This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Crash Injury Prevention: A Case Study of Fatal Crashes of Lap-Shoulder Belted Occupants
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Event:
Stapp Car Crash Conference
Language:
English
Abstract
A case study was conducted of 123 crashes involving 144 fatally injured lap-shoulder belted front-seat occupants. The crashes occurred throughout the United States in 1985-86 and involved 97 driver and 47 right-front passenger deaths in new vehicles. A judgment was made by consensus of a safety panel on the potential for saving the victim's life by the addition of safety technology. Supplemental airbags provided the greatest potential for improving the life-saving effectiveness of current lap-shoulder belts. Overall, airbags may have prevented 12% of the belted occupant fatalities and 27% of the deaths in frontal crashes. The benefit of supplemental airbags was greater for the right-front passenger, in part, because of more females and occupants over 60 years of age in that seating position. A majority (68%) of the belted fatalities were judged unpreventable by reasonable restraint or vehicle modifications. This level is indicative of the extreme severity of many of the fatal crashes involving extensive vehicle damage and forces on the occupant compartment, unusual crash configurations and causes of death, and unique situations related to seating position and crash dynamics. Using published levels of belt effectiveness, 50% of all fatalities may not be preventable by the use of lap-shoulder belts, supplemental airbags, and practicable changes in crashworthiness systems. The study addressed only the potential benefit of supplemental-restraint components and airbags and did not consider possible adverse effects which might occur in real-world crashes.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Viano, D., "Crash Injury Prevention: A Case Study of Fatal Crashes of Lap-Shoulder Belted Occupants," SAE Technical Paper 922523, 1992, https://doi.org/10.4271/922523.Also In
References
- Danner, M. Langwieder, K. Hummel, T. The effect of restraint systems and possibilities of future improvements derived from real-life accidents SAE Technical Paper # 840394 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1984
- Evans, L. The effectiveness of safety belts in preventing fatalities Acci Anal Prev 18 229 241 1986a
- Evans, L. Double pair comparison -- a new method to determine how occupant characteristics affect fatality risk in traffic crashes Acci Anal Prev 18 217 227 1986b
- Evans, L. Young driver involvement in severe car crashes Alcohol, Drugs and Driving 3 3-4 63 78 1987
- Evans, L. Restraint effectiveness occupant ejection from cars, and fatality reductions General Motors Research Report GMR-6398 General Motors Research Laboratories Warren, MI 1988
- Evans, L. Frick, M. Seating position in cars and fatality risk Am J Pub Health 78 1456 1458 1988
- Evans, L. Airbag effectiveness in preventing fatalities predicted according to type of crash, driver age, and blood alcohol concentration 33rd Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine 307 322 AAAM Des Plaines, IL 1989
- Gloyns, P.F. Jones, I.S. Characteristics of fatal frontal impacts and future countermeasures in Great Britain Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Report 1989
- Green, R.N. German, A. Gorski, Z.M. et al. Improper use of occupant restraints: case studies from real-world collisions Proceedings of the 30th Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine 423 438 American Association for Automotive Medicine Des Plains, IL 1986
- Grosch, L. Baumann, K.H. Holtze, H. Schwede, W. Safety performance of passenger cars designed to accommodate frontal impacts with partial barrier overlap Automotive Frontal Impacts SP-782 29 36 SAE Technical Paper # 890748 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1989
- Hartemann, F. Thomas, C. Henry, C. et al. Belted or not belted: the only difference between two matched samples of 200 car occupants Proceedings of the 21st Stapp Car Crash Conference 95 150 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1977
- Horsch, J.D. Evaluation of occupant protection from responses measured in laboratory tests SAE Paper Technical # 870222 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1987
- Horsch, J. Lau, I.V. Andrzejak, D. Viano, D. Melvin, J. Pearson, J. Cok, D. Miller, G. Assessment of Airbag Deployment Loads Proceedings of the 34th Stapp Car Crash Conference 267 288 SAE Technical Paper # 902324 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA November 1990
- Huelke, D.F. Sherman, H.W. Murphy, M.J. Kaplan, R.J. Flora, J.D. Effectiveness of current and future restraint systems in fatal and serious injury automobile crashes SAE Technical Paper # 790323 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1979
