This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Evaluation of Pedal Cycle Helmet Performance Requirements
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The paper describes an evaluation of impact performance requirements for pedal cycle helmets. The paper examines the results of two related studies, evaluates other helmet test results and proposes performance criteria more effective for the amelioration of head injury. The two main studies are of pedal cycle helmet performance in real accidents (McIntosh and Dowdell IRCOBI 1992) and head impact tests conducted under conditions relevant to those occurring during pedal cycle accidents (McIntosh et al Stapp 1993). The results of other helmet evaluations are drawn upon. The paper examines a number of areas of helmet performance and focuses on head coverage and impact test criteria.
The results of the studies demonstrate that pedal cycle helmets are failing to provide adequate coverage in the temporal region, and that standards tests are not sensitive to this problem. The Test Line could be measured directly from the Frankfort Plane delineating a region below which head impacts are unlikely or do not pose a serious risk of brain injury. The helmet should cover the head almost to the Frankfort Plane laterally and posteriorly.
Although drop heights of 1 500 mm result in a suitable impact test velocity, the permissible acceleration levels are too high. Statistical analysis of head impact data showed that maximum acceleration was a suitable test criterion for helmet performance. but that pass/fail criteria should be reduced, i.e. maximum centre of gravity head acceleration < 200 g. Levels of acceleration of 300 to 400 g, currently allowed by helmet standards are too high.
Recommended Content
| Technical Paper | Facial Impact Tolerance and Response |
| Technical Paper | The Influence of Arm Position on Thoracic Response in Side Impacts |
Authors
Topic
Citation
McIntosh, A., Kallieris, D., Mattern, R., Svensson, N. et al., "An Evaluation of Pedal Cycle Helmet Performance Requirements," SAE Technical Paper 952713, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/952713.Also In
References
- ANSI Z90.4, American National Standard for Protective Headgear - for Bicyclists American National Standards Institute 1984
- AS 2063.1 & .2, Australian Standard ‘Lightweight Protective Helmets (for use in Pedal Cycling, Horse Riding & other activities requiring similar protection)’. Part 1- Basic Performance Requirements (AS 2063.1), 1986 & Part 2 - Helmets for Pedal Cyclists (AS 2063.2) 1990 Australian Standards Association
- AS 2512.3.1 Australian Standard ‘Determination of Impact Energy - Helmet Drop Test 1981 Australian Standards Association
- Benz, G. McIntosh, A. Kallieris, D. Daum, R. ‘A Biomechanical Study of Bicycle Helmets’ Effectiveness in Childhood' Eur. J Pediatr Surg 3 1993 259 263
- Cameron, M. H. Vulcan, A.P. Finch, C. F. Newstead, S.V. ‘Mandatory Bicycle Helmet Use Following a Decade of Helmet Promotion in Victoria, Australia -- an Evaluation,’ Accident Analysis and Prevention 26 3 1994 325 337
- Hurt, H. Thom, D. ‘Laboratory Tests and Accident Performance of Bicycle Safety Helmets’ 29th. Annual Proceedings of the AAAM 1985
- Janssen, E. Wismans, J. ‘Experimental and Mathematical Simulation of Pedestrian-Vehicle and Cyclist-Vehicle Accidents’ Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1988 977 988
- Maimaris, C. Summers, C.L. Browning, C. Palmer, C.R. ‘Injury Patterns inCyclists Attending and Accident and Emergency Department: A Comparison of helmet Wearers and Non-wearers’ British Medical Journal 308 6943 1994 1537 1540
- McDermott, F.T. Lane, J.C. Brazenor, G. A. Debney, E.A. ‘The Effectiveness of Bicyclists Helmets: A Study of 1710 Casualties,’ Journal of Trauma 34 6 1993 834 844
- McIntosh, A.S. Dowdell, B. ‘A Field and laboratory Study of the Performance of Pedal Cycle Helmets in Real Accidents’ Proceedings of the 1992 International Conference on the Biomechanics of Impact 1992 51 60
- McIntosh. A.S. Kallieris, D. Mattern, R. Miltner, E. ‘Head and Neck Injury Resulting from Low Velocity Direct Impact’ Proceedings of the 37th. Stapp Car Crash Conference 1993 43 58
- Smith. T. Tees, D. Thom, D. Hurt, H. ‘Evaluation and Replication of Impact Damage to Bicycle Helmets’ 37th Proceedings of the AAAM 1993
- Snell 1990 Standard for Protective Headgear - for use in Bicycling St. James New York Snell Memorial Foundation 1990
- Vulcan, A.P. Cameron, M.H. Watson, W.L. ‘Mandatory Bicycle Helmet Use: Experience in Victoria, Australia’ World Journal of Surgery 16 3 1992 389 97
- Walz, F. Dubas, L. Burkart, F. Kosik, D. ‘Head Injuries in Moped and Bicycle Collisions: Implications for Bicycle Hemet Design’ Proceedings of the IRCOBI Conference 1985 91 103
- Williams, M. ‘The Protective Performance of Bicyclists Helmets in Accidents’ Technisearch Ltd. Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology 1989
- Worrell. J. ‘Head Injuries in Pedal Cyclists: How Much Will Protection Help’ Injury 18 1987 5 6