Browse Topic: Biomechanics

Items (443)
Biomechanical response targets for the thorax have largely focused on the 50th percentile male, limiting their relevance for smaller females. Previous studies have provided side-impact female postmortem human subjects (PMHS) data from either oversimplified or realistic boundary conditions. This study aimed to generate thoracic biomechanical responses of small female PMHS in a simplified side-impact condition with realistic components and compare responses between two input energy levels. Twelve small female PMHS were seated on a simplified seat with FMVSS No. 213a seat foam and fabric and impacted once on the left thorax with either a 14.0 kg (low energy) or 23.7 kg (high energy) pneumatic impactor at 4.5 m/s. A rectangular impactor face (22.9 × 25.4 cm) covered with FMVSS No. 213a armrest foam simulated an intruding door panel. Thoracic deflection was measured using a chestband. Inertially compensated force was recorded via a load cell. Spinal kinematics were captured using six-degree-of-freedom motion blocks. Biomechanical responses were compared between groups using two-sample t-tests. The high-energy group exhibited significantly higher peak forces (2.5 vs. 1.9 kN, p = 0.0001), greater thoracic deflections (41.0 vs. 33.9 mm, p = 0.016), and increased deformation energy (91.6 vs. 61.0 J, p = 0.0001). Effective stiffness did not differ significantly between groups (p = 0.734). Energy loss increased with impact severity (66.2 vs. 56.7%, p = 0.020). Kinematic responses also increased with increased input energy. Peak y-accelerations were significantly greater at T4 in the high-energy group (p = 0.049). The sternum exhibited significantly greater peak z-angular velocity in the high-energy group (p = 0.038). Mean BioRank System Score (BRSS) of the force–deflection corridors between groups was 0.93. In summary, these findings provide essential biomechanical data and establish an important foundation for developing improved testing conditions and advancing the evaluation of female human body models (HBMs) and anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs) in side-impact scenarios.
Anantharamakrishnan, Srinivas, Kemper, Andrew, Baker, Gretchen H., Guettler, Allison J., Rhule, Heather, Kang, Yun-Seok, Agnew, Amanda M.
The performance of Midwest Guardrail Systems (MGS) during impact with electric vehicles (EVs) has raised concerns with recent observations demonstrating a higher susceptibility to rail failures. These failures are hypothesized to be related to EV-specific design, including variations in front-end geometry and inertial properties. Current guardrail evaluations rely on two vehicle types, a small car and a pickup truck, potentially overlooking sensitivity to front-end geometry variations, potentially leading to unanticipated impact responses. Additionally, the extent to which geometry influences occupant injury risks and trends during vehicle-guardrail impact remains insufficiently investigated. The objective of this study is to quantify the influence of vehicle front-end geometry on occupant injury risk during vehicle-guardrail impacts using finite element (FE) simulations. Occupant injury risk is analyzed using Hybrid III anthropomorphic test device (ATD)-based injury criteria and flail space-based vehicle severity metrics to identify trends and relationship between geometric variations and injury probability. Front-end geometry data from the Insurance Institute of Highway Safety (IIHS) were analyzed to identify parameters and ranges associated with adverse MGS performance. Based on vehicle alignment with the W-beam, hood leading-edge height, hood leading-edge angle, and bumper height were morphed on the Toyota Yaris model. A Latin Hypercube Design of Experiments generated 13 unique configurations for detailed analysis. Full-scale Manual for Assessing Safety Hardware (MASH) Test Level 3 FE simulations were then performed between the morphed vehicle models integrated with Hybrid III 50th percentile male ATD and MGS guardrail. Occupant injury metrics were evaluated alongside vehicle-based crash severity measures. All vehicle geometries fulfilled MASH criteria with occupant impact velocity (OIV) and occupant ride down acceleration (ORA) within tolerance with no rail rupture. Simulations suggest that probability of serious full-body injury (AIS3+) was estimated at 17.11% while probability of severe neck injury was the highest at 15.64% among the component level probabilities. While front-end geometry influences occupant kinematics, resulting injury metrics and vehicle-guardrail interaction characteristics, it does not independently govern occupant injury risk. Although, the MASH tests have the same outcome as the geometries studied, the changes in EV inertial properties could interact with the geometry leading to barrier failure, which will be explored in future work.
Bubna, Maheep, Buckland, Elijah, Riexinger, Luke E., Untaroiu, Costin
Instrumented mouthguards (iMGs) capture thousands of head acceleration events in contact sports, though processing the data from these into meaningful information remains a challenge. To bridge this gap, we developed a principled clustering pipeline to extract concise kinematics that are representative of real-world impact scenarios. We evaluated six multivariate time-series distance metrics using k-medoids clustering and a dataset of 5149 impacts across three sports: mixed martial arts, boxing, and rugby union. Model performance was evaluated using a Coverage Quality Score (CQS), prioritizing reconstruction coverage and cluster separation. Joint Shape-Based Distance (SBD) significantly outperformed all other metrics, including Dynamic Time Warping (DTW), driven primarily by superior reconstruction coverage. The methodology yielded two complementary archetypes. First, a 36-impact canonical set provides distinct medoids representing core kinematic mechanisms; however, distributional checks confirm these medoids alone do not reproduce cohort severity distributions. To resolve this, we generated a second, extended impact set sampled proportionally within clusters along specific severity axes (e.g., peak acceleration and whole-brain strain). This targeted sampling recovers full severity-distribution fidelity using fewer than 150 impacts per dataset. Ultimately, this framework successfully distills large iMG datasets into manageable cohorts providing a scalable solution for assessment, experimental targets, and finite element simulations.
Koumantou, Eleni, Chan, Emily Yik Kwan, Jones, Chris M., Austin, Kieran, Loosemore, Mike, Ghajari, Mazdak
Pelvis fractures can be complex and occur in many different regions of the bone. Loading due to side impact can transfer anteriorly through the pubic symphysis and posteriorly through the sacroiliac joint. Virtual testing with human body models (HBMs) has the potential to capture the complex loading mechanisms that contribute to pelvis fractures, but injury prediction with HBMs must be refined and validated using physical test data. Most postmortem human subject (PMHS) studies testing side-impact and pelvic injuries use simplified test modes rather than simulating realistic boundary conditions. It is important to understand the differences between pelvis fractures resulting from in-lab tests and those sustained in real-world collisions, particularly for when these PMHS tests are used in injury risk function development to predict injuries caused by collisions in the real world. This study seeks to compare injury types and loading mechanisms from existing PMHS tests to those observed in real-world side-impact collisions from Crash Injury Research and Engineering Network (CIREN) to examine their suitability for refining HBM injury prediction for the pelvis. Seventy-seven percent of PMHS tests with injuries had fractures in the anterior region of the pelvis, 23% in the iliac wing, 30% in the sacroiliac region, and 16% in the acetabulum, where a PMHS test could have fractures in multiple regions. Fractures were divided into primary- and secondary-side fractures, where the primary side was defined as the side impacted in a PMHS test and the side closest to the crash in a CIREN case. A higher proportion of cases with secondary-side acetabulum and sacroiliac pelvis fractures was observed in CIREN compared to PMHS tests, which may be related to interaction with structures in a vehicle environment. A pattern of “squeezing” the pelvis between the intruding door and the center console in near-side crashes was observed.
Nazari, Isabella, Heo, Jaehyuk, Gepner, Bronislaw, Forman, Jason
Modern combat helmets improve wearer survivability through preventing ballistic penetration via delamination or deformation of the shell material. However, this deformation may impinge upon the skull and present a risk of behind-helmet blunt trauma (BHBT). While legacy aramid helmets from the late 1970s–1980s inform current NIJ testing standards, the advent of lower areal density ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) and modern suspensions may incur unknown changes that present an unknown effect on BHBT risk. This study investigates whether current standards relying on a peak acceleration threshold and residual clay deformation may not reflect changes in deformation geometry seen in newer shell materials and suspension designs. Thirty-eight helmets categorized into three groups, older aramid, newer aramid (with new suspension), and prototype UHMWPE (with old suspension), were mounted on Hybrid III ATD head-necks and impacted on the temporal surface with 9 mm NATO projectiles at velocities between 388 and 482 m/s. Flash x-ray imaging captured deformation geometry. Deformations were digitized to measure maximum depth, volume, and surface area recruited. Multiple linear regression identified the influence of shell material and suspension on geometry. Results indicated that shell material significantly affected deformation volume and area (p < 0.05). Notably, UHMWPE exhibited a qualitatively more “pointed” deformation profile compared to aramid, recruiting material differently as depth increased. In contrast, suspension type and helmet design did not significantly influence deformation geometry. These findings suggest that the BHBT geometry in UHMWPE helmets differs fundamentally from aramid helmets. As UHMWPE helmets encounter higher-energy threats, current acceleration threshold or depth-based standards may not fully capture the risk of skull fracture. To future-proof helmet validation, testing standards should evolve beyond current standards to include area recruitment and other geometric measures.
