This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Estimating Vehicle Deformation Energy for Vehicles Struck in the Side
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The reconstruction of accidental impacts to the side structure of one or more accident vehicles often incorporates estimates of the energy absorbed by laterally struck vehicle(s). Such estimates generally involve considerably more issues than does the assessment of frontal or rear impact deformation energy. The sides of vehicles are, compared to the usual striking object, relatively broad, and they contain zones of varying stiffness supported by collapsible box structures. Side stiffnesses can vary widely, depending upon impact geometry. Most side impact crash tests that can readily be used to make estimates of side stiffness have been conducted by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). These tests are almost exclusively conducted against one particular area of the side structure, the damage sustained by test vehicles is generally poorly documented, and reported crush is obtained via procedures which contain measurement discontinuities as the severity of the impacts increase. Published “recommended” crush coefficients generally assume that the CRASH constant stiffness model holds over the complete range of crush depths. The concept of a Force Saturation model is recommended to deal with the more realistic structural behavior seen in practice at larger crush depths.
This paper has two main objectives: (1) to summarize and critique the currently available side impact data base upon which side stiffness models and their associated coefficients have and can be based, and (2) to provide guidelines and insights into the development of reasonable energy estimates by use of improved crush models and crush measurement procedures.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Strother, C., Kent, R., and Warner, C., "Estimating Vehicle Deformation Energy for Vehicles Struck in the Side," SAE Technical Paper 980215, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/980215.Also In
References
- Corner, A. “NHTSA Data Tape Reference Guide. Vol. 1 - Vehicle Crash Tests (V2)” Office of Vehicle Research, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation Automated Sciences Group Inc. August 1985
- Hargens, R. Day T. “Vehicle Crush Stiffness Coefficients for Model Years 19701984 With Damage Profile Supplement” EDC Library Ref. No. 1042 First 1987
- El-Habash, N.A. “Dynamic Testing for Side Crush MRB-TO-CAR Side Impact Test of a 90-Degree Moving Rigid Barrier to a 1980 Chevrolet Citation: Test No. 1 18.5 mph, Test No. 2 46.6 mph” TFIC Report No. 860326, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH-85-C-08123 June 1986
- El-Habash, N.A. “CRASH III MODEL IMPROVEMENTS MRB-To-Car Side Impact Test of A 90-Degree Moving Rigid Barrier To A 1981 Chevrolet Citation Test Speed 35.2 mph” TRC Report No. 861015, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH-85-C-08123 October 1986
- El-Habash, N.A. “DYNAMIC TESTING FOR SIDE CRUSH MRB-To-Car Side Impact Test of A 90-Degree Moving Rigid Barrier To A 1980 Chevrolet Citation Test #1 18.1 mph, Test #2 36.0 mph” TFIC Report No. 860429, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-85-C-08123 June 1986
- El-Habash, N.A. “DYNAMIC TESTING FOR SIDE CRUSH MRB-To-Car Side Impact Test of a 90-Degree Moving Rigid Barrier To A 1980 Ford LTD Test No. 1 20.9 mph, Test No. 2 42.1 mph” TRC Report No. 860506, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-85-C-08123 June 1986
- El-Habash, N.A. “DYNAMIC TESTING FOR SIDE CRUSH MRB-To-Car Side Impact Test of a 90-Degree Moving Rigid Barrier To A 1983 Ford Escort Test No. 1 16.1 mph, Test No. 2 32.2 mph” TRC Report No. 860516, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-85-C-08123 June 1986
- El-Habash, N.A. “DYNAMIC TESTING FOR SIDE CRUSH MRB-To-Car Side Impact Test of a 90-Degree Moving Rigid Barrier To A 1983 Mitsubishi Tredia Test No. 1 16.7 mph, Test No. 2 33.5 mph” VRT Report No. 860523, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-85-C08123 June 1986
