This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Crashworthiness Investigation of General Aviation Accidents
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
General aviation accident investigations can provide valuable data to the design engineer concerning the crash performance of current models and can indicate needed improvements for occupant protection in future aircraft. Current statistics and the historical background of major investigations during the past 65 years are provided. A five-year study of general aviation accidents occurring in the State of Michigan is used as a basis to illustrate recent findings relative to occupant injury mechanisms, relative crash protection, and crashworthiness performance of current models of aircraft. Results indicate that the degree of structural damage may not relate to the degree of occupant injury when the cabin area remains relatively intact. A primary requirement is documented for adequate upper-torso restraint for all occupants, and the excellent crash performance of such a system is described. Relationships of injuries to structural components are shown, and examples of good fuselage crashworthiness but unsatisfactory seat/restraint systems noted. The primary conclusion is that many fatal and serious injuries still occur in low-velocity impacts where the cabin structure shows little damage but the occupant is inadequately protected from structural contact.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Rib Cage Strain Pattern as a Function of Chest Loading Configuration |
Technical Paper | The Prediction of Thoracic Impact Injuries |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Snyder, R., "Crashworthiness Investigation of General Aviation Accidents," SAE Technical Paper 750537, 1975, https://doi.org/10.4271/750537.Also In
References
- Brown T. C. Croft P. Lane J. C. “Injury Production in General Aviation Accidents” Annual Scientific Meeting Aerospace Medical Association May 8 1973
- Barnes, A. C. Jr. Carroll J. J. Gregg L. W. “Handbook for Aircraft Accident Investigators Cooperating in Crash Injury Research.” Aviation Crash Injury Research Flight Safety Foundation, Inc. Phoenix, Arizona
- U. S. Army Board for Aviation Accident Research “Handbook of Inadequate Aircraft Design.” Fort Rucker, Ala. 1964
- Green D. L. Breeden J. D. Heid T. L. “Crashworthy Design Principles.” General Dynamics/Convair San Diego, Calif. Federal Aviation Agency Technical Report FAA ADS-24 September 1964
- Turnbow J. W. Carroll D. F. Haley, J. L. Jr. Robertson S. H. “Crash Survival Design Guide.” US Army Aviation Material Laboratories Ft. Eustis, Va. AVSER Phoenix, Arizona USAAVLABS Tech. Report 70-22 August 1969
- Dynamic Science Engineering Operations “Crash Survival Design Guide.” Marshall Industries Phoenix, Arizona Eustis Directorate, U.S. Army Air Mobility Research and Development Laboratory Fort Eustis, Va. Dynamic Science Report No. 1500-71-6; USAAMRDL Technical Report 71-22 October 1971
- Pennybaker A. L. Ross, J. W. Jr. Wilson G. L. “A Summary of crashworthiness Information for Small Airplanes.” Federal Aviation Administration Aeronautical Center Flight Standards Technical Division Oklahoma City, Oklahoma February 1973
- Aero-Amateur “Avoidable Accidents. Their Causes and Some Suggested Remedies.” The Aero November 30 1910 424 425
- Aero-Amateur “Avoidable Accidents. Their Causes and Some Suggested Remedies.” The Aero December 7 1910 444 446
- Bergey K. “Crash Program.” Air Progress 32 2 February 1973 23 29
- Bergey K. “The Design of Crashworthy General Aviation Aircraft.” Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. New York April 1974
- Frias G. Garsido-Lecca “el accidente de Jorge Chavez.” Lima, Peru 1963
- Snyder R. G. Early J. C. Mohler S. 1962
- Reals W. R. “Medical Investigation of Aviation Accidents.” College of American Pathologists 1968 2
- Foulois B. “And Teach Yourself to Fly.” The Reader's Digest 77 October 1960 50 55
