This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Motor Vehicle Conspicuity
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 1, 1983 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper addresses the relationship between vehicle conspicuity and probability of accident involvement. As used here, conspicuity refers not only to the “noticeability” of the vehicle, but also to the recognizability of the vehicle and its behavior relative to the observer. All classes of vehicles are considered during both day and night driving on all types of roadways.
Relevant vehicle, driver, and environmental characteristics are identified, and their frequency of occurrence and relationship to accidents (or pertinent proxies) discussed whenever such information is available. The bulk of the report is devoted to reviewing, summarizing, and integrating the available body of data concerning vehicle conspicuity, including engineering analyses and other analytic studies, as well as experimental data from laboratory, simulation and field studies.
The major output of this review and summary is the identification of: 1) the major problems associated with vehicle conspicuity, 2) mitigating concepts, including a discussion of how these concepts should be evaluated, and 3) considerations for future attention of the research community.
CitationHenderson, R., Ziedman, K., Burger, W., and Cavey, K., "Motor Vehicle Conspicuity," SAE Technical Paper 830566, 1983, https://doi.org/10.4271/830566.
- Allen M. J. Running light questionnaire. American Journal of Optometry, 1965, 164 - 167.
- Allen M. J. The current status of automobile running lights. Journal of the American Optometric Association, 1979, 50, 179 - 180.
- Allen M. J., Strickland J., Ward B., and Siegal A. Daytime headlights and position on the highway. American Journal of Optometry and Archives of American Academy of Optometry, 1969, 46, 33 - 36.
- Allen M.J., Strickland J., and Adams A. J. Visibility of red, green, amber and white signal lights in a highway scene. American Journal of Optometry and Archives of American Academy of Optometry, 1967, 44, 105 - 109.
- American Motorcyclist Association. American Motorcyclists Association study disproves of light-on effectiveness. News Release, March 24, 1975, Westerville, Ohio.
- American Motorcyclist Association. “Lights-On.” News Release, Department of Government Relations, October, 1982, Westerville, Ohio.
- Anders son K. and Nilsson G. The preliminary report on the effects of the DNRL-Law regarding traffic accidents - The Swedish Road and Traffic Research Institute, Traffic Department, March 30, 1979.
- Andersson K., Nilsson G., and Salusjarvi M. The effect of recommended and compulsory use of vehicle lighting on road accidents in Finland. Nation Road and Traffic Research Institute, Report No. 102, 1976.
- Attwood D. A. Daytime running lights project. II: Vehicle detection as a function of headlight use and ambient illumination. Transport Canada, Road Safety Unit, Technical Report, RSU 15/2, April, 1975.
- Attwood D. A. Daytime running lights project. II: Two-lane passing performance as a function of headlight intensity and ambient illumination. Transport Canada, Road Safety Unit, Technical Report No. RSU 76/1, February, 1976.
- Attwood D. A. and Angus R. G. Daytime running lights project. II: Pilot validation study of a field detection experiment. Transport Canada, Road Safety Unit, Technical Memo 75/3, October, 1975.
- Berlin L. and Bjorklund S. The influence of different colors on distance judgment (in Swedish). Thesis, Department of Psychology, University of Uppsala, Sweden, 1979, 22 pp.
- Burger W., Smith R., Ziedman K., Mulholland M., Bardales M., and Sharkey T. Improved Commercial Vehicle Conspicuity and Signalling Systems. Task I: Accident Analysis and Functional Requirements. U. S. Department of Transportation Interim Report No. DOT HS-806-100, March, 1981.
- Bursill A. E. Restriction of peripheral vision during exposure to hot and humid conditions. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1958, 10, 113 - 129.
- Campbell B. J. and Rouse W. S. Reflectorized License Plates and Rear-End Collisions at Night. University of North Carolina, Highway Safety Research Center, January, 1968.
- Cantilli E. J. Daylight “lights-on” plan by the Port of New York Authority. Traffic Engineering, December, 1965, 17.
- Cantilli E. J. Accident experience with parking lights as running lights. Transportation Research Board, Highway Research Board Record No. 332, 1970, 1 - 13.
- Cole B. L. and Jenkins S. E. The nature and measurement of conspicuity. Proceedings of the Australian Road Research Board, 1980, 10, pt. 2, 99 - 107.
- Diesel Equipment Superintendent. What happened to all the lights? Editorial, November, 1973.