Pang, Derek Y., Salzar, Rober S., Boggess, Brian M., Bass, Cameron R.
Letter from the Guest Editors
Mueller, Becky, Forman, Jason
Fifteen research posters were prepared and presented by student authors. The posters covered a wide breadth of works-in-progress and recently completed projects. Topics included a variety of body regions and injury scenarios: Assessment of Layered Seat Cushion Configurations for Underbody Blast Protection Quantifying Head Impact Exposure in Collegiate 15s Rugby and Relationship to Clinical Measures Elderly Fatality in CIREN Cases: A Matched-Case Review The Relationship between Injury Risk for Child, Teen, and Adult Pedestrians in Collisions Preceded by PAEB Activation and PAEB Pulse Characteristics Quantifying Kinematic and Vibrational Responses in Hockey-Style Catcher’s Mask Incorporating Cortical Bone Property Variability into Simulations of Isolated Ribs under Anterior–Posterior Bending Lacrosse Ball Impacts on Women’s Headgear Mechanical Characterization of the Liver and Kidney: A Systematic Review Quantifying Changes in Mouthguard–Dentition Fit to Support Head Impact Measurement Validity Whole-Body MRI to Assess Perfusion Success and Soft Tissue Injuries in PMHS Subjected to High-Rate Loading Quantitative CT and MRI-Based Modeling Assessment of Spine Injury Risk Following Long-Duration Spaceflight An Investigation of Local Accelerator Pedal Geometry Effects on Ankle Motion How Do Different Human Body Models Affect Occupant Impact Responses and Restraint Design Optimizations in Frontal Crashes? The Potential Effects of Youth Hockey Helmet Shell Add-Ons Evaluation of Surrogate Soft Tissue Candidates for Biofidelity and Durability
Forman, Jason, Mueller, Becky
Youth bicycle helmet manufacturers often add shell protrusions to make helmets more attractive or fun for children, yet the safety implications of these features are not well understood. While prior work suggests protrusions may affect head impact kinematics, no study has evaluated their effectiveness in location-matched impacts between helmets with and without protrusions. Twelve youth bicycle helmet models, with protrusions intact and removed, underwent matched oblique impacts at three locations and 4.2 m/s to capture resulting peak linear acceleration (PLA) and peak rotational acceleration (PRA). A linear mixed model was used to quantify the effect of protrusion presence on PLA, PRA, and impact duration. The youth bicycle helmet models produced a wide range of kinematics. Protrusion presence had a strong effect on PLA, PRA, and impact duration. PLA averaged 103.0 ± 22.8 g for helmets with protrusions compared to 143.9 ± 21.4 g for helmets without protrusions, while PRA averaged 4432 ± 1570 rad/s2 for helmets with protrusions and 5177 ± 2110 rad/s2 for helmets without protrusions. These findings suggest that helmet protrusions can reduce peak head accelerations in youth bicycle helmet impacts.
Jung, Caitlyn, Stark, Nicole E.-P., Rowson, Steve
Lower extremity injuries remain common in frontal motor vehicle crashes, with evidence suggesting increased vulnerability among female occupants. While prior research has established failure tolerances of midsize male lower extremities under bending and combined loading conditions, limited data exist for small female specimens. This study aimed to characterize and compare the failure tolerance of small female and midsize male postmortem human subject lower leg specimens under combined axial compression and posterior–anterior (PA) bending using consistent boundary conditions. Twenty-four lower leg specimens, including the tibia, fibula, and surrounding soft tissue, were obtained from 50th percentile male (n = 12) and 5th percentile female (n = 12) donors. Dynamic tests to failure were conducted at 1.5 m/s using a test apparatus designed to apply three-point bending in the PA direction with varying levels of superimposed axial compression (0, 2, 4, and 6 kN). When paired left and right legs from the same donor were available, they were assigned to different loading conditions to assess the influence of axial compression magnitude. Fracture timing was determined using force, strain, acoustic emission data, high-speed video, and post-test CT imaging. Results indicated that 18 specimens fractured at the tibial shaft, 5 near the potting interface, and 1 did not fracture. Under pure bending, mean failure moments were 255 ± 57 Nm for males and 156 ± 15 Nm for females. At 6 kN axial compression, failure moments decreased to 195 Nm and 72 Nm for male and female specimens, respectively. Among matched pairs, increasing axial load resulted in an average 21% reduction in bending moment at failure. These findings demonstrate reduced failure tolerance with increasing axial compression and highlight sex-based differences. The data provide a foundation for developing improved injury risk functions and scaling methodologies for diverse occupant populations as well as informing anthropometric test devices and human body models.
Carbon, Maria, Nazari, Isabella, Edinger, Timothy, Shin, Jeesoo, Hanggi, Connor, Kerrigan, Jason, Forman, Jason
Globally, approximately 11 million pedestrian impacts each year result in injury or death. The lower extremity is the most frequently injured body region in pedestrian impacts, and these injuries often lead to long-term disability. To better understand lower-extremity injury risk, biomechanical testing of the leg and tibia has previously been conducted. However, this work has mainly focused on males, despite females having a higher risk of sustaining lower-extremity injuries in these loading events. This study aimed to evaluate the effects of sex and age on biomechanical properties of the isolated human tibia in a diverse sample. Sixty-six tibiae from 35 females and 31 males with similar age distributions (p > 0.05; females = 68.8 ± 3.4 years; males = 59.8 ± 4.0 years) were utilized. Tibial diaphyses were loaded to failure at 6 m/s in lateral–medial four-point bending to replicate vehicle bumper interaction in pedestrian impacts. Reaction forces were measured at each end of the bone. Proximal and distal moments were calculated as the product of reaction force and the distance from the axis of rotation to the nearest impact site. Peak bending moment at midshaft was further calculated as the maximum of the average proximal and distal moments. Strain at time of fracture was determined from axial strain gages on the lateral and medial bone surface between impactor locations. Maximum deflection was normalized by specimen length and area moment of inertia. Males exhibited significantly greater peak moments than females (p = 0.001). In the full sample, age demonstrated a weak but significant negative relationship with peak moment (p = 0.013, R2 = 9.3%); however, no significant age relationship was observed when males or females were analyzed separately. Male tibiae had a significantly greater deflection than female tibiae (p = 0.001), but no significant sex difference was observed with normalized deflection. Age was strongly and negatively associated with deflection in the full sample (p < 0.0001, R2 = 39.7%), and for males (p < 0.0001, R2 = 44.8%) and females (p < 0.0001, R2 = 25.4%) separately. No significant sex differences were observed for tensile strain at fracture. However, age had a significant negative relationship with tensile strain in the full sample and within each sex (p < 0.0001). Further investigation with larger sample sizes is needed to characterize the interacting effects of sex, age, and size. Overall, this work advances understanding of tibial biomechanics and provides insight for improving pedestrian safety tools including anthropomorphic test devices and human body models.
Spangler, Jonathon, Agnew, Amanda, Kang, Yun-Seok, Kemper, Andrew, Hunter, Randee, Baker, Gretchen, Guettler, Allison, Harden, Angela
The widespread use of explosive weapons in recent military conflicts has contributed to an increased incidence of traumatic brain injuries. Although current infantry helmets provide effective protection against fragmentation, ballistic impact, and blunt trauma, they are not designed to mitigate primary blast loading. Previous studies suggest that blast waves may infiltrate the space between the head and helmet, leading to localized increases in pressure on the head surface, a phenomenon referred to as the underwash effect. However, experimental validation of the underwash effect remains limited, particularly for blast scenarios representative of buried-charge detonations, despite their potential to increase underwash-related loading across large regions of the cranial surface. This study experimentally evaluated the effects of combat helmet use, blast orientation, and blast intensity on head surface loading to assess helmet protective performance across various blast scenarios. A human surrogate headform instrumented with four flush-mounted pressure sensors was exposed to blast overpressures of approximately 16 and 24 psi using a large advanced blast simulator. Tests were conducted at 0° and 45° head orientations (rotation about the transverse axis), both with and without a combat helmet, with three repetitions per combination of experimental conditions. In the 0° orientation, helmet use reduced loading at the forehead and anterior head but increased loading at the posterior region. In the 45° orientation, helmet use led to increased peak pressure and total impulse at all measured locations. Increasing the blast intensity resulted in similar trends for both orientations and helmet conditions but with greater peak pressures and total impulses at each measured location. These findings suggest that certain blast orientations exacerbate the underwash effect and amplify cranial loading beneath the helmet. This work advances understanding of orientation-dependent blast loading, highlights limitations in current helmet performance, and offers guidance to support the development of future protective technologies.
