This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Method to Assess the Effectiveness of Child Restraint Systems
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 24, 1997 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The performance of child restraint systems (CRS) in precise and constant laboratory testing and their effectiveness in real-life-accidents may differ substantially, mainly due to the variety of interface conditions between motor vehicles and CRS and to misuse of the CRS by the consumer. These differences may grossly impair the safety performance of CRS in a traffic crash.
Most accident reports available to crash researchers lack detailed data on crash severity that can be related to injury severity. However, reports usually include full information on injuries of all occupants. The paper proposes a comparison of the injury rate of restrained children and belted adult occupants, the latter “substituting” the unknown data on crash seventy. Given a sufficient number of accident reports, the effectiveness of CRS under real-life-conditions can be assessed, providing a very useful tool, particularly for CRS manufacturers.
|Technical Paper||An Energy Based Analysis for Neck Forces in Frontal Impacts|
|Technical Paper||Injury Patterns Associated with Child Restraint Misuse|
|Technical Paper||Quantification of Side Impact Responses and Injuries|
CitationCzernakowski, W. and Bell, R., "A Method to Assess the Effectiveness of Child Restraint Systems," SAE Technical Paper 970499, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/970499.
- Kahane Charles J. Kossar Jerome Chi George Y. “Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Child Safety Seats in Actual Use” Child Injury and Restraint Conference SAE 135 San Diego 1983
- Klinich Kathleen DeSantis Burton Ronald W. “Injury Pattern of Older Children in Automotive Accidents” Child Occupant Protection, SAE SP986 San Antonio 1993
- Partyka Susan C. “Lives Saved by Child Safety Seats from 1982 through 1987” ESV Report Number 89-1A-0-002
- Mackay Murray Breen Jeanne “Road Accidents in Childhood” Institution of Civil Engineers London 1987
- Petrucelli Elaine “The USA's Experience with Child Passenger Safety” VOLVO/TNO Workshop Netherlands 1986
- Weber Kathleen Melvin John “Injury Potential with Misused Child Restraining Systems” SAE 831604 , SAE Child Injury and Restraint Conference Proceedings San Diego 1983
- Shelness, A. Jewett, J. “Observed Misuse of Child Restraints” SAE 831665 , SAE Child Injury and Restraint Conference Proceedings San Diego 1983
- Zeidler Falk 1982
- Huelke Donald F. Compton Charles P. “Rear Seat Occupants in Frontal Crashes - Adults and Children - the Effects of Restraint Systems” 1995 Proceedings of IRCOBI Brunnen
- Evans Leonard “Occupant Protection Device Effectiveness in Preventing Fatalities” 11th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles Washington 1987
- Huelke Donald F Compton Charles P. “The Effects of Seat Belts on Injury Severity of Front and Rear Seat Occupants in the same Frontal Crash” 38th Annual Proceedings AAAM Lyon 1994
- Chipman Mary L. Hu Xiaohan “The Effectiveness of Safety Belts in Preventing Fatalities and Major Injuries Among School-Aged Children” 39th AAAM Proceedings Chicago 1995
- Miller Ted R. Demes Joan Catherine Bovbjerg Randall R. “Child Seats: How large are the Benefits and Who Should Pay?” VOLVO/TNO Workshop Netherlands 1986
- Abbreviated Injury Scale Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine Des Plaines, Illinois
- “Road Vehicles - Child Restraint Systems - Report form for accidents with children in vehicle”
- Czernakowski Waldemar Mueller Manfred “Misuse Mode and Effects Analysis An Approach to Predict and Quantify Misuse of Child Restraint Systems” 35th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine Toronto 1991
- Czernakowski Waldemar “The Effects of PreImpact Braking on Dynamic Performance of Child Restraint Systems in Frontal Impacts” International IRCOBI Conference Berlin 1991