS3+ injuries and 91 with MAIS 2+ lower limb injuries. 48% of the MAIS 3+ injuries and 68% of the MAIS 2+ lower limb injuries were associated with intrusion. It was found that intrusion injury percentage for belted occupants varied from 53% for AIS3+ injuries to 100% for AIS6 injuries while for unbelted occupants it varied from 46% for AIS3+ injuries to 21% for AIS6 injuries. Lower extremities AIS2 intrusion injuries were found to be 76% for belted occupants and 60% for unbelted occupants. AIS3+ intrusion injury percentage at different crash severities varied from 29% for deltaV under 20mph to 93% for deltaV over 35mph for belted occupants and from 18% for deltaV under 20mph to 68% for deltaV over 35mph for unbelted occupants. By improving geometric compatibility, injuries in lower severity crashes may increase due to the higher levels of acceleration caused by matching stiff structures. On the other hand, injuries in higher severity crashes would significantly decrease due to reduction in intrusion. There should be an overall benefit; however, belted occupant would realize this benefit more than unbelted occupants.
Augenstein, JeffreyPerdeck, ElanaMostafa, KhaledDigges, KennerlyBahouth, GeorgeMorgan, Richard
The Effects of Measurement Uncertainty on the Reconstruction of Various Vehicular Collisions2004-01-12203/8/2004
This paper continues a previous study of the effects of uncertainty of measurement upon accident reconstruction. The task is to identify, given the many inevitable errors of observation, the few of greatest import, so that these errors may be reduced, and to document the accuracy of the associated reconstruction. Until recently, it was not for lack of method that such studies could not be properly performed, but for lack of good data on uncertainty of measurement. The essential data was provided in 2002 in a report by Bartlett and others of juried studies performed by volunteer field investigators, summarized and supplemented in 2003 by Bartlett and Fonda in the form of a single table of all likely errors of measurement (furnished again here). In that paper, Finite Difference Analysis (FDA) was reviewed and with the aid of the new data was applied to automotive accident reconstruction. FDA includes identification of “the vital few among the trivial many” (a Pareto analysis) as a guide to the benefits of investigative efforts both past and pending. Both studies consider the effect of three levels of measurement uncertainty on the results of reconstruction, but previous only the speeds of approach to eccentric intersection impact were treated, by means of CRASH3 only. The present paper treats reconstruction of more output parameters of more cases by means of more algorithms, and for those cases and parameters reports as well the methodological errors of those differing treatments. In addition to approach speed V0, which correlates with accident causation, the outputs now include values, independently based on momentum and on energy, of the speed change ▵V, which correlates with injury causation. The cases now include three more types of impact, namely symmetric intersection impact, axial (in-lane) impact, and impact with a stationary object. As before the study uses a version of CRASH3 which provides routines dedicated to FDA and optionally treats motions and forces occurring during impact. The broadened study extends the available guidelines for the optimization of field investigation expenditures and efforts, and for the recitation of the bounds of uncertainty of result due to the uncertainties of measurement and subsequent treatment.
Fonda, Albert G.
Vehicle Acceleration and Compartment Intrusion for Far-Sided Occupants v. Near-Sided Occupants in Frontal Offset Collisions2003-01-01593/3/2003
Vehicle acceleration and compartment intrusion play major roles in occupant injury causation, in frontal offset collisions. The knowledge of injury causation may enable the injury risk to be directly assessed from accident conditions, once a relationship between accident conditions and vehicle response is known. To establish such a relationship, a simulation study was carried out, in which vehicle acceleration and local compartment intrusion were calculated for various crash speeds and overlap configurations. The simulation model was validated against crash-tests in terms of the local vehicle deformation, acceleration and local dash and toepan intrusion. It was found that average acceleration generally decreased with reduced overlap, while intrusion increased for narrower overlap and impact locations more closely to the dash and/or toepan. This general trend indicates the relatively high injury risk for near-side occupants and a low risk for far-side occupants. Far-side, low-overlap (<50%) offset collisions at 45 or even 50 mph resulted in similar average acceleration and local intrusion levels as those seen in full overlap at 35 mph. However, crush reaching into the stiff firewall may cause vehicle peak accelerations to rise above expected levels in low overlap and high speed, especially in case the engine enhances firewall deformation. Furthermore, far-side intrusions may reach similar levels as near-side intrusions in offset collisions (>33% overlap), due to induced damage and the load distributing effect of the engine. Vehicle average acceleration and local intrusion levels may reach injurious levels for the far-side occupant in offset collisions. Vehicle crashworthiness improvements with a sole focus on near-side occupants may result in reduced protection of the far-side occupant.
Jewkes, Dagmar Buzeman
Items per page:
1 – 50 of 102