This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Exhaust Emission and Energy Consumption Effects from Hydrogen Supplementation of Natural Gas
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 01, 1995 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
An experiment was conducted to evaluate the efficiency and emissions of an engine fuelled with a mixture of natural gas and approximately 15% hydrogen by volume. This mixture, called Hythane™, was compared with natural gas fuel using engine efficiency and engine-out emissions at various engine operating conditions as the basis of comparison. Throughout most of the experiment, fuel mixtures were slightly rich of stoichiometry. It was found that at low engine loads, using the same spark timing, engine efficiency increased under HythaneTM fuelling but at higher engine loads, natural gas and Hythane™ had the same efficiency. At low engine speed and load conditions with the same spark timing, engine-out total hydrocarbon (THC) emissions were lower for Hythane™ fuelling. When compared on a carbon specific basis, however, natural gas hydrocarbon emissions were lower. At some test conditions, engine-out carbon monoxide (CO) emissions were lower under Hythane™. Engine-out oxides of nitrogen (NOx) were higher under Hythane™ fuelling for all test conditions when compared with natural gas at the same spark timing.
Advancing spark timing (ST) from 20 °BTDC to 28 °BTDC increases engine efficiency slightly for both fuels. Engine-out NOx, increased with advanced spark timing at a greater rate under Hythane™ fuelling. An increase in THC emissions also occurred as spark timing was advanced with a similiar rate of increase for both fuels. Finally, CO emissions were almost completely independent of changes in spark timing.
Fuel-air equivalence ratio (ϕ) was varied between 1.00 and 1.03. Maximum engine efficiency occurred at f values between 1.01 and 1.02 for both fuels. THC and CO emissions increased with richer mixtures while NOx emissions decreased. The rate of change of THC and NOx emissions with changing was greater under Hythane™ fuelling. CO dependence on was similiar for both fuels.
Hydrocarbon speciation resulted in an exhaust gas hydrocarbon breakdown of 92% methane, 3% ethane, 3% ethene, 1.5% acetylene and trace quantities of other species. This result was consistent regardless of fuel type, engine speed or engine load.
CitationCattelan, A. and Wallace, J., "Exhaust Emission and Energy Consumption Effects from Hydrogen Supplementation of Natural Gas," SAE Technical Paper 952497, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/952497.
- Lynch F., Foute S., Knowlton T., Ragazzi R. and Raman V., “The Denver Hythane Project - Recent Progress”, Presented at the Tenth Anniversary Conference, Industry and Hydrogen, Kananaskis, Alberta, 1992.
- Ryan T.W. and Lestz S.S., “The Laminar Burning Velocity of lsooctane, N-Heptane, Methanol, Methane and Propane at Elevated Temperature and Pressures in the Presence of a Dilutent”, SAE Paper No. 800103.
- Eccleston D.B. and Fleming R.D., “Clean Automotive Fuel”, U.S. Bureau of Mines Automotive Exhaust Emissions Program, Technical Progress Report 48, 1972.
- Swain M.R., Yusuf M.J., Dülger Z. and Swain M.N., “The Effects of Hydrogen Addition on Natural Gas Engine Operation”, SAE Paper No. 932775, 1993.
- Wallace J.S., Cattelan A. and Larsen J., “The Use of a Surface-Response Experiment to Optimize Engine Operating Parameters”, Continuous Improvement Symposium 7, General Motors of Canada Ltd, Dec. 1-2, 1993, Oshawa, Ontario.
- Poulsen J.H. and Wallace J.S., “Operating Parameter Effects on the Speciated Hydrocarbon Emissions from a Natural Gas Fueled Engine”, SAE Paper No. 942007, 1994.
- Milton B.E. and Keck J.C., “Laminar Burning Velocities in Stoichiometric Hydrogen and Hydrogen-Hydrocarbon Gas Mixtures”, Combustion and Flame, 58, 13-22, 1984.
- Kuroda H., Nakajima Y., Sighara K., Takagi Y. and Muranka S., “The Fast Burn with Heavy EGR, New Approach for Low NOx and Improved Fuel Economy”, SAE Paper 780006, 1978.
- Robinson J.A., “Humidity Effects on Engine Nitric Oxide Emissions at Steady State Conditions”, SAE Paper No. 700467.
- Weaver Christopher, “Natural Gas Vehicle - A Review of the State of the Art”, SAE Paper 892133, 1989.
- Jääskeläinen H.E. and Wallace J.S.. “Performance and Emissions of a Natural Gas-Fuelled 16 Valve DOHC Four-Cylinder Engine”, University of Toronto, SAE Paper 930380, 1993.
- Thompson N.D. and Wallace J.S., “Effect on Engine Operating Variables and Piston and Ring Parameters on Crevice Hydrocarbon Emissions”, SAE Paper No. 940480, 1994.
- Reynolds W.C. and Perkins H.C., Engineering Thermodynamics, Edition Second, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1977.