This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Comparison of the Safety Performance of Aluminum and Steel in Conventional Automotive Construction
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 29, 1998 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
It is often said that heavier cars are inherently safer than lighter ones. However, when all cars are built with steel, larger size necessarily implies greater weight, so it is unclear whether the improved safety correlates to the weight or size of the vehicle. Using a publicly available computer model of the Ford Taurus, it was thought that this perception could be tested. The existing steel model, with the addition of a Hybrid III dummy and driver side airbag, was validated against actual crash test data. The structure was converted to aluminum, structural stiffness was calculated, and the steel and aluminum crash simulation results were compared. The aluminum model, utilizing monocoque sheet structure, weld bonded joining, and tailor welded blanks, weighed 200 kg less than the steel model and performed as well.
CitationWiese, J., Kan, C., and Marzougui, D., "A Comparison of the Safety Performance of Aluminum and Steel in Conventional Automotive Construction," SAE Technical Paper 982389, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/982389.
- Varadappa, S., Shyo, S. C., and Mani, A., “Development of a Passenger Vehicle Finite Element Model,” Final Report DOT HS 808 145, Department of Transportation, November 1993, Washington, DC.
- Bedewi, N. E., Kan, C. D., Summers, S., and Ragland, C., “Evaluation of Car-to-Car Frontal Offset Impact Finite Element Models Using Full Scale Crash Data,” Issues in Automotive Safety Technology, SAE Publication SP-1072, pp. 212-219, February 1995.
- Reichert, R., “Validation of a Ford Taurus Finite Element Model for Frontal Offset Impacts,” Masters thesis, The George Washington University, May 1995.
- Noureddine, A., Digges, K. H., and Bedewi, N., “An Evaluation of Deformation Based Chest Injury Criteria Using a Hybrid III Finite Element Model,” International Journal of Crashworthiness, Vol. 1, 1996, pp. 181-189.
- Bedewi, N. E., Marzougui, G., and Motevalli, V., “Evaluation of Parameters Effecting Simulation of Airbag Deployment and Interaction With Occupants,” Accepted for publication, International Journal of Crashworthiness.
- Markusic, C. A., “Vehicle Safety Compliance Testing for Occupant Crash Protection, Windshield Mounting, Windshield Zone Intrusion, and Fuel System Integrity,” Final Report of FMVSS Nos. 208, 212, 219, and 301 Compliance Testing, NHTSA No. CP0203, Department of Transportation, November 1992, Washington, DC