This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Human Factors Simulation Investigation of Driver Route Diversion and Alternate Route Selection Using In-Vehicle Navigation Systems
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 01, 1991 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper describes a human factors simulation study of the decision making behavior of drivers attempting to avoid nonrecurring congestion by diverting to alternate routes with the aid of in-vehicle navigation systems. This study is the first phase of a two part project in which the second phase will apply the driver behavior data to a simulation model analysis of traffic flow. The object of the driver behavior experiment was to compare the effect of various experimental navigation systems on driver route diversion and alternate route selection. The experimental navigation system configurations included three map based systems with varying amounts of situation information and a non map based route guidance system.
The overall study results indicated that navigation system characteristics can have a significant effect on driver diversion behavior, with better systems allowing more anticipation of traffic congestion. Subject route familiarity, commercial driving experience and gender did not significantly affect the results. Alternate route analysis tended to confirm the main route diversion results, and also showed that a majority of drivers were willing to accept alternate routes suggested by advanced navigation systems. These results were consistent over three significantly different congestion conditions. Driver age was also a factor, with old drivers being more reluctant to divert from the main freeway route. The paper describes the simulation approach and summarize results on diversion decision behavior and alternate route selection.
- R. Wade Allen - Systems Technology, Inc. Hawthorne, CA
- Anthony C. Stein - Systems Technology, Inc. Hawthorne, CA
- Theodore J. Rosenthal - Systems Technology, Inc. Hawthorne, CA
- David Ziedman - Systems Technology, Inc. Hawthorne, CA
- Jaime F. Torres - JFT Assoc. Pacific Palisades, CA
- Abolhassan Halati - JFT Assoc. Pacific Palisades, CA
CitationAllen, R., Stein, A., Rosenthal, T., Ziedman, D. et al., "A Human Factors Simulation Investigation of Driver Route Diversion and Alternate Route Selection Using In-Vehicle Navigation Systems," SAE Technical Paper 912731, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/912731.
- King, G.F., “Driver Performance in Highway Navigation Tasks,” Visibility and Highway Navigation, Transportation Research Record, N1093, 1986, pp. 1-11.
- Jurgen, R.K., “Smart cars and highways go global,” IEEE Spectrum, The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc., May 1991.
- Wierwille, W.W., Hulse M.C., et al., “A Strategic Use of Visual Resources by the Driver while Navigating with an In-Car Navigation Display System,” SAE P-211, pp 25-30, 1988
- Zwahlen, H.T. and DeBald D.P., “Safety Aspects of In-Vehicle Information Displays and Controls,” Proc. of the Human Factors Society 30th Annual Meeting, Dayton, OH, 1986.
- Route Guidance and In-Car Communication Systems, OECD, Paris, France, 1988.
- Dial, R., “The ETAK Digital Map Database: Potential Application in Highway Transportation,” Technology Options for Highway Transportation Operations, Univ. of Calif., Berkeley, Inst. for Transportation Studies, UCITS-P-87-1, 1987, pp. 82-93.
- Tomkewitsch, Romuald von, “The Traffic Guidance System: ALI-SCOUT,” Technology Options for Highway Transportation Operations, Univ. of Calif., Berkeley, Inst. for Transportation Studies, UCITS-P-87-1, 1987, pp. 130-142.
- Jeffery, D. J., Russam K., and Robertson D. I., “Electronic Route Guidance by AUTOGUIDE: The Research Background.”Traffic Engineering and Control, Vol. 28, No. 10, Oct. 1987, pp. 525-529.
- Evans, G.W., “Environmental Cognition,” Psych. Bul. 88, pp. 259-287.
- Anderson, J.R., and Bower G.F., Human Associative Memory, V.H. Winston, New York, 1973.
- Kosslyn, S.M., “Information Representation in Visual Images,” Cognitive Psychology, Vol. 7, 1975, pp. 341-370.
- Streeter, Lynn A., and Vitello Diane, “A Profile of Drivers' Map-Reading Abilities,” Human Factors, Vol. 28, No. 2, April 1986, pp. 223-239.
- Verwey, W.B., and Janssen W.H., Route Following and Driving Performance with In-Car Route Guidance Systems, Institute for Perception TNO, The Netherlands, Report No. IZF C-14, 1988.
- Allen, R.W., Ziedman D., etc., “Laboratory Assessment of Driver Route Diversion in Response to In-Vehicle Navigation and Motorist Information Systems,” Paper No. 910701, Transportation Research Board, Wash, DC, Jan. 1991.
- Allen, R.W., Stein A.C., et al., “A Human Factors Study of Driver Reaction to In-Vehicle Navigation Systems,” SAE paper No. 911680, Society for Automotive Engineers, August 1991.
- Allen, R. Wade, Stein Anthony C., Hill David, et al, Traffic Signal Display Complexity, Systems Technology, Inc., TR-1204-1, March 1986.
- Krendel, Ezra S., Allen R. Wade, Parseghian Zareh, et al, Pilot Risk Assessment of Windshear Hazards, Systems Technology, Inc., TR-1246-1, Oct. 1988.
- Yeldin, M., Lieberman M., Andrews B., Rathi A., Torres J., TRAF User Guide, KLD Associates, Inc., Contract DTFH61-85-C-00005, March 1988