This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Heavy Truck Cab Safety Study
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 01, 1991 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Event: Stapp Car Crash Conference
Nearly 1000 occupants of large trucks die each year in traffic accidents. Examination of yearly trends shows about a 25% decline in tractor-driver fatalities from 674 in 1984 to 508 in 1987. Over that same period of time, reported restraint use by tractor drivers involved in fatal accidents increased from 9.6% to 37.3%. The primary factors associated with tractor driver fatalities remain the same as identified in earlier studies. About 80% are single vehicle accidents. Rollover is identified as the most harmful event in 41.4% and frontal impact is the most harmful event in 40.3%. Thirty-four percent of the fatally injured tractor drivers were ejected and 21.5% required extrication. Fire on the truck was associated with 16.2% of the tractor driver fatalities.
The recent TIFA data on restrained truck drivers indicates that restraint use reduces the probability of fatality by about 77%. However, this estimate must be tempered by the evidence of over-reporting of restraint use on police accident reports. Information obtained through a review of 186 National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) reports on truck driver fatalities in eight states indicated that there was not sufficient occupant survival space in about 65% of the collisions examined. Forty-two percent were judged to be not survivable because of the severity of the impact. Restraint use alone appears sufficient to alter the outcome of only about 27%. Cab structural modifications sufficient to maintain adequate survival space, particularly in rollover, will be required in order to address an additional 23% that appeared survivable.
|Technical Paper||Heavy Truck Rollover Crashworthiness: Testing Methods and Development of Recommended Practices|
|Technical Paper||The Crash Survival Space|
|Technical Paper||Status Report on Large Truck Safety in the United States|
CitationCampbell, K. and Sullivan, K., "Heavy Truck Cab Safety Study," SAE Technical Paper 912903, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/912903.
- A Study of Heavy Truck Occupant Protection: Accident Data Analysis Ranney T.A. Springfield, VA National Technical Information Service DOT-HS-806-426 April 1983
- Heavy Truck Occupant Protection Mergel J. Springfield, VA National Technical Information Service DOT-HS-806-368 December 1982
- Rollover, Ejection, and the Potential Effectiveness of Restraints in Heavy-Truck Occupant Fatalities Campbell KL. Warrendale, Pa Society of Automotive Engineers 1982 Paper No. 821271
- Truck Occupant Protection Clarke R.M. Leasure W.A. Jr. Springfield, VA National Technical Information Service DOT-HS-807-081 December 1986
- Heavy Truck Occupant Restraint Use Allison P. Tarkir R. Final Report prepared under NHTSA contract No. DTNH22-80-C-07457 September 1982
- Heavy Truck Occupant Restraint Use Copenhaver M. Wilkinson T. Final Report prepared under NHTSA contract No. DTNH22-90-D-07010 August 1991
- Safety Study: Fatigue, Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Medical Factors in Fatal-to-the-Driver heavy Truck Crashes (Volume 1 and 2) Washington D.C. National Transportation Safety Board Report No. NTSB/SS-90/01 and NTSB/SS-90/02 February 1990
- Direct Observation of Seat Belt Use in Michigan: April 1985 Wagenaar A.C. Wiviott M.B.T. Compton C. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute June 1985
- Direct Observation of Seat Belt Use in Michigan: July 1985 Wagenaar A.C. Wiviott M.B.T. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute August 1985
- Rear Seat Belt Effectiveness in Michigan Campbell K.L. Text of a presentation made at the 1987 SAE International Congress February 1987
- “Limits and Challenges of Crash Protection.” Viano D.C. Accident Analysis and Prevention 20 6 421 429 1988
- “Collision Severity and Cab Deformation.” Campbell KL. Proceedings of the National Truck Safety Symposium Washington, D.C. Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association June 30 1986 62 82