- Still E. G. “Prevention of Aviation Accidents.” Scientific American 109 October 4 1913 259
- Snyder R. G. “Occupant Restraint Systems of Automotive, Aircraft and Manned Space Vehicles: An Evaluation of the State-of-the-Art and Future Concepts.” Chapter XXII in Impact Injury and Crash Protection.” Grudjian E. S. Lange W. A. Patrick L. M. Thomas L. M. Springfield, Illinois Thomas Charles C. 1970
- Snyder R. G. “A Survey of Automotive Occupant Restraint Systems: Where We've Been Where We Are, and Our Current Problems.” Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. N.Y. Paper Number 690243
- DeHaven H. “Beginnings of Crash Injury Research.” Proceedings of Thirteenth Stapp Car Conference Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. N. Y. 422 428
- War Department “Aviation and Its Medical Problems.” Air Service Medical, Air Service Division of Military Aeronautics Washington, D.C. 1919 31 32
- Unfallerfahrungen S. Ruff Protection Against Possible Injuries Caused by Airplane Crashes March 1937
- Armstrong H. G. “Accidents in Aviation.” Principles and Practice of Aviation Medicine 1939 395
- Material Division Correspondent “Safety Shoulder Belt Developed at Wright Field.” Air Corps News Letter Washington, D.C. 22 20 October 15 1939 1 2
- Preston G. M. Band M. E. “Crash Impact Survival in Light Airplanes.” NACA Lewis Flight Propulsion Laboratory 1947
- Eiband A. M. Simpkinson S. H. Black D.O. “Accelerations and Passenger Harness Loads Measured in Full-Scale Light Airplane Crashes.” National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics 1953
- “NACA Reveals Crash Data to Industry.” Aviation Week November 23 1953 26
- DeHaven H. “The Relationship of Injuries to Structure in Survivable Aircraft Accidents.” National Research Council, Committee on Aviation Medicine Report No. 440 July 9 1945
- DeHaven H. “Injuries in Thirty Light-Aircraft Accidents.” Crash Injury Project
- DeHaven H. “Crash Research from the Point of View of Cabin Design.” Aeron Engineer Rev 5 6 June 1946 1 7
- DeHaven H. “The Site, Frequency, and Dangerousness of Injury Sustained by 800 Survivors of Light Plane Accidents.” Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Cornell University Medical College N.Y. July 1952
- DeHaven H. “Crash Deceleration, Crash Energy, and their Relationship to Crash Injury.” Air Force Material Command Dayton, Ohio December 1950
- DeHaven H. “injury in Light Aircraft Accidents.” The Air Surgeon's Bulletin 1 1944 5
- DuBois E. F. “Limits of Factors of Safety in the Human Body.” Mechanical Engineering 68 January 1946 625 627
- DuBois U. E. F. “The Safer Cockpit.” Skyways 4 June 1945 41 90
- DuBois E. F. “The Anatomy and Physiology of the Airplane Cockpit.” Aeron. Engr. Rev 4 4 1945 1 3
- Marrow D. J. “Analysis of Injuries of 1942 Persons in 1442 Light Plane Accidents.” CAA Medical Service Records Washington, D.C. 1949
- DeHaven H. “Development of Crash-Survival Design in Personal, Executive and Agricultural Aircraft.” Crash Injury Research Cornell University Medical College New York May 1953
- “How Light Planes Can Be Made Safer; Crash Safety Can Be Engineered.” Aviation Week March 13 1950
- Beechcraft “Shoulder Harness & Protective Structural Design Features.” BEECHCRAFT Service Engineering Report N. 101
- Sprinkle J. V. “Static and Dynamic Tests of Combination Shoulder-harness-Lap-belt Safety Harness.” Model A35, Structural Analysis 49, Report No. 946 Beech Aircraft Corp. Wichita 1951
- Miller P. A. “Beechcraft Safety Harness Experience in Bonanza Serial D399.” Beech Aircraft Corp. Wichita 1953
- Hasbrook A. H. “The Historical Development of the Crash Impact Engineering Point of View.” Clinical Orthopaedics 8 Fall 1956 268 274
- Hasbrook A. H. “Crash Survival Study of a Survivable Accident Involving a Piper PA-11.” Aviation Crash Injury Research Cornell-Guggenheim Aviation Safety Center New York May 1954
