This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Analysis and Development of A Real-Time Control Methodology in Resistance Spot Welding
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1991 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The single-parameter, in-process monitor and automatic control systems for the resistance spot welding process have been studied by many investigators. Some of these have already been commercialized and used by sheet metal fabricators. These control systems operate primarily on one of the three process parameters: maximum voltage or voltage drop, dynamic resistance, or thermal expansion between electrodes during nugget formation.
Control systems based on voltage or dynamic resistance have been successfully implemented for industrial applications. A great amount of experience on these two control methods has been accumulated through trial-and-error approaches. The expansion-based control system is not commonly utilized due to lack of experience and understanding of the process.
Since the expansion displacement between electrodes during welding responds directly to the weld nugget formation, this control parameter provides a better means to produce more precise spot welds. However, the control algorithm of this method is more complex than that for the other two methods. Fruitful development of a such system can not be obtained by trial-and-error approaches.
This paper presents a systematic approach to develop the expansion-based control algrithm for resistance spot welding. The finite element method was used to simulate the welding process and to determine the physical response of the joint material to the various welding conditions. Direct correlations between nugget formation and expansion displacement between electrodes were obtained.
By systematic computer simulations, the weldability characteristic curves for resistance spot welding were developed. These weldability curves show inadeguate welding conditions which would cause nugget expulsion and current shunting. A welding duration curve, which shows appropriate time for squeeze, weld, and hold cycles, was developed and used as a basis for in-process resistance spot welding control.
CitationTsai, C., Dai, W., and Dickinson, D., "Analysis and Development of A Real-Time Control Methodology in Resistance Spot Welding," SAE Technical Paper 910191, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/910191.
- Greenwood, J. A. “Temperatures in Spot Welding, ” Brit. Weld J. June 1961 316 322
- Andrews, D. R. Dunn, A. Broomhead, J. “ Dynamic Deviation Monitoring for Resistance Welding - a Low Budget System, ” Welding Research International 1976 6 4 1 27
- Hess, W. F. Doty, W. D. Childs, W. J. “The Fundamentals of Spot Welding Steel Plate,” Weld J. 6 10 1947 583s 593s
- Snee, R. K. Taylor, J. L. “Infrared Monitoring of Resistance Spot Welding, ” Metal Construction and Brit. Weld J. April 1972 142 148
- Burbank, G. E. Taylor, W. D. “Ultrasonic In-Process Inspection of Resistance Spot Welds,” Weld J. 44 5 1965 193s
- Wrigley, A. “GM Using Acoustic-Type Adaptive Welding Controls,” American Metal Market /Metalworking News March 21 1977
- Nagel, G. “`,” Paper No. 880371 SAE Conference 1988 Detroit, Michigan
- Janota, M. “Control of Current and Time on the Basis of Weld Nugget,” IIW Dec. III-521-75
- Johnson, K. I. “ Resistance Welding Quality-control Techniques, ” Metal Construction and Brit. Weld J. May 1973 176 181
- Johnson, K. I. Hannah, M. D. Rosewell, S. L. Dinsdale, W. D. “Properties of Splashed Resistance Spot Welds, ” Metal Construction and Brit. Weld J. November 1973 401 406
- Waller, D. N. “ Head Movement as a Means of Resistance Welding Quality Control, ” Metal Construction and Brit. Weld J. 11 3 1964 118 122
- Waller, D. N. Knowlson, P. M. “Electrode Separation Applied to Quality Control in Resistance Welding,” Weld J. 12 4 1965 168s 174s
