This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Change in Performance of Engine Oils with Degradation
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 01, 1990 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A bench test was performed with Toyota 1500 cc OHC engines using a modified AMA mode in order to determine the change in performance, such as oxidation stability, thermal stability and antiwear performance, of gasoline engine oils as a consequence of their degradation. For the purpose of analyzing the relationship between the degradation of engine oils and their performance in detail, engine tests were performed without any new oil supply. The remaining performance of used oils was discussed in connection with both the degradation of engine oils and the depletion of oxidation inhibitors.
The oxidation inhibitors, such as ZDTP, diarylamine and high molecular weight phenol, remaining in used oils were measured quantitatively with liquid chromatography. Oxidation stability, thermal stability and antiwear performance were measured with TFOUT, the hot tube test and the four ball test, respectively.
It was found that the higher the temperature, the larger the rate of depletion of the oxidation inhibitors. In particular, the duration at high revolution speeds in which the sump temperature was raised up to 115° C accelerated the depletion of the oxidation inhibitors, resulting in the degradation of oils. The order of the rate of additive depletion was ZDTP > diarylamine > high molecular weight phenol, which corresponded to the thermal stability of these additives.
The remaining oxidation stability of the used oils decreased gradually with the depletion of oxidation inhibitors; however, an adequate stability was observed even after the complete depletion of the additives. This might be explained as that the decomposition products of ZDTP could also act as an oxidation inhibitor in oils. The antiwear performance decreased rapidly within 50 h of the test and then decreased with the increase in the total acid number of the oils, probably because of corrosive wear. The thermal stability also decreased slightly around 150 h and then decreased rapidly when the total base number of the used oil dropped to less than 2.5 mgKOH/g.
|Technical Paper||Nitro-Oxidation of Lubricating Oil in Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine|
|Technical Paper||Field Test Data Analysis Techniques|
|Technical Paper||The Effect of Base Stock Composition on Lubricant Performance|
CitationInoue, K. and Yamanaka, Y., "Change in Performance of Engine Oils with Degradation," SAE Technical Paper 902122, 1990, https://doi.org/10.4271/902122.
- Korcek S. Johnson M.D. Jensen R.K. Zinbo M. “Determination of the high-temperature antioxidant capability of lubricants and lubricant components” Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. Dev. 25 621 1986
- Johnson M.D. Korcek S. Zinbo M. “Inhibition of oxidation by ZDTP and ashless antioxidants in the presence of hydroperoxides at 160°C-Part 1” SAE Paper 831684 1983
- Johnson M.D. Korcek S. Zinbo M. “Inhibition of oxidation by ZDTP and ashless antioxidants in the presence of hydroperoxides at 160°C-Part 2” ASLE Trans. 29 136 1986
- Johnson M.D. Korcek S. Zinbo M. “High-temperature antioxidant capabilities of base oils and base oil-additive mixtures” Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 26 1754 1987
- Hsu S.M. Ku C.S. Pei P.T. “Oxidative degradation mechanisms of lubricant” ASTM Spec. Tech. Pubi. 916 27 1986
- Nakamura K. Matsumoto E. Kurosaka S. Murakami Y. “Effect of ventilation and lubricants on sludge formation in passenger car gasoline engines” SAE Paper 881577 1988
- Hanson J.B. Harris S.W. West C.T. “Factors influencing lubricant performance in the sequence V E test” SAE Paper 881581 1988
- Kawamura M. Moritani H. Nakada M. Oohori M. “Sludge formation and engine oil dispersancy evaluation with a laboratory scale sludge simulator” SAE Paper 892105 1989
- Hsu S.M. “Review of laboratory bench tests in assessing the performance of automotive crankcase oils” Lubr. Eng. 37 722 1981
- Ku C.S. Hsu H.S. “A thin film oxygen uptake test for the evaluation of automotive crankcase lubricants” Lubr. Eng. 40 75 1984
- Ohkawa S. Seto K. Nakashima T. Takase K. “Hot tube test-analysis of lubricant effect on diesel engine scuffing” SAE paper 840262 1984
- Korcek S. Mahoney L.R. Johnson M.D. Hofman S. “Antioxidant decay in engine oils during laboratory test and long drain interval service” SAE Paper 780955 1978
- Mahoney L.R. Otto K. Korcek S. Johnson M.D. “The effect of fuel combustion products on antioxidant consumption in a synthetic engine oil” Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. Dev. 19 11 1980
- Willermet P.A. Kandah S.K. “Lubricant degradation and wear V. Reaction products of a zinc dialkyldithiophosphate and peroxy radicals” ASLE Trans. 27 67 1984
- Paddy J.L. Lee N.C.J. Waters D.N. “Zinc dialkyldithiophosphate oxidation by cumene hydroperoxide: Kinetic studies by raman and 31 P-NMR spectroscopy” Tribology Trans. 33 15 1990
- Korcek S. Mahoney L.R. Johnson M.D. Siegel W.O. “Mechanisms of antioxidant decay in gasoline engines: Investigations of zinc dialkyldithiophosphate additives” SAE paper 810014 1981
- Yamada Y. Inoue K. “Effect of metallic detergents on antiwear performance of ZDTