Browse Topic: Icing and ice detection

Items (843)
Wind-tunnel tests were conducted using a 30%-scale DrivAer model, in estateback and notchback rear-geometry configurations, to investigate aerodynamic performance changes associated with snow and ice buildup on passenger vehicles. Around 20 snow/ice accumulation patterns were tested, at a Reynolds number of 2.8 × 106 based on model wheelbase, for each of the notchback and estateback variants. 5 additional patterns were tested on the estateback with roof-rack support bars. Snow accumulation was modelled with foam, while ice accumulation was simulated with aluminum tape hand-formed to the desired shape. A simulated full-scale snow thickness of 58 mm on the hood, roof and trunk increased the wind-averaged drag coefficient by 16% for both model variants. With 90 mm of snow, the drag of the estateback variant increased by 19%. Drag changes increased with, but were not proportional to, snow thickness. Chamfered front and rear edges, representing windblown shapes, reduced the drag penalty
de Souza, FenellaMcAuliffe, Brian
This study investigates the phenomenon of receptacle icing during Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) refueling at filling stations, attributing the issue to excessive moisture content in the gas. The research examines the underlying causes, including the Joule-Thomson effect, filter geometries, and their collective impact on flow interruptions. A comprehensive test methodology is proposed to simulate real-world conditions, evaluating various filter types, seal materials and moisture levels to understand their influence on icing and flow cessation. The findings aim to offer ideas for reducing icing problems. This will improve the reliability and safety of CNG refueling systems.
Virmani, NishantSawant, Shivraj MadhukarC R, Abhijith
This SAE Aerospace Recommended Practice (ARP) provides recommended practices for the calibration and acceptance of icing wind tunnels to be used in testing of aircraft components and systems and for the development of simulated ice shapes. This document is not directly applicable to air-breathing propulsion test facilities configured for the purposes of engine icing tests, which are covered in AIR6189. This document also does not provide recommended practices for creating Supercooled Large Drop (SLD) or ice crystal conditions, since information on these conditions is not sufficiently mature for a recommended practice document at the time of publication of ARP5905A. Use of facilities as part of an aircraft’s ice protection Certification Plan should be reviewed and accepted by the applicable regulatory agency prior to testing. Following acceptance of a test plan, data generated in these facilities may be submitted to regulatory agencies for use in the certification of aircraft ice
AC-9C Aircraft Icing Technology Committee
Crawler Dozers play a critical role in global construction, mining and industrial sectors, performing essential tasks like pushing the material, grading, leveling and scraping. In the highly competitive dozer market, meeting the growing demand for increased productivity requires strategies to enhance blade capacity and width. Dozer operations involve pushing the material and dozing, where blade capacity significantly influences performance. Factors such as mold board profile, blade height, and width impact the blade capacity which are crucial for productivity in light weight applications such as snow removal and dirt pushing. Blade width is also pivotal for grading and leveling tasks. Traditional blade designs, like straight or fixed U-type blades, constrain operator flexibility, limiting overall productivity. The integration of hydraulic-operated foldable wings on both sides of the blade offers the adaptability to adjust blade capacity which also helps to reduce material spillage
Sahoo, Jyoti PrakashSarma, Neelam Kumar
This SAE Aerospace Standard (AS)/Minimum Operational Performance Specification (MOPS) specifies the minimum performance requirements of remote on-ground ice detection systems (ROGIDS). These systems are ground based. They provide information that indicates whether frozen contamination is present on aircraft surfaces. Section 1 provides information required to understand the need for the ROGIDS, ROGIDS characteristics, and tests that are defined in subsequent sections. It describes typical ROGIDS applications and operational objectives and is the basis for the performance criteria stated in Sections 3 through 5. Section 2 provides reference information, including related documents, definitions, and abbreviations. Section 3 contains general design requirements for the ROGIDS. Section 4 contains the Minimum Operational Performance Requirements for the ROGIDS, which define performance in icing conditions likely to be encountered during ground operations. Section 5 describes environmental
G-12HOT Holdover Time Committee
Ice build-up on aircraft and wind turbines can impact the safety and efficiency of their systems.
