This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Technical Demands on Safety in the Design of Crash Helmets for Biomechanical Analysis of Real Accident Situations
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Event:
Stapp Car Crash Conference
Language:
English
Abstract
Crash helmets for motorcyclists are subject to certain test specifications by national and international reglements. For the European community the ECE-R 22 is valid, in America the tests are made according to SNELL as well as FMVSS 218. In all test procedures the protruding stability, the form stability of the carrier device and the shock absorption is tested. This study investigate impact situations in real accidents. The impact situation of 598 analysed crash helmets reveals that only 57.5% of all impact points are situated within the protection region of helmets defined by ECE, 14.1% in the marginal region and 28.2% clearly outside this protected region. The highest percentage of impacts occurres in the chin region, which is not taken into consideration in test definitions ECE as well as FMVSS. The so-called ‘double-impact’, which is a base of test procedures and induce therefore, is not confirmed in accident reality. The most frequent impact for the chin region is an impact placed 4 to 6cm away from the middle of the chin-bar. Biomechanically regarded, two typical force directions were defined, on the one hand oblique from below, with subsequent injuries to the lower jaw and other indirect injuries to the top of the scull, and on the other hand a more sagittal rectangular force direction, causing fractures to the lower jaw as well as extensive facial fractures. The fracture of the scull base appears to be a frequent secondary effect. In an oblique force direction from below it is valuated as an indirect injury, in a rectangular impact, however, it is regarded as a direct injury. Within the respective frame- work of this study, optimum helmet test conditions can be defined by this analysis.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Investigation of the Performance of Motorcycle Helmets Under Impact Conditions |
Technical Paper | High and Low Rate Force-Deformation Characteristics of Motorcycle Helmets |
Technical Paper | Structural Characteristics of Motorcycle Helmets |
Authors
Citation
Otte, D., "Technical Demands on Safety in the Design of Crash Helmets for Biomechanical Analysis of Real Accident Situations," SAE Technical Paper 912911, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/912911.Also In
References
- April 1989
- Snively, G.G. C.O. Chichester Evaluation and Design Criteria of Protective Headgear Proc. 5th Stapp Automotive Crash Conference Minneapolis, Minn. September 1961
- FMVSS-Standard § 571.218 Motorcycle helmets National Highway Traffic Safety Admin., DOT National Archives and Records Administration October 1990
- Otte, D. et.al 1982
- Dilling, J Otte, D. 1986
- American Association for Automotive Medicine The Abbreviated Injury Scale - Revision 85 American Ass. f. Autom. Med., Morton Grove Illinois/USA 1985
- Cooter, D. David, J. McLean, J. Simpson, A. Helmet - Indused Skull Base Fracture in a Motorcyclist 84 85 January 1988