This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Evaluation of Glycerin (Glycerol) as a Heavy Duty Engine Antifreeze/Coolant Base
Technical Paper
2007-01-4000
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
In the early years of antifreeze/coolants (1920s & 30s) glycerin saw some usage, but because of higher cost and weaker freeze point depression, it was not competitive with ethylene glycol. Glycerin is a by-product of the manufacture of biodiesel (fatty acid methyl esters) made by reacting natural vegetable or animal fats with methanol. Biodiesel fuel is becoming increasingly important and is expected to gain a large market share in the next several years. Regular diesel fuels blended with 2%, 5%, and 20% biodiesel are now commercially available. The large amount of glycerin generated from high volume usage of biodiesel fuel has resulted in this chemical becoming cost competitive with the glycols currently used in engine coolants. For this reason, and lower toxicity comparable to that of propylene glycol, glycerin deserves to be reconsidered as a base for antifreeze/coolant.
Results of a literature search are presented as well as recent laboratory, bench, engine/dyno, chassis/dyno and field test data pertinent to the use of glycerin as a base fluid for heavy duty engine antifreeze/coolant. The performance of glycerin is addressed in areas including:
- Heat transfer
- Corrosion protection
- Cylinder liner cavitation corrosion
- Freeze point and other physical properties
- Low temperature viscosity
- Thermal stability
- Elastomer compatibility
- Toxicity relative to ethylene glycol and propylene glycol
Finally, areas for further work are proposed.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Hudgens, R., Hercamp, R., Francis, J., Nyman, D. et al., "An Evaluation of Glycerin (Glycerol) as a Heavy Duty Engine Antifreeze/Coolant Base," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-4000, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-4000.Also In
References
- Tally, L. H. Sequin, C. “Running on Empty” Purdue Engineering Impact Fall 2005 10
- Tally, L. H. Sequin, C. “Running on Empty” Purdue Engineering Impact Fall 2005 11
- “Scitechtrendlets” Reader's Digest August 2005 172
- Parfit, Michael “Future Power” National Geographic Aug. 2005 22
- Marsh, Stephen Coradi, Marco “The Effect of Biodiesel on Engine Lubricants,” Lubes ‘N’Greases 13 6 June 2007 30
- Parfit, Michael “Future Power” National Geographic Aug. 2005 23
- Hannigan, H. J. “A Review of Automotive Engine Coolant Technology” Engine Coolant Testing: Third volume, ASTM STP 1192 Beal Roy E. American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia, PA 1993 7
- “Three Chemicals Compete for Antifreeze Market” Chemical Industries May 1948 764
- Shreve, R. Norris The Chemical Process Industries 2nd McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc. New York 1956 635
- Cummings, H. K. “Antifreeze Solutions and Compounds” SAE 260054 1926 711
- Cummins, H. K. “Antifreeze Solutions and Compounds” SAE 260054 1926 687 715
- Cummins, H. K. “Antifreeze Solutions and Compounds” SAE 260054 1926 694 695
- Cummins, H. K. “Antifreeze Solutions and Compounds” SAE 260054 1926 693
- Hercamp, Richard D. “Use of Fully Formulated Heavy Duty Antifreeze/Coolant in Hot Climates Instead of Treated Water Reduces Cooling System Problems” SAE 1999-01-2824 New Diesel Engines, Components, and Cooling Systems SP-1470 1999 2 4
- Mark, F. E. Jetten, W. “Propylene Glycol, A New Base Fluid for Automotive Coolants,” Engine Coolant Testing: Second Symposium ASTM STP 887 Beal Roy E. American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia 1986 62
- “Cummins Coolant Requirements and Maintenance” Cummins Service Bulletin No. 3666132-04 Oct 2005 9
- “Prestone II, Physical Properties Data” Union Carbide Corp. Ninth 1984 1 38
- Greaney, James P. et al “Low Temperature Performance of Propylene Glycol Engine Coolant” SAE 950463 1995 2
- Perry, John H. Chemical Engineers' Handbook McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc. New York 1950 191
- Perry, John H. Chemical Engineers' Handbook McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc. New York 1950 1696
- Perry, John H. Chemical Engineers' Handbook McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc. New York 1950 1697
- International Critical Tables of Numerical Data, Physics, Chemistry and Technology 5 McGraw-Hill Books Co. New York 1929 23
- Gehres, E. “An Analysis of Engine Cooling in Modern Passenger Cars” SAE 630187 (660C) 1963 6
- Greaney, James P. Cozzone, Glenn E. “Comparative Performance of Aqueous Propylene Glycol and Aqueous Ethylene Glycol Coolants” SAE 1999-01-0134 Engine Coolants and Cooling Systems, SP-1456 1999 65 70
- Pulskamp, Douglas A. Hercamp, Richard D. “Chassis Dyno Heat Transfer Comparison of Glycerin Base VS Ethylene Glycol Base Coolant” Cummins Report #00000123 09 11 2006 1 6
- “Standard Specification for Glycol Base Engine Coolant for Automobile and Light-Duty Service” Annual Book of ASTM Standards, 2006, Section Fifteen 15.05 110
- Scott, L.F. Jr. Weir, T.W. “Comparing the Performance of Ethylene Glycol and Propylene Glycol Coolants in Heavy Duty Engines,” Engine Coolants and Cooling System Components SAE 961039 Feb 1996 179 186
- Stafford, R.J. “Investigation of Deposits on Water Pump Seal Faces” Engine Coolant Testing: Third volume Beal R.E. American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia 1993 205 214
- Kiryu, K. et al “The Relationship Between Sealing Performance of Mechanical Seals and Composition of Coolants for Automotive Engines” Engine Coolant Testing: Third volume Beal R.E. American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia 1993 215 233
- “Diesel Engine Coolant Cavitation Test” Research Report: D15 - 1023, ASTM Committee D15 on Engine Coolants
- “Coolant, Engine, Performance Specification,” Cummins Engineering Standard CES 14603 Cummins Inc. 27
- “Engine Coolant Hot Surface Deposit Test,” Research Report: D15 - 1024, ASTM Committee D15 on Engine Coolants
- Coolant, Engine-Performance Specification” 9 22
- Hercamp, Richard D. Cox, Anthony B. “Evaluation of Fleetguard ES Compleat Glycerin in CES 14603 Elastomer Compatibility Test and Assessment of the Accuracy and Repeatability of the Compression Set Section of that Test Procedure” Cummins Report # 00000524 12 15 2006 1 13
- Chen Yu-sen Hudgens R Doug Eaton Edward R “Comparison of Bench Test Methods to Evaluate Heavy Duty Coolant Thermal Stability” Journal of ASTM International 4 4 Paper ID JAI100634
- Martin, Harold R. et al “A Comparison of Accelerated Coolant Aging Laboratory Tests and Field Test Results” Engine Coolants and Cooling Systems, SP-1456 SAE 1999-01-0130 47 51
- Sax, N. Irving Dangerous Properties of Industrial Materials Third Van Nostrand Reinhold Company New York 1968
- Perry, John H. Chemical Engineers' Handbook Third McGraw-Hill Book Company 1950 1584
- Budavari, Susan The Merck Index 12th Merck & Co., Inc. 1996