Protecting against atmospheric icing conditions is critical for the safety of aircraft during flight. Sensors and probes are often used to indicate the presence of icing conditions, enabling the aircraft to engage their ice protection systems and exit the icing cloud. Supercooled large drop icing conditions, which are defined in Appendix O of 14 CFR Part 25, pose additional aircraft certification challenges and requirements as compared to conventional icing conditions, which are defined in Appendix C of 14 CFR Part 25. For this reason, developing sensors that can not only indicate the presence of ice, but can also differentiate between Appendix O and Appendix C icing conditions, is of particular interest to the aviation industry and to federal agencies. Developing detectors capable of meeting this challenge is the focus of SENS4ICE, a European Union sponsored project. While participating in the SENS4ICE Project, Collins Aerospace has developed an ice detection and differentiation
Hamman, MatthewGelao, GiancarloRidouane, El HassanChabukswar, RohanBotura, Galdemir
Historically, smaller Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS), such as Class 2 RQ-1B Raven and Class 3 RQ-7Bv2 Shadow, have been restricted to not be approved to fly in icing conditions under the assumption that any ice accretion would cause an unacceptable risk of loss of the aircraft. However, interest exists in better understanding potential icing accretion on UAS to determine if less extreme icing conditions could result in only partial degradation and not total loss of the vehicle for the purpose of expanding approved flight envelopes. Icing accretion can be tested during a flight test, which is considered unacceptable due to lack of controlled conditions and risk to the UAS or in a controlled experiment, by using wind tunnel testing to evaluate a single icing condition. Cryogenic wind tunnel tests, such as those conducted at the National Aeronautical and Space Administration (NASA) Glenn Icing Research Tunnel (IRT), Cleveland, OH, as shown in figures 1 and 2, are prohibitively expensive
Ice prediction capabilities for Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS) is of growing interest as UAS designs and applications become more diverse. This report summarizes the current state-of-the-art in modeling aircraft icing within a computational framework as well as a recent U.S. Army DEVCOM AvMC effort to evaluate ice prediction models for current use and future integration into the Computational Research and Engineering Acquisition Tools and Environments (CREATE) Air Vehicle (AV) framework. U.S. Army Combat Capabilities Development Command, Redstone Arsenal, Alabama Historically, smaller Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS), such as Class 2 RQ-1B Raven and Class 3 RQ-7Bv2 Shadow, have been restricted to not be approved to fly in icing conditions under the assumption that any ice accretion would cause an unacceptable risk of loss of the aircraft. However, interest exists in better understanding potential icing accretion on UAS to determine if less extreme icing conditions could result in only
Brake squeal is a common phenomenon across all types of vehicles. It becomes prominent in the absence of other noise sources, as in the case of electric vehicles. Earlier simulation attempts date back to late nineties and early 2000s. Identification of unstable modes of the coupled system of brake rotor and pads, and occasionally some caliper components, was the primary goal. Simulating the rotation of the rotor along with squeezing of the pads was attempted in a multi-body dynamics tools with flexible representation of rotor and pads. Though this gave some insights into the dynamics of stopping mechanism, squeal required capturing the nonlinearities of the contact in a more rigorous sense. Also, efforts were made to capture noise from vibrations using boundary- and finite- element methods [1]. In this attempt at digitalizing a brake dynamometer, the author used a nonlinear implicit solver to mimic the dynamics and transient vibro-acoustic solver to convert transient vibrations to
Kappagantu, Ramana
Determining local ice crystal icing concentration factors in the region of the forward fuselage is critical for setting the Total Water Content levels for air data probe qualification testing. Simulation, modeling, and testing techniques for this concentration-factor phenomenon are still in their infancy, and there is currently not a significant amount of this type of analysis in the literature. A representative, 3D analysis was conducted using transport airplane geometry and flight conditions that explored the sensitivities resulting from parametric changes to flight and ice crystal icing conditions, particle modeling parameters, and bouncing effects.
Malone, Adam
The purpose of this paper to is to review the methodology applied by Collins Aerospace to develop, test and qualify a more robust surface ply rubber compound that has demonstrable improvements in durability and performance at sub-freezing temperatures. Using in-service products as a reference, pneumatic deicers in use on regional turboprop applications were selected as a basis for operational characteristics and observed failure modes. Custom test campaigns were developed by Collins to comparatively evaluate key characteristics of the surface ply material including low temperature elasticity, erosion durability, and fluid susceptibility. Collins’ proprietary engineered rubber formulations were individually evaluated and built into fully functional test deicers for component level testing to DO-160G environmental exposure, comparative ice shed performance in Collins’ Icing Wind Tunnel and erosion in Collins’ Rain Erosion Silo.
