This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Experimental Study of Combustion Chamber Deposits and Their Effects in a Spark-Ignition Engine
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1995 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A 1.8 litre four-cylinder engine with a slice between the head and the block carrying instrumented plugs has been used to study the growth of combustion chamber deposits and some of their effects on engine operation. Different techniques for measuring deposit thickness, knock onset and deposit effects on the thermal characteristics of the cylinder have been developed. Deposit growth as measured by deposit weight on the plugs is reasonably repeatable from run to run and cylinder to cylinder. The presence of deposits already in the cylinder does not affect deposit growth on clean plugs introduced into the combustion chamber. Deposit thickness and morphology vary substantially at different locations, the thickness being greatest at the coolest surfaces. Deposits increase the flame speed and reduce the metal temperatures just below the surface. They also reduce the mean heat flux away from the cylinder. There is a good correlation between this mean heat flux and knock-limited spark advance. Deposits in the cylinder head also led to significant reductions in fuel consumption at the operating condition used for deposit build-up. In contrast piston-top deposits have little effect on fuel consumption and on octane requirement increase.
DEPOSITS, derived primarily from the fuel but with some contribution from the oil are formed inside the combustion chamber of a spark ignition engine with use. The literature on the deposits that form on all the internal surfaces of a spark ignition engine, including those in the combustion chamber, was reviewed in (1); an earlier source of useful information is (2). Combustion chamber deposits (CCD) have been reported to cause an increase in octane requirement and, to some extent, an increase in emissions, a reduction in volumetric efficiency and power and an improvement in fuel economy - a beneficial effect (1-11). More recently, new field problems like carbon rap (e.g.3,12) attributed to CCD have been recognised. Moreover, fuel and additives technology to ensure satisfactory control of deposits in other parts of the engine viz carburetters, port fuel injectors and inlet valves has matured and is being increasingly mandated. There has been growing concern that some of this additives technology might cause an increase in CCD. The spurt in interest in CCD is reflected in industry initiatives like the 1993 CRC Workshop on Combustion Chamber Deposits (3).
This paper describes an experimental study of combustion chamber deposits and some of their effects in a four cylinder engine modified and instrumented for research. Deposit growth was monitored by measuring the weight and local deposit thicknesses on removable plugs in a slice carried between the head and the block. Deposit growth was reasonably repeatable from cylinder to cylinder and test to test. Knock rating was done on individual cylinders by determining the Knock Limited Spark Advance (KLSA) at the trace knock level. Techniques to measure deposit thickness and to detect knock were developed after assessing many options. Flame progress was monitored by ion-gaps in the head. The effect of deposits on heat transfer from the combustion chamber was monitored by using a plug with thermocouples embedded at different distances from the surface particularly during engine warm-up. Specific fuel consumption was also monitored and, for the operating condition used, decreased as deposits built up. We also assessed the effect of deposits from different parts of the combustion chamber by removing them selectively.
|Technical Paper||Spark Ignition Engine Performance During Warm-Up|
|Technical Paper||Modelling Methodology of a Spark-Ignition Engine and Experimental Validation: Part I: Single-Zone Combustion Model|
CitationKalghatgi, G., McDonald, C., and Hopwood, A., "An Experimental Study of Combustion Chamber Deposits and Their Effects in a Spark-Ignition Engine," SAE Technical Paper 950680, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/950680.
- Kalghatgi, G.T. “Deposits in Gasoline Engines - A Literature Review” SAE Paper No. 902105 1990
- Chemistry of Engine Combustion Chamber Deposits Ebert, L.B. Plenum Press 1985
- “Proceedings of the CRC Workshop on Combustion Chamber Deposits, Orlando, Florida, November 15-17, 1993.” CRC Inc. 219 Perimeter Ceter Parkway, Suite 400, Atlanta, GA 30346, U.S.A.
