This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Analysis of Trends of Vehicle Frontal Impact Stiffness
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Impact induced vehicle residual deformation serves as a basis for the reconstruction engineer to make a determination of the energy absorbed during the impact phase of a collision. Many impact phase reconstruction algorithms assume a linear relation between an absorbed energy function and residual crush in order to derive collision severity (Delta V, BEV, etc.). This is done through the assumption of a constant spring stiffness value to describe the vehicle frontal impact stiffness. However, some recent rigid barrier impact test data has demonstrated non-linear trends between crash energy and residual crush. The total body of available crash test data indicates that vehicle frontal stiffness cannot be precisely modeled through the use of a single linear spring stiffness for all vehicles. This paper will explore stiffness trends and make comparisons to the previously assigned linear assumption for a diverse sample of vehicles and test speeds into frontal fixed barriers. The available crash test data is plotted and analyzed and the resulting linear and non-linear trends are discussed. Applications to the accident reconstruction field are also explored.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Crash Recorder for Safety System Studies and as a Consumer's Product |
Technical Paper | Simulation of a Two-Car Oblique Side Impact Using a Simple Crash Analysis Model |
Technical Paper | How to Use PC-CRASH to Simulate Rollover Crashes |
Citation
Varat, M., Husher, S., and Kerkhoff, J., "An Analysis of Trends of Vehicle Frontal Impact Stiffness," SAE Technical Paper 940914, 1994, https://doi.org/10.4271/940914.Also In
References
- Campbell, K. Energy Basis for Collision Severity SAE Paper # 740565 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1974
- Carlson, L.E. Safety Compliance Test Program: FMVSS 212, 219, 301-75, NCAP Accident Investigation Division Data 1979
- Dance, M. Enserink, B. Safety Performance Evaluation of Seat Belt Retractors SAE Paper # 790680 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1979
- EL-Habash, N.A. Final Report of Frontal Barrier Impacts of a 1985 Ford Escort in Support of Crash III Damage Algorithm Reformation 1988
- EL-Habash, N.A. Final Report of Frontal Barrier Impacts of a 1986 Ford Taurus 4-Door Sedan in Support of Crash III Damage Algorithm Reformulation 1988
- EL-Habash, N.A. Frontal Barrier Impacts in Support of Crash III Damage Algorithm Reformulation of a 1985 Pontiac Grand Am 2-Door Coupe Final Report 1988 VRTC Report #881017
- Fonda, A.G. Crush Energy Formulations and Single - Event Reconstruction SAE Paper # 900099 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1990
- Kerkhoff, J.F. Husher, S.E. Varat M.S. Busenga, A.M. Hamilton, K.G. BH2VK Crash Testing Project Seminar Notes Conjunction with seminar DeVore, CA. 1992
- Kerkhoff, J.F. Husher, S.E. Varat M.S. Busenga, A.M. Hamilton, K.G. An Investigation into Vehicle Frontal Impact Stiffness, BEV, and Repeated Testing for Accident Reconstruction SAE Paper # 930899 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1993
- Knipling, R.R. NASS Field Techniques V CRASH Measurements, Contract #DTNH22-83-C-07023 Allen Corporation of America Institute for Research in Public Safety Indiana University April 1983
- Machey, J.M. Gauthier, C.L. Results, Analysis and Conclusions of NHTSA's 35 MPH Frontal Crash Repeatability Program SAE Paper # 840201 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1984
- Navin, F. MacNabb, M. Miyasaki, Grant W. Elastic Properties of Selected Vehicles SAE Paper # 880223 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1988
- Neilson, I.D. Kemp, R.N. Wall, J.G. Harris, J. Controlled Impact Investigations: Head-On Impacts of Four Similar Cars From Different Speeds Against a Rigid Barrier Road Research Laboratory, Ministry of Transport Crowtherne Berkshire 1968
- NHTSA-VCTDB - Crash Test Data From Vehicle Crash Test DataBase 700 7th Street SW, Washington, DC, 20590
- Pirie, A.I. Linear Regression Analysis (Two Variables) SAE Publication SP-250 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1982
- Prasad, A.K. CRASH 3 Damage Algorithm Reformulation For Front and Rear Collisions SAE Paper # 900098 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1990
- Prasad, A.K. Energy Dissipated in Vehicle Crush -- A Study Using the Repeated Test Technique SAE Paper # 900412 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1990
- Ryder, M.O. Classification of Automobile Frontal Stiffness/Crashworthiness by Impact Testing 1976
- Shoemaker, N.E. Ryder, M.O. Delays, N.J. Consumer Information Crash Test Program: Prediction of Dynamic Crash Responses for Vehicle and Occupants I Summary Report 1976
- Shoemaker, N.E. Ryder, M.O. Delays, N.J. Automobile Consumer Information: Crash Test Program II 1976
- Strother, C.E. Woolley, R.L. James, M.B. Warner, C.Y. Crush Energy in Accident Reconstruction SAE Paper # 860371 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1986
- Tanner, R.B. Crashworthiness of the Subcompact Vehicle 1976
- Transport Canada Test Data Trauttmansdorff F. 1990
- Warner, C.Y. Allsop, D.L. Germane, G.J. A Repeated-Crash Test Technique for Assessment of Structural Impact Behavior SAE Paper # 860208 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA. 1986
- Wingenbach, W.J. Lagerquist, R.E. Frontal and Side Impact Crashworthiness -- Compact Cars 1974
- Yee, R. Cropper, R. Davis, S. Shaw, M. Development of a Test Methodology for Evaluating Crash Compatibility and Aggressiveness II Technical Report 1979