Nelson, Allison J., Burt, Ethan T., Hamilton, Joseph M., Espinoza, Kenny J., Magallanes, Joseph, VandeVord, Pamela J.
The gathered journalists cover their ears as a loud hydraulic ram begins to load and a warning alarm sounds. Less than a minute later… FOOSH… BAM! A 9.9-pound model of a human head is launched into the front-end structure of a test vehicle, deforming the hood and sending the head bouncing to the ground. The violence of the moment, which is part of pedestrian safety research, is a stark reminder of the seriousness of all the testing that happens at Toyota's North American Research and Development Headquarters in York Township, Michigan. The $187-million (in 2007 dollars) facility includes 180,000 sq.ft. of research and testing space.
Clonts, Chris
Thoracic injuries are common for belted occupants in frontal motor vehicle crashes. However, there remains a lack of female post-mortem human subject (PMHS) data in the literature to generate female-specific biomechanical response corridors and evaluate engineering tools such as anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs) and computational human body models (HBMs). Additionally, the effect of breast tissue on thoracic response has not been directly investigated despite female ATDs and HBMs having features representing breasts. As such, this study sought to utilize simplified frontal hub impacts to (1) generate female PMHS thoracic response corridors both with breasts positioned with a bra and without breasts (no bra) and (2) preliminarily explore the influence of breasts on the thoracic responses of female PMHS. Twelve female PMHS (9 small and 3 midsize) were subjected to frontal impacts at mid-sternum with a 14.0 kg circular impactor at 4.3 m/s in conditions with and without breasts. Force versus deflection (FD) response corridors were generated, and comparisons were made between groups and to scaled FD corridors representing female response. Overall, female PMHS with and without breasts displayed differences in FD response compared to scaled corridors in terms of the shape of the initial response and peak force and deflection. Additionally, female PMHS with breasts produced lower peak force and greater peak deflection compared to those without breasts. These results suggest the importance of collection and evaluation of female biomechanical data that can be used for continued evaluation of female-specific safety tools as well as the further reduction of injury risk for all occupants during motor vehicle crashes.
Baker, Gretchen H., Kang, Yun-Seok, Marcallini, Angelo, Lang, Ryan, Hutter, Erin, Moorhouse, Kevin, Agnew, Amanda M.
Letter from the Editor-in-Chief
Hardy, Warren N.
Objective: This study sought to implement pressure mapping methodology to assess variation in children’s center of force positions in reclined vehicle scenarios. Methods: Thirty-four children between 4 and 12 y (8.1 ± 2.0 y) were statically evaluated on a vehicle seat across two seating conditions (with and without a backless booster) and three seatback recline conditions (25°, 45°, and 60°). Center of force was recorded using pressure sensors attached to the seating surface. Average center of force fore/aft positions were calculated and transformed into the vehicle coordinate system using 3D coordinate measurements. Descriptive statistics and repeated measures ANOVA were used to assess variation in center of force position across seating and recline conditions, with subject included as a random effect. Results: Center of force fore/aft position varied (p < 0.05) with recline condition, seating condition, and the recline/seating condition interaction term. On the booster, the average center of force position became more aft in the 45° (131.1 ± 17.5 mm) and 60° (125.5 ± 16.7 mm) conditions compared to 25° (148.7 ± 17.4 mm). Without the booster, the center of force also became more aft in the 45° (197.7 ± 31.1 mm) condition compared to the 25° condition (204.6 ± 29.1 mm), but the position in the 60° (206.1 ± 31.8 mm) condition was similar. As children assumed more reclined postures, the center of force became more aft, except for the no-booster 60° condition. Discussion: Changes in center of force followed the same trends observed in the pelvis and lower extremity position (became more aft) with increasing seatback recline on the booster and smaller changes observed on the no-booster condition. Future work should investigate additional vehicle/booster geometries and longer seating durations. The changes in center of force observed with seatback recline emphasize the importance of understanding how real children modify their posture over time to different vehicle environments as posture directly influences belt fit, occupant–restraint interaction, and injury risk. Center of force data can inform the positioning of child surrogates in future dynamic evaluations of reclined configurations.
Baker, Gretchen H., Connell, Rosalie R., Graci, Valentina, Mansfield, Julie A.
The objective of this study was to investigate occupant injury patterns and predictors in rear-impact crashes using recent US field data. Cases were queried from the Crash Investigation Sampling System (CISS, 2017–2023) and the Crash Injury Research and Engineering Network (CIREN, 2017–2024), yielding 1923 front-row outboard occupants from 1533 crashes. Crash documentation and vehicle photographs were manually reviewed to classify seatback deformation magnitude and secondary impact severity. Multivariable logistic regression models estimated associations between occupant, vehicle, and crash characteristics and Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) ≥ 2 and AIS ≥ 3 injury outcomes across body regions. Sensitivity analyses included CISS-only, weighted, single-event, and interaction models. Thoracic injuries were further subdivided into skeletal and cardiopulmonary categories. Findings reflect associations within the pooled CISS + CIREN analytic sample rather than nationally representative injury rates. Seatback deformation and multievent crash classification are proxy measures and may introduce misclassification and residual confounding. A total of 188 occupants sustained AIS ≥ 2 injuries and 81 sustained AIS ≥ 3 injuries. Head injury was the most frequent AIS ≥ 2 outcome, while thoracic injury was the most frequent serious injury outcome, accounting for 60% of AIS ≥ 3 cases. Across AIS ≥ 2 and AIS ≥ 3 models, crash severity (delta-v) was the most consistent predictor of injury. Age was strongly associated with injury across most AIS ≥ 2 outcomes and several AIS ≥ 3 models, particularly for overall maximum Abbreviated Injury Scale (MAIS) and thoracic injury. Seatback deformation was associated with injury across multiple models after controlling for crash severity and occupant characteristics, with severe deformation showing stronger associations with AIS ≥ 3 outcomes. Unbelted status was associated with abdominal, pelvic, and lumbar spine injury. Female sex was associated with thoracic injury, primarily attributable to cardiopulmonary rather than skeletal injury. These findings highlight statistical associations between seatback deformation severity, restraint status, occupant characteristics, and injury outcomes in rear-impact crashes.
Lockerby, Jack, Rudd, Rodney
This study investigated sex-specific differences in thoracic injury prevalence, causation, and rib fracture patterns among seriously injured occupants in frontal motor vehicle collisions. Crash Injury Research and Engineering Network (CIREN) data from 2005 to 2022 included 793 front-seat occupants aged 16 years and older with Abbreviated Injury Scale 2+ thorax injury, representing 1802 thoracic injuries. Injuries were grouped as rib fracture, sternum fracture, hemo/pneumothorax, lung injury, heart injury, and other. A weighted scoring system captured contributions of involved physical components to each injury. Logistic and linear regression with generalized estimating equations assessed sex associations with injury presence and causation. Two models were estimated: a comprehensively adjusted model including demographic, crash, vehicle, restraint, and airbag deployment, and a simplified model adjusting for age, body mass index, delta-V, and occupant role. Among occupants with AIS 2+ thoracic injuries, sex-specific differences were observed in injury patterns and causation. Females were less likely than males to sustain lung injuries (OR = 0.70, p = 0.038) and more likely to sustain rib fractures (OR = 1.25, p = 0.006). Females had higher odds of rib fractures attributed to seatbelt loading in both models (Full: OR = 2.20, p = 0.005; Simplified: OR = 1.55, p = 0.021). Females were less likely than males to sustain lung injuries (OR = 0.17, p = 0.042) and hemo/pneumothoraces (OR = 0.15, p = 0.044) from instrument panel loading. Steering wheel, airbag, and other components showed no significant sex-specific associations with thoracic injury. Rib fracture patterns showed clusters along the seatbelt path in belted occupants and a more diffuse pattern in unbelted occupants, with minimal significant findings of differences between sexes. These findings contribute to the growing evidence of sex-specific injury patterns and may inform future research on injury prediction and prevention strategies. However, this dataset includes only occupants with AIS 2+ thoracic injuries and therefore cannot be extrapolated to the general population or to collisions outside those represented in the sample.
