Crashworthiness of WC19 Wheelchairs in Vertical Dynamic Aircraft Seating Tests

Currently, people who use wheelchairs are not permitted to use their own wheelchairs as seats on commercial aircraft. To advance equitable aircraft travel for these passengers, we need to determine whether wheelchairs would be safe seating for their occupants and not pose a safety hazard for other passengers in case of emergency landing. We hypothesized that wheelchairs meeting the voluntary standards for vehicle crashworthiness (Rehabilitation Engineering Society of North America [RESNA] Section 19 Wheelchairs Used as Seats in Motor Vehicles [WC19]) would be able to pass the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) vertical crashworthiness standards for aircraft seating. Wheelchairs were secured using surrogate 4-point strap tiedowns using the geometry specified by WC19. The FAA Hybrid III anthropomorphic test device (FH3 ATD) was restrained by both the wheelchair-attached lap belt and a vehicle-mounted lap belt identified as necessary to pass FAA dynamic horizontal test requirements. For the dynamic vertical testing with the wheelchairs oriented 60 degrees relative to horizontal, modeling demonstrated the suitability of using the trapezoidal pulse achieved with the UMTRI sled produced rather than the typical triangular shaped FAA pulse. Of the five manual and three power wheelchairs tested, four had broken components that would not impede emergency exit, four did not have visible damage, and the FH3 remained within the seat in all tests. The three power wheelchairs did not meet lumbar compression requirements. Based on these results, it may be feasible for people to use their own WC19-compliant wheelchairs on aircraft when secured to the aircraft with 4-point strap tiedown systems, supplemented by an occupant lap belt anchored to the aircraft, notwithstanding the lumbar force requirement.