- Engle F. L. Visual conspicuity, visual search and fixation tendencies of the eye. Vision Research, 1977, 17, 95 - 108.
- Engle F. L. Visual conspicuity, directed attention and retinal locus. Vision Research, 1971, 11, 563 - 575.
- Finch D. M. and Horning D. O. Motor Vehicle Rear Lighting and Signalling. Institute of Transportation and Traffic Engineering, Vehicle Technology Facility, University of California, Berkeley, Final Report, May, 1968.
- Foldvary L. A. Road accident involvement per miles travelled - III. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 1977, 21 - 54.
- Foldvary L. A. and Ashton H. T. Road accidents and weather. 3 Proceedings of the Australian Road Research Board, 1962, 1, pt. 1, 529 - 595.
- Griffin L. I. Motorcycle Accidents: Who, When, Where and Why. University of North Carolina, Highway Safety Research Center, March, 1974.
- Gutoskie P. Internal Memo. Traffic Safety Branch, Transport Canada, 1979.
- Hakkinen S. Traffic Accidents and Driver Characteristics. Finland’s Institute of Technology, Scientific Researches No. 13, Helsinki, 1958.
- Harano R. M. and Peck R. C. The California Motorcycle Study: Driver and Accident Characteristics. Division of Administration, California Department of Motor Vehicles, 1968.
- Hare C. T. and Hemion R. H. Headlamp Beam Usage on U.S. Highways. Southwest Research Institute, San Antonio, Texas, December 1968.
- Hisdal B. Running Lights. Sentralinstitutt for Industrial Forskning, January, 1973.
- Hockey G. R. J. Effect of loud noise on attentional selectivity. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1970a, 22, 28 - 36.
- Hockey G. R. J. Signal probability and spatial location as possible bases for increased selectivity in noise. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1970b, 22, 37 - 42.
- Horberg U. Running Light-Twilight Conspicuity and Distance Judgement. Department of Psychology, University of Uppsala, Sweden, Report 215, 1977.
- Horberg U. and Rumar K. Running Lights, Conspicuity and Glare. Department of Psychology, University of Uppsala, Sweden, Report 178, 1975.
- Hulbert S. F. and Burg A. Are Reflectoriaed License Plates a Good Idea? Special Report, January, 1975.
- Huntley M. S. Effects of alcohol and fixation task difficulty on choice reaction to extrafoveal stimulation. Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 1972, 33, 1155.
- Hurt H. H. Jr., Ouellet J. V., and Thorn D. R. Status Report of Accident Investigation Data, Motorcycle Accident Cause Factors and Identification of Countermeasures. Vol. I: Technical Report. Vol. II: Appendix/Supplemental Data. Institute of Management and Safety, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California, Final Report No. DOT-HS-5-01160, January, 1981.
- Ivey D. L., Lehtipuu E. K., and Button J. W. Rainfall and Visibility - The View from Behind the Wheel. Texas Transportation Institute, Texas A’M University, Final Report for the Texas Highway Department, Planning and Research Division, February, 1975.
- Janoff M. S., Cassel A., Fertner K. S., and Smierciak E. S. Daytime Motorcycle Headlight and Taillight Operation. Franklin Institute Report No. FC2488, August 1970.
- Johns E. H. and Sumner F. C. Relation of the brightness differences of colors to their apparent distances. Journal of Psychology, 1948, 26, 25 - 29.
- Johnson R. T. Freeway fatal accidents: 1961 and 1962. Highway Research Board Record No. 99, 1965, 117 - 137.
- Johnston A. W. and Cole B. L. Investigations of distractions by irrelevant information. Australian Road Research, 1976, 6, 3 - 23.
- Koth B. W. , McCunney W. D., Duerk C. P., Janoff M. S., and Freedman M. Vehicle Fog Lighting: An Analytical Evaluation. Franklin Institute Research Laboratories, Philadelphia, PA, Final Report on DOT Contract No. DOT-HS-6-01499, March, 1978.
- Lee P. N. J. and Triggs T, J. The effects of driving demand and roadway environment on peripheral visual directions. Proceedings of the Australian Road Research Board, 1976, 8, pt. 5, 7 - 12.
- Leibowitz H. W. and Apelle S. The effect of a cental task on luminance thresholds for peripherally presented stimuli. Human Fac to rs, 1969, 11, 387 - 392.