Armstrong, William, Devane, Karan, Hsu, Fang-Chi, Heilmann, Nina, Sink, Joel, Miller, Anna N., Kiani, Bahram, Martin, R. Shayn, Stitzel, Joel D., Weaver, Ashley
Research Question/Methods The study examined abdominal injuries of 87 belted occupants in CIREN frontal crashes for sex-based differences in abdominal injury patterns. It introduced a more anatomically detailed method for identifying injury locations in an abdominal-pelvic region that includes skeletal structures. The study introduces and applies a novel Abdominal New Injury Severity Score (AbNISS) to address limitations of traditional AIS coding in capturing sex-based differences in injury patterns. The operative reports/EDR/imaging data in CIREN cases enabled identification of sex-specific crash outcomes. The dominant analytical motif is Bertrand Russell’s knowledge by acquaintance and definite descriptions. Results Females had a higher rate of moderate to severe abdominal injuries than males: Only females sustained AIS 5 injuries, lumbar Chance fractures, posterior pelvic arch injuries, and more AIS 2, 3, and 4 injuries, with more injuries in superior-mid, left-superior, and medial-mid-abdominal zones. Males had more in the medial-inferior zone. 13 females had muscle ruptures. Four had combined muscle and Morel–Lavallée injuries, and four had Morel–Lavallée injuries alone. 13 of 14 males had muscle ruptures only. Pelvic morphology: Statistically significant (p < 0.05) sex-based difference in pelvic aspect ratios: Females: 1.37 ± 0.053, with the male ratio of 1.28 ± 0.079. By incorporating anatomical precision and enhanced injury mapping, it supports the development of more representative ATD/human body models. Discussion and Limitations Limitations of the study include its retrospective design, possible inconsistencies in clinical documentation, and challenges in applying AbNISS coding to non-CIREN datasets due to specificity constraints.
Halloway, Dale, Curry, William, Somasundaram, Karthik, Pintar, Frank
The objective of this study is to use parametric human body models (HBMs) to understand how geometric variability among individuals who have the same sex, stature, and body weight may affect the impact responses and injury outcomes, using midsize male and midsize female populations as representative cases. Methods were developed to quantify skeletal and external body surface variations using principal component analysis, regression, and residual error analysis. Based on this analysis, nine midsize male and nine midsize female geometric models were created, focusing on ribcage and pelvis variations, which account for most of the observed variability. These geometries were then applied to morph the simplified Global Human Body Model Consortium (GHBMC) midsize male model, producing 18 distinct HBMs. Each morphed HBM was subjected to nine impact scenarios, resulting in a total of 162 simulations to assess the effects of geometric variability. Substantial geometric variation was observed in the ribcage and pelvis, while the femur and tibia showed minimal variability for both midsize males and females. All morphed HBMs had good mesh quality, and all crash simulations terminated normally without error. Component-level tests showed relatively minor differences in impact responses among HBMs with identical sex, stature, and body weight. However, the United States New Car Assessment Program (US-NCAP) frontal crash simulations revealed considerable differences in injury risk, especially in the front passenger position. These findings highlight the importance of accounting for geometric variability, even among HBMs with the same sex, stature, and body weight, when evaluating injury risks in severe frontal crashes. It is especially important to consider ribcage geometry variations, which could impact occupant sitting height, posture, and injury risks at different body regions in frontal crashes. This study demonstrated that future virtual testing frameworks using HBMs should consider human geometric variations, especially in the ribcage and pelvis, when assessing injury risks in vehicle frontal crashes.
Hu, Jingwen, Lin, Yang-Shen, Boyle, Kyle, Khandare, Sujata, Bonifas, Anne, Reed, Matthew P., Hasija, Vikas
Researchers recently helped Skydio, the leading U.S. drone manufacturer, demonstrate compliance to the Federal Aviation Administration's rules for safe flights over people and vehicles. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA Operators using a drone from the leading manufacturer in the U.S. can now conduct missions over people and vehicles much easier and with even greater confidence in their safety. In January, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) accepted a declaration of compliance for such flights for the parachute-equipped Skydio X10 drone from Skydio, a San Mateo, California-based company that supplies its drones to customers in public safety, utilities, and national security. The acceptance came as the result of working with Virginia Tech's Mid-Atlantic Aviation Partnership (MAAP) and Center for Injury Biomechanics to complete their FAA-approved means of compliance testing.
Vehicle-to-vehicle sideswipe collisions are unique in their impact characteristics because the vehicles typically do not reach a common velocity at impact. To better understand the characteristics and dynamics of sideswipe collisions, vehicle-to-vehicle crash testing was performed to find the relationships between variables related to the impact, such as closing speed, relative angle, and overlap depth. This paper discusses data collected for three sideswipe (oblique) impact tests conducted at a testing facility in Buffalo, New York. The tests were conducted using a passenger vehicle as the sideswiping vehicle, which impacted a stationary cargo van. The passenger vehicle was towed into the van at relative angles ranging from 8 to 15 degrees and at velocities of 5 to 20 mph. Two different (but identical) passenger cars and two cargo vans were used during the testing series. Test results were then utilized to investigate a methodology of analyzing sideswipe collisions as a combination of low-speed lateral impact in conjunction with longitudinal sliding friction for application to accident reconstruction. One instrumented Hybrid III 5th percentile female Anthropomorphic Test Device (ATD) outfitted with a 15 pound weighted vest was placed in the front driver designated seating position according to instructions specified in the TP-208 Test Procedure. TP-208 is the USDOT laboratory test procedure for FMVSS 208, Occupant Crash Protection. The testing facility performed all acquisition, setup, and instrumentation operations for the vehicles utilized in crash testing, as well as provided the reported data obtained during testing. For testing, the ATD and test vehicles were instrumented with accelerometers, which were used to record the accelerations to the occupant and vehicles throughout each sideswipe impact test. The ATD was additionally instrumented with force transducers to measure the forces experienced by the ATD during the testing. The objective of this research was to examine the collision dynamics and the instrumented ATD responses for each sideswipe test performed to provide data relevant to accident reconstruction and biomechanical analysis. The research also compared the collected test data to a proposed methodology for reconstructing sideswipe collisions.
Danaher, David, McDonough, Sean, Donaldson, Andrew, Neale, William, Cochran, Reece
It all started when Owen Kent and Todd Roberts became roommates at the University of California Berkeley. Owen has muscular dystrophy and had recently acquired a robotic arm, which he noticed he was using to do range of motion. Todd had come to Berkeley to study mechanical engineering with a focus on biomechanics, and both were enrolled in Designing for the Human Body, a biomechanics course taught by Mechanical Engineering Professor Grace O’Connell.
In the pre-crash emergency braking scenario, the occupant inside the vehicle will move forward due to inertia, deviating from the standard upright seating position for which conventional restraint systems are designed. Previous studies have mainly focused on the influence of out-of-position (OOP) displacement on occupant injuries in frontal collisions, and provided solutions such as active pretensioning seatbelts (APS). But little attention has been paid to the influence of OOP on whiplash injury during a subsequent rear-end collision. To investigate the forward OOP impact on whiplash injuries and the effectiveness of APS in this accident scenario, a vehicle interior model with an active human body model (AHBM) was setup in the MADYMO simulation platform. Different braking strengths (0.8g and 1.1g), APS triggering times (from 0.2s before to 0.2s after the braking initiation) and pretensioning forces (from 100N to 600N) were input to the simulation matrix. The occupant’s forward OOP displacement prior to the rear-end collision and the corresponding whiplash injury metrics including neck shear force, tension force, and neck injury criteria (NIC) in the subsequent moderate rear-end collision were recorded. The simulation results indicated that: (1) The occupant’s whiplash injury metrics were positively linearly correlated with the pre-crash forward OOP displacement. (2) The APS could not fully eliminate the forward displacement brought by neck flexion, causing whiplash injury metrics to exceed the capping limits (upper bounds) defined in current vehicle safety assessment protocols like Euro-NCAP.
Fei, Jing, Qiu, Hang, Wang, Peifeng, Liu, Yu, Cheng, James Chih, Zhou, Qing, Tan, Puyuan
Vehicles equipped with automated driving systems (ADS) may have non-traditional seating configurations, such as rear-facing for front-row occupants. The objectives of this study are (1) to generate biomechanical corridors from kinematic data obtained from postmortem human subjects (PMHS) sled tests and (2) to assess the biofidelity of the Global Human Body Models Consortium (GHBMC) 50th male (M50-O) v6.0 seated in an upright (25-deg recline) Honda Accord seat with a fixed D-ring (FDR) in a 56 km/h rear-facing frontal impact. A phase optimization technique was applied to mass-normalized PMHS data for generating corridors. After replicating the experimental boundary conditions in the computational finite element (FE) environment, the performance of the rigidized FE seat model obtained was validated using LSTC Hybrid III FE model simulations and comparison with experiments. The most recent National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) Biofidelity Ranking System (BRS) method was used to assess the biofidelity of the GHBMC M50-O. The occupant response score for GHBMC was 2.00. The average normalized root mean squared deviation (NRMSD) for seat reaction loads in the GHBMC simulation was less than 10%. Peak T-spine accelerations (avg. BRS = 2.28) and anterior-to-posterior (AP) chest deflection (BRS = 2.61) were underestimated. No rib fractures were predicted in the GHBMC using the default failure strain criteria of 1.8%; however, fractures were predicted in the 3rd rib (both left and right sides) using an updated failure strain criteria of 0.52%. Ramping up the seat back, as indicated by pelvis Z-displacement, was underestimated using a coefficient of contact friction of 0.2 (BRS = 3.65) but improved using a coefficient of 0.1 (BRS = 1.44). Local strain hotspots were predicted at the pubic rami locations in the GHBMC, corresponding well with fracture sites in the PMHS.
