This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Experimental Evaluation of 1-D Computer Codes for the Simulation of Unsteady Gas Flow Through Engines - A First Phase
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 01, 1994 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper reports on the first phase of an experimental evaluation of five different methods for the mathematical modelling of unsteady gas flow in engine ducting. The five methods under investigation are the homentropic method of characteristics, the non-homentropic method of characteristics, the two-step Lax-Wendroff method with flux corrected transport, the Harten-Lax-Leer upstream difference method and the Blair method of pressure wave propagation through finite spaces.
A single cycle pressure wave generator consisting of a cylinder, connected via a sliding valve to a long duct, has been designed and built. The pressure waves it creates closely mimic those to be found in i.e. engines. The cylinder and the ducts of the device can be filled with any gas and at elevated temperatures. A perfect seal exists between the cylinder and the valve thus enabling mass- flow correlation. The initial cylinder pressure may be set to simulate an induction or an exhaust process. The duct attached to the pressure wave generator can simulate virtually any configuration to be found on an i.c. engine. Pressure and temperature are recorded by transducers positioned at various locations in the apparatus and stored using a high speed data acquisition system.
A series of tests have been conducted to simulate exhaust and intake flow in a constant area duct sufficiently long, to permit wave observation unclouded by superposition effects and to determine the accuracy of the simulation methods and the cylinder to pipe boundary conditions.
A computer simulation of the test apparatus has been written for each of the five theoretical methods using the Queen's University of Belfast (QUB) non-isentropic treatment of the boundary conditions. The accuracy of each prediction method is then correlated with the experimental results. As might be expected, most of the computer codes produce good correlation for unsteady flow in a constant area duct. However, this paper is the first in a series of papers which will report the exposition of the various computer codes to increasingly difficult pipe modelling geometry and thermodynamic discontinuities.
CitationKirkpatrick, S., Blair, G., Fleck, R., and McMullan, R., "Experimental Evaluation of 1-D Computer Codes for the Simulation of Unsteady Gas Flow Through Engines - A First Phase," SAE Technical Paper 941685, 1994, https://doi.org/10.4271/941685.
- Benson R.S. Garg R.D. Woollatt D. “A Numerical Solution of Unsteady Flow Problems” Int. J. Mech. Sci. 6 1964 117
- Low S.C. Baruah P.C. “A Generalised Computer Aided Design Package for an I.C. Engine Manifold System” SAE Paper No. 810498
- Blair G.P. Fleck R. “The Unsteady Gas Flow Behaviour in a Charge Cooled Rotary Piston Engine” SAE Paper No. 770763
- McGinnity F.A. Douglas R. Blair G.P. “Application of an Entropy Analysis to Four-Cycle Engine Simulation” SAE Paper No. 900681
- Lax P.D. Wendroff B. “Systems of Conservation Laws” Communs. Pure Appl. Math. 15 1960 217 237
- Richtmyer R.D. Morton K.W. “Difference Methods for Initial Value Problems” 2nd John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 1967
- Niessner H. Bulaty T. “A Family of Flux-Correction Methods to Avoid Overshoot Occurring With Solutions of Unsteady Flow Problems” Proceedings of GAMM 4th Conf. 1981 241 250
- Book D.L. Boris J.P. Hain K. “Flux-Corrected Transport II: Generalization of the Method” J. Comp. Phys. 18 1975 248 283
- Harten A. Lax P.D. Van Leer B. “On Upstream Differencing and Gudunov-type Schemes for Hyperbolic Conservation Laws” SIAM Rev. 25 1983 35 61
- Chen C. Veshagh A. Wallace F.J. “A Comparison Between Alternative Methods for Gas Flow and Performance Prediction of Internal Combustion Engines” SAE Paper No. 921734
- Blair G.P. “An Alternative Method for the Prediction of Unsteady Gas Flow Through the Internal Combustion Engine” SAE Paper No. 911850
- Blair G.P. “Correlation of an Alternative Method for the Prediction of Engine Performance Characteristics with Measured Data” SAE Paper No. 930501
- Blair G.P. Magee S.J “Non-Isentropic Analysis of Varying Area Flow in Engine Ducting SAE Paper No. 932399
- Blair G.P. “Non-Isentropic Analysis of Branched Flow in Engine Ducting” SAE Paper No. 940395
- Bannister F.K. Mucklow G.F. “Wave Action Following the Release of Compressed Gas from a Cylinder” Proc. I. Mech. E. 159 1948 269
- Benson R.S. “Influence of Exhaust Belt Design on the Discharge Process in Two-Stroke Engines” Proc. I. Mech. E. 174 24 1960 713
- Woods W.A. “On the Formulation of a Blowdown Pulse in the Exhaust System of a Two-Stroke Cycle Engine” Int. J. Mech. Sci. 4 1962 259
- Benson R.S. Horlock J.H. Winterbone D.E. “The Thermodynamics and Gas Dynamics of Internal Combustion Engines” I Clarendon Press Oxford 1982
- Ikeda T. Nakagawa T. “On the SRASTA FCT Algorithm for the Equation ” Maths. Comput. 33 148 October 1979 1157 1169
- Gudunov S.K. “A Difference Scheme for Numerical Computation of Discontinuous Solutions of Equations of Fluid Dynamics” Mat. Sb. 47 1959 271 290
- Cahoon W.L. “Unsteady Gas Flow Through a Naturally Aspirated Two-Stroke Internal Combustion Engine” Dept. Mech. Eng., The Queen's University of Belfast Nov. 1971
- McConnell J.H. “Unsteady Gas Flow Through a Naturally Aspirated Four-Stroke Internal Combustion Engine” Dept. Mech. Eng., The Queen's University of Belfast March 1974
- Wallace F.J. Stuart-Mitchell R.W. “Wave action following the Sudden Release of Air Through an Engine Port System” Proc. I. Mech. E. IB 1953 343
- Wallace F.J. Nassif M.H. “Air Flow in a Naturally Aspirated Two-Stroke Engine” Proc. I. Mech. E. 168 1954 515