- Harrow, G.A. Orman, P.L. “Study of flame propagation and cyclic dispersion in a spark ignition engine” ASAE Symposium on Combustion in Engines, July 1965. Advances in Automobile Engineering 3 27 Pergamon Press 1966
- Bradish, J.P. Myers, P.S. Uyehara, O.A. “Effects of deposit properties on volumetric efficiency, heat transfer and preignition in internal combustion engines” SAE Paper No. 660130 1966
- Gibson H.J. Hall, C.A. Huffman, A.E. “Combustion chamber deposition and power loss” SAE Quart. Trans. 6 4 595 1952
- Cornetti, G. Liguori, V. Amendola, L. “Power loss due to combustion chamber deposits” Journal of Automotive Engineering 8 14 June 1971
- Bitting, W.H. Firmstone, G.P. Keller, C.T. “Effects of combustion chamber deposits on tailipipe emissions” SAE Paper No. 940345 1994
- Studzinsky, W.M. Liiva, P.M. Choate, P.J. Acker, W.P. Smooke, M. Brezinsky, K. Litzinger, T. Bower, S. “A Computational and Experimental Study of Combustion Chamber Deposit Effects on NOx Emissions” SAE Paper No. 932815 1993
- Pahnke, A.J. Conte, J.F. “Effect of combustion chamber deposits and driving conditions on vehicle exhaust emissions” SAE Paper No. 690017 1969
- Gagliardi, J.C. The effects of fuel anti-knock compounds and deposits on exhaust emissions” SAE Paper No. 670128 1967
- Moore, S.M. “Combustion Chamber Deposit Interference Effects in Late Model Vehicles” SAE Paper No. 940385 1994
- Cheng, S.S. Kim, C. “Effect of Engine Operating Parameters on Engine Combustion Chamber Deposits” SAE Paper No. 902108 1990
- Shore, L.B. Ockert, K.F. “Combustion Chamber Deposits - A Radio Tracer Study” SAE Transactions 66 285 294 1958
- Hayes, T.K. White, R.A. Peters, J.E. “The Insitu Measurement of Thermal diffusivity of Combustion Chamber Deposits in a Spark Ignition Engine” SAE paper No. 920513 1992
- Nakic, D.J. Assanis, D.N. White, R,A. “Effect of elevated piston temperature on Combustion Chamber Deposit Growth” SAE Paper No. 940948 1994
- French, C.C.J. Atkins, K.A. “Thermal loading of a petrol engine” Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs. 187 49 73 561 573 1973
- Hayes, T.K. White, R.A. Peters, J.E. “Combustion chamber temperature and instantaneous local heat flux measurements in a spark ignition engine” SAE Paper No. 930217 1993
- Peyla R.J. “Motor gasoline and deposit control additives - a challenge for the 90s” 1991 NPRA National Fuels and Lubricants meeting Houston 1991
- Yonekawa, Y. Kokubo, K. Nakamura, Y. Okamoto, N. “The study of combustion chamber deposit (part 5): The role of combustion chamber deposits in fuel economy” J.Japan Petroleum Institute 25 177 182 1982
- Young, M.B. “Cyclic Dispersion - Some quantitative cause and effect relationships,” SAE Paper No. 800459 1980
- Nakamura, Y. Yonekawa, Y. Okamoto, N. “The Effect of Combustion Chamber Deposits on Octane Requirement Increase and Fuel Economy” 199 211
- Spink, C.D. Barraud, P.G. Morris, G.E.L. “A critical road test evaluation of two high-performance gasoline additive packages in a fleet of modern European and Japanese vehicles” SAE Paper No. 912393 1991
- Graiff, L.B. “Some new aspects of deposit effects on engine octane requirement increase and fuel economy” SAE Paper No. 790938 1979
- Peyla, R.J. 7 109
- Valtadoros, T.H. Wong, V.W. Heywood, J.B. “Fuel additive effects on deposit build-up and engine operating characteristics” Symposium on fuel composition/deposit formation tendencies Division of Petroleum Chemistry, ACS Atlanta 66 April 1991
- Gao, X. Stone, R. Hudson, C. Bradbury, I. “The detection and quantification of knock in spark-ignition engines” SAE Paper No. 932759 1993