Taylor, AndrewSlane, CaseyHu, JinBotura, Galdemir
Threats to aviation safety as a result of super-cooled large drops (SLD) has been addressed by the FAA rules change (14 CFR Part 25) with the additional icing certification requirement. SLD clouds often consist of bi-modal drop size spectra leading to significant problems in simulating and characterizing these conditions in situ and in icing wind tunnels. Legacy instrumentation for measuring drop size distributions and liquid water content are challenged under these conditions. The large size range measurement problem is addressed with the development of the Phase Doppler Interferometer, Flight Probe Dual-Range (PDI FPDR). The method is described in this report along with the measurement capabilities including the dynamic measurement range and overall working size range. The PDI instrument bases drop size measurements on the light wavelength as the measurement length scale. The light wavelength is a much more robust scale, especially as compared to the light scattering intensity
Bachalo, William DonPayne, GregoryIbrahim, KhalidFidrich, Michael
Urban air mobility (UAM) is a fast-growing industry that utilizes electric vertical take-off and landing (eVTOL) technologies to operate in densely populated urban areas with limited space. However, atmospheric icing serves as a limitation to its operational envelope as in-flight icing can happen all year round anywhere around the globe. Since icing in smaller aviation systems is still an emerging topic, there is a necessity to study icing of eVTOL rotors specifically. Two rotor geometries were chosen for this study. A small 15-inch rotor was selected to illustrate a multirotor UAV drone, while a large 80-inch rotor was chosen to represent a UAM passenger aircraft. The ice accretion experiments were conducted in an icing wind tunnel on the small 15-inch rotor. The icing simulations were performed using FENSAP-ICE. The ice accretion simulations of the 15-inch rotor sections at –5 °C show a large, rather streamlined ice shape instead of the expected glaze ice characteristics. At –15 °C
Heramarwan, HenidyaMüller, NicolasHann, RichardLutz, Thorsten
Computational icing analysis results were compared to experimental icing tunnel data including aerothermal (e.g., dry air) and supercooled water droplet rime-ice conditions from tests conducted in early 2022 at the NASA Icing Research Tunnel (IRT). The Simulated Inter-compressor Duct Research Model (SIDRM) test article was used in this study, and its geometry represents the inter-compressor duct region of a turbofan engine. The test article’s purpose is to study the physics of supercooled water icing and ice crystal icing. This study compared three different icing codes: FENSAP-ICE (Eulerian approach), LEWICE3D (Lagrangian approach), and GlennICE (Lagrangian approach). All three icing codes were conducted on SIDRM’s complex body flow-field and compared to different experimental supercooled water rime runs. The test article instrumentation (pressure taps, thermocouples, etc.) and 3D laser scans of final ice shapes were used to compare against the different icing code simulations. The
Stewart, EricBartkus, Tadas
In the last decades there have been many temporary engine failures, engine-related events and erroneous airspeed indication measurements that occurred by a phenomenon known as Ice Crystal Icing (ICI). This type of icing mainly occurs in high altitudes close to tropical convection in areas with a high concentration of ice crystals. Direct measurements or in-situ pilot observations of ICI that could be used as a warning to other air-traffic are rare to nearly non-existent. To detect those dangerous high Ice Water Content (IWC) areas with already existing airborne measurement instruments, Lufthansa analyzed observed Total Air Temperature (TAT) anomalies and used a self-developed search algorithm, depicting those TAT anomalies that are related to ice crystal icing events. To optimize the flight route for dispatchers several hours before the flight, e.g. for long distance flights through the intertropical convergence zone (ITCZ), reliable forecasts to identify hazardous high IWC regions are
Kalinka, FrankButter, MaxJurkat, TinaDe La Torre Castro, ElenaVoigt, Christiane
This paper presents the current state of a three-layer surface icing model for ice crystal icing risk assessment in aircraft engines, being developed jointly by Ansys and Honeywell to account for possible heat transfer from inside an engine into the flow path where ice accretion occurs. The bottom layer of the proposed model represents a thin metal sheet as a substrate surface to conductively transfer heat from an engine-internal reservoir to the ice layer. The middle layer is accretion ice with a porous structure able to hold a certain amount of liquid water. A shallow water film layer on the top receives impinged ice crystals. A mass and energy balance calculation for the film determines ice accretion rate. Water wicking and recovery is introduced to transfer liquid water between film layer and porous ice accretion layer. Numerical tests have been conducted to verify new model behaviors like substrate surface heat absorption into the accretion layer in the form of meltwater, water
Zhang, YueNarayanasamy, KarthikSandel, WolfgangNilamdeen, ShezadOzcer, Isik
This paper presents the adhesion strength of ice on sanded and machine-finished aluminum test coupons as measured using the National Research Council of Canada (NRC) Altitude Icing Wind Tunnel (AIWT) spin rig. This rig is used to evaluate commercial and internally-developed coatings for low-adhesion properties, and the performance of ice on aluminum is required as a baseline to compare the coatings against. The tests are performed over a range of aerodynamic and icing cloud conditions, including variations in static air temperature and exposure time (and therefore accumulated ice mass). The data analysis includes an evaluation of the uncertainty in the results based on the measured ice mass repeatability and the measured shear stress repeatability. The results show the adhesive shear stress of ice, generated with a 20 μm icing cloud at a true airspeed of 80 m/s and a static air temperature of -20°C to create rime ice conditions, is 682 kPa (±13%) for aluminum coupons with a sanded