Pradhan, Vikram, Ramachandra, Rakshit, Stammen, Jason, Kracht, Corey, Moorhouse, Kevin, Bolte, John H., Kang, Yun-Seok
The introduction of unrestrained torso neck braces as a safety intervention for helmeted motorcycle riders has introduced a set of unsolved challenges. Understanding the injury prevention afforded by these devices depends on a reliable test methodology by which to critically evaluate their efficacy against the most common mechanisms of neck injury. An inverted pendulum test is proposed to evaluate compression flexion (CF), tension flexion (TF), and tension extension (TE) of the neck using a Hybrid III anthropomorphic test device (HIII ATD) neck and a motorcycle-specific ATD (MATD) neck. In addition to investigating methods to quantify the beneficial effects of a neck brace, potential adverse effects of such a device are evaluated by measuring and evaluating relevant neck response measures. To that end, measured data using a current neck brace were analyzed and applied to various injury criteria related to the ATD neck used to compare the injury risk predicted by each parameter. The HIII ATD neck allows for a more conservative evaluation due to its exaggerated response in compression and may be more suitable in evaluating the neck injury criterion and injury risk in CF loading for low energy impacts. The MATD neck is limited to certain impact modalities, particularly the uncoupled behavior between head and neck during hyperextension, and individual neck measures at lower impact energy due to its limited structural integrity in direct head impacts. In the proposed tests, injury mechanisms were initially associated with a pre-impact head orientation and expected head and neck motion. However, these associations are not definitive. Although the most relevant neck injury mechanisms related to the unrestrained torso were addressed, the authors suggest that the presented tests are supplemented by a method to evaluate higher energy vertex impacts as a means to determine a neck brace’s efficacy during this loading modality.
de Jongh, Cornelis U., Basson, Anton H., Knox, Erick H., Leatt, Christopher J.
With the capability of predicting detailed injury of occupants, the Human Body Model (HBM) was used to identify potential injuries for occupants in car impact events. However, there are few publications on using HBM in the aviation industry. This study aims to investigate and compare the head, neck, lumbar spine and thoracic responses of the Hybrid III and the THUMS (Total Human Model for Safety) model in the horizontal 26g and vertical 19g sled tests required by the General Aviation Aircraft Airworthiness Regulations. The HIC of THUMS and Hybrid III did not exceed the requirements of airworthiness regulations. Still, THUMS had higher intracranial pressures and intracranial stresses, which could result in brain injury to the occupants. In vertical impact, the highest stress of the neck of THUMS appears at the cervical spine C2 and the upper neck is easily injured; in horizontal impact, the cervical spine C7 has the highest load, and the lower neck is easily injured. Due to the low biofidelity of the Hybrid III ATD neck structure, the injuries that appeared at different neck locations cannot be identified by the Hybrid III ATD. Because of the submarining phenomenon, the lumbar spine load and bending moment of the THUMS are much smaller than that of the ATD model, which shows a lower risk of injuries. In both impact scenarios, the THUMS chest deformation was higher. In the vertical 19g impact, the THUMS developed much higher shoulder belt loads than the ATD. The results indicate the Hybrid III ATD underestimates the risk of injury to passengers' heads and chests, while overestimating the risk to the lumbar spine compared to THUMS. Furthermore, due to limitations in the locations of sensors, the Hybrid III ATD is unable to identify the severe injury at lower neck and upper lumbar.
Shi, Xiaopeng, Ding, Xianghe, Guo, Kai, Liu, Tianfu, Xie, Jiang
Seventeen research posters were prepared and presented by student authors. The posters covered a wide breadth of works-in-progress and recently completed projects. Topics included a variety of body regions and injury scenarios: Biofidelity Corridors of Powered Two-Wheeler Rider Kinematics from Full-Scale Crash Testing Using Postmortem Human Subjects, Meringolo et al. Cervical Vertebral and Spinal Cord Injuries Remain Overrepresented in Rollover Occupants, Al-Salehi et al. The Effect of Surfaces on Knee Biomechanics during a 90-Degree Cut, Rhodes et al. Investigating the Variabilities in the Spinal Cord Injury in Pig Models Using Benchtop Test Model and Ultrasound Analyses, Borjali et al. Relationship between Tackle Form and Head Kinematics in Youth Football, Holcomb et al. Comparing Motor Vehicle Collision Injury Incidence between Pregnant and Nonpregnant Individuals: A Case–Control Study, Levine et al. Development of an Automated Pipeline to Characterize Full Rib Cage Shape Variability, Robinson et al. Soft Tissue Force Attenuation and Redistribution during Lateral Hip Impacts, Pretty et al. Hybrid III Small Female Neck Interaction with a Driver Airbag: Preliminary Observations, Boyle et al. Changes in Youth Football Athletes’ Oculomotor Task Metrics across Three High School Seasons of Play, Pang et al. Measurement of Shielding Stiffness in Ice Hockey, Vakili et al. Investigating the Relationship between Vehicle-Based and Biomechanics Injury Metrics in Car-to-End Terminal Crashes Using a Human Finite Element Model, Buckland et al. On-Field Instrumented Mouthguard Coupling, Luke et al. Investigation of Rear-Seat Occupant Safety during High-Speed Frontal Crashes Using GHBMC M50-O, Dahiya et al. Deformable Headform Design Choices: An Evaluation of Brain Simulant Stiffness Influence on Intracranial Displacements and Strain, Xu et al. Changes in Neurocognitive Outcomes among Youth Football Teams Participating in an Intervention, Marks et al. A Parametric Skeleton Model of Human Upper Extremities Accounting for Morphological Variations among the Diverse Population, Neeluru et al.
Bautsch, Brian T., Cripton, Peter A., Cronin, Duane
Fragility fracture of the hip is a global health concern with generally poor outcomes. Clinical studies have shown prophylactic augmentation of the femur to be a plausible intervention with success in some approaches; however, its use is not yet widespread in the clinical community. We aimed to evaluate the efficacy and clinical safety of prophylactic intramedullary nailing for hip fracture prevention after a fall impact in six cadaveric pelvis–femurs. Post-fall fracture status of the native specimens was determined in a virtual control group built using a validated and peer-reviewed finite element method. A commercially available intramedullary nailing system was prophylactically implanted in all specimens. After augmentation, specimens were subjected to an experimental sideways fall impact and inspected for fracture. Overall, fracture status was unchanged or lowered in severity in the augmented group compared to the native control group. No sign of femur fracture was found in the group augmented by intramedullary nailing, but two augmented specimens exhibited pelvis fractures after the impact. No safety concerns associated with prophylactic nailing were found. These results suggest that prophylactic nailing may reduce the potential for hip fracture in a sideways fall impact but would not reduce the likelihood of pelvis fracture, and may shift femur fractures to instead be pelvis fractures. This study provides a robust biomechanical evaluation of prophylactic augmentation with a device already familiar to orthopedic surgeons, broadening the options currently considered for the prevention of hip fractures.
Bliven, Emily K., Fung, Anita, Baker, Alexander, Helgason, Benedikt, Guy, Pierre, Cripton, Peter A.
Thorax injuries are a significant cause of mortality in automotive crashes, with varying susceptibility across sex and age demographics. Finite element (FE) human body models (HBMs) offer the potential for injury outcome analysis by incorporating anthropometric variations. Recent advancements in material constitutive models, cortical bone fracture and continuum damage mechanics model (CFraC) and an orthotropic trabecular bone model (OrthoT), offer the opportunity to further improve rib models. In this study, the CFraC and OrthoT material modes, coupled with age-specific material properties, were progressively implemented to the Global Human Body Model Consortium small female 6th rib. Four distinct 6th rib models were developed and compared against sex and age-specific experimental data. The updated material models notably refined the predictions of force–displacement responses, aligning them more closely with the experimental averages. The CFraC model significantly improved the prediction of displacement at fracture, suggesting that incorporating stress triaxiality criteria can better account for the complex loading conditions ribs face in crashes, such as combined cortical tension and shear due to rib bending and torque. The study highlights the importance of using biofidelic material models and sex and age-specific data to simulate hard tissue fractures. The improved rib model demonstrates the effectiveness of integrating updated material properties and constitutive models to enhance injury prediction accuracy, which can inform better automotive safety designs and reduce mortality rates. Further research is recommended to extend these models across different demographic groups to fully capture population variability in rib fracture risk.
