This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Comparison of Engine Coolant in an Accelerated Heavy Duty Engine Cavitation Test
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1996 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Propylene glycol (PG) is gaining in popularity as an engine coolant in market areas concerned about the toxicity of ethylene glycol (EG). With the possibility of PG coolants being used in heavy duty diesel engines, the requirement to control cylinder liner cavitation must be maintained. The purpose of this test program was to compare the ability of propylene glycol and ethylene glycol based heavy duty engine coolants to suppress cavitation of wet-cylinder liners in heavy duty diesel engines.
The first task was to develop an engine test that would duplicate liner cavitation in a short time. This was accomplished with a 250 hour accelerated cycle test of a modified Deere six cylinder, 10.1 liter engine. The next step was to establish a baseline with both PG and EG using a modified GM 6038 engine coolant mixed 50 percent by volume with American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) standard corrosive water. This was followed by tests using coolants with the same formulation containing a full charge of a generic supplemental coolant additive (SCA). Five runs were made in this test program.
This study demonstrated that PG and EG based coolants are essentially equivalent in their ability to suppress cylinder liner cavitation in diesel engines; and, the addition of a suitable heavy duty engine SCA to both types of coolant is equally effective in reducing cavitation sensitivity. This test program also demonstrated a poor correlation between the proposed ASTM Ultrasonic Bench Test and engine tests.
|Technical Paper||Cavitation Damage of Diesel Engine Wet-Cylinder Liners|
|Technical Paper||Cavitation Erosion on Cylinder Liners|
|Technical Paper||Cavitation Intensity Measurements for Internal Combustion Engines|
CitationDavis, G. and Christ, R., "A Comparison of Engine Coolant in an Accelerated Heavy Duty Engine Cavitation Test," SAE Technical Paper 960883, 1996, https://doi.org/10.4271/960883.
- Hudgens, R.D. Bustammate, “Toxicity and Disposal for Engine Coolants” ASTM STP 1192, Engine Coolant Testing Third Beal Roy E. Philadelphia 1993 149 164
- Hercamp, R.D. Hudgens, R.D. Coughenour, G.E. “Aqueous Propylene Glycol Coolant for Heavy Duty Engines” SAE SP 811, Worldwide Trends in Engine Coolants, Cooling System Materials and Testing Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1990 47 77
- Kilmartin, W.J. Dehm, D.C. “Aqueous Propylene Glycol Engine Coolant for Automotive and Light Duty Applications” SAE SP 960, Engine Coolants, Cooling System materials, and Components, Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1993 121 124
- Hercamp, Richard D. “An Overview of Cavitation Corrosion of Diesel Cylinder Liners” ASTM STP 1192, Engine Coolant Testing Third American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia 1993 107 127
- Hudgens, R.D. Carver, D.P. Hercamp, R.D. Lauterback “Refinement of the Vibratory Cavitation Erosion Test for the Screening of Diesel Cooling System Corrosion Inhibitors” ASTM STP 705, Engine Coolant Testing, State of the Art American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia 1980 233 269
- John Deere Engine Engineering Internal performance records, comparisons of alternate coolant products by engine dynamometer testing
- Minutes of committee activities, ASTM D15 Committee on Engine Coolants (methods under development not available for general distribution, until adopted by ASTM action)
- Hudgens, R.D. Hercamp, R.D. “Test Methods for the Development of Supplemental Additives for Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine Coolants” ASTM STP 887, Engine Coolant Testing, Second Symposium Beal Roy E. Philadelphia 1984 189 215
- Thou, Yu-Kang Hammitt, F.G. “Cavitation Damage of Diesel Engine Wet-Cylinder Liners” SAE SP-811 Worldwide Trends in Engine Coolants, Cooling Systems Materials and Testing Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1990 119 133
- Miegand, H. Schulmeister, R. Weiser, H. “On the Cavitation Resistance of Gray Cast Iron for Cylinder Liners” MTZ 30 1969 8 Motor Technische Zeitschrift 271 281
- Okada, T. Iwai, Y. Yamamoto, A. “A Study of Cavitation Erosion of Cast Iron” Wear 84 1983 Elsevier Sequoia The Netherlands 297 312
- Hercamp, R.D. Hudgens, R.D. “Cavitation Corrosion Bench Test for Engine Coolants” SAE Paper 881269 SAE International Off-Highway & Powerplant Congress Milwaukee, WI September 1988 17
- Oaks, B.D. “Cavitation Corrosion” ASTM STP 705, Engine Coolant Testing, State of the Art American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia 1980 284 294
- Schulmeister, Robert “Vibratory Tests in Water on the Combined Action of Cavitation (Erosion) and Corrosion” ASTM STP 474, Characterization and Determination of Erosion Resistance American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia 1970 113
- Liebold, G.A. Starke, K.W. “European Test Methods for Automotive Coolants: Experience Gained on Recent Cavitation and Corrosion Tests” ASTM STP 887, Engine Coolant Testing, Second Symposium American Society for Testing and Materials Beal Roy E. Philadelphia 1984 176 188
- Mark, F.E. Jetten, W. “Propylene Glycol, A New Base Fluid for Automotive Coolants” ASTM STP 887, Engine Coolant Testing, Second Symposium Beal Roy E. Philadelphia 1984 61 77
- Standard Test Method for Foaming Tendencies of Engine Coolants in Glassware” 1995 Annual Book of ASTM Standards 15.05 Philadelphia 1995 36 38
- Hudgens, R.D. “Phosphate - Molybdate Supplement Coolant Additives for Heavy Duty Diesel Engines” ASTM STP 1192, Engine Coolant Testing, Second Symposium Third Beal Roy E. Philadelphia 1993 128 148
- Borgman, E.H. Mitigating Cavitation - Erosion of Engine Cylinder Liners” The Diesel & Gas Engine Power Conference Washington D.C. April 1973 The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, United Engineering Center N.Y., NY. 9