This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Effect of Traffic Reports on Commuters' Route and Departure Time Changes
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Considerable public and private resources are devoted to the collection and dissemination of real-time traffic information in the Chicago area. Such information is intended to help drivers make more informed trip decisions, yet its effect on driver behavior remains largely unexplored. This study was conducted to evaluate the effect of traffic reports on route and departure time changes.
Downtown Chicago automobile commuters were surveyed during the AM peak period by giving them mail-back questionnaires. Drivers indicated whether or not they had changed their route and departure time decisions based on traffic reports. Further, drivers indicated how they perceived the traffic information system in terms of key attributes. Respondents also evaluated suggested improvements to the traffic information system.
A majority (more than 60%) of drivers reported that they used traffic reports for modifying their trip decisions. Drivers perceived radio traffic reports positively in terms of information system attributes. Commuters were more likely to use traffic reports for their route changes if they perceived traffic reports to be accurate and timely, frequently listened to traffic reports, perceived their regular route as congested, knew multiple alternate routes, were male and higher income. Drivers were more likely to change departure times if they perceived traffic reports to be accurate and relevant, frequently listened to traffic reports and perceived their regular route as congested.
Drivers indicated a relatively lower level of overall satisfaction with traffic reports indicating the existence of opportunities for improvement. One promising improvement is near-term prediction of traffic conditions on congested and unreliable routes (where conditions may change rapidly). This is because:
-
Drivers generally want to know the conditions at any given point (or link) along their route when they reach that point.
-
Drivers would be able to make better and more informed judgments regarding their trip decisions due to reduced uncertainty of traffic conditions.
-
The possibility that drivers may find traffic conditions significantly better or worse would be reduced. This would improve the credibility of radio traffic reports.
Authors
Citation
Khattak, A., Schofer, J., and Koppelman, F., "Effect of Traffic Reports on Commuters' Route and Departure Time Changes," SAE Technical Paper 912813, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/912813.Also In
References
- Khattak, Asad Driver response to Unexpected Travel Conditions: Effect of Traffic Information and Other Factors Civil Engineering Department, Northwestern University Evanston, Illinois 1991
- Bovy, Piet Stern E. Route choice: Wayfinding in Transport Networks Kluwer Academic Publishers The Netherlands 1990
- Mahmassani, Hani Caplice C. Walton C. “Characteristics of Urban Commuter Behavior: Switching Propensity and Use of Information,” 69th Annual Meeting of Transportation Research Board Washington, D.C. 1990
- Mannering, Fred “Poisson Analysis of Commuter Flexibility in Changing Routes and Departure Times,” Transportation Research 23 1 1989 53 60
- Dudek, Conrad Friebele J. Loutzenheizer R. “Evaluation of Commercial Radio for Real-Time Driver Communications on Urban Freeways,” Highway Research Record 358 Highway Research Board Washington, D.C. 1971
- Daniels, E. Levin M. McDermott J. “Improving Commercial Radio Traffic Reports in the Chicago Area,” Transportation Research Record 600 Transportation Research Board Washington D.C. 1976 52 57
- Hendrickson, Chris Plank E. “The Flexibility of Departure Times for Work Trips,” Transportation Research 18 1 Pergamon Press 1984 25 36
- Abkowitz, Mark “An Analysis of the Commuter Departure Time Decision,” Transportation 10 1981 283 297
- Abu-Eisheh, Sameer Mannering F. “Discrete/Continuous Analysis of Commuters' Route and Departure Time Choices,” Transportation Research Record 1138 Transportation Research Board Washington D.C. 1987 27 34
- Small, Kenneth “The Scheduling of Consumer Activities: Work Trips,” American Economic Review 72 1982 467 479
- Mannering, Fred Hamed M. “Occurrence, Frequency and Duration of Commuters' Work-To-Home Departure Delay,” Transportation Research B 24B 2 1990 99 109
- Haselkorn, Mark Spyridakis J. Conquest L. Barfield W. “Surveying Commuter Behavior as a Basis for Designing Motorist Information Systems,” Paper Presented at the 1st Vehicle Navigation and Information Systems Conference IEEE Toronto, Canada 1989
- Koppelman, Frank Pas E. “Travel-Choice Behavior: Models of Perceptions, Feelings, Preference, and Choice,” Transportation Research Record Transportation Research Board Washington, D.C. 1980 26 33
- Brown, Gordon Copeland T. Millward M. “Monadic Testing of New Products--An Old Problem and Some Partial Solutions,” Journal of Marketing Research Society 15 2 1973 112 131
- McKelvey, W. Zavoina T. “A Statistical Model for Analysis of Ordinal Level Dependent Variables,” Journal of Mathematical Sociology Summer 1975 103 120
- Greene, William Econometric Analysis Macmillan Publishing Company New York 1990