Corrales, Miguel A., Holcombe, Sven, Agnew, Amanda M., Kang, Yun-Seok, Markusic, Craig, Sugaya, Hisaki, Cronin, Duane S.
Prevention and diagnosis of traumatic brain injuries (TBI) are reliant on understanding the biomechanical response of the brain to external stimuli. Finite element models (FEM) and artificial head surrogates are becoming a common method of investigating the dynamic response of the brain to injurious impact and inertial stimuli. The accuracy and validity of these models is reliant on postmortem human subject (PMHS) research to produce biofidelic brain tissue responses. Previous PMHS research has been performed to measure intracranial pressures, displacements, and strains when subjected to impact and inertial loading; however, there remains a need for additional PMHS datasets to improve our understanding of the brain’s dynamics. The purpose of this study is to measure the relative brain–skull displacement in a PMHS specimen when subjected to blunt force impacts. A high-speed X-ray (HSXR) imaging system and embedded radiopaque elastomeric markers were used to record PMHS impacts at varying impact velocities for two specimens: specimen CO-108 was subjected to a series of frontal impacts and specimen CO-109 was subjected to a series of rear impacts. Brain–skull relative deformation in each specimen indicates that brain deformation is dependent both on anatomical regions and of impact direction.
Demiannay, Jean-Jacques, Rovt, Jennifer, Brannen, MacKenzie, Xu, Sheng, Kang, Gia, Yip, Ashley, Azadi, Amir Hossein, Dehghan, Parisa, Goodwin, Shannon, Taylor, Reggie, Poon, Katherine, Brien, Susan, Hoshizaki, Blaine, Karton, Clara, Petel , Oren
Rear-end vehicle collisions may lead to whiplash-associated disorders (WADs), comprising a variety of neck and head pain responses. Specifically, increased axial head rotation has been associated with the risk of injuries during rear impacts, while specific tissues, including the capsular ligaments, have been implicated in pain response. Given the limited experimental data for out-of-position rear impact scenarios, computational human body models (HBMs) can inform the potential for tissue-level injury. Previous studies have considered external boundary conditions to reposition the head axially but were limited in reproducing a biofidelic movement. The objectives of this study were to implement a novel head repositioning method to achieve targeted axial rotations and evaluate the tissue-level response for a rear impact condition. The repositioning method used reference geometries to rotate the head to three target positions, showing good correspondence to reported interverbal rotations. Under a 7 g rear impact scenario, the head-turned models were compared with the neutral position and demonstrated increases in the maximum capsular ligament distractions. Increased head rotation was associated with increased ligament distractions. The locations with critical ligament distractions shifted to the lower cervical spine (below C3) and lateral portion of the capsular ligaments for the head-turned position cases. The proposed repositioning method introduced in this study enabled the model to achieve steady head rotations with realistic cervical spine movements, increasing the biofidelity of out-of-position rear impact simulations.
Reis, Matheus Seif, Cronin, Duane
Exploring the mechanical properties of soft tissues under compressive loading is crucial for understanding their role in automobile incidents. Soft tissues, which serve as cushions or padding between bone and vehicle interiors, significantly influence contact duration and forces, thereby altering incident kinematics and injury. In this investigation, muscle and soft connective tissues from post-mortem human subjects (PMHS) forearms were excised and subjected to compression and indentation testing methods at various rates and strains. Specific samples with higher proportions of muscle were compared against samples without muscle tissues to evaluate the role of compositional changes. Anthropomorphic test device (ATD) upper extremity foam and vinyl–foam composite analog tissues underwent similar testing for comparison. High impact rates simulating those in high-speed automotive collisions were achieved using a custom-built drop tower impactor setup. The results revealed significantly higher stiffness values for samples with large proportions of muscle tissue compared to no muscle samples at smaller deformations. Substantial differences in stiffness were seen between soft tissues and ATD materials across most loading rates and strains, although some exceptions were noted at higher rates and strains. An indentation and modified Zener model were used to quantify material parameters. These findings provide a solid basis for advancing ATD analogs and have broader implications for soft tissue research. Moreover, this work represents a crucial step toward enhancing safety standards in the automotive industry.
Dennis, Cole J., Quenneville, Cheryl E.
Drop tower testing was conducted using 50th percentile male PMHS at 15G peak acceleration in a rigid seat, with a seat pan-to-seatback angle of 90°. Subjects were instrumented with 6DOF motion blocks at T1, T4, T12, L3, and S1 to capture detailed vertebral body kinematics. Pressure sensors were also placed throughout the lumbar spine to estimate force in the intervertebral discs from S1-L2. PMHS were restrained using a pilot torso harness attached to the seat at the shoulders and lap belt, both pretensioned to 89 N. Reaction forces were measured in the seat using six-axis loads under the seat pan. Final positioning of the occupant was documented using a FARO arm point probe and laser scanner. To recreate the experimental setup, CAD models of the experimental fixture were meshed using a commercial FE modeling software (Hypermesh) and imported into LS-Dyna for incorporation with the THUMS model. The belt routing tool in LS-PrePost v4.9.12 was used to develop the torso harness and shoulder and lap belts. Pre-simulation was performed to position the THUMS model in accordance with recorded FARO data, and the experimentally recorded seat vertical acceleration was assigned using Boundary_Prescribed_Motion. Finally, instrumentation locations were duplicated within the THUMS model to match the PMHS experimental setup. The THUMS model showed similar head kinematics compared to the experiment, which went first into extension, followed by flexion during the primary pulse. The torso of the model, however, experienced an increased flexion/compression response compared to PMHS. The peak reaction force in the simulated seat load cells measured 12.7 kN, which was within one standard deviation of the average normalized experimental values (average = 12.8 kN, standard deviation = 0.4 kN). The average load in the lumbar spine in the model was found to be 3.3 kN, which was lower than PMHS average by more than two standard deviations.
DeWitt, Timothy R., Marcallini, Angelo M., Bolte IV, John H., Kang, Yun-Seok
Athletes may sustain numerous head impacts during sport, leading to potential neurological consequences. Wearable sensors enable real-world head impact data collection, offering insight into sport-specific brain injury mechanisms. Most instrumented mouthguard studies focus on a single sport, lacking a quantitative comparison of head impact biomechanics across sports. Additionally, direct comparison of prior studies can be challenging due to variabilities in methodology and data processing. Therefore, we gathered head impact data across multiple sports and processed all data using a uniform processing pipeline to enable direct comparisons of impact biomechanics. Our aim was to compare peak kinematics, impulse durations, and head impact directionality across ice hockey, American football, rugby, and soccer. We found that American football had the highest magnitude of head impact kinematics and observed directionality differences in linear and angular kinematics between sports. On the other hand, there were no significant differences in impulse durations, which was unexpected given the different impacting objects and protective equipment across sports. In future work, we aim to expand our dataset to better match sports for understanding the influence of sex, equipment, and playstyle on head impact biomechanics.
Masood, Zaryan Z., Luke, David S., Kenny, Rebecca A., Bondi, Daniel R., Clansey, Adam C., Wu, Lyndia C.
Extreme out-of-position pre-crash postures may need high-force pre-pretensioner (PPT) for effective repositioning (Mishra et al., 2023). To avoid applying a high force on the chest, we hypothesized that in case of these extreme postures the PPT may be activated in the absence of a pre-crash motion as a cautionary measure. Therefore, the aims of this study were: (1) to understand the effect of the PPT in repositioning a forward-leaning occupant in static conditions and (2) to characterize occupants’ kinematic variability during repositioning. Sixteen healthy volunteers (8 males, 8 females, 23.8 ± 4.2 years old) were seated with a 40° forward posture on a vehicle seat and restrained with a 3-point seat belt equipped with a PPT. Two PPT seatbelt conditions were examined: low PPT (100 N) and high PPT (300 N). Head and trunk rearward displacements relative to the initial forward-leaning position at 350 ms from PPT onset were collected with a 3D motion-capture system and compared between sexes, repetitions, and PPT levels with repeated measure 3-way ANOVAs (p-level = 0.05). Head and trunk rearward displacements were greater with the high PPT (head −93.8 ± 9.3 mm, trunk −78.7 ± 6.7 mm) than the low PPT (head −44.6 ± 8.9 mm, trunk −39.7 ± 7.6 mm) (p < 0.001). There were no statistically significant differences between sexes (p > 0.19), repetition (p > 0.28), and no interaction effects (p > 0.18). There was greater inter-subject variability in the low (head −109.5 to −22.1 mm, trunk −105.0 to −17.5 mm) compared to high PPT (head −175.0 to −62.5 mm, trunk −128.4 to −54.8 mm). Although no sex differences were found, the high inter-subject variability suggests that PPT timing and force level might not be designed as one-size-fits-all. This study shows that triggering the PPT when the vehicle is traveling at a constant speed could reduce the PPT force needed to reposition forward-leaning occupants during pre-crash maneuvers.
