This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Driver Perceptual Adaptation to Nonplanar Rearview Mirrors
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This study examined perceptual adaptation to nonplanar (spherical convex and aspheric) rearview mirrors. Subjects made magnitude estimates of the distance to a car seen in a rearview mirror. Three different mirrors were used: plane, aspheric (with a large spherical section having a radius of 1400 mm), and simple convex (with a radius of 1000 mm).
Previous research relevant to perceptual adaptation to nonplanar mirrors was reviewed. It was argued that, in spite of some cases of explicit interest in the process of learning to use nonplanar mirrors, previous research has not adequately addressed the possibility of perceptual adaptation.
The present experiment involved three phases: (1) a pretest phase in which subjects made distance judgments but received no feedback, (2) a training phase in which they made judgments and did receive feedback, and (3) a posttest phase with the same procedure as the pretest phase.
Initially subjects showed substantial overestimation of distance with the convex mirror relative to the aspheric mirror, and with the aspheric mirror relative to the plane mirror. At the beginning of the training phase, overestimation with the convex mirror quickly diminished, but after about one hour of experience the convex and aspheric mirrors still showed significant overestimation relative to the plane mirror.
The present results demonstrate the existence of a rapid, but incomplete, form of adaptation. Whether there is a further mechanism that might operate over a longer time, but lead to more complete adaptation, is an open question that should be addressed by further research. Future research should also address the question of what forms of experience or training are most conducive to adaptation. If substantial adaptation is indeed possible, the use of nonplanar rearview mirrors would be strongly encouraged.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Flannagan, M., Sivak, M., and Traube, E., "Driver Perceptual Adaptation to Nonplanar Rearview Mirrors," SAE Technical Paper 960791, 1996, https://doi.org/10.4271/960791.Also In
Automotive Design Advancements in Human Factors: Improving Drivers Comfort and Performance
Number: SP-1155; Published: 1996-02-01
Number: SP-1155; Published: 1996-02-01
References
- Burger, W. J. Mulholland, M. U. Smith, R. L. Sharkey, T. J. 1980 Passenger vehicle, light truck and van convex mirror optimization and evaluation studies: Vol. 1: Convex mirror optimization (DOT HS 805 695) Washington, D.C. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Burger, W. J. Ziedman, D. 1987 Development and implementation of a rear vision device test protocol: Volume I: Physical characteristics measurement (DOT HS 807 233) Washington, D.C. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Burger, W. J. Ziedman, D. 1987 Development and implementation of a rear vision device test protocol: Volume II, Simulated-use testing (DOT HS 807 232) Washington, D.C. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Flannagan, M. J. 1988 Human performance aspects of rearview mirrors: An applied-literature review (Report No. UMTRI-88-20) Ann Arbor, Michigan The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute
- Flannagan, M. J. Sivak, M. 1993 Indirect vision systems Peacock B. Karwowski W. Automotive ergonomics 205 217 London Taylor & Francis
- Marks, L. E. 1974 Sensory processes: The new psychophysics New York Academic Press
- Mourant, R. R. Donohue, R. J. 1979 Driver performance with right-side convex mirrors Transportation Research Record 95 104
- Platzer, G. E. 1995 The geometry of automotive rearview mirrors: Why blind zones exist and strategies to overcome them SAE Technical Paper Series No. 950601 Warrendale, Pennsylvania Society of Automotive Engineers
- Rock, I. 1966 The nature of perceptual adaptation New York Basic Books
- Seeser, J. 1974 Automotive convex mirrors: Optical properties (Technical Report 201) Holland, Michigan Donnelly Mirrors
- Smith, R. L. Bardales, M. C. Burger, W. J. 1978 Perceived importance of zones surrounding a vehicle and learning to use a convex mirror effectively (DOT HS 803 713) Washington, D.C. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration