This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Development of Injury Criteria for Human Surrogates to Address Current Trends in Knee-to-Instrument Panel Injuries
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published November 2, 1998 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Event: Stapp Car Crash Conference
Injuries to the lower extremities are common during car accidents because the lower extremity is typically the first point of contact between the occupant and the car interior. While injuries to the knee, ankle and hip are usually not life threatening, they can represent a large societal burden through treatment costs, lost work days and a reduced quality of life. The aim of the current study was to specifically study injuries associated with the knee and to propose a methodology which could be used to prevent future knee injuries. To understand the scope of this problem, a study was designed to identify injury trends in car crashes for the years 1979-1995. The NASS (National Accident Sampling System) showed that 10% of all injuries were to the knee, second only to head and neck injuries. Most knee injuries resulted from knee-to-instrument panel contact. Subfracture injuries were most common (contusions, abrasions, lacerations) followed by gross fracture injuries. Our recent studies on the human cadaver knee show that increasing the contact area for a given contact force over the knee significantly reduces acute injury in fracture and subfracture experiments. Unfortunately, the cadaver force-area data cannot be directly applied to the Hybrid III dummy, which currently serves as a human surrogate in car crash simulations. Thus, another aim of this study was to develop a transformation of the cadaver contact force-area relationship to the dummy. Numerous experiments were conducted on the dummy to establish a comparison with companion experiments conducted on cadavers. Data points representing a 50% risk of gross fracture were calculated for the cadaver and transformed into the dummy response to yield data directly relevant to sled testing with dummies. Several sled tests were run, using an idealized instrument panel, to show the utility of the data in predicting joint injury for depowered air bags and a variety of restraint scenarios. Mathematical models were developed to demonstrate a theoretical scenario in which load and area could be estimated without the need for physical sled testing. This study shows that a simple measure of the knee contact load and area could be used to predict injuries in the human cadaver knee from blunt insult via dummy test data. Such data may prove useful in the design of future instrument panels to provide increased knee injury protection for car occupants.
CitationAtkinson, P., Atkinson, T., Haut, R., Eusebi, C. et al., "Development of Injury Criteria for Human Surrogates to Address Current Trends in Knee-to-Instrument Panel Injuries," SAE Technical Paper 983146, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/983146.
- Fildes, B., Lenard, J., Lane, J., Vulcan, P., and Seyer, K., (1997) Lower Limb Injuries to Passenger Car Occupants, Accid. Anal.and Prev., Vol(29):785-791.
- States, J. Adult occupant injuries of the lower limb.(1986) In: Biomechanics and medical aspects of lower limb injuries. Warrendale, PA: SAE: 97-107.
- Luchter, S. and Walz, M.C. Long-term Consequences of Head Injury (1995) J Neurotrauma 12(4):517-526, 1995.
- MacKenzie, E.J., Siegel, J.H., Shapiro, S., and et.al. (1988) Functional Recovery and Medical Costs of Trauma: An analysis by Type and Severity of Injury. Journal of Trauma 28:281-298.
- Miller, T., Martin, P., and Crandall, J.R. (1995) Costs of Lower Limb Injuries in Highway Crashes. Proceedings of The International Conference on Pelvic and Lower Extremity Injuries: 47-57.
- Hartemann, F., Thomas, C., Henry, C., Foret-Bruno, J-Y., Faverjon, G., Tarriere, C., Got, C., Patel, A. (1977) Belted or not Belted: The Only Difference Between Two Match Samples of 200 Car Occupants. 21st Stapp Car Crash Conference (21):97-150.
- Bourret, P., Corbelli, S., and Cavallero, C. (1977) Injury Agents and Impact Mechanisms in Frontal Crashes about 350 in the Field Accidents. 21st Stapp Car Crash Conference (21):215-258.