Witmer, Maitland, Griffith, Madeline, Graci, Valentina
Head injuries account for 15% of snowsport-related injuries, and the majority of head impacts occur against ice or snow, low-friction surfaces. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate how surface friction affects snowsport helmets’ oblique impact kinematics. Ten helmet models were impacted using an oblique drop tower with a 45-degree anvil and NOCSAE headform, at three locations, two surface friction conditions, and a drop speed of 5.0 m/s. Our findings indicate that friction affects peak linear acceleration, peak rotational acceleration, and peak rotational velocity during helmet impacts, with changes in post-impact rotation and impact response varying by location. Surface friction affects head impact kinematics, underscoring the need for sport-specific lab testing and emphasizing the need for friction-specific and sport-specific testing, particularly for snowsports, where surface conditions like snow and ice can alter kinematics.
Stark, Nicole E.-P., Calis, Andrew, Wood, Matthew, Piwowarski, Summer Blue, Dingelstedt, Kristin, Begonia, Mark, Rowson, Steve
Mitigating both neck and head injuries in the pediatric population relies heavily on improving our understanding of the underlying biomechanics of the pediatric cervical spine. The tensile response for individual motion segments and the whole cervical spine (WCS) has been reported, but there is no data characterizing the intersegmental kinematics of pediatric WCS under axial loading conditions. The structural response of motion segments and WCS provide valuable data for the design and validation of biofidelic physical and computational models for the pediatric population. However, the use of motion segment data to construct WCS response or the use of WCS axial response to accurately characterize intersegmental response may present limitations to accurately modeling the pediatric cervical spine response. In this secondary analysis of the work of Luck et al. (2008, 2013), the fixed-fixed, low load, quasi-static tensile response of the WCS and individual motion segments (O-C2, C4-C5, and C6-C7) of a six-year-old postmortem human surrogate (PMHS) was investigated to quantify and compare the intersegmental kinematics under both conditions. In the whole spine, O-C2, C3-C4, C6-C7, and C7-T1 exhibited a tensile response, C2-C3 and C5-C6 exhibited a compressive response, and C4-C5 did not exhibit an appreciable response in the axial loading direction. Furthermore, when compared to the tensile behavior of the individual motion segment load-controlled tests, C6-C7 exhibited reduced axial displacement and an increased stiffness at higher loads (≥13.5 N), suggesting the recruitment of more superficial ligamentous layers that span multiple vertebrae in the whole spine. Regarding vertical displacement and rotation, O-C2 exhibited the largest amount of rotation of 5.57 degrees in flexion and all segments exhibited some amount of anterior–posterior (AP) displacement. The intersegmental kinematics provide biomechanical response data that may support both physical and computational surrogate design and validation as well as data for comparison to isolated FSU testing conditions.
Liu, Miranda, Luck, Jason F.
Human body models have been used for decades to inform efforts in promoting automobile occupant and pedestrian safety. However, many of these models fail to capture the intricacies of individual variability. Cadaveric subjects typically exceed representative age ranges and hence mechanics. Animal subjects typically require specific setups that stray from that which is representative of human crash scenarios. Computational models can only consider so many practical real-world variables. Artificial surrogates, dummies being popular among them, are very popular for reusability and robust data collection. However, even the biomechanically accurate skeletal surrogates available commercially are limited in that they do not consider human variability and skeletal microstructure local variability. The objective of the work herein is to assess computational methods of metastructural variability mimicry by fabrication material. We implement mimicry approaches focusing on bulk isotropic elasticity and in-house structural optimization approaches focusing on pure anisotropy skeletal microstructure mimicry. This allows us to assess rapid and detailed approaches alike and determine which fabrication materials are ideal under which approach. We found that Fortify DT was ideal for mimicking the phenomena present in the GHBMC M50 L5 model when using a walled Gyroid. For microstructural mimicry, we found there to be a range in acceptable bulk material elastic moduli between 2.98 and 36.6 GPa. Ultimately, these findings have the potential to guide practitioners of skeletal microstructure biomimicry.
Hezrony, Benjamin S., C. F. Lopes, Pedro, Brown, Philip J.
Pelvic orientation in vehicles is crucial for preventing injuries and creating safer vehicles and restraint systems. A better understanding of pelvic orientation could provide more accurate anthropomorphic test device (ATD) models of underrepresented populations such as obese individuals, children, and small females. Sonomicrometry is the use of piezoelectric transducers that transmit ultrasound signals to each other to measure the distance between them. These signals may be aggregated using triangulation. In this experiment, ultrasound crystals were secured to the surface of a porcine surrogate to evaluate pelvic movement. This data was then processed using Sonometrics software to generate a 3D model of four static positions and three dynamic tests. The test was validated using a camera and a 3D measurement arm (CMM) to validate XYZ positions. This article discusses how this method could be helpful for developing more accurate ATD models, preventing fatalities in vehicle crashes.
Mrozek, Allison, Sirhan, Katerena, MacDonald, Robert, Dannaoui, Abdul, Mazloum, Aisha, Ochocki, Katarzyna, ‘Dale’ Bass , Cameron R.
Ongoing research in simulated vehicle crash environments utilizes postmortem human subjects (PMHS) as the closest approximation to live human response. Lumbar spine injuries are common in vehicle crashes, necessitating accurate assessment methods of lumbar loads. This study evaluates the effectiveness of lumbar intervertebral disc (IVD) pressure sensors in detecting various loading conditions on component PMHS lumbar spines, aiming to develop a reliable insertion method and assess sensor performance under different loading scenarios. The pressure sensor insertion method development involved selecting a suitable sensor, using a customized needle-insertion technique, and precisely placing sensors into the center of lumbar IVDs. Computed tomography (CT) scans were utilized to determine insertion depth and location, ensuring minimal tissue disruption during sensor insertion. Tests were conducted on PMHS lumbar spines using a robotic test system for controlled loading in flexion, compression, and a combination, while monitoring pressure changes. The compression force, flexion angle, and sensor-recorded IVD fluid pressure were recorded during tests. CT images were analyzed to assess sensor placement and its impact on sensing ability. Pressure readings during various loading conditions were examined for different specimens, with data reported from the beginning of tests through relevant loading phases. The study successfully established a methodology for inserting pressure sensors into the IVD and assessed their ability to detect changes in flexion angle, compression, and combined loading. Sensors accurately tracked compression force and detected changes in flexion angle, although with some differences in response. Sensors placed optimally showed expected responses, while those placed suboptimally exhibited variability, particularly in detecting changes during flexion. This variability underscores the importance of sensor placement for accurate detection of loading states. Overall, the study provides a foundation for utilizing pressure sensors to monitor loading states in sled tests, with future work focusing on refining differentiation between loading types.
Burns, Michael R., Caldwell, A. James, Shin, Jeesoo, Sochor, Sara H., Kopp, Kevin P., Shaw, Greg, Gepner, Bronislaw, Kerrigan, Jason R.
University of Waterloo Chemical Engineering Researcher Dr. Elisabeth Prince teamed up with researchers from the University of Toronto and Duke University to design the synthetic material made using cellulose nanocrystals, which are derived from wood pulp. The material is engineered to replicate the fibrous nanostructures and properties of human tissues, thereby recreating its unique biomechanical properties.
The increased use of computational human models in evaluation of safety systems demands greater attention to selected methods in coupling the model to its seated environment. This study assessed the THUMS v4.0.1 in an upright driver posture and a reclined occupant posture. Each posture was gravity settled into an NCAC vehicle model to assess model quality and HBM to seat coupling. HBM to seat contact friction and seat stiffness were varied across a range of potential inputs to evaluate over a range of potential inputs. Gravity settling was also performed with and without constraints on the pelvis to move towards the target H-Point. These combinations resulted in 18 simulations per posture, run for 800 ms. In addition, 5 crash pulse simulations (51.5 km/h delta V) were run to assess the effect of settling time on driver kinematics. HBM mesh quality and HBM to seat coupling metrics were compared at kinetically identical time points during the simulation to an end state where kinetic energy was near zero. A gravity settling time of 350 ms was found to be optimal for the upright driver posture and 290 ms for the reclined occupant posture. This suggests that reclined passengers can be settled for less time than upright passengers, potentially due to the increased contact area. The pelvis constrained approach was recommended for the upright driver posture and was not recommended for the reclined occupant posture. The recommended times were sufficient to gravity settle both postures to match the quality metrics of the 800 ms gravity settled time. Driver kinematics were found to be vary with gravity settling time. Future work will include verifying that these recommendations hold for different HBMs and test modes.
