This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Use of FCRASH in a Door Openability Simulation
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 08, 1997 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
During frontal and rear end type collisions, very large forces will be imparted to the passenger compartment by the collapse of either front or rear structures. NCAP tests conducted by NHTSA involve, among other things, a door openability test after barrier impact. This means that the plastic/irreversible deformations of door openings should be kept to a minimum. Thus, the structural members constituting the door opening must operate during frontal and rear impact near the elastic limit of the material. Increasing the size of a structural member, provided the packaging considerations permit it, may prove to be counter productive, since it may lead to premature local buckling and possible collapse of the member. With the current trend towards lighter vehicles, recourse to heavier gages is also counterproductive and therefore a determination of an optimum compartment structure may require a number of design iterations.
In this article, FEA is used to simulate front side door behavior. Ford guidelines require the side doors, hatches and lift gates to be designed to remain closed during 35 mph perpendicular front (fixed) barrier crash tests. These guidelines also require the side doors to be designed to be capable of being opened without tools after the impact. While earlier analytical techniques  to handle door openability were based on door aperture deformation computations, this work describes a technique that is based on more realistic approach which directly simulates the process of door openability itself, using a finite element simulation. Therefore, it enables the simulation of an actual door behavior during and after perpendicular fixed barrier impacts.
CitationRiesner, M. and Hassan, J., "Use of FCRASH in a Door Openability Simulation," SAE Technical Paper 971526, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/971526.
- FCRASH V2.8 users manual Ford Motor Company 1996
- SAE 830977 “An analysis of the vehicle occupant impact dynamics and its application” Matthew Huang 1983
- Belytschko, Ted “On Computational Methods for Crashworthiness,” Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Vehicle StructuralMechanics SAE Detroit 1988 93 102
- Cofie, E. Ray, M. “Simplified finite element vehicle model,” Transportation Research Board Publications, Circular on Computer Simulation April 1994
- Varadappa, S. Shyo, S. C. Mani, A. “Development of Passenger Vehicle Finite Element Model,” Final Report DOT HS 808 145 Department of-Transportation Washington, DC November 1993
- Perfect, S. Logan, R. “Evaluation of the Honda Civic Based FE Model,” Transportation Research Board Publications, Circular on Computer Simulation April 1994
- Eskandarian, A. Bedewi, N.E. Meczkowski, L. “FHWA/NHTSA National Crash Analysis Center,” Public Roads, A Journal of Highway research and Development 1993
- Eskandarian, A. Bedewi, N.E. Meczkowski, L. “Finite Element Modeling of 4 Lb/Ft. U-Channel Post Sign Support Systems,” Research and Technology Transporter, a DOT, FHWA Quarterly Accomplishment Report
- Bedewi, N.E. Omar, T. Eskandarian, A. “Effect of Mesh Density Variation in Vehicle Crashworthiness Finite Element Modeling,” Proceedings of the ASME Winter Annual Meeting, Transportation Systems Session November 6-11 1994 Chicago, III
- Kan, C. D. Yang, C. “Impact of the Ford Taurus Based FE Model into a Rigid Pole,” FHWA/ NHTSA National Crash Analysis Internal Report August 1994
- Bedewi, N.E. Kan, C.D. Summers, S. Ragland, C. “Evaluation of Car-to-Car Frontal Offset Impact Finite Element Models Using Full Scale Crash Data,” Issues in Automotive safety Technology 212 219 February 1995
- Miller, L. Bedewi, N. Chu, R. “Performance Benchmarking of LS-DYNA3D for Vehicle Impact Simulation on the Silicon Graphics POWER CHALLENGE” High Performance Computing Asia 95 Taiwan October 1995
- Schinke, H. Zaouk, A. Kan, C.D. “Vehicle Finite Element Development of A Chevy C-1500 Truck with Varying Application,” FHWA/NHTSA National Crash Analysis Internal Report May 1995
- Hallquist, J.O. Stillman, D.W. Lin, T.L. LS-DYNA3D Theoretical Manual Livermore Software Technology Corporation LSTC Report 1007 1992