- Leibowitz H. W., Johnson C. A., and Isabelle E. Peripheral motion detection and refractive error. Science, 1972, 177, 1207 - 1208.
- Michon J. A., Ernst J. T., and Koutstall G. A. Safety clothing for human traffic obstacles. Ergonomics, 1969, 12, 61 - 70.
- Miller Herbert R., Allen R. Wade, and Shadle G. Driver Factors, Simulators and Other Instrumented Measurement Approaches. SAE Paper 830563, 1983.
- Minahan D. J. and O’Day J. Car-Truck Fatal Accidents in Michigan and Texas. Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan, October, 1977.
- Minahan O. J. and O’Day J. Comparison of Michigan Fatal and Non-Fatal Car-Into-Truck Accidents. Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan, August, 1979.
- Morris R. S., Mounce J. M., Button J. W., and Walton N. E. Driver Visual Performance During Rainfall. Texas Transportation Institute, Texas ASM University, January, 1977.
- Mortimer R. G. Psychological research in automobile rear lighting. 1970 International Automobile Safety Conference Compendium. Society of Automotive Engineers, New York, 580-597.
- Mortimer R. G. A decade of research in vehicle rear lighting: What have we learned? Proceedings of American Association for Automotive Medicine, 21st Conference, 1977, 101 - 112.
- Moskowitz H. and Sharma S. Effects of alcohol on peripheral vision as a function of attention. Human Factors, 1974, 16, 174 - 180.
- Muller A. Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Motorcycle Daytime Headlight Use and Helmet Reflectorization Laws. Health Planning and Administrative Program, Pennsylvania State University, Final Report, November 1981 (Revised 2/15/82).
- Nagayama Y., Morita T., Miura T., Watanaben J., and Murakami N. Motorcyclist’s visual scanning pattern in comparison with automobile drivers. Paper presented at the Society of Automotive Engineers Congress and Exposition, Paper No. SAE 790252, 1979.
- National Safety Council. Accident Facts, 1966, Chicago, IL, 1966.
- Ng W. A Note on the Cost/Effectiveness of Daytime Running Lights in Canada. Draft Technical Memo., Traffic Safety Branch, Transport Canada, August, 1980.
- Olson P. L., Halstead-Nussloch R., and Sivak M. Development and Testing of Techniques for Increasing the Conspicuity of Motorcycles and Motorcycle Drivers. Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan, Final Report, October, 1979 (DOT Report No. HS-805 143) (summarized in Human Factors, 1981, 23, 237-248)
- Olson P. L. and Post D. Review of Research Evidence Bearing on the Desirability of Using Retroreflective License Plates in Michigan. Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan, Report No. UM-HSRI-77-24, 1977.
- Olsen R. A. Detection of Events in the Visual Periphery during Pursuit Tracking in Long Term Performance and in Hypnotically Induced Fatigue. Ph.D. Dissertation, Pennsylvania State University, 1970.
- Polanis S. F. Motorcycle accident patterns in Pennsylvania. Traffic Quarterly, 1979, 33, 139 - 155.
- Reid J. A. Recognition Distances of Vehicle Rear Markings at Night. Accident Investigation Division, Safety Department, Transport and Road Research Laboratory, Supplementary Report No. 321, 1977.
- Reiss M. L., Berger W. G., and Vallette C. R. Analysis of Motorcycle Accident Reports and Statistics. Biotechnology, Falls Church, VA, February, 1974.
- Research Triangle Institute. Speed and Accidents. Volume I and II. National Highway Safety Bureau Contract No. FH-11-6965, 1970.
- Ricker E. R., Candlepower of Rear Lights on Trucks, Highway Research Board, Highway Research Board Bulletin No. 127, 1955, 15 - 18.
- Sacks W. L. An Investigation of the Effects of Reflectorized License Plates Upon Driver Behavior in a Moving Traffic Environment. February, 1974. (referenced in Cook, 1975)
- Savey B. E. and Staughton G. C. Interacting roles of road environment, vehicle and road use in accidents. Paper presented at the 5th International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine, London, 1975.
- Schwab R. N. Minimizing the hazard of restricted visibility in fog. Highway Visibility. Highway Research Board Special Report No. 134, 1973, 19 - 27.
- Shoaf R. T. Are advertising signs near freeways traffic hazards? Traffic Engineering, 1955, November, 71-76.