- Taylor, J. L. Xie, P. “ A New Approach to the Displacement Monitor in Resistance Spot Welding of Mild Steel Sheet,” Metal Construction and Brit. Weld J. Feb. 1987 72 75
- Roberts, W. L. “Resistance Variations During Spot Welding.” Weld J. 10 11 1951 1004 1019
- Towey, M. Andrews, D. R. “Instantaneous Resistance during Spot weld Formation as a Parameter for an Automatic Control System, ” Welding and Metal Fabrication Oct. 1968 383 392
- Needham, J. C. Hannah, M. D. Newling, R. G. “Automatical Quality Control in Resistance Spot Welding of Mild Steel,” Weld Research Int. 1972 2 1 35 69
- Johnson, K. I. Needham, J. C. “New Design of Resistance Spot Welding Machine for Quality Control,” Weld J. 51 3 1972 122s 131s
- Bhattacharya, S. Andrews, D. R. Green, L. W. “In-Process Quality Control of Spot Welding, ” Metal Construction April 1975 277 229
- Havens, J. R. “Controlling Spot Welding Quality and Expulsion, ” SME Paper AD76-279 1976
- Savage, W. F. Nippes, E. F. “Dynamic Contact Resistance of Series Spot Welds,” Weld J. 57 2 1978
- Dickinson, D. W. Franklin, J. E. Stanya, A. “Characterzation of Spot Welding Behavior by Electrical Parameter Monitoring,” Weld J. 59 6 1980 170s 176s
- Kaiser, J. G. Dunn, G. “The Effect of Electrical Resistance on Nugget Formation during Spot Welding, ” Weld J. 61 6 1982 167s 174s
- Gedeon, S. A. Ulrich, K. T. Eagar, T. W. “Measurement of Dynamic Electrical and Mechanical Properties of Resistance Spot Welding, ” Weld J. 65 12 1987 378s 385s
- Bowden, F. P. Williamson, J. B. P. “Electrical Conduction in Solid-I: Influence of the Passage of Current on the Contact Between Solids, ” Proc. Rov. Soc. Aug. 1958 1 12
- Greenwood, J. A. Williamson, J. B. H. “Electrical Conduction in Solid-II: Theory of Temperature-dependent Conductors, ” Proc. Rov. Soc. London Aug. 1958 13 31
- Archer, G. R. “Calculation for Temperature Response in Spot Welds,” Weld J. 19 8 1960 327s 330s
- Bentley, K. P. Greenwood, J. A. Knowlson, P. M. Backer, R. G. “Temperature Distributions in Spot welds,” Brit. Weld J. 1963 613 619
- Dix, A. F. J. “Metallurgical Study of Resistance Weld Nugget Formation and Stuck Welds, ” Brit. Weld J. January 1968 7 16
- Rice, W. Funk, E. J. “An Analytical Investigation of the Temperature Distributions During Welding,” Weld J. 46 4 1967 175s 186s
- Houchen, A. F. Page, R. E. Yang, W. H. “Numerical Modeling of Resistance Spot Welding, ” Numerical Modeling Manufacturing Processes, ASME Winter Conference Nov. 27 Dec. 2 1977 117 129
- Gould, J. E. “An Examination of Nugget Development during Spot Welding Using Both Experimental and Analytical Techniques,” Weld J. 65 1 1987 1s 10s
- Cho, H. S. Cho, Y. J. “A Study of Thermal Behavior in Resistance Spot Welds,” Weld J. 67 6 1989 236s 244s
- Han, Z. Orozco, J. E. Chen, C. H. “Resistance Spot Welding: A Heat Transfer Study, ” Weld J. 67 9 1989 363s 371s
- Nied, H. A. “The Finite Element Modeling of the Resistance Spot Welding Process,” Weld J. 63 4 1984 123s 132s
- Dickinson, D. W. Tsai, C. L. Jammal, O. “Modeling of Resistance Spot Weld Nugget Growth-Applications for the Automotive Industry, ” International Congress and Exposition Detroit, Michigan Feb. 26 Mar. 2 1990
- Metals Handbook 1 2
- Resistance Welding Manual RWMA December 1989
- Dickinson, D. W. “Welding in the Automotive Industry “American Iron and Steel Institute August 1981
- Jammal, O. A. “Analysis of Stress Distribution and Nugget Formation in Resistance Spot Welding Process, ” M.S. Thesis Ohio State University 1988
- Tabor, D. “The Hardness of Metals,” Oxford at the Clarendon Press 1951
- O'Neil Hug “Hardness Measurement of Metals and Alloys,” Barnes & Noble, Inc. 1967
- Holm, R. “Electric Contact Theory and Application, ” New York 1967 21 25
- White, M. W. “An Investication into the Dynamic Resistance Curves Generated during the Resistance Spot Welding of Prepainted Sheet Steels,” M.S. Thesis Ohio State University 1986
- Waters, D. G. “The Design of Resistance Welding Feedback Controllers, ” M.S. Thesis Ohio State University 1985