Clark, Catherine
In-flight icing is an important consideration that affects aircraft design, performance, certification and safety. Newer regulations combined with increasing demand to reduce fuel burn, emissions and noise are driving a need for improvements in icing simulation capability. To that end, this paper presents the results of additional ice accretion testing conducted in the NASA Icing Research Tunnel in January 2022 with a large swept wing section typical of a modern commercial transport. The model was based upon a section of the Common Research Model wing at the 64% semispan station with a streamwise chord length of 136 in. The test conditions were developed with an icing scaling analysis to generate similar conditions for a small median volumetric diameter (MVD) = 25 μm cloud and a large MVD = 110 μm cloud. A series of tests were conducted over a range of total temperature from -23.8 °C to -1.4 °C with all other conditions held constant. Another series of tests explored cloud MVD
Broeren, AndyLee, SamTsao, Jen-Ching
In-flight atmospheric icing is a severe hazard for propeller-driven unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) that can lead to issues ranging from reduced flight performance to unacceptable loss of lift and control. To address this challenge, a physics-based first principles model of an electric UAV propulsion system is developed and identified in varying icing conditions. Specifically, a brushless direct current motor (BLDC) based propeller system, typical for UAVs with a wing span of 1-3 meters, is tested in an icing wind tunnel with three accreted ice shapes of increasing size. The results are analyzed to identify the dynamics of the electrical, mechanical, and aerodynamic subsystems of the propulsion system. Moreover, the parameters of the identified models are presented, making it possible to analyze their sensitivity to ice accretion on the propeller blades. The experiment data analysis shows that the propeller power efficiency is highly sensitive to icing, with a 40% reduction in thrust
Løw-Hansen, BogdanMüller, Nicolas C.Coates, Erlend M.Johansen, Tor ArneHann, Richard
In-flight atmospheric icing is a significant threat to the use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) in adverse weather. The propeller of the UAV is especially sensitive to icing conditions, as it accumulates ice at a faster rate than the wings of the UAVs. Ice protection systems can be developed to counteract the danger of icing on the propeller of UAVs. In this study, the influence of different meteorological conditions on a propeller of a UAV is analyzed for a UAV with a wingspan of a few meters. The ice accretion and the performance degradation and the required anti-icing heat fluxes have been calculated using numerical methods with ANSYS FENSAP-ICE. This analysis has been used to evaluate the critical conditions for the operation of a UAV in icing conditions and the design of a thermal IPS system for a propeller. The highest ice mass has been found at a temperature of −10 °C and an MVD of 20 μm in intermittent maximum icing conditions. The performance degradation has been the highest
Müller, Nicolas CarloHann, Richard
If an Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS) encounters icing conditions during flight, those conditions might result in degraded aerodynamic performance of the overall UAS. If the UAS is not reacting appropriately, safety critical situations can quickly arise. Thereby, the rotors, respectively the propellers of the UAS are especially susceptible due to the increased airflow through their domain and the corresponding higher impingement rate of supercooled water droplets. In many cases, the UAS cannot be properly operated if the rotors are not fully functional, as they are a vital component. The FFG/BMK funded research and development project “All-weather Drone” is investigating the icing phenomenon on UAS rotors for a 25 kg maximum take-off weight (MTOW) multirotor UAS and evaluating the feasibility of possible technical ice detection and anti-/de-icing solutions. This paper presents results from the investigation carried out at the Rail Tec Arsenal (RTA) icing wind tunnel (IWT) in Vienna
Kozomara, DavidAmon, JakobPuffing, ReinhardNeubauer, ThomasSchweighart, SimonDiebald, StefanRapf, AndreasMoser, RichardBreitfuss, Wolfgang
The process for certifying an existing aircraft for flight into known icing is well defined and must follow specific guidelines and meet specific milestones. As UAVs are still a relatively recent development, guidelines for icing flight certification of a UAV have not yet been developed by the FAA, and no UAVs have yet been certified for FIKI under the FAA. As part of a research program, engineers at the Battelle Memorial Institute in Columbus, OH USA worked with partners to integrate its ice protection system, HeatCoatTM, onto an existing UAV platform as a retrofit with the ultimate goal of flying in icing conditions. This research program was funded by the US Government with intent to integrate HeatCoat on the TigerShark-XP UAV. The integration on the TigerShark was demonstrated to present challenges specific to the nature of this UAV that had to be overcome. This research program required simulation of icing accretion using multiple software packages, ground based icing tunnel
Yugulis, KevinChase, DavidKenney, Brian
The present paper showcases the predicting ability of an in-house 2D/ Quasi-3D steady state Ice Crystal Accretion Tool (ICAT) applicable for both heated and un-heated surfaces. The previously existing code for unheated surfaces, has been extended to heated scenarios with the inclusion of: 1) coupling with solid conduction model 2) inclusion of advanced models for crystal melting, water film modeling, sticking and erosion. The results obtained from ICAT are verified against the experimental results of heated NACA0012 airfoil, conducted in the icing wind tunnel of TU Braunschweig as part of MUSIC-haic project. ICAT predictions are found to be well in agreement with the ICI physics, which is proven with the various parameters addressed in this paper, such as tunnel temperature, ice crystal temperature, inlet melt ratio, heating power, etc.
Roychowdhury, SomasreePoornima, RajaniBokade, VilasJebauer, SteffenVanacore, PaoloMalik, Yasir A.
