This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Error Analysis of the Vehicle Exhaust Emission Measurement System
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published March 01, 1993 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
An error model of the Constant Volume Sampler (CVS) and the exhaust emission analyzers using standard error propagation techniques has been developed. The model, based on the individual errors of the different equipment involved in the measurement process, was used to compute the total uncertainty in grams/mile of the regulated pollutants Non Methane Hydrocarbons (NMHC), Oxides of Nitrogen (NOx) and Carbon Monoxide (CO) emitted by a vehicle during the U.S. Federal Test Procedure. The uncertainties resulting from the errors introduced by the vehicle, the driver and the chassis dynamometer are not accounted for in this analysis.
At Ultra Low Emission Vehicle (ULEV) standards, the analysis showed that errors associated with the measurement of Total Hydrocarbon (THC), NMHC and NOx resulted in a high level of uncertainty. However, the results showed that the CO measurement uncertainty is acceptable.
The model showed that one of the major sources of error is the analyzer repeatability. A minimum of 19% uncertainty in NMHC at ULEV levels (0.04 grams/mile) can be expected using current instrumentation. The model also revealed that there would not be significant differences in uncertainty in testing a large or small vehicle for a given emissions standard.
The model also showed that a Variable CVS system reduced NMHC uncertainties from 19% to 9.4% and NOx uncertainties, from 8% to 5% at ULEV levels. The model was also used to predict the potential benefit of using a direct measurement of NMHC. This error model could be utilized to specify the instrumentation sensitivity that will be required at ULEV standards.
CitationVelosa, J., "Error Analysis of the Vehicle Exhaust Emission Measurement System," SAE Technical Paper 930393, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/930393.
- Sheth Narendra J. Rice Timothy I. “Identification, Quantification and Reduction of Sources of Variability in Vehicle Emissions and Fuel Economy Measurements” SAE Paper No. 790232 1979
- Fock M. Lies K. Pazsitka L. “Critical Study of the United States Exhaust Emission Certification Test Error and Probability Analysis” SAE Paper No 750678 1975
- Juneja W.K. Horchler D.D. Haskew H.M. “A Treatise on Exhaust Emission Test Variability” SAE Paper No 770136 1977
- Code of Federal Regulations Environmental Protection Agency “Federal Register” 40 July 1990
- Taylor James L. “Fundamentals of Measurement Error” Neff Instrument Corporation 1988
- Urban C.M. “Calculation of Emissions and Fuel Economy when Using Alternate Fuels” EPA report 460/3-83-009 1983