This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
On the Use and Misuse of Statistical Energy Analysis for Vehicle Noise Control
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published May 1, 1993 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The use of Statistical Energy Analysis (SEA) in the field of vehicle noise is discussed. Theoretical fundamentals and basic assumptions of the method are summarized. Examples of successful prediction of interior noise levels in vehicles using the “classical” formulation for SEA are reviewed.
Recently methods have been presented for the in-situ experimental determination of coupling- and internal loss factors for vehicles, based on the power balance equations. The methods are a result of applying the SEA hypothesis to multi-subsystem models of complex structures. This approach is attractive for vibratory power flow models of very complex structures such as car bodies. Simple substructures or junctions can not easily be identified for such structures why models based on theoretical estimations for basic substructures or junctions become uncertain. This experimental approach is sometimes called “inverse SEA”, since the elements of the loss-factor matrix are determined instead of the subsystem energies.
Some serious fundamental problems and erroneous assumptions for the “inverse SEA” method are discussed and illustrated using a finite element and an analytical model of a simple plate structure.
CitationPlunt, J., Fredö, C., and Sanderson, M., "On the Use and Misuse of Statistical Energy Analysis for Vehicle Noise Control," SAE Technical Paper 931301, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/931301.
- Proc. SAE 1987 Noise and Vibr. Conference. Traverse City, 1987. Papers 870997, 870998.
- Proc. SAE 1889 Noise and Vibr. Conference. Traverse City, 1989. Papers 891142, 891153, 891169
- Proc. SAE 1991 Noise and Vibr. Conference. Traverse City, 1991. Papers 911066, 911067, 911074, 911075, 911076.
- Wood L A, Joachim C A: Interior Noise Scatter in Four-Cylinder Sedans and Wagons. Int J Vehicle Design, 8(1987) p428.
- Lyon R H: Statistical Energy Analysis of Dynamic Systems: Theory and Applications. MIT Press, Cambridge 1975.
- Plunt J: Methods for Predicting Noise Levels in Ships, Part II. Ph.D. Thesis, Chalmers Univ. of Technology, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1980.
- Craik R J M: The Prediction of Sound Transmission through Buildings Using Statistical Energy Analysis. J Sound and Vibr, 82(1982) p505-516.
- DeJong R G: A study of Vehicle Interior Noise Using Statistical Energy Analysis. Proc SAE Surface Vehicle Noise and Vibr Conf. SAE Paper 850960, 1985.
- Rennison D C, Bremner P G: Prediction of Tracked Vehicle Noise Using SEA and Finite Elements. Proc. 2nd Int Congr Rec Dev in Air- & Structure-borne Sound and Vibration. Auburn, 1992.
- Shaw S: Analysis and Prediction of the Acoustical Characteristics of Automobile Bodies using Statistical Energy Analysis. Unikeller Conference 1987.
- Walsh S J, Lalor N: Optimization of Noise Control Measures in Complex Lightweight Sheetmetal Structures by Using Energy Flow Analysis. BRITE/EURAM 2nd Technological Days Conference, Brussels 1989.
- Lalor N: The Experimental Determination of Vibration Energy Balance in Complex Structures. Paper 108429, SIRA Conference “Stress and Vibration: Recent Developments in Industrial Measurement and Analysis”, London 1989.
- Ming R S, Stimpson G, Lalor N: On the Measurement of Individual Coupling Loss Factor in a Complex Structure. Proc. Inter-Noise 90, p 961-964, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1990.
- Walsh S J, Stimpson G, Lalor N: A Computer System to Predict Internal Noise in Motor Cars Using Statistical Energy Analysis. Proc. Inter-Noise 90, p 961-964, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1990.
- Stimpson G, Lalor N: A Practical Noise Modeling of Car Body Structures Using Energy Flow Analysis. Proc. Inter-Noise 91, p 1233-1236, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1991.
- Bies D A, Hamid S: In situ determination of loss and coupling factors by the power injection method. J Sound and Vibration, 70(1980), p187-204.
- Lyon R H, Maidanik G: Power flow between linearly coupled oscillators JASA 34(1962), p 623.
- Cremer L, Heckl M, Ungar E E: Structure-Borne Sound. 2nd Edition, Springer Verlag, 1988.
- Plunt J: The Power Injection Method for Vibration Damping Determination of Body Panels with Applied Damping Treatments and Trim. SAE Paper 911085, 1991.
- Dimitriadis E K, Pierce A D: Analytical Solution for the Power Exchange between Strongly Coupled Plates Under Random Excitation: A test of Statistical Energy Analysis Concepts. J Sound and Vibration, 123(1988), p397-412.
- Fredö C R: “Derivation of Energy Flow with a Finite Element Model”. Chalmers University of Technology, Dept of Appl. Acoustics. Report F 93-01, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1993.
- Gärdhagen B, Emretsson B-G: Vibrations of a Heavy Truck Diesel Engine and Gearbox Unit: Examining Structure-borne Sound Transmission with Statistical Energy Analysis. Chalmers University of Technology, Dept of Appl. Acoustics. Report E 93-03, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1993.