This paper provides information on the comparison of numerical simulations with experimental data for an electrothermal ice protection system with a focus on Appendix O [1] Freezing Drizzle (FZDZ) and Freezing Rain (FZRA) conditions. The experimental data is based on a test campaign with a 2D NACA23012 wing section in the RTA Icing Wind Tunnel in Vienna. 22 icing runs (all either unheated or in anti-ice mode) were performed in total and all residual ice shapes were documented by means of high-resolution 3D scanning. Unheated FZDZ and FZRA reference as well as heated cases with different heater configurations are presented. The experimental results are compared to numerical predictions from two different icing codes from AeroTex GmbH (ATX) and the University of Applied Sciences FH JOANNEUM (FHJ) in Graz. The current capabilities of the codes were assessed in detail and regions for improvement were identified. Overall, the codes were able to predict the ice shapes of both the unheated
Breitfuß, WolfgangMoser, RichardHassler, WolfgangFerschitz, HermannNeubauer, ThomasPuffing, ReinhardDiebald, StefanSchweighart, Simon
In response to safety regulations regarding aircraft icing, Collins Aerospace has developed and tested a new generation of optical ice detectors (OID Lite) intended to discriminate among icing conditions described by Appendix C and Appendix O of 14 CFR Part 25 and Appendix D of Part 33. The OID Lite is a flush-mounted, short-range, polarimetric optical sensor that samples the airstream up to two meters beyond the skin of the aircraft. The intensity and polarization of the backscatter light correlate with bulk properties of the cloud, such as cloud density and phase. Drizzle-sized droplets, mixed within a small droplet cloud, appear as scintillation spikes in the lidar signal when it is processed pulse-by-pulse. Scintillation in the backscatter (in combination with the outside air temperature monitored by another probe) signals the presence of supercooled large droplets (SLD) within the cloud—a capability incorporated into the OID Lite to meet the requirements of Appendix O. Recent
Ray, MarkAnderson, KaareRamthun, Kent
This paper focuses on the design of the thermoelectric ice protection system (IPS) for the engine air intake of the Next Generation Civil Tiltrotor (NGCTR), a demonstrator under development in Leonardo Helicopters. A specific IPS design strategy for the novel intake configuration is proposed. The main constraint which driven the design strategy is a maximum power of 10.6 kW available for the full intake IPS system. The IPS was designed for safe aircraft operations within the Appendix-C icing envelope. The numerical approach adopted to perform the design and the resulting IPS concept are presented. Calculations of the required IPS heat fluxes revealed that maintaining running wet conditions on the entire intake surface is not feasible due to the limitation to the maximum IPS power demand. Therefore, a de-icing IPS design strategy is proposed. The anti-icing mode is adopted only on the lip region to avoid formation of ice caps whereas de-icing zones are defined within the intake duct
Tormen, DamianoZanon, AlessandroDe Gennaro, Michele
A research program was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of icing tunnel hybrid model design. A hybrid design is where the full-scale leading edge of a wing section is maintained only to a certain percentage of the local chord, while the aft section of the model is redesigned into a shortened or truncated planform. An initial study was conducted in 2020 where the ice shape geometries on a full-chord length version of the swept CRM65 wing model were compared to those from the hybrid version of CRM65 that were obtained in the NASA Icing Research Tunnel in 2015. The results were reported in a 2021 paper. For most test conditions, the overall size and shape of the ice shapes compared well. However, the ice shapes from the full-chord model were generally slightly smaller than those from the hybrid model. A follow-on test was conducted in 2022 and obtained ice shapes on both full-chord and hybrid wing models during the same test campaign to eliminate the differences in the tunnel spray
Lee, SamBroeren, Andy
In-flight icing significantly influences the design of large passenger aircraft. Relevant aspects include sizing of the main aerodynamic surfaces, provision of anti-icing systems, and setting of operational restrictions. Empennages of large passenger aircraft are particularly affected due to the small leading edge radius, and the requirement to generate considerable lift for round out and flare, following an extended period of descent often in icing conditions. This paper describes a CFD-based investigation of the effects of sweep on the aerodynamic performance of a novel forward-swept horizontal stabilizer concept in icing conditions. The concept features an unconventional forward sweep, combined with a high lift leading edge extension (LEX) located within a fuselage induced droplet shadow zone, providing passive protection from icing. In-flight ice accretion was calculated, using Ansys FENSAP-ICE, on 10°, 15° and 20° (low, intermediate, and high) sweep horizontal stabilizers, with
Page, JamesOzcer, IsikZanon, AlessandroDe Gennaro, Michele
This paper is focused on the numerical analysis of the impingement and water catch rate of snow particles on the engine air intake of the Next Generation Civil Tilt Rotor (NGCTR). This NGCTR is developed by Leonardo Helicopters. The collection efficiency and water catch rate for the intake geometry are obtained for the test cases that have been defined for the relevant snow conditions. These conditions are related to the flight envelope of the NGCTR, existing EASA/FAA certification specifications, and the snow characterization. The analyses have been performed for the baseline air intake geometry. A range of particle diameters has been simulated with a particle density equal to the density of ice and with a particle drag relation that disregards the particle shape. Based on the results for the water catch rate on the basic nacelle configuration in snow conditions it is concluded that the ‘cheeks’ of the duct are more susceptible to impingement of larger snow crystals (>75 μm), whereas
Kool, NinaVan der Weide, EdwinSpek, Ferdinandvan der Ven, Harmenvan 't Hoff, Stefan
