This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Effects of Unsteady On-Road Flow Conditions on Cabin Noise
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 12, 2010 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
At higher speeds aerodynamic noise tends to dominate the overall noise inside the passenger compartment. Large-scale turbulent conditions experienced on the road can generate different noise characteristics from those under steady-state conditions experienced in an acoustic wind tunnel. The objective of this research is to assess the relationship between on-road flow conditions and the sound pressure level in the cabin.
This research, covering links between the unsteady airflow around the vehicle and aeroacoustic effects, is a natural progression from previous aerodynamic studies. On-road testing was undertaken using a current production vehicle equipped with a mobile data logging system. Testing was carried out on major roads at typical highway speeds, where wind noise is very significant. Of particular interest are high-yaw conditions, which can lead to a blustering phenomenon. Flow data were collected from a five-hole aerodynamic probe mounted above the roof of the vehicle, which recorded both flow speed and direction. Sound data were recorded using an acoustic head located in the passenger seat of the vehicle. GPS data were also recorded, allowing information about the vehicle's speed, location and heading to be logged. Video recordings of each run were also taken, allowing probe and audio data to be correlated against the road surroundings.
It was found that the variation of in-cabin sound pressure level with yaw in the wind tunnel was in close agreement with on-road data at low lateral turbulence intensities. However, at higher lateral turbulence intensity there was a discrepancy between the wind tunnel and on-road sound pressure level, specifically to noise levels near the leeward sideglass. Sound pressure levels in this area were quieter than expected, indicating that transient flows around the leeward side of the vehicle do not have time to fully develop to their steady, high SPL condition. This is not necessarily beneficial from the point of view of perceived noise.
CitationOettle, N., Sims-Williams, D., Dominy, R., Darlington, C. et al., "The Effects of Unsteady On-Road Flow Conditions on Cabin Noise," SAE Technical Paper 2010-01-0289, 2010, https://doi.org/10.4271/2010-01-0289.
Vehicle Aerodynamics, 2010
Number: SP-2269; Published: 2010-04-13
Number: SP-2269; Published: 2010-04-13
- Engineering and Sciences Data Unit Report “Characteristics of Atmospheric Turbulence Near the Ground: Part 1,” 74030 1976
- Cooper, K. R. Watkins, S. “The Unsteady Wind Environment of Road Vehicles, Part One: A Review of the On-Road Turbulent Wind Environment,” SAE Paper 2007-01-1236 2007
- Wordley, S. Saunders, J. “On-Road Turbulence,” SAE Int. J. of Pass. Cars - Mech. Sys. 1 1 341 360 2008
- Cooper, K. R. Watkins, S. “The Unsteady Wind Environment of Road Vehicles, Part Two: Effects on Vehicle Development and Simulation of Turbulence,” SAE Paper 2007-01-1237 2007
- Wordley, S. Saunders, J. “On-Road Turbulence: Part 2,” SAE Int. J. of Pass. Cars - Mech. Sys. 2 1 111 137 2009
- Wordley, S. “On-Road Turbulence,” Department of Mechanical Engineering, Monash University Clayton, Victoria, Australia 2009
- Lawson, A. A. Dominy, R. Sims-Williams, D. B. Mears, P. “A Comparison Between On-Road and Wind Tunnel Surface Pressure Measurements on a Mid-Sized Hatchback,” SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-0898 2007
- Lawson, A., A. Dominy, R., G. Sims-Williams, D., B. “Effects of On-Road Turbulence on Vehicle Surface Pressures in the A-Pillar Region,” SAE Technical Paper, 2008-01-0474 2008
- George, A., R. “Automobile Aerodynamic Noise,” SAE Technical Paper, 900315 1990
- Haruna, S. Nouzawa, T. Kamimoto, I. Sato, H. “An Experimental Analysis and Estimation of Aerodynamic Noise Using a Production Vehicle,” SAE Technical Paper, 900316 1990
- Watkins, S. “Chapter III: Gusts and Transients,” in “Topics in Wind Noise: Automobile Wind Noise and Its Measurement Part II,” SAE International, SP-1457 1999
- Cogotti, A. “Generation of a Controlled Level of Turbulence in the Pininfarina Wind Tunnel for the Measurement of Unsteady Aerodynamics and Aeroacoustics,” SAE Technical Paper, 2003-01-0430 2003
- Cogotti, A. Cardano, D. Carlino, G. Cogotti, F. “Aerodynamics and Aeroacoustics of Passenger Cars in a Controlled High Turbulence Flow: Some New Results,” SAE technical Paper, 2005-01-1455 2005
- Lindener, N. Miehling, H. Cogotti, A. Cogotti, F. Maffei, M. “Aeroacoustic Measurements in Turbulent Flow on the Road and in the Wind Tunnel,” SAE Technical Paper, 2007-01-1551 2007
- Peric, C. Watkins, S. Lindqvist, E. Saunders, J. “Effects of On-Road Turbulence on Automotive Wind Noise: Comparing Wind-Tunnel and On-Road Tests,” SAE Technical Paper, 970406 1997
- Irwin, H. Cooper, K., R. Girand, R. “Correction of Distortion Effects Caused by Tubing Systems in Measurements of Fluctuating Pressures,” Journal of Industrial Aerodynamics 5 1-2 93 107 1979
- Sims-Williams, D., B. Dominy, R., G. “Experimental Investigation into Unsteadiness and Instability in Passenger Car Aerodynamics,” SAE Technical Paper, 9800391 1998
- Hucho, W-H. Aerodynamics of Road Vehicles Fourth SAE International Warrendale PA 0-7680-0029-7 345 1998
- He, L. “Time Marching Calculations of Unsteady Flows, Blade Row Interaction and Flutter,” Von Kármán Institute for Fluid Dynamics Unsteady Flows in Turbomachines 1996
- Watkins, S. Riegel, M. Wiedemann, J. “The Effect of Turbulence on Wind Noise: A Road and Wind-Tunnel Study,” 4th International Stuttgart Symposium FKFS/Stuttgart University 20-22nd February 2001 Automotive and Engine Technology Expert-Verlag 3-8169-1981-2