This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Legal Issues Associated with the Use of Probabilistic Design Methods
- Aerospace Standard
- AIR5113
- Reaffirmed
Downloadable datasets available
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Issuing Committee:
Language:
English
Scope
This SAE Aerospace Information Report (AIR) addresses legal issues concerning use of non-deterministic methods in the design and/or analysis of systems. The investigation includes an assessment of legal precedent for use of these methods both in the aerospace industry and in other non-aerospace engineering contexts. The investigation is primarily, but not exclusively, focused on United States of America Federal and State Law.
This document is not intended to be used in any way as a “legal justification” for the use of Probabilistic Methods - it is simply a compilation of experience and past precedent.
Many engineers note that the use of Probabilistic Methods for failure risk assessment implies an acceptance that any design will have a finite, albeit small, risk of loss of function, and express concern that this could be seized upon in a Court of Law to indicate that the design was “unsafe”. This report helps to allay some of these fears by presenting the logic used in past legal determinations to assess liability following loss of function of artifacts designed using both deterministic and probabilistic engineering methods.
Some recommendations are also provided in the report of “good practice” to be followed when using non-deterministic design methods - most of which are equally applicable to deterministic design methods.
Rationale
AIR5113 has been reaffirmed to comply with the SAE five-year review policy.
Recommended Content
| Aerospace Standard | Minimum Design and Performance of Airplane Galley Insert Equipment, Electrical/Pressurized |
| Ground Vehicle Standard | Standard for Refrigerant Risk Analysis for Mobile Air Conditioning Systems |
Data Sets - Support Documents
| Title | Description | Download |
|---|---|---|
| Unnamed Dataset 1 |
Issuing Committee
G-11 Probabilistic Methods and Uncertainty Quantification
The G-11PM/UQ Committee is a part of SAE's G-11 Division. The Committee has the charter to facilitate industry consensus on Probabilistic Methods and Uncertainty Quantification approaches in order to enhance the competitiveness of industry by enabling more intelligent, affordable, and reliable product development and deployment life-cycles.
Reference
| Number | Title |
|---|
* Redlines comparisons are available for those standards
listed in the Revision History that contain a radio button. A
redline comparison of the current version against a revision is
accomplished by selecting the radio button next to the standard and
then selecting 'compare'. At this time, Redline versions only exist
for some AMS standards. SAE will continue to add redline versioning
with ongoing updates to SAE MOBILUS.