Hazardous atmospheric icing conditions occur at sub-zero temperatures when droplets come into contact with aircraft and freeze, degrading aircraft performance and handling, introducing bias into some of the vital measurements needed for aircraft operation (e.g., air speed). Nonetheless, government regulations allow certified aircraft to fly in limited icing environments. The capability of aircraft sensors to identify all hazardous icing environments is limited. To address the current challenges in aircraft icing detection and protection, we present herein a platform designed for in-flight testing of ice protection solutions and icing detection technologies. The recently developed Platform for Ice-accretion and Coatings Tests with Ultrasonic Readings (PICTUR) was evaluated using CFD simulations and installed on the National Research Council Canada (NRC) Convair-580 aircraft that has flown in icing conditions over North East USA, during February 2022. This aircraft is a flying laboratory
Nichman, LeonidFuleki, DanSong, NaihengBenmeddour, AliWolde, MengistuOrchard, DavidMatida, EdgarBala, KennySun, ZhigangBliankinshtein, NataliaRanjbar, KeyvanDiVito, Stephanie
The Icing Research Tunnel at NASA Glenn follows the recommended practice for calibration outlined in SAE’s ARP5905. The calibration team has followed the schedule of a full calibration every five years with a check calibration done every six months following. The liquid water content of the IRT has maintained stability within the stated specifications of variation within +/- 10% of the curve fit equation generated from calibration data. Using past measurements and data trends, IRT characterization engineers wanted to develop methods for the ability to know when data were not within variation. Trends can be observed in the liquid water content measurement process by constructing statistical process control charts. This paper describes data processing procedures for the Multi-Element Sensor in the IRT, including collision efficiency corrections, canonical correlation analysis, process for rejection of data, and construction of control charts. Data are presented to display the control
Timko, EmilyKing-Steen, LauraInsana, Eric
Pitot probes and Total Air Temperature (TAT) probes are critical to aircraft performance. They are also susceptible to becoming overwhelmed and produce erroneous outputs when flying in icing conditions, especially in high altitude ice crystal situations. When the probes are overwhelmed with ice crystals, it can have significant impacts to aircraft operations. Through design and process iterations, Collins Aerospace (also known as Rosemount Aerospace™), has developed new Appendix D compliant pitot and TAT probes that are much more capable in high ice crystal content icing environments which greatly reduce the adverse risks to the aircraft and engine systems that depend on these probes.
Sable, Robert
As the everyday use of flying small to medium size Remotely Piloted Aircraft System (RPAS) continues to evolve, so does the need to fly them in icing environments. To investigate an RPAS’ ability to fly in these conditions, an outdoor test rig has been developed at the National Research Council Canada (NRC) in which a range of RPAS have been tested in icing environments. This rig has an available test area of 3.05 m × 3.05 m, and is 5.1 m high. An array of spray nozzles installed at the top of the test rig provides a cloud that, when operated at sub-zero temperatures, enables simulation of in-flight icing conditions. The spray cloud is calibrated to provide water concentration and drop size distributions consistent with Appendix C, freezing drizzle and freezing rain conditions. Six RPAS were tested and their performance under icing conditions has been monitored via video and, where available, data provided by the on-board acquisition system was downloaded to enable flight information
Orchard, David
Innovative carbon nanotube (CNT) electrothermal heating technology for ice protection systems is one of the alternatives under development that shall contribute to more efficient and sustainable aircraft. CNT heater technology allows for more rapid heat up rates over legacy metallic electrothermal heaters that utilize resistance wires or metallic foils. This more rapid heat up rate can lead to more energy efficient electrothermal ice protection system designs and is being studied to determine how much the rapid heat up properties of CNT can lead to a minimization of residual ice build-up aft of the heated area. Due to the inherent redundancy of CNT material used, leads to a very robust and damage tolerant heating element. To mature this technology to prepare to implement CNT on an in-service aircraft platform, a multi-staged flight testing effort to prove out the technology on an actual aircraft and in a relevant environment is mandatory. Recently a major milestone was achieved after
Hein, BrandonBotura, GaldemirHamman, MatthewSlane, Casey
A fundamental understanding of the icing process for aircraft requires a more thorough analysis of the thermodynamics of supercooled droplet impingement. To better study such thermodynamic processes, a novel temperature sensor that functions within supercooled water and ice crystals was developed. The temperature sensor is non-intrusive and provides temperature and phase change information for both liquid water and solid ice. The temperature sensor is an optical sensor based on the luminophore pyranine. The use of pyranine allows for the measurement of spatially and temporally resolved temperature fields for icing applications. The sensitivity of the sensor is -9.2±0.1%/K for temperature measurement in the solid phase and 0.8±0.1%/K for the liquid phase. The performance of the sensor was demonstrated through a calibration process using spectral analysis, the observation of the melting process of a rectangular prism created from the luminescent ice, and the study of the temperature
Gonzales, JosephYamazaki, MasafumiSakaue, Hirotaka
The paper describes the upgrade and validation of a Cartesian solver able of estimating the mass deposition of super-cooled large droplets (SLD) on aerodynamic surfaces. A decoupled approach is applied in which the air-flow field is first computed by using a RANS method and then passed to an Eulerian solver for obtaining the water-field. Both tools are based on a finite-volume (FV) approach based on locally refined Cartesian meshes and immersed boundaries. The use of semi-empirical models allow to take into account the primary effects due to splashing and bouncing of large droplets on aerodynamic surfaces. Here, we discuss the results of a numerical campaign with the aim of estimating the accuracy of two mass-deposition models on benchmarks from different experimental databases. Besides, for some cases we compare the present results with the ones obtained by using a body-conforming method.