Wade von Kleeck, B., Caffrey, Juliette, Weaver, Ashley A., Gayzik, F. Scott, Hallman, Jason
The advent of neck braces for the helmeted motorcycle rider has introduced a pertinent research question: To what extent do they reduce measures related to the major mechanism of neck injury in unrestrained torso accidents, i.e., compression flexion (CF)? This question requires a suitable method of testing and evaluating the measures for a load case resulting in the required mechanism. This study proposes a weighted swinging anvil striking the helmeted head of a supine HIII ATD by means of a near vertex impact with a low degree of anterior head impact eccentricity to induce CF of the neck. The applied impact was chosen for the baseline (no neck brace) so that the upper and lower neck axial forces approached injury assessment reference values (IARV). The head impact point evaluated represents those typically associated with high-energy burst fractures occurring within the first 20 ms, with possible secondary disruption of posterior ligaments. The proposed test can be used to evaluate the initial and secondary period of neck loading resultant from a near vertex impact and the effect of a neck brace thereon. The presented case study shows that unless almost touching the helmet, neck braces are likely to have a negligible effect on the axial load response of the neck within the first 20 ms after impact and are, therefore, unlikely to affect injury risk related to initial compressive loading of the neck. Conversely, a neck brace can affect neck response in bending during a near vertex CF loading event. Hence, assessing these devices is important to determine their potential in stabilizing the spine. The proposed test shows that the neck loading mechanism does not necessarily correspond with the observed head motion, especially in the early stages of neck response. These head/neck kinetics are important to consider when designing an evaluation load case.
de Jongh, Cornelis U., Basson, Anton H., Knox, Erick H., Leatt, Christopher J.
Scientists at Osaka University, in cooperation with Joanneum Research (Weiz, Austria), have introduced wireless health monitoring patches that use embedded piezoelectric nanogenerators to power themselves with harvested biomechanical energy. This work may lead to new autonomous health sensors as well as battery-less wearable electronic devices.
In the context of Rotorcraft Pilot Couplings, the biomechanics of the pilot body play a fundamental role in determining the stability of the pilot-vehicle closed loop system. The response of the pilot body is, in turn, inherently stochastic, being a function of pilot biometrics and muscular activation. Coupling the statistical distribution of pilot biomechanical behavior determined in specialized experimental campaign with linear models of the helicopter heave dynamics, an uncertainty propagation procedure is developed, with the aim of estimating the statistical distribution of the stability margins of the closed loop pilot-vehicle system. Results obtained varying the collective lever characteristics, as well as the helicopter model parameters, align well with results obtained previously in deterministic settings. However, the new scheme allows to define quantitative robustness indices.
Zanoni, Andrea, Masarati, Pierangelo, Colombo, Francesca, Zilletti, Michele, Marchesoli, Davide, Talamo, Carmen, Cassoni, Gianni
The goal of this study was to gather and compare kinematic response and injury data on both female and male whole-body Post-mortem Human Surrogates (PMHS) responses to Underbody Blast (UBB) loading. Midsized males (50th percentile, MM) have historically been most used in biomechanical testing and were the focus of the Warrior Injury Assessment Manikin (WIAMan) program, thus this population subgroup was selected to be the baseline for female comparison. Both small female (5th percentile, SF) and large female (75th percentile, LF) PMHS were included in the test series to attempt to discern whether differences between male and female responses were predominantly driven by sex or size. Eleven tests, using 20 whole-body PMHS, were conducted by the research team. Preparation of the rig and execution of the tests took place at the Aberdeen Proving Grounds (APG) in Aberdeen, MD. Two PMHS were used in each test. The Accelerative Loading Fixture (ALF) version 2, located at APG’s Bear Point range was used for all male and female whole-body tests in this series. The ALF was an outdoor test rig that was driven by a buried explosive charge, to accelerate a platform holding two symmetrically mounted seats. The platform was designed as a large, rigid frame with a deformable center section that could be tuned to simulate the floor deformation of a vehicle during a UBB event. PMHS were restrained with a 5-point harness, common in military vehicle seats. Six-degree-of-freedom motion blocks were fixed to L3, the sacrum, and the left and right iliac wings. A three-degree-of freedom block was fixed to T12. Strain gages were placed on L4 and multiple locations on the pelvis. Accelerometers on the floor and seat of the ALF provided input data for each PMHS’ feet and pelvis. Time histories and mean peak responses in z-axis acceleration were similar among the three PMHS groups in this body region. Injury outcomes were different and seemed to be influenced by both sex and size contributions. Small females incurred pelvis injuries in absence of lumbar injures. Midsized males had lumbar vertebral body fractures without pelvis injuries. And large females with injuries had both pelvis and lumbar VB fractures. This study provides evidence supporting the need for female biomechanical testing to generate female response and injury thresholds. Without the inclusion of female PMHS, the differences in the injury patterns between the small female and midsized male groups would not have been recognized. Standard scaling methods assume equivalent injury patterns between the experimental and scaled data. In this study, small female damage occurred in a different anatomical structure than for the midsized males. This is an important discovery for the development of anthropomorphic test devices, injury criteria, and injury mitigating technologies. The clear separation of small female damage results, in combination with seat speeds, suggest that the small female pelvis injury threshold in UBB events lies between 4 – 5 m/s seat speed. No inference can be made about the small female lumbar threshold, other than it is likely at higher speeds and/or over longer duration. Male lumbar spine damage occurred in both the higher- and lower lower-rate tests, indicating the injury threshold would be below the seat pulses tested in these experiments. Large females exhibited injury patterns that reflected both the small female and midsized male groups – with damaged PMHS having fractures in both pelvis and lumbar, and in both higher- and lower- rate tests. The difference in damage patterns between the sex and size groups should be considered in the development of injury mitigation strategies to protect across the full population.
Pietsch, Hollie, Cristino, Danielle, Danelson, Kerry, Bolte, John, Mason, Matthew, Kemper, Andrew, Cavanaugh, John, Hardy, Warren
Compared to other age groups, older adults are at more significant risk of hip fracture when they fall. In addition to the higher risk of falls for the elderly, fear of falls can reduce this population’s outdoor activity. Various preventive solutions have been proposed to reduce the risk of hip fractures ranging from wearable hip protectors to indoor flooring systems. A previously developed rubberized asphalt mixture demonstrated the potential to reduce the risk of head injury. In the current study, the capability of the rubberized asphalt sample was evaluated for the risk of hip fracture for an average elderly male and an average elderly female. A previously developed human body model was positioned in a fall configuration that would give the highest impact forces toward regular asphalt. Three different rubber contents with 14, 28, 33 weight percent (% wt.) were implemented as the ground alongside one regular non-rubberized (0%) asphalt mixture, one baseline, and one extra-compliant playground rubber-composite material. The whole-body model was simulated to fall on the rubberized asphalt mixtures with an initial vertical velocity of 3 m/s with a 10° trunk angle and +10° anterior pelvis rotation. The impact forces were measured on the femoral head, and a previously developed hip fracture risk function was used to compare the rubberized asphalt mixtures. It was found that the rubberized asphalt mixture with 33% wt. rubber can reduce the impact forces up to 10% for the elderly male and female model compared to regular asphalt. The impact forces were most reduced for the extra-compliant playground material, with a 23% reduction for the female model. The risk of injury for the asphalt mixture with 33% wt. rubber was reduced up to 18% for elderly females and 20 for elderly males, compared to regular asphalt. The extra-compliant playground material had the most reduction of hip fracture risk for both sexes, 39 and 43% for elderly females and males, respectively.
Sahandifar, Pooya, Wallqvist, Viveca, Kleiven, Svein
Bilateral knee impacts were conducted on Hybrid III and THOR 5th percentile female anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs), and the results were compared to previously reported female PMHS data. Each ATD was impacted at velocities of 2.5, 3.5, and 4.9 m/s. Knee–thigh–hip (KTH) loading data, obtained either via direct measurement or through exercising a one-dimensional lumped parameter model (LPM), was analyzed for differences in loading characteristics including the maximum force, time to maximum force, loading rate, and loading duration. In general, the Hybrid III had the highest loading rate and maximum force, and the lowest loading duration and time to peak force for each point along KTH. Conversely, the PMHS generally had the lowest loading rate and maximum force, and the highest loading duration and time to peak force for each point along KTH. The force transfer from the knee to the femur was 79.2 ± 0.3% for the Hybrid III 5th female, 82.7 ± 0.4% for the THOR-05F, and 70.6 ± 1.7% for the PMHS. The force transfer from the knee to the hip was 60.6 ± 0.5% for the Hybrid III 5th female, 41.4 ± 0.4% for the THOR-05F, and 57.0 ± 3.0% for the PMHS. While the Hybrid III aligned more with the PMHS force transfer ratios, the loading characteristics of the THOR-05F were more similar to the PMHS.
Carpenter, Randolff L., Berthelson, Parker R., Donlon, John-Paul, Forman, Jason L.
Items per page:
1 – 50 of 443