This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Usability Trials of Alternative Child Restraint Attachment Systems
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published November 12, 1997 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper describes usability trials conducted to determine the ease of use and incidence of misuse of four alternative child restraint/vehicle attachment systems compared to the current system attached via the vehicle seat belt and a top tether. The accuracy of use of each of the alternative systems was significantly higher than the conventional system, and the 76 participants reported they were much easier to use. Systems which utilise the ISOFIX pins were used without difficulty by participants who had no prior experience with this concept. The systems which depend on the users to tighten side straps on the child restraints were improperly installed more frequently than the ISOFIX pin systems.
|Technical Paper||Child Restraint Tether Straps - A Simple Method of Increasing Safety for Children|
|Technical Paper||Development of Testing and Evaluation of Child Restraint Systems and Child Test Dummies by NHTSA|
CitationPedder, J., Gane, J., Pasco, D., Deibert, M. et al., "Usability Trials of Alternative Child Restraint Attachment Systems," SAE Technical Paper 973301, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/973301.
- Weber, K. Child Passenger Protection In Accident Injury - Biomechanics and Prevention Nahum A. M. Melvin J. W. Springer-Verlag New York, Inc. 1993
- Henderson, M. Children in Car Crashes: An in-depth study of car crashes in which child occupants were injured Report prepared for the Motor Accidents Authority Sydney, Australia 1994
- Wilson, R. J. Grant, B. Hurley, J. 1992 Observational and Telephone Survey of Restraint Use by Children in Motor Vehicles The Road Safety and Motor Vehicle Regulation Directorate of Transport Canada 1994
- Rattenbury, S.J. Gloyns, P.F. A Population Study of UK Car Accidents in Which Restrained Children Were Killed, Child Occupant Protection SAE Publication SP-986 1993
- Blue Ribbon Panel on Child Restraint & Vehicle Compatibility - Recommendations May 30 1995
- Brown, J. Kelly, P. Griffiths, M. The Performance of Tethered and Untethered Forward Facing Child Restraints International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Impact Brunnen, Switzerland 1995
- Turbell, T. Lowne, R. Lundell, B. Tingvall, C. ISOFIX - A New Concept of Installing Child Restraints in Cars SAE Paper 933085 SAE Publication SP-986 1993
- Motor Vehicle Branch 1995 Traffic Collisions British Columbia, Canada
- Pedder, J. Brown, B. Pasco, D. Review of Child Injury Claim Files at Selected Claim Centres and Incidence of Child Passengers Injured in Motor Vehicle Crashes in B.C. Work in progress for Public Affairs and Road Safety Insurance Corporation of British Columbia Victoria, B.C., Canada 1997
- Pedder, J. Legault, F. Salcudean, G. Hillebrandt, D. Gardner, W. Labreque, M. Development of the CanFIX Infant and Child Restraint/Vehicle Interface System 38th Stapp Car Crash Conference Ft. Lauderdale 1994
- ISO/22/12/WG1 N390 ISO/WD 13216-1 Road vehicles - Child restraint systems - Standardised universal attachment to vehicle (ISOFIX) - Part 1: Dimensions and general requirements February 1996
- Noy, Y.I. Arnold, A-K. Installing Child Restraint Systems in Vehicles. Towards Usability Criteria Transport Canada, Road Safety, Ergonomics Division 1995
- Martin, A. Personal communication 1996
- Bell, R. Misuse Test Panels - A Technique for the Identification and Prevention of Misuse of Child Restraints Proceedings of the Thirty-fifth Conference of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine Toronto, Canada 1991
- NHTSA Public Meeting on Child Restraint Attachment Systems Washington D.C. 17-18 October 1996