This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Frontal Crash Tests - A Comparison of Methods
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published November 01, 1994 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Event: Stapp Car Crash Conference
Frontal collisions account for the majority of car accidents. Regulations have been in effect since the late sixties, aiming at assuring a basic safety performance for cars in this type of crash.
From a legislative point of view tests as e.g. FMVSS 208 are about to be complemented by other frontal impact configurations. Two of the reasons behind this is to allow assessment also of asymmetric loads to the vehicle front and the level of passenger compartment intrusion.
This paper offers a comparison of different frontal crash tests, including Volvo's Severe Partial Overlap Collision (SPOC) and offset tests against a deformable barrier. The methods are evaluated with respect to their results, both from a dummy performance point of view and based on car deformation characteristics. Also, the practicability and possible effect on vehicle designs are discussed.
CitationPlanath-Skogsmo, I. and Nilsson, R., "Frontal Crash Tests - A Comparison of Methods," SAE Technical Paper 942228, 1994, https://doi.org/10.4271/942228.
- Hackney, J.R. “Comparative Analysis of Occupant Protection as Measured in Crash Tests in the United States” TÜV Seminar on Comparative Crash Tests within the EC. Brussels December 1992
- Evans, L. “Traffic Safety and the Driver” Van Nostrand Reinhold New York 1991
- Planath, I. Norin, H. Nilsson, S. “Severe Frontal Collisions with Partial Overlap - Significance, Test Methods and Car Design.” SAE Warrendale paper no 930636 1993
- Scheunert, D. et al. “What is a Realistic Frontal Offset Test Procedure?” Proceedings of the IRCOBI Conference IRCOBI Secretariat Bron, France 1992
- Lowne, R.W. “EEVC Working Group 11 Report on the Development of a Frontal Impact Test Procedure” Paper no. 94-S8-O-05 14th ESV Conference Munich, Germany 1994
- ISO/TC22/SC10/WG1 “Synthesis of Accident Data Presented to the EEVC WG11”
- ISO/TC22/SC10/WG1 “NHTSA's Frontal Impact Testing”
- Korner, J. “A Method for Evaluating Occupant Protection by Correlating Accident Data with Laboratory Test Data” SAE Warrendale paper no. 890747 1989
- Planath, I. “Strategies for Side Impact Protection Improvement” SP-974 SAE Warrendale 1993
- Katoh, H. Nakahama, R. “A Study on the Ride-Down Evaluation” Proceedings of the 9th ESV Conference 190 195 Kyoto, Japan 1982
- Hobbs, C.A. “The Need for Improved Structural Integrity in Frontal Car Impacts” Paper no. 91-S9-O-12 13th ESV Conference Paris, France 1991
- Norin, H. et al. “Avoiding Sub-Optimized Occupant Safety by Multiple Speed Impact Testing” Paper no. 91-S9-O-89 13th ESV Conference Paris, France 1991
- Hobbs, C.A. “The Response of Car Structures to Frontal Impact and Their Influence on Occupant Protection” Paper no. 93SF056 26th ISATA Conference Aachen, Germany 1993
- Ore, L.S. Tanner, C.B. “Summary of Design and Performance Requirements for the Dummy Lower Extremities” SAE Warrendale Paper no. 930097 1993
- Eppinger, R. et al. “Advanced Injury Criteria and Crash Evaluation Techniques” Paper no. 94-S1-O-11 14th ESV Conference Munich, Germany 1994