This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Investigation into the Noise Associated with Airbag Deployment: Part II - Injury Risk Study Using a Mathematical Model of the Human Ear
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Event:
Stapp Car Crash Conference
Language:
English
Abstract
Airbag deployments are associated with loud noise of short duration, called impulse noise. Research performed in the late 1960's and early 1970's established several criteria for assessment of the risk of impulse noise-induced hearing loss for military weapons and general exposures. These criteria were modified for airbag noise in the early 1970's, but field accident statistics and experimental results with human volunteers exposed to airbags do not seem to agree with the criteria.
More recent research on impulse noise from weapons firing, in particular that of Price & Kalb of the US Army Research Laboratory, has led to development of a mathematical model of the ear. This model incorporates transfer functions which alter the incident sound pressure through various parts of the ear. It also calculates a function, called the “hazard”, that is a measure of mechanical fatigue of the hair cells in the inner ear. The repeatability of the model was examined in the present study by comparing its predictive behavior for airbag noise impulses generated by nominally identical airbag systems. Calculations of potential “hazard” made by the model were also examined for reasonableness based on mechanical and biomechanical considerations. A large number of airbag noise pulses were examined using the model.
The results provide some counter-intuitive insights into the mechanism of noise-induced hearing loss from deployment of airbag systems. They also indicate that, based upon testing of feline subjects (which are believed to be a good indicator of the risk to the more susceptible segment of the human population), there could be a risk of temporary and possibly permanent threshold shifts in approximately sixty seven percent of the 1990-1995 model year vehicles from 19 manufacturers which were tested and assessed using the human ear model. A statistical estimate of the risk for the human population has yet to be quantified, but work is in progress to do so.
Work is also underway to develop a pre-production airbag component test for deployment noise that component suppliers can incorporate into the design and development process. Once injury risk curves and test protocols are established, it is recommended that the ARL Human Ear Model be utilized by the automotive community as the assessment method of choice.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Rouhana, S., Webb, S., and Dunn, V., "Investigation into the Noise Associated with Airbag Deployment: Part II - Injury Risk Study Using a Mathematical Model of the Human Ear," SAE Technical Paper 983162, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/983162.Also In
References
- Zador, P. Ciccone, M. “Automobile Driver Fatalities in Frontal Impacts: Air Bags Compared with Manual Belts” Am. J. Public Health 83 5 May 1993
- Blower, D. Campbell, K.L. “Comparison of Occupant Restraints Based on Injury-Producing Contact Rates” Proceedings of the 38th Stapp Car Crash Conference SAE Technical Paper Number 942219 1994
- Ward, W.D. “Proposed Damage-Risk Criterion for Impulse Noise (Gunfire)” NAS-NRC Committee on Hearing, Bioacoustics, and Biomechanics, Report of Working Group 57 1968
- Allen, C.H. Bruce, R.D. Dietrich, C.W. Pearsons, K.S. “Noise and Inflatable Restraint Systems” BBN Report Number 2020, DOT Final Report, DOT-HS-006-1-006 1971
- Nixon, C.W. “Human Auditory Response to an Air Bag Inflation Noise” Final Report, DOT Contract Number P.O. 9-1-1151 1969
- Price, G.R. Kalb, J.T. “Mathematical Model of the Effect of Limited Stapes Displacement on Hazard from Intense Sounds” J. Acoustical Society of America 80 Fall 1986
- Price, G.R. Kalb, J.T. “Insights into hazard from intense impulses from a mathematical model of the ear” J. Acoustical Society of America 90 1 1991
- Hickling, R. “The Noise of the Automotive Safety Air Cushion” Noise Control Engineering 6 3 May-June 1976
- Sommer, H.C. “Description and Use of a Measurement System for Air Bag Acoustic Transient Data Acquisition and Analysis” Final Report, DOT IA-0-1-2160 Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base March 1973
- Posey, J. Hickling, R. “Noise Mechanisms in the Inflation of the Automotive Safety Air Bag” 85th Annual Meeting of the Acoustical Society of America GM Research Publication 1973
- Rouhana, S.W. Webb, S.R. Wooley, R.G. McCleary, J.D. Wood, F.D. Salva D.B. “Investigation into the Noise Associated with Air Bag Deployment: Part I - Measurement Technique and Parameter Study” Proceedings of the 38th Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE Technical Paper Number 942218 1994
- Hassall, J.R. Zaveri, K. “Acoustic Noise Measurements” 41 Brüel & Kjaer 1988
- Hassall, J.R. Zaveri, K. “Acoustic Noise Measurements” 42 43 Brüel & Kjaer 1988
- Melnick, W. “Temporary and Permanent Threshold Shift” Noise and Audiology Lipscomb D. M. University Park Press Baltimore 1978
- Durrant, J.D. “Anatomic and Physiologic Correlates of the Effects of Noise on Hearing” Noise and Audiology Lipscomb D. M. University Park Press Baltimore 1978
