This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Flight Evaluation of an Insect Contamination Protection System for Laminar Flow Wings
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 01, 1985 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The ability of modern airplane surfaces to achieve laminar flow has been well-accepted in recent years. Obtaining the maximum benefit of laminar flow for aircraft drag reduction requires maintaining minimum leading-edge contamination. Previously proposed insect contamination prevention methods have proved impractical due to cost, weight, or inconvenience. Past work has shown that insects will not adhere to water-wetted surfaces, but large volumes of water required for protection rendered such a system impractical. This paper presents results of a flight experiment conducted by NASA to evaluate the performance of a porous leading-edge fluid discharge ice protection system operated as an insect contamination protection system. In addition, these flights explored the environmental and atmospheric conditions most suitable for insect accumulation. These tests have shown that the protection of laminar flow wings against insect debris contamination appears feasible with very small volumes of fluid, thus offering an attractive alternative to the insect protection systems previously proposed.
CitationCroom, C. and Holmes, B., "Flight Evaluation of an Insect Contamination Protection System for Laminar Flow Wings," SAE Technical Paper 850860, 1985, https://doi.org/10.4271/850860.
- Holmes, B. J., Obara, C. J., Gregorek, G. M., Hoffman, M. J., and Freuler, R. J., “Flight Investigation of Natural Laminar Flow on the Bellanca Skyrocket H,” SAE Paper 830717, April 1983.
- Atkins, P. B., “Wing Leading Edge Contamination by Insects”, ARL Flight Note, October 17, 1951.
- Bragg, Michael B., and Maresh, J. L., “The Role of Airfoil Geometry in Minimising the Effect of Insect Contamination of Laminar Flow Sections,” AIAA Paper no. 84-2170, 1984.
- Coleman, W. S.: “Roughness Due to Insects,” Boundary Layer and Flow Control, vol. 2, Pergaramon Press, 1961.
- Coleman, W. S., “Wind Tunnel Experiments on the Prevention of Insect Contamination by Means of Soluble Films and Liquids Over the Surface,” Rep. to the Boundary Layer Control Committee, BLCC Note 39, 1952.
- Smith, F., and Higton, D. J., “Flight Tests on a King Cobra FZ440 to Investigate the Practical Requirements for the Achievement of Low Profile Drag Coefficients on a Low Drag Aerofoil,” R&M No. 2375, British A.R.C., 1950.
- Beech, G. and Nicholas, W. M., “A Mechanical Type of Scraper for Dealing with Insect Contamination of Aircraft Wings,” Armstrong Whitworth Rep. No. W.T. 53/18, 1953.
- Anon, “Note on the Blackburn and General Aircraft Wind Tunnel Tests of the Armstrong Whitworth Fly Scraper,” BLCC Paper No. B 0142, M.O.S. London, 1953.
- Wortmann, F. X., “A Method for Avoiding Insect Roughness on Aircraft,” NASA TT F-15454, 1974. (Translation of “Eine Moglichkeitzur Vermeidung der Insect Tenrauhigkeit an Flugzeugen,” Luftfahrttechnik, Raumfahrttechnik, vol. 9, no. 9, September 1963, pp. 272-274).
- Carmichael, Bruce H., “Summary of Past Experience in Natural Laminar Flow and Experimental Program for Resilient Leading Edge,” NASA CR 152276, 1979.
- Coleman, W. S., “Development of a Mechanical Device for the Protection of Wings Against Insect Contamination,” Report to the Boundary Layer Control Committee, BLCC Note 34, M.O.S. London, 1952.
- McDonnell Douglas Corp., “Evaluation of Laminar Flow Control Systems Concepts for Subsonic Commercial Transport Aircraft,” NASA CR 159251, 1983.
- Fischer, M. C., Wright, A. S., Jr. and Wagner, R. D., “A Flight Test of Laminar Flow Control Leading Edge Systems,” NASA TM 85712, 1983.
- Ash, M., and Ash, I., “Encyclopedia of Surfactants,” Chemical Publishing Co., Inc., N.Y., vol. III, 1981.
- Peterson, J. B., Jr., and Fisher, D. F., “Flight Investigation of Insect Contamination and its Alleviation,” NASA CP 2036, 1978.
- Etchberger, F. R.; et al, “LFC Leading Edge Glove Flight-Airplane Modification, Design, Test Article Development, and Systems Integration,” NASA CR 172136, 1983.
- Kohlman, D. L., “Icing Tunnel Tests of a Glycol-Exuding Porous Leading Edge Ice Protection System on a General Aviation Airfoil,” NASA CR 165444, 1981.
- Click, P. A., “The Distribution of Insects, Spiders, and Mites in the Air,” Technical Bulletin No. 673, U.S. Department of Agriculture, 1935.
- Freeman, J. A., “Studies in the Distribution of Insects by Aerial Currents - The Insect Population in the Air from Ground Level to 300 Ft. Journal of Animal Ecology, vol. 14, 1945, pp. 128-154.
- Hardy, A. C., and Milne, P. S., “Studies in the Distribution of Insects by Aerial Currents,” Journal of Animal Ecology, vol. 7, 1938, pp. 199-229.