- Smith D. I. An Investigation to Determine Whether the Daytime Usage of Motorcycle Headlights and Taillights Should be Made Compulsory in Western Australia. Road Traffic Authority, July, 1975.
- Solomon D. Accidents on Main Rural Highways Related to Speed, Driver and Vehicle. Bureau of Public Roads, U. S. Department of Commerce, Washington, D.C., 1964.
- Staughton G. C. and Storie V. J. Methodology of an In-Depth Accident Investigation Survey. Department of the Environment, Department of Transport, Transportation and Road Research Laboratory, 1977.
- State of California. Report on Reduced Visibility (Fog) Study. Division of Highways, Transportation Agency, State of California, Senate Resolutions No. 33, 1963 Regular Session and No. 23, 1965 First Extraordinary Session, Febraury, 1967.
- Stoke C. B. Reflectorized License Plates: Do They Reduce Night Rear/End Collisions? University of Virginia, Virginia Highway and Transportation Research Council, Reprint No. 93, February 1975.
- Storie V. J. Male and Female Car Drivers; Differences Observed in Accidents. Department of the Environment, Department of Transport, Transportation and Road Research Laboratory, Report L4761, 1977.
- Smith G. M. and Janson M. H. Reflectorized Flagman Vests. Michigan Department of Highways and Transportation, September, 1976.
- Stadler H. I. and Lauer A. R. Effect of pattern distribution on perception of relative motion in low levels of illumination. Highway Research Board Bulletin No. 56, 1952, 25 - 35.
- Taylor I. L. and Sumner F. C. Actual brightness and distance of individual colors when their apparent distance is held constant. Journal of Psychology, 1945, 9, 79 - 85.
- TRRL. The Effect of Rear Markings on Rear Impact Accidents Involving Heavy Goods Vehicles. Transportation and Road Research Laboratory Leaflet No. 1???626, October, 1976.
- Treat J. R. Tri-level study of the causes of traffic accidents: an overview of final results. Proceedings of the American Association of Automotive Medicine, 21st Conference, 1977, 391 - 403.
- Treat J. R., Jones R. K., and Joscelyn K. B. Analysis of unsafe driving actions - data requirements and methodological issues. Accident Causation, Special Publication SF-461, Paper No. 800391, 1980, 55 - 66.
- U.S. Bureau of the Census. Statistical Abstracts of the United States: 1979, 100th Edition, Washington, D.C., 1979.
- Vanstrum R. and Austin R. L. The passive approach to greater conspicuity - an update on reflective technology. Proceedings of the International Motorcycle Safety Conference, Vol. III, Washington, D.C., 1980, 1107 - 1127.
- Vaughan R. G. A study of motorcycle crashes. Motorcycles and Safety Symposium. Australian Road Research Board and Department of Transport, Melbourne, June, 1976, 24 - 58.
- Waller P. F. and Griffin L. I., III. The impact of a motorcycle lights-on law. Proceedings 21st Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine, Vancouver, September, 1977.
- Waller P. F. and Griffin L. I., III. The impact of a motorcycle lights-on law: an update. Paper presented to the National Safety Council Symposium on Traffic Safety Effectiveness. Chicago, IL, May, 1981.
- Weltman G., Smith J. E., and Egstrom G. H. Perceptual narrowing during simulated pressure-chamber exposure. Human Factors, 1971, 13, 99 - 107.
- Williams M. J. and Hoffman E. R. The Influence of Motorcycle Visibility in Traffic Accidents. Department of Mechanical Engineering, Melbourne University, Australia, July, 1977.
- Woltman H. L. and Austin R. L. Some day and night visual aspects of motorcycle safety. Proceedings of the 2nd International Congress on Automotive Sarety, Paper No. 73036, 1973.
- Woltman H. L. and Youngblood W. P. An Assessment of Indirect Factors Affecting Reflective Sign Brightness. 3M Company, January, 1976.
- Zaidel D., Paarlberg W. T., and Shinar D. Indicators of driver inattention. Proceedings of the American Association for Automotive Medicine, 23rd Conference, 1979, 117 - 129.
- Ziedman K., Burger W., Smith R. L., Mulloholland M., and Sharkey T. Improved Commercial Vehicle Conspicuity and Signalling Systems. Task II: Analysis, Experiments and Design Recommendations. U. S. Department of Transporation Interim Report No. DOT-HS-806-098, October, 1981.