- Hasbrook A. H. “Crash Injury Research; A Means of Greater Safety in Aircraft Accidents.” Aviation Medicine 28 December 1957 541 552
- Hasbrook A. H. “The Bio-mechanical Analysis of Survivable-Type Aircraft Accidents as a Factor in Improving Safety.” Institute of the Aeronautical Services, Inc. N.Y. January 1957
- Hasbrook A. H. “Severity of Injury in Light Plane Accidents: A Study of Injury Rate, Aircraft Damage, Accident Severity, Impact Angle, and Impact Speed Involving 1596 Persons in 913 Light Plane Accidents.” September 1959
- Hasbrook A. H. “Crash-Safe' Design Can Make Many Accidents Survivable.” Aerospace Engineering September 1960 78 80 82 87
- Hasbrook A. H. “Recommendations for Crash Safety Design Criteria for General Aviation Aircraft.” The Flying Physician 10 2 April 1966 18 23
- Hasbrook A. H. “Crash Load Vectors in Severe but Survivable Light Plane Accidents.” Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. New York March 26 1969
- Hasbrook A. H. Dille J. R. “Structural and Medical Analysis of a Civil Aircraft Accident.” Aerospace Medicine 35 10 October 1964 958 961
- Swearingen J. J. “Injury Potentials of Light Aircraft Instrument Panels.” Civil Aeromedical Research Institute Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Federal Aviation Agency Report AM66-12 April 1966
- Swearingen J. J. “General Aviation Structures Directly Responsible for Trauma in Crash Decelerations.” Civil Aeromedical Research Institute Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Federal Aviation Agency Report AM-71-3 January 1971
- Wallace T. F. Swearingen J. J. “Crash Injury Severity as Related to Aircraft Altitude During Impact.” Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., Paper No. 710399 New York March 1971
- Mohler S. R. Swearingen J. J. “Cockpit Design for Impact Survival.” Civil Aeromedical Research Institute Oklahoma City Oklahoma Federal Aviation Agency Publication AM 6603 February 1966
- Snyder R. G. “Civil Pilot Accident Experience with High Performance Single-Engine Light Executive Type Aircraft.” A Summary of the Flight Safety Foundation 19th Annual International Air Safety Seminar Madrid, Spain Seitz C.P. 1966 15 23
- Snyder R. G. “Aeromedical Aspects of Impact Protection in General Aviation Accidents.” Proceedings, Fourth Annual Symposium on Concepts in Modern Aviation Medicine Civil Aviation Medical Association, Manned Space Flight Center Houston, Texas November 4 1969
- Snyder R. G. “Occupant Impact Injury Tolerances for Aircraft Crashworthiness Design.” Technical Paper No. 710406 SAE National Business Aircraft Meeting Wichita, Kansas March 26 1971
- Snyder R. G. “In-Flight Structural Failures Involving General Aviation Aircraft.” Aerospace Medicine 43 10 October 1972 1132 1140
- Snyder R. G. “Crashworthiness and Occupant Protection in General Aviation Aircraft Accidents” Proceedings, Second International Meeting Aerospace Medicine Melbourne, Australia October 30 1972
- Snyder R. G. “Bioengineering Impace Survival in Business Aircraft.” SAE National Business Aircraft Meeting Wichita March 28 SAE Paper No. 690335 April 1972 SAE Journal 77 6 121 SAE Transactions 78 1969
- Snyder R. G. “Crashworthiness Considerations in Design of General Aviation Aircraft.” The Consumer Factor. Proceedings of the Seventeenth Annual Meeting of the Human Factors Society Washington, D.C Ranc, M.P. Jr. Malone T. B. October 1973 222
- Snyder R. G. “Survivability Factors in U.S. General Aviation Accidents.” Proceedings, Aerospace Medical Association May 8 1973
- Mason J. K. “Protective Helmets and Harness Restraint in Fatal Light Aircraft Accidents - UK Experience.” Proceedings, Aerospace Medical Association May 8 1973
- Mason J. K. “The Effects of Aircraft Accidents.” Aviation Accident Pathology Butterworths London 1962 61 117
- Stevens P. J. “Light Aircraft Accidents” Fatal Civil Aircraft Accidents. Their Medical and Pathological Investigation John Wright & Sons, Lts.
