This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Aircraft Performance Degradation - the Effects of Inflight Icing upon Lift, Drag and Propulsive Efficiency
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published June 13, 2011 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Data is presented from a number of flight research aircraft, which have been involved in the research of the effects of inflight icing, in a variety of atmospheric supercooled droplet and mixed-phase icing environmental conditions. The aircraft Types considered cover both Pneumatic and Thermal Ice Protection Systems (IPS). Icing includes supercooled droplet impact icing upon airframe and propeller blades and cold-soaked frost icing. The drag effects of inflight icing, from mixed-phase small and large droplets encountered during the course of SALPEX cloud physics research operations, upon a Fokker F-27 turboprop transport aircraft, have been analyzed. Furthermore, during the course of AIRS 1.5 and AIRS II inflight icing flight research operations, the NRC Convair conducted aerodynamic characterization maneuvers, following and during icing accretion in a wide range of environmental conditions of altitude, air temperature, LWC and droplet spectra. The correlation of the effects of inflight icing accretion on the drag of the NRC Convair, with full droplet spectral parameters, for which the small (FSSP) and large (2D) portions of droplet spectra have been combined, has been analyzed. The changes to profile drag, CDo, lift-dependent drag, k, and lift-curve slope, a, were analyzed initially for correlation with Ta, LWC and FSSP MVD. With the airframe IPS ON, ΔCD
increases did not correlate with SLW exposure. Maximum Δk and Δa degradations correlated with each other, and with air temperature. With airframe IPS OFF, maximum Δa degradations correlated with exposure to SLW, whereas maximum ΔCD
and Δk correlated with exposure to small droplet conditions. Furthermore, correlation of the aerodynamic parametric effects with LWC and the full-spectra droplet spectral parameters of 50VD (or MVD, when defined as median volumetric diameter), 80VD, 95VD and spectral width, approximated as maximum droplet diameter. When combined with LWC, the parameters of 95VD and maximum droplet diameter provided the better correlation of CD
, k and a icing-induced effects, essentially limiting canyons in the contour cross-plot of effects. The analysis also highlighted the need to include the full droplet size distribution for the determination of the most detrimental icing accretion environmental regimes. The effects of icing upon propulsive efficiency have been directly measured and correlated with atmospheric conditions. Finally, the drag effects of SLD icing upon an aircraft with high lift devices deployed has been analyzed and correlated with atmospheric conditions.
CitationBrown, A., "Aircraft Performance Degradation - the Effects of Inflight Icing upon Lift, Drag and Propulsive Efficiency," SAE Technical Paper 2011-38-0073, 2011, https://doi.org/10.4271/2011-38-0073.
- Etkin, B. and Reid, L. D., Dynamics of Flight: stability and control, Wiley, New York, 1996.
- Brown, A.P., “Negative Speed Stability, a Factor in Transport Airplane Icing Upsets,” AIAA-2002-3051, AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference, St Louis, June 2002.
- Brown, A.P., “Correlation of AIRS Inflight Icing Lift/Drag Effects with Supercooled Droplet Spectra Atmospheric Conditions,” AIAA-2008-0433, 46th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno NV, January 2008.
- Ahendon, R. and Marwitz, J., “Characterising the Supercooled Large Droplet Environment with Corresponding Turboprop Aircraft Response,” Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 35, No.6, 1998, pp. 912-920.
- Hui, K., Wolde, M., Brown, A., Isaac, G., Cober, S., “Flight Dynamics Model of Turboprop Transport Aircraft Icing Effects Based Upon Preliminary Flight Data,” AIAA2005-1068, 43rd Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno NV, January 2005.
- Brown, A.P., “An Investigation into the Identification of Net Installed Propulsive Efficiency on a Turboprop Transport Aeroplane.” AIAA-2004-4940, AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Rhode Island, August 2004.
- Brown, A.P., “The Aerodynamic Effects of Engine Power on Lift and Drag of a Turbo-propellor Transport Aeroplane in Light Rime Icing Accretion,” AIAA-2004-4847, AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Rhode Island, August 2004.
- Barnhart, B., Dickes, E., Gingras, D., and Ratvasky, T., “Simulation Model Development for Icing Effects Flight Training,” SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-1527, 2002, doi:10.4271/2002-01-1527.
- Myers, T.T., Klyde, D.H. and Magdaleno, R.E., “The Dynamic Icing Detection System (DIDS),” Paper No. 562, Systems Technology Inc., October, 1999.
- Deters, R.W., Dimock, G.A. and Selig, M.A., “Icing Encounter Flight Simulator,” JofA, Vol.43, No.5, September-October, 2006.
- Brown, A.P., Aitken, J. F., Isaac, G. A., Cober, S. G., Bailey, M. and Korolev, A., “Aerodynamic Effects of Freezing Drizzle in the Landing Pattern: A Case Study,” AIAA-2006-0263, 44th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 2006.
- Anon., “Aviation Investigation Report: Roll Oscillations on Landing Air Canada Airbus A321-211, C-GJVX and C-GIUF, Toronto/Lester B. Pearson International Airport, Ontario 07 December 2002,” Report Number A02O0406, Updated 2005-10-07, http://www.tsb.gc.ca/en/reports/air/2002/a02o0406/a02o0406.asp
- Beyers, M.E., Mamou, M., Brown, A.P. and Mebarki, Y., “Computational Fluid Dynamics and Experimental Investigation of StallDynamics with Wing Contamination,” ICAS 2008 Paper No. 528, September 2008.
- Brown, A.P., Nazarov, A., Vertigan, G., de Hoog, M. and Lenton, A., “INFLIGHT ICING DATA, A COMPARISON OF TASMANIA AND BRITISH ISLES/CENTRAL FRANCE AIR OPERATIONS ICING ENCOUNTERS,” AIAA-2004-0229, 42nd Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 2004.