This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Validation of Newtonian Reconstruction (CRASHEX) Against Simulations of RICSAC Staged Collisions
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 24, 1997 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The accuracy of the CRASHEX version of CRASH, which uses a Newtonian rather than a Cartesian treatment of impact, is compared with that of a substantially “original” version of CRASH, both evaluated with respect to EDSMAC computer simulations of the RICSAC series of staged, partially braked collisions; and with similar data for EDCRASH, as published but recomputed.
Special problems inherent in treatment of impact with a stopped vehicle, quasi-head-on impact, failure to separate after initial impact, and spin truncated by side slap are discussed.
Appropriate use of the statistical confidence interval in single-event reconstruction is also discussed, as are anomalies in previously published standard deviations for EDCRASH applied to the RICSAC data.
The study shows that the Cartesian simplification incurs dominantly large errors, a finding not generally recognized. For complete and accurate reconstruction, Newtonian treatment, as now provided in CRASHEX, is requisite.
CitationFonda, A., "Validation of Newtonian Reconstruction (CRASHEX) Against Simulations of RICSAC Staged Collisions," SAE Technical Paper 971108, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/971108.
- Campbell, K L “Energy Basis for Collision Severity,” SAE 740565 July 1974
- “CRASH2 User's Manual,” Calspan Corporation DOT HS 802-106 Nov 1976
- “CRASH3 User's Guide and Technical Manual,” DOT HS 805-372 Feb 1981 Apr 1982
- Day, T D Hargens, R L “Further Validation of EDCRASH Using the RICSAC Staged Collisions,” SAE 890740 (in SP-777) Feb 1989
- Day, T D Hargens, R L “Further Validation of EDSMAC Using the RICSAC Staged Collisions,” SAE 900102 (in SP-814) Feb 1990
- Day, T D Siddall, D E “Validation of Several Reconstruction and Simulation Models in the HVE Scientific Visualization Environment,” SAE 960891 Feb 1996
- “Dictionary of Scientific Biography.” IV Charles Scribners Sons 1971
- Fonda, A.G. “CRASH Extended for Desk and Handheld Computers,” SAE 870044 Feb. 1987
- Fonda, A G Metz, D L “Post-Impact Spin,” SAE 930653 (in SP-946) Feb 1993
- Fonda, A G “Nonconservation of Momentum During Impact,” SAE 950355 Feb 1995
- Fonda, A G “Energy and Major Diversion in Accident Reconstruction,” SAE 960888 Feb 1996
- Fonda, A G “Momentum Loss Determination and Advanced Trajectory (and Damage) Analysis for Accident Reconstruction on a PC,” International Symposium on Automotive Technology and Automation Florence, Italy June 1996
- Jones, I S “Results of Selected Applications to Actual Highway Accidents of SMAC Reconstruction Program,” SAE 741179 (18th Stapp) Dec 1974
- Marquard, E. “Progress in the Calculations of Vehicle Collisions,” ATZ 68 3 1966
- McHenry, R R “Computer Program for Reconstruction of Highway Accidents,” SAE 730980 Nov 1973
- McHenry, R R “A Comparison of Results Obtained with Different Analytical Techniques for Reconstruction of Highway Accidents,” SAE 750983 Oct 1975
- McHenry, R R et al “Research Input for Computer Simulation of Automobile Collisions,” I-IV Calspan Corporation DOT HS-805 037 through 040 Dec 1978
- Woolley, R L Kinney, J R “Reference Cases for Comparison of Collision Algorithms Used in Accident Reconstruction,” SAE 940567 Feb 1994