This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Anti-Submarining Scale Determined from Theoretical and Experimental Studies Using Three-Dimensional Geometrical Definition of the Lap-Belt
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 01, 1981 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A theoretical study was conducted to prove that the Part 572 dummy submarines more easily than human cadavers because of their different pelvic shapes. The three-dimensional geometrical definition of the lap-belt was developed in this paper for the study of the submarining problem. It was found that not only the lap-belt angles from side view (β1) but also from the upper view in respect to the X-axis (β2) play a significant role in the submarining tendency for each side. The anti-submarining scale is defined by a coefficient which is a function of both angles β1, β2 and the orientation of the upper half of the pelvic notch.
A series of sled tests was performed on human cadavers, the Part 572 dummy and the modified dummy. Good agreement was found between the present theory and the experimental results. Some of the experimental results cannot be explained with the traditional geometry definition of the lap-belt given in two dimensions, but they are clarified with the present definition given in three dimensions.
The graphs of the anti-submarining scales can be used as tools for checking the risk of submarining tendency in the geometrical design of the seat-belt system.
The evaluations of the Part 572 dummy with modified abdominal tissue and pelvic shape at the notch are also presented: the submarining tendency, indicated by the relative occurrence number and the, instant, are achieved more simulatively in the modified dummy than in the Part 572 dummy with respect to the human cadaver.
- Y. C. Leung - Laboratory of Physiology and Biomechanics Peugeot-Renault Association
- C. Tarrière - Laboratory of Physiology and Biomechanics Peugeot-Renault Association
- A. Fayon - Laboratory of Physiology and Biomechanics Peugeot-Renault Association
- P. Mairesse - Laboratory of Physiology and Biomechanics Peugeot-Renault Association
CitationLeung, Y., Tarrière, C., Fayon, A., Mairesse, P. et al., "An Anti-Submarining Scale Determined from Theoretical and Experimental Studies Using Three-Dimensional Geometrical Definition of the Lap-Belt," SAE Technical Paper 811020, 1981, https://doi.org/10.4271/811020.
- Leung Y.C. Tarrière C. Fayon A. Mairesse P. Delmas A. Banzet P. “A Comparison Between Part 572 Dummy and Human Subject in the Problem of Submarining” in the Proceedings of 23rd Stapp Car Crash Conference San Diego Calif. Oct. 17/19 1979 Sae Transaction paper No. 791.026
- Gragg C.D. Bendiven C.D. Clarke T.D. Klopfenstein H.S. Sprouffske “Evaluation of the Lap-Belt, Air-Bag and Air Force Restraint System During Impact With Living Human, Sled Subjects” SAE paper No. 700 904in the Proceedings of 14th Stapp Car Crash Conference Ann Arbor, Michigan Nov. 17 1970
- Haley J.L. Jr. “Fundamentals of Kinetics and Kinematics as Applied to Injury Reduction” “Impact Injury and Crash Protection” C.C Thomas publisher 1970
- King A.I. Grosby W.M. Stout L.C. Eppinger P.H. “Effects of Lap-Belt and Three-Point Restraint on Pregnant Baboons Subjected to Deceleration” SAE paper No. 710 850in the Proceedings of 15th Stapp Car Crash Conference Coronado Calif. Nov 17 1971
- Clarke T.D. Smedley D.C. Muzzy W.H. Grapp C.D. Schmidt R.E. Trout E.M. “Impact Tolerance and Resulting Injury Patterns in the Baboon, Air Force Shoulder Harness-Lap-Belt Restraint” SAE paper No. 720 975in the Proceedings of 16th Stapp Car Crash Conference Detroit, Mi Nov. 8 1972
- Mc Elhaney J.H. Roberts V.L. Melvin J.W. Shelton W. Hammond A.J. “Biomechanics of Seat-Belt Design” SAE paper No. 720 972in the Proceedings of 16th Stapp Car Crash Conference Detroit, Mi Nov. 8 1972
- Patrick L.M. Andersson A. “Three-Point Harness Accident and Laboratory Data Comparison” SAE Paper no 741 181, in the Proceedings of the 18th Stapp Car Crash Conference Ann Arbor, Michigan Dec. 4th 1974
- Adomeit D. Heger A. “Motion Sequence Criteria and Design Proposals for Restraint Devices in Order to Avoid Unfavorable Biomechanic Condition and Submarining” SAE paper No. 751 146in the Proceedings of 19th Stapp Car Crash Conference San Diego, Calif. Nov. 17th 1975
- Holt B.W. Stott J.D. “Anatomical Factors in Lap/Sash Seat-Belt Wearing” Traffic Accident Research Unit, Department of Motor Transport New South Wales Dec. 1976
- Herbert D.C. Corbon C.W. “Human Measurements and Performance in Retracting Seat-Belts” Traffic Accident Research Unit, Department of Motor Transport New South Wales July 1977
- Svensson L.G. “Means for Effective Improvement of the Three-Point Seat-Belt in Frontal Crashes” SAE Paper No. 780 898.in the Proceedings of the 22nd Stapp Car Crash Conference Ann Arbor, Michigan Oct. 24th 1978
- Billault P. Tisseron C. Dejeammes M. Biard R. Cord P. Jenoc P. “The Inflatable Diagonal Belt” 7th International Technical Conference on the Experimental Safety Vehicles Paris June 5/8 1979
- Hontschik H. Muller E. Rüter G. “Necessities and Possibilities of Improving the Protectice Effect of Three-Point Seat-Belts” in the Proceedings of the 21st Stapp Car Crash Conference New Orleans Louisiana Oct. 19-21st 1977
- Eppinger P.H. “Prediction of Thoracic Injury Using Measurable Experimental Parameters” Report on the 6th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles, DOT-HS 802 501 Washington D.C. Oct. 1976 770 780
- Patrick L.M. Levine R.S. “Injury to Unembalmed Belted Cadavers in Simulated Collisions” SAE Paper No. 751 144in the Proceedings of the 19th Stapp Car Crash Conference San Diego Calif. Nov. 17 1975