- El-Habash, N.A. “Final Report of 270 Degree Contoured Moving Barrier Impact Into a 1983 Honda Prelude 2-Door Coupe in Support of CRASH III Damage Algorithm Reformulation” TRC Report No. 890209, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-89-C-07292 March 1989
- El-Habash, N.A. “Final Report of 270 Degree Contoured Moving Barrier Impact Into a 1985 Chrysler LeBaron 5-Door Hatchback in Support of CRASH III Damage Algorithm Reformulation” TRC Report No. 890302, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-89-C-07292 April 1989
- El-Habash, N.A. “Final Report of 270 Degree Contoured Moving Barrier Impact Into a 1985 Nissan Sentra 2-Door Coupe in Support of CRASH III Damage Algorithm Reformulation” TRC Report No. 890323, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-89-C-07292 April 1989
- El-Habash, N.A. “Final Report of 270 Degree Contoured Moving Barrier Impact Into a 1985 Celebrity 4-Door Sedan in Support of CRASH III Damage Algorithm Reformulation” TRC Report No. 890413, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-89-C-07292 May 1989
- El-Habash, N.A. “Final Report of 270 Degree Contoured Moving Barrier Impact Into a 1983 Ford Tempo 4-Door Sedan in Support of CRASH III Damage Algorithm Reformulation” TRC Report No. 890424, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-89-C-07292 May 1989
- El-Habash, N.A. “Final Report of 270 Degree Contoured Moving Barrier Impact Into a 1984 Audi 5000 4-Door Sedan in Support of CRASH III Damage Algorithm Reformulation” TFIC Report No. 900924, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22 -88-C-07292 October 1990
- Looker, K. “Final Report of a Non-Deformable Crabbed Impactor Into a 1988 Ford Taurus 4-Door Sedan in Support of CRASH3 Damage Algorithm Reformulation” TRC Report No. 941007, D.O.T. Contract No. DTNH22-88-C 07292
- McHenry, R. Jones, I. Lynch, J. “Mathematical Reconstruction of Highway Accidents” U. S. Department of Transportation, NHTSA Washington, D. C. December 1974
- McHenry, R. “Users Manual for the CRASH Computer Program” CALSPAN Report ZQ 5708-V-3 January 1976
- Monk, M. Guenther, D. “Update of CRASH2 Computer Model Damage Tables, Vol. I” Vehicle Research and Test Center, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration P.0 Box 37 East Liberty, OH 43311 U. S. Department of Transportation March 1983
- Nash, C. Letter to Dr. Charles Y. Warner April 21 1986
- Neptune Engineering “Crush Stiffness Coefficients for Vehicle Model Years 1960 1994” 1994
- NHTSA Notice of Proposed Rulemaking to Revise Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 214: Side Impact Protection Federal Register 53 17 January 1988
- Prasad, A. “Energy Absorbed by Vehicle Structures in Side-Impacts” SAE 910599 February 1991
- Scott, L. Fell J. “An Historical Review of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's Field Accident Investigation Activities” National Center for Statistics and Analysis Washington, D.C. August 1988
- Smith, G. “Conservation of Momentum Analysis of Two-Dimensional Colliding Bodies, With or Without Trailers” SAE paper # 940566 1985
- Strother, C. Woolley R. James M. Warner C. “Crush Energy in Accident Reconstruction” SAE 860371 February 1986
- Strother, C. Warner C. Woolley R. James M. Egbert T. “Aspects of the Assessment of Societal Benefits Associated with Side Impact Countermeasures” February 1989
- Strother, C. Woolley R. James M. “A Comparison Between NHTSA Crash Test Data and CRASH3 Frontal Stiffness Coefficients” SAE 900101 February 1990
- Warner, C. Allsop D. Germane G. “A Repeated-Crash Test Technique for Assessment of Structural Impact Behavior” SAE Paper 860208 February 1986
- Wilke, D. Monk M. “CRASH3 Model Improvements: Derivation of New Side Stiffness Parameters for Crash Tests, Volume 2.” June 1987
- Woolley, R. Warner C. Tagg M. “Inaccuracies in the CRASH3 Program” SAE 850255 February 1985
- Woolley, R. ‘The “IMPAC” Computer Program for Accident Reconstruction,” SAE paper # 850254 February 1985
- Woolley, R. Strother C. James M. “Rear Stiffness Coefficients Derived from Barrier Test Data” SAE 910120 February 1991