- Hodge, D.C. Price, G.R. “Hearing Damage Risk Criteria” Noise and Audiology Lipscomb D. M. University Park Press Baltimore 1978
- Coles, R.R.A. Garinther, G.R. Hodge, D.C. Rice, C.G. “Hazardous Exposure to Impulse Noise” J. Acoustical Society of America 43 2 1968
- United States Department of Defense “Noise Limits for Army Materiel - Military Standard 1474B” 1979
- Kryter, K.D. Ward, W.D. Miller, J.D. Eldredge, D.H. “Hazardous Exposure to Intermittent and Steady-State Noise” Report of CHABA Working Group 46 to the NAS, J. Acoustical Society of America 39 3 1966
- McRobert, H. Ward, W.D. “Damage-Risk Criteria: The trading relation between intensity and the number of nonreverberant impulses” J. Acoustical Society of America 53 5 1973
- Report Committee on Hearing, Bioacoustics and Biomechanics “Hazardous Exposure to Impulse Noise” National Academy of Sciences, National Academy Press 1992
- Price, G.R. “Functional Changes in the Ear Produced by High-Intensity Sound. I. 5.0-kHz Stimulation” J. Acoustical Society of America 44 6 1968
- Price, G.R. “Functional Changes in the Ear Produced by High-Intensity Sound. II. 500-Hz Stimulation” J. Acoustical Society of America 51 2 1972
- Price, G.R. “Implications of a Critical Level in the Ear for Assessment of Noise Hazard at High Intensities” J. Acoustical Society of America 69 1 1981
- Price, G.R. “Loss of Auditory Sensitivity Following Exposure to Spectrally Narrow Impulses” J. Acoustical Society of America 66 2 1979
- Price, G.R. “Relative Hazard of Weapons Impulses” J. Acoustical Society of America 73 2 1983
- Price, G.R Kim, H.N. Lim, D.J. Dunn, D. “Hazard From Weapons Impulses: Histological and Electrophysiological Evidence” J. Acoustical Society of America 85 3 1989
- Price, G.R. Lim, D.J. “Susceptibility to Intense Impulses” J. Acoustical Society of America 74 Fall 1983
- Price, G.R. “Hazard From Intense Low-Frequency Acoustic Impulses” J. Acoustical Society of America 80 4 1986
- Price, G.R. Wansack, S. “Hazard From an Intense Midrange Impulse” J. Acoustical Society of America 86 6 1989
- Price, G.R. “Age as a Factor in Susceptibility to Hearing Loss: Young versus Adult Ears” J. Acoustical Society of America 60 4 1976
- Price, G.R. “Upper Limit to Stapes Displacement: Implications for Hearing Loss” J. Acoustical Society of America 56 1 1974
- Price, G.R. “Transformation Function of the External Ear in Response to Impulsive Stimulation” J. Acoustical Society of America 56 1 1974
- Kalb, J.T. Price, G.R. “Mathematical Model of the Ear's Response to Weapons Impulses” Proceedings of the Third Conference on Weapon Launch Noise Blast Over-pressure, Special Publication BRL-SP-66 U.S. Army Ballistics Research Lab Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 1987
- Price, G.R. Rouhana, S.W. Kalb, J.T. “Hearing Hazard From the Noise of Air Bag Deployment” J. Acoustical Society of America 99 4 1996
- Price, G.R. Kalb, J.T. “Auditory Hazard From Airbag Noise Exposure” J. Acoustical Society of America 1998
- Johnson, D. L. “Blast overpressure studies with animals and men: A walk-up study” USAARL Contract Report No. CR-94-2 U.S.Army Aeromedical Res. Lab. Ft. Rucker, AL 1994
- Patterson, J. H. Johnson, D. L. “Temporary threshold shifts produced by high intensity free field impulse noise in humans wearing hearing protection” USAARL Report No. 94-46 24 U.S.Army Aeromedical Res. Lab. Ft. Rucker, AL 1994
- Johnson, D. L. “Blast overpressure studies” USAARL Contract Report No. CR-98-03 U.S.Army Aeromedical Res. Lab. Ft. Rucker, AL 1998
- Price, G.R. Kalb, J.T. “Welcome to the ARL Auditory Hazard Assessment Algorithm - Human (AHAAH) Version 1,0” Ear Model Users Manual 1998
- Price, G. R. Kalb, J. T. “Modeling auditory hazard from impulses with large low-frequency components” J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 99 2464 1996
- Mattox, D.E. Lou, W. Kalb, J. T. Price, G. R. “Histologic changes of the cochlea after airbag deployment” Abstracts of the 20 th Midwinter Meeting of the Association for Research in Otolaryngology St. Petersburg, FL 200 1997
- Sommer, H.C. Nixon, C.W. “Primary Components of Simulated Air Bag Noise and Their Relative Effects on Human Hearing” Final Report, DOT Contract Number IA-0-1-2160 1973
- Saunders, J.E. Slattery, W.H. Luxford, W.M. “Automobile Airbag Impulse Noise: Otologic Symptoms in Six Patients” American Academy of Otolaryngology - Head Neck Surgery Annual Meeting September 19 1995
- Kramer, M.B. Shattuck, T.G. Charnock, D.R. “Traumatic Hearing Loss Following Air-Bag Inflation” New England J. of Medicine 337 8 1997
- McFeely, W.J. Bojrab, D.I. Davis, K.G. Hegyi, D. “Otologic Injuries Secondary to Airbag Deployment” Poster Presentation at the American Academy of Otolaryngology - Head Neck Surgery Foundation Annual Meeting September 13-16 1998
- Mertz, H.J. “Anthropomorphic Test Devices” Accidental Injury: Biomechanics and Prevention Nahum A.M. Melvin J.W. Springer-Verlag New York 1993
- Rouhana, S.W. “Airbag Noise: Research, Description and Status” SAE Airbag Systems Task Force May 13 1997
- Rouhana, S.W. “Issues to be Considered in Drafting a Standard Measurement Procedure for Assessing Airbag Noise” SAE Airbag Systems Task Force May 13 1997
- Ochs, J. “Airbag Inflation Noise - Evaluation and Analysis” SAE Airbag Systems Task Force May 13 1997