Capizzano, Francescode Rosa, Donato
Aircraft icing is the phenomenon that forms an ice layer on the solid surface by impingement of supercooled water droplets in the atmosphere. In icing on rotor blades, ice is shed from the blade surface by centrifugal force as the accumulated ice grows. The ice shedding on rotor blades is a dangerous phenomenon, but the physical mechanism and properties are unclear, and most simulations have not considered it. Therefore, it’s necessary to establish an ice shedding model for icing simulations. In this study, we proposed an ice shedding model in which the condition for ice shedding is that the centrifugal force exceeds both the adhesion and tensile forces. Centrifugal force exceeding adhesion force expresses adhesion failure, while centrifugal force exceeding tensile force expresses cohesion failure. We also proposed functions of temperature and medium volume diameter (MVD) as adhesion strength and tensile strength for ice shedding judgment. Numerical simulations were performed to
Baba, TatsuyaFukudome, KojiYamamoto, MakotoMizuno, TakuyaSuzuki, Masaya
The development and calibration of a new facility to test medium size rotors for Remotely Piloted Aircraft Systems (RPAS) under in-flight icing conditions is described. This facility has made use of a 3 m x 6 m cold room available at the NRC which includes a spray system to provide the icing cloud as well as a dedicated rotor stand assembly that incorporates a load cell and dynamometer. Calibration data of the spray drop sizes and liquid water content are provided and compared to conditions of the natural environment as detailed in icing regulations for transport category airplanes, i.e., CFR 14 Part 25 Appendix C and O. Data to examine the sensitivity of rotor performance, under a constant liquid water content to various droplet sizes are provided for a medium sized rotor. Tests have also been performed that examine the ability of the rotor to maintain predefined thrust, torque and power performance throughout an icing encounter of fixed duration. For the purposes of this study, the
Orchard, David
Modifications have been implemented in the GlennICE software to accommodate a non-inertial reference frame. GlennICE accepts a flow solution from an external flow solver. It then introduces particles and tracks them through the flow field in a Lagrangian manner. Centrifugal and Coriolis terms were added to the GlennICE software to account for relative frame simulations. The objective of the present paper is twofold. First, to check that the new terms are implemented correctly and that the code still behaves as expected with respect to convergence. And second, to provide some initial insight into an upcoming propeller experiment in the NASA Icing Research Tunnel. The paper presents a description of the code modifications. In addition, results are presented for two operating conditions, and three particle sizes. Each case was simulated with four different grid densities to assess grid dependence.
Rigby, Davidvon Hardenberg, Paul
Modeling of icing is important for the design of aircraft lifting surfaces and for the design of efficient propulsion systems. The computational modeling of ice accretion prediction is important to replace the expensive experimental techniques for calculating the ice shapes in Icing tunnels, and the first step toward modeling ice accretion is to accurately compute the droplet collection efficiency which acts as the input to the accretion model. In this work, we perform large-eddy simulations of supercooled droplet transport and impingement onto complex aircraft geometries using a Lagrangian particle approach. We assess the improvement in modeling droplet impingement by computing the droplet collection efficiency and by comparing with the existing experimental data.
Jain, SuhasBornhoft, BrettBose, SanjeebMoin, Parviz
In this research, the performance of two commercially available icephobic coatings is evaluated on an 81% scaled-down version of the Bell Flight APT 70 drone propeller. Tests are performed in an icing wind tunnel (IWT) under selected severe icing conditions to test the ice protection capability of coatings against both glaze and rime ice. Two different coating formulations are used, one is a polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) acetoxy terminated coating, the other an epoxy-silicone. The coatings were briefly characterized in terms of their surface roughness, water contact angle and ice adhesion reduction factor compared to aluminum using the centrifugal adhesion test (CAT). Blade sets were prepared for both coatings and a third uncoated set was tested for reference purposes. Tests in the IWT were performed to simulate a true airspeed of 35 m/s and a constant propeller rotational speed of 5 500 RPM. Two conditions of liquid water content (LWC) and droplet median volumetric diameter (MVD) were
Harvey, DerekVilleneuve, EricVolat, ChristopheBeland, MathieuLapalme, Maxime
Considerable amounts of water accumulate in aircraft fuel tanks due to condensation of vapor during flight or directly during fueling with contaminated kerosene. This can result in a misreading of the fuel meters. In certain aircraft types, ice blocks resulting from the low temperatures at high altitude flights or in winter time can even interfere with the nozzles of the fuel supply pipes from the tanks to the engines. Therefore, as part of the maintenance operations, water has to be drained in certain intervals ensuring that no remaining ice is present. In the absence of an established method for determining residual ice blocks inside, the aircraft operator has to wait long enough, in some cases too long, to start the draining procedure, leading potentially to an unnecessary long ground time. A promising technology to determine melting ice uses acoustic signals generated and emitted during ice melting. With acoustic emissions, mainly situated in the ultrasonic frequency range, a very
