This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparison of Vehicle Running Loss Evaporative Emissions Using Point Source and Enclosure Measurement Techniques
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 23, 1998 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Two test techniques are currently used for the measurement of evaporative hydrocarbon emissions during the running loss portion of the Enhanced Evaporative Emission Test Sequence: point source and enclosure. The point source technique uses a constant volume sampling (CVS) system to sample and measure running loss emissions at the vehicle's discrete vapor vents. The enclosure technique uses atmospheric sampling within a sealed housing for evaporative determination (SHED) to measure running loss emissions.
A test program was carried out to compare the two measurement techniques and investigate the differences between the measurements. During the test program, point source emissions averaged 0.001 grams/mile (0.0006 grams/km), or 2% of the standard (0.05 grams/mile or 0.031 grams/km), while enclosure emissions averaged 0.021 grams/mile (0.013 grams/km), or 41% of the standard. Running loss enclosure samples were speciated to examine possible causes for the enclosure emissions being higher than the point source emissions. This analysis indicated that the majority of the running loss enclosure hydrocarbon emissions were fuel-based. Exhaust emissions and background hydrocarbon emissions from the vehicle and test equipment also contributed to enclosure emissions. Hot soak and diurnal emissions were speciated for the same vehicles, and though the results were similar, the species present in each test were not present in the same ratios. This indicates that the hydrocarbon emissions measured in evaporative emission tests are weighted by the different mechanisms effective in each test.
- Dave DeWaard - Chrysler Chelsea Proving Grounds, Chrysler Corporation
- Morgan LaPan - Chrysler Chelsea Proving Grounds, Chrysler Corporation
- Ted Jensen - Research Laboratory, Ford Motor Company
- Walter Siegl - Research Laboratory, Ford Motor Company
- Steve Baldus - Vehicle Emission Laboratory, General Motors Powertrain
- Jeff Loo - Vehicle Emission Laboratory, General Motors Powertrain
CitationGuenther, M., DeWaard, D., LaPan, M., Jensen, T. et al., "Comparison of Vehicle Running Loss Evaporative Emissions Using Point Source and Enclosure Measurement Techniques," SAE Technical Paper 980403, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/980403.
SAE 1998 Transactions - Journal of Fuels and Lubricants
Number: V107-4; Published: 1999-09-15
Number: V107-4; Published: 1999-09-15
- Brooks D. J. Baldus S. L. Diegel H. L. Gorse R. A. Sherby R. D. “Running Loss Test Procedure Development” SAE Paper No. 920322 Society of Automotive Engineers 1992
- Environmental Protection Agency “Code of Federal Regulations” July 1 1995
- California Air Resources Board “California Evaporative Emission Standards and Test Procedures for 1978 and Subsequent Model Motor Vehicles” 5 11 95
- Siegl W. O. Richert J. F. O. Jensen T. E. Schuetzle D. Swarin S. J. Loo J. F. Prostak A. Nagy D. Schlenker A. M. “Improved Emissions Speciation Methodology for Phase II of the Auto/Oil Air Quality Improvement Research Program. Hydrocarbons and Oxygenates.,” SAE Paper No. 930142 Society of Automotive Engineers 1993
- Johansen N. G. Ettre L. S. “Retention Index Values of Hydrocarbons on Open Tubular Columns Coated with Methyl Silicone Liquid Phases” Chromatographia 15 625 30 1982
- Johansen N. G. Ettre L. S. Miller R. L. “Quantitative Analysis of Hydrocarbons by Structural Group Type in Gasolines and Distillates, Part I.” J. Chromagraphy 256 393 417 1983
- Johansen N. G. “The Determination of Individual Components and Groups of Components in Gasoline by High Efficiency Open Tubular Column Gas Chromatography (Detailed Hydrocarbon Analysis)” September 4 1993 102 Pine Tree Lane, Boulder, CO 80304
- Schubert A. J. Johansen N. G. “Cooperative Study to Evaluate a Standard Test Method for the Speciation of Gasolines by Capillary Gas Chromatography” SAE Paper No. 930144 Society of Automotive Engineers 1993
- Burns V. R. et. al. “Effects of Gasoline Composition on Evaporative and Running Loss Emissions - Auto/Oil Air Quality Improvement Research Program SAE Paper No. 920323 Society of Automotive Engineers 1992