- Cullin S. A. “Death in General Aviation Accidents and Its Prevention.” Aerospace Pathology Mason J. K. Reels W.J. College of American Pathologists Foundation Chicago 1973
- Brown T. C. Croft P. Lane J. C. “Injury Production in General Aviation Accidents” Proceedings Aerospace Medical Association May 8 1973
- Brown T. C. Lane J. C. “Aviation Pathology in General Aviation.” Aerospace Medicine 41 7 July 1970 748 753
- Lane J. C. “Safety in Airline and General Aviation.” Proceedings, 10th Annual Conference of the Ergonomics Society of Australia and New Zealand November 1973 15.4
- Snyder R. G. State-of-the-Art-Human Impact Tolerance 1970 International Automobile Safety Conference Compendium Brussels May 1970 712 758 Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. N.Y. August 1970 October 1972
- Bruce J. Draper J. “Crash Safety in General Aviation Aircraft.” Report of the Nader Student Group Center for Study of Responsive Law January 1970
- Parsons H. “Presidential Address to the Human Factors Society,” 1969
- Mohler S. R. Swearingen J.J. “Cockpit Design for Impact Survival,” Office of Aviation Medicine Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Federal Aviation Agency CAMI Report No. AM-66-3 February 1966
- Department of Transportation FAA Statistical Handbook of Aviation 1970 Federal Aviation Administration Washington, D.C. 1970
- Department of Transportation FAA Statistical Handbook of Aviation 1972 Federal Aviation Administration Washington, D.C. 1972
- Communication Personal Federal Aviation Administration, Information Service Branch Washington, D.C. March 19 1975
- National Transportation Safety Board Annual Report to Congress Washington, D.C. 1973
- Department of Transportation 1970 Study of General Aviation Flying Occupant Load Factors Based Upon Accident Records for General Aviation Flying 1964-1968 Federal Aviation Administration, Information and Statistics Division May 1970
- Accidents, Fatalities, Rates. U. S. General Aviation 1964-1974 FAA Aviation News 14 March 1975
- National Safety Council Accident Facts Chicago, Ill. 1974 1973 40
- National Transportation Safety Board 1966
- Leak J. S. “Aircraft Accident Investigation: Organization and Procedures of the National Transportation Safety Board.” Medical Investigation of Aviation Accidents Reals W. J. Doyle B. C. Mohler S. R. College of American Pathologists Chicago 1968 110 30
- Reals W. J. Danielson R. E. “Autopsy Investigation of Aircraft Accidents.” Journal of Kansas Medical Society 64 1963 354
- Dille J. R. Morris E. W. “Human Factors in General Aviation Accidents.” Aerospace Medicine 38 1967 1063 1066
- Reals W. J. Mohler S. R. Doyle B. D. Gibbons H. “An Integrated Approach to the Aeromedical Investigation of Civil Aircraft Accidents.” Aerospace Medicine 39 1 January 1968 84
- Gibbons H. May 1970
- “NTSB Seeks Employe Increase with Newly Independent Status.” Aviation Week February 1975
- National Transportation Safety Board A Preliminary Analysis of Aircraft Accident Data-U. S. Civil Aviation 1969 13
- Dille J. R. “The Contribution of Pioneer Aircraft Accident Investigation to Improved Transportation Safety.” VIII International Symposium on Aviation Medicine Civil Aviation Medical Association Guadalajara, Mexico October 22 1973
- Federal Aviation Regulations “Part 23 Airworthiness Standards: Normal, Utility, and Acrobatic Category Airplanes.” Department of Transportation June 1974
- Underhill B. McCullough B. “An Energy Absorbing Seat Design for Light Aircraft.” Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. New York Paper No. 720322 March 1972