- Huelke, D.F. Lawson, T.E. Scott, R. Marsh, J.C. The effectiveness of belt systems in frontal and rollover crashes SAE Technical Paper # 770148 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1977
- Huelke, D.F. Sherman, H.W. Elliott, A.F. Clinical case studies of lap-shoulder belt effectiveness in passenger car crashes SAE Technical Paper # 840197 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1984
- Huelke, D.F. Compton, C. Studer, R. Injury severity, ejection, and occupant contacts in passenger car rollover crashes SAE Technical Paper # 850336 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1985
- Korner, J. A method for evaluating occupant protection by correlating accident data with laboratory test data Automotive Frontal Impacts SP-782 13 28 SAE Technical Paper # 890747 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1989
- Langwieder, K. Danner, M. Schmelzing, W. Appel, H. Kramer, F. Hofmann, J. Comparison of passenger injuries in frontal car collisions with dummy loadings in equivalent simulations Proceedings of the 23rd Stapp Car Crash Conference 199 232 SAE Technical Paper # 791009 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1979
- Lau, I.V. Viano, D.C. The viscous criterion - bases and applications of an injury severity index for soft tissues Proceedings of the 30th Stapp Car Crash Conference (P-189) 123 142 SAE Technical Paper # 861882 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1986
- Lau, I.V. Horsch, J.D. Andrzejak, D.V. Viano, D.C. Biomechanics of liver injury by steering wheel loading J Trauma 27 3 225 235 1987
- NHTSA FMVSS 208 Regulatory Impact Analysis National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Department of Transportation Washington, DC 1984
- NHTSA Fatal Accident Reporting System 1987 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Department of Transportation Report #807 360 Washington, DC 1988
- Mulligan, G. Dalkie, H. Redwood, A. An indepth study of 121 fatal motor vehicle collisions involving 154 vehicle occupant fatalities; collision characteristics, causation and seat belt effectiveness Proceedings of the Canadian Multidisciplinary Road Safety Conference V Calgary, Alberta 1987
- Pursel, H.D. Bryant, R.W. Scheel, J.W. Yanik, A.J. Matching case methodology for measuring restraint effectiveness SAE Technical Paper # 780415 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1978
- Rutherford, W.H. Greenfield, T. Hayes, H.R.M. Nelson, J.K. The medical effects of seat belt legislation in the United Kingdom Department of Health and Social Security. Research Report No. 13 Her Majesty's Stationary Office London
- Searle, J.A. Bethell, J. Baggaley, G. The variation of human tolerance to impact and its effect on the design and testing of automotive impact performance Proceedings of the 22nd Stapp Car Crash Conference (P-77) 1 32 SAE Paper # 780885 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1978
- States, J.D. Huelke, D.F. Dance, M. Green, R.N. Fatal injuries caused by underarm use of shoulder belts J Trauma 27 7 740 744 1987
- Thomas, C. Koltchakian, S. Tarriere, C. Got, C. Patel, A. Inadequacy of 0 degree barrier with frontal real-world accidents Proceedings of the 12th E.S.V. Conference xx yy NHTSA Paper #89-2a-0-002 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Washington, DC 1989
- Thomas, C. Koltchakian, S. Tarriere, C. et al. Primary safety priorities in view to technical feasibility limited to secondary automotive safety Proceedings of the 1990 FISITA Conference Milan, Italy 1990
- Viano, D.C. Evaluation of the benefit of energy-absorbing material for side impact protection: part ii Proceedings of the 31st Stapp Car Crash Conference 205 224 SAE Technical Paper # 872213 SAE Transactions 96 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1987
- Viano, D.C. Cause and control of automotive trauma Bull NY Acad Med 64 5 376 421 1988b
- Viano, D.C. Limits and challenges of crash protection Acci Anal Prev 20 6 421 429 1988a
- Viano, D.C. Lau, I.V. A viscous tolerance criterion for soft tissue injury assessment J Biomech 21 5 387 399 1988
- Viano, D.C. Culver, C.C. Evans, L. Frick, M. Scott, R. Involvement of older drivers in multi-vehicle side impact crashes Acci Anal Prev 22 2 177 188 1990
- Viano, D.C. Effectiveness of safety belts and airbags in preventing fatal injury Frontal Crash Safety Technologies for the 90's (SP-852) 159 171 SAE Technical Paper # 910901 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1991
- Wilson, R.A. Savage, C.M. Restraint system effectiveness - a study of fatal accidents Proceedings of Automotive Safety Engineering Seminar 27 39 General Motors Corporation, Automotive Safety Engineering, Environmental Activities Staff Warren, MI 1973
- Zador, P.L. Ciccone, M.A. Driver fatalities in frontal impacts: comparisons between cars with air bags and manual belts Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Arlington, VA 1991