- Viano D (1977) Considerations for a femur injury criterion. 21st Stapp Car Crash Conference 445-473
- Melvin J, Stalnaker R, Alem N, Benson J, Mohan D (1975) Impact Response and Tolerance of the Lower Extremities. Stapp Car Crash Conf 19: 543-559
- Patrick L, Kroell C, Mertz H (1965) Forces on the human body in simulated Crashes. Stapp Car Crash Conf 9: 237-259
- Powell W, Ojala S, Advani S, Martin R (1975) Cadaver Femur Responses to Longitudinal impacts. Stapp Car Crash Conf 19: 561-579
- Viano DC, Stalnaker RL (1980) Mechanisms of Femoral Fracture. Journal Biomechanics 13: 701-715
- Atkinson PJ, Garcia JJ, Altiero NJ Haut RC (1997) The influence of impact interface on human knee injury: implications for instrument panel design and the lower extremity injury criterion. Stapp Car Crash Conf 41:167-180. paper 973327
- Atkinson PJ, MacKenzie C, Haut RC (1998) Joint fracture load prediction using geometrical, physical and pathological measures: the human knee. SAE International Congress: paper 980358
- Hering W, Patrick L (1977) Response Comparisons of the Human Cadaver Knee and a Part 572 Dummy Knee to Impacts by Crushable Materials. Stapp Car Crash Conference 21: 1015-1053
- Nyquist GW (1974) Static force-penetration response of the human knee. Stapp Car Crash Proceedings. Paper 741189
- Dischinger PC, Kerns TJ, Kufera JA (1995) Lower extremity fracturesin motor vehicle collisions: the role of gender and height. Accident Analysis and Prevention 27(4): 601-606
- Viano, D., Culver, C., Haut, R., Melvin, J., Bender, M., Culver, R., and Levine, R. (1978) Bolster impacts to the knee and tibia of human cadavers and an anthropomorphic dummy. Stapp Car Crash Proceedings 22:403-428.
- Haut R (1989) Contact Pressures in the Patello-femoral Joint during Impact Loading on the Human Flexed Knee. Journal of Orthopaedic Research 7: 272-280
- Cheng, R, Yang, KH, Levine, RS, King, AI (1984) Dynamic impact loading under passive restrained condition. Stapp Car Crash Conference 28:101-118.
- Donohue MJ, Buss D, Oegema T, Thompson R (1983) The Effects of Indirect Blunt Trauma on Adult Canine Articular Cartilage. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 65-A(7): 948-957
- Thompson, R.C., Oegema, T.R., Lewis, J.L., and Wallace, L. (1991) Osteoarthritic changes after acute transarticular load. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 73-A(7):990-1001.
- Atkinson PJ, Haut RC (1995) Subfracture Insult to the Human Cadaver Patellofemoral Joint Produces Occult Injury. Journal of Orthopaedic Research 13: 936-944
- Huberti H, Hayes W, Stone J, Shybut G (1984) Force ratios in the quadriceps tendon and ligamentum patellae. Journal of Orthopaedic Research 2: 49-54
- Parenteau, C.S., Viano, D.C., Lovsund, P., and Tingvall, C., (1996), Foot-Ankle Injuries: Influence of Crash Location, Seating Position, and Age, Accid. Anal. and Prev., Vol(28):607-617.
- Lewis, P.R., Molz, F.J., Schmidtke, S.Z., and Bidez, M.W., (1996) A NASS-Based Investigation of Pelvic Injury within the Motor Vehicle Crash Environment, 40th Stapp Car Crash (40):123-129.
- Atkinson PJ, Haut RC (1995) Insult to the human cadaver patellofemoral joint: effects of age on fracture tolerance and occult injury. Stapp Car Crash Conference 39:281-294
- Armstrong C, Mow V, Wirth C (1985) Biomechanics of impact-induced microdamage to articular cartilage: a possible genesis for chondromalacia patella. In: Amer Acad of Orth Surg Symp on Sports Med, ed by Fenerman G. pp70-84.