This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Electric Truck in America: Why Did It Fail?
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Since the Californian ZEV mandate caused a new wave of interest in the electric automotive propulsion system to sweep over the world, the question of why earlier attempts to bring the electric vehicle to the market failed is heavily debated. As to the possible causes of failure of the electric vehicle during the first two decades of this century, the consensus among automotive engineers tends to be that it was the high weight and the low energy density of the battery which prevented the electric motor from becoming the dominant automotive propulsion system. Since then, this argument goes, the situation hasn't changed very much.
In this paper, based upon a recently finished doctoral dissertation on the history of early American and European electric vehicles [1], other, mainly non-technical, failure factors are suggested as being more convincing. Although this paper will be limited to the case of the American electric truck, it is argued that the history of automotive technology should become an integral part of engineering education, as it helps young engineers to weigh technological impulses of change against other, non-technical influences.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Mom, G., "The Electric Truck in America: Why Did It Fail?," SAE Technical Paper 980618, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/980618.Also In
References
- Technical University of Eindhoven, Faculty Technology Management Lintsen H.W. Geschiedenis van de Auto van Morgen; cultuur en techniek van de elektrische auto Deventer 1997 90 2012991 0
- Shnayerson Michael The car that could; the inside story of GM's revolutionary electric vehicle New York 1996 Fogelberg Hans ‘The electric car controversy: a social-constructivist interpretation of the California zero-emission vehicle mandate’ Göteborg 1996 Chalmers University of Technology, Department of History of Technology and Industry
- Shnayerson, The car that could 183 274
- Mom Gijs Mom Gijs van der Vinne Vincent De elektro-auto: een paard van Troje? Deventer 1995 11 110
- ‘Census report on automobile manufacture in 1900’ Horseless Age 17 September 1902 307
- Kirsch David A. ‘The electric car and the burden of history; studies in automotive systems rivalry in America, 1890-1996’ Stanford University September 1996 61
- ‘The importance of the storage battery’ Electrical Review New York 21 June 1902 815 816
- Montagu Lord McComb F. Wilson Behind the wheel; the magic and manners of early motoring New York/London 1977 111 112
- cord tires cord tire cord fabric
- Mom G. Polytechnisch tijdschrift, editie Werktuigbouw November 1991 44 47
- Schiffer Michael Brian Butts Tamara C. Grimm Kimberly K. Taking charge; the electric automobile in America Washington/London 1994
- ‘Storage battery traction’ Electical Review 8 June 1901 715
- ‘The situation regarding the Edison storage battery’ Electrical Review 8 August 1903 198 199
- Lloyd R. McAllister ‘The influence of the pioneering spirit on electric vehicle progress’ The Central Station 1914 1915 179 181
- ‘Doubling an electric wagon equipment’ The Commercial Vehicle June 1907 159 160
- Harris S.C. ‘Vehicle battery practice in central station companies’ Electric Vehicle Association of America; Second annual convention; papers, reports and discussions New York City October 10th 1911 New York City, n.y. 1911 November The central station) 16 18
- ‘A substantial industry’ The Commercial Vehicle April 1910 150 Centralblatt für Accumulatoren- und Elementenkunde; Organ für Wissenschaft und Technik, mit besonderer Berücksichtigung des Accumobilism Berlin 20 July 1908 111
- Vinson Taylor ‘Auto history at NAIAS’ SAH Journal; the newsletter of the Society of Automotive Historians 167 March April 1997 7
- Beckmann H. ‘Das Elektromobil als Nutzwagen’ Aligemeine Automobil-Zeitung (1914 Nr. 22 ) 23 26
- ‘Electric vehicle efficiency in department store work’ NELA Bulletin 1916 922
- Pender Harold Thomson H.F. The economical transportation of merchandise in metropolitan districts Boston March 1912 Pender Harold Thomson H.F. Notes on the costs of motor trucking Boston Pender Harold Thomson H.F. Observations on horse and motor trucking Boston March 1913
- La Schum ‘The electric truck in modem transportation’ National Electric Light Association 42nd Convention 19 - 22 May 1919 New York 1919 Electric Vehicle Section sessions; papers, reports and discussions 150 162
- La Schum Edward E. The electric motor truck; selection of motor vehicle equipment, its operation and maintenance New York 1924
- La Schum The electric motor truck 223 299
- Lieb John W. Electric vehicles; Report prepared for the Union Internationale des Producteurs et Distributeurs d'Energie Electrique, Paris Meeting July 5th to 10th 1928
- Lieb Electric vehicles; ‘Third session, Commercial National Section, Transportation Committee’ in: National Electric Light Association, Proceedings Volume 82 48th convention, Exposition Auditorium San Francisco, California June 15 to 19 1925 In one volume New York 1925 National Electric Light Association, Proceedings of the war convention 9 - 10 May 1917 New York City Electric Vehicle Section; papers and reports, (Advance reports and papers prepared for presentation at the Fortieth Convention at Atlantic City May 28th June 1st 1917 but received at the annual meeting in New York on May 9th and l0th 1917 for publication in the Annual Proceedings 84 102
- Rabum Robert Alan ‘Motor freight and urban morphogenesis with reference to California and the West’ (unpubl. University of California Berkeley May 1988
- Wagoner P.D. ‘Battery service’ The Central Station August 1916 40 42 ‘Report of the Garage and Rates Committee. 1915’ Reports of Committees, Sixth annual convention of the Electric Vehicle Association Of America October 18 19 1915 Cleveland, Ohio 17 22
- Gilchrist J.F. Marshall AI ‘The electric vehicle and the central station’ National Electric Light Association, 38th convention 7 - 11 June 1915 San Francisco New York General sessions, executive sessions, celebration exercises, public policy sessions; papers, reports and discussions 326 330 McGraw James H. Stimulating electric vehicle progress Electric Vehicle Association of America Fifth annual convention of the Electric Vehicle Association of America Philadelphia, Penna. October 19 20 21 1914 4 ‘Speed maniac new menace to trucks’ The Central Station June 1912 367 368
- Electric vehicles and other alternatives to the internal combustion engine (Joint hearings before the Committee on Commerce and the Subcommittee on Air and Water Pollution of the Committee on Public Works United States Senate, Ninetieth Congress First Session March 14 15 16 17 and April 10 1997 ) Washington 1967
- Brandt William Van C. ‘The national increase in the use of electric trucks’ NELA Proceedings, 46th convention, Hotel Commodore New York City June 4 to 8 1923 Containing the Proceedings of the General and Executive, Public Policy, Customer Ownership, Accounting Section and Commercial Section sessions New York 1923