Pfeiffer, HelgeReynaert, JohanSeveno, DavidJordaens, Pieter-JanCeyhan, OzlemWevers, Martine
Weather situations that are associated with hazardous icing conditions near the ground impact multiple kinds of infrastructure. A prominent example of a transmission system failure due to wintry conditions was the snow storm over the Münsterland, Germany, in 2005, as exceptional high amounts of wet snow in conjunction with supercooled water led to heavy damages on conductor cables and tower collapses (Klinger et al., 2011). In this work, an interdisciplinary approach between energy and aviation meteorology is presented. The study was conducted for the purpose of providing a forecast tool of hazardous icing conditions for German transmission system operators (TSOs). TSOs are faced with icing on ground-based objects just like aviation on the ground. For the purpose of obtaining an ensemble-based forecasting tool to detect hazardous icing of structures near the ground, the already existing aeronautical icing model “Advanced Diagnosis and Warning System for Aircraft Icing Environments
März, BenediktFundel, VanessaKalinka, FrankSchultze, MarkusSchmidli, Jürg
This work presents the anti-icing simulation results from a pressure sensing probe. This study used various turbulence models to understand their influence in surface temperature prediction. A fully turbulence model and a transition turbulence model are considered in this work. Both dry air and icing conditions are considered for this study. The results show that at low Angle of Attack (AOA) both turbulence model results compared well and at higher AOA the results deviated. Overall, as AOA increases, the k-ꞷ SST model predicted the surface temperature colder than the Transition SST model result.
Thangavel, SathishBajpai, Shivanshu
Protecting against atmospheric icing conditions is critical for the safety of aircraft during flight. Sensors and probes are often used to indicate the presence of icing conditions, enabling the aircraft to exit the icing cloud and engage their ice protection systems. Supercooled large drop (SLD) icing conditions, which are defined in Appendix O of 14 CFR Part 25, pose additional risk to aircraft safety as compared to conventional icing conditions, which are defined in Appendix C of 14 CFR Part 25. For this reason, developing sensors that can not only indicate the presence of ice, but can also differentiate between Appendix O (App O) and Appendix C (App C) icing conditions, is of particular interest to the aviation industry and to federal agencies. Developing a detector capable of meeting this challenge is the focus of SENS4ICE, a European Union sponsored project. This paper summarizes the work that was done to develop the Collins Ice Differentiator System, an ice detection and
Hamman, MatthewRidouane, El HassanGelao, GiancarloChabukswar, RohanBotura, Galdemir
The Glenn Icing Computational Environment (GlennICE) is a computational tool designed to calculate ice growth on complex three-dimensional geometries using the input from a user-supplied computational fluid dynamics (CFD) solution for the geometry of interest. The most significant developments in the advancement of GlennICE have been investigating the convergence of the collection efficiency, efficiently finding trajectories, and improving the refinement methodology. Such developments have increased the efficiency of GlennICE for practical engineering application. With the increasing demand for applying GlennICE for more memory-intensive problems, the scalability of GlennICE has yet to be investigated. This paper is aimed at presenting a method to benchmark the scalability of GlennICE utilizing a relevant engineering problem within a parallel environment. This leads to the final goal of investigating whether an increase in the number of processors utilized results in a linear speedup
Sabri, ZaidPorter, Christopher
Accurate simulation of icing is important for the assessment of several potential icing scenarios and complex icing regulations. However, performing all possible icing scenarios is a demanding process in terms of computational cost, especially when modification of the geometry due to ice accretion is required. Additionally, aircraft icing safety assessment necessitates an evaluation of the accumulated ice. Thus, numerical representation of the non-linear and complex geometries is essential for the parametrization of this ice. Indeed, surrogate models have the capability of predicting these complex, non-linear shapes. For this purpose, a method for ice accretion prediction on a selected airfoil, NACA 22112, is proposed in this study with different surrogate models that will later be used for fast prediction in 6DOF simulations to directly evaluate its effects on aerodynamic performance during flight. The required datasets in order to train for clean and iced airfoils are based on
Akbal, OmerAyan, ErdemMurat, CanibekOzgen, Serkan
This paper introduces the Lagrangian particle tracking technology readily available in Ansys Fluent in the in-flight icing simulation workflow, which normally uses the Eulerian approach for droplet flows. The Lagrangian solver is incorporated in the Fluent Icing workspace which is to become the next-gen in-flight icing simulation tool provided by Ansys. Lagrangian tracking will eventually be used for SLD and ice crystal rebound and re-impingement calculations in the Ansys workflow. Here we introduce some preliminary results with the current state of its implementation as of Fluent Icing release 2023R2. Example cases include several selections from the 1st Ice prediction workshop with experimental comparisons as well as results obtained earlier with the Eulerian droplet solution strategy. Collection efficiency comparisons on clean geometries show good agreement between Eulerian and Lagrangian methods when the particle seeds are in the millions range. Shadow zones are resolved with more
Moula, GuillaumeOzcer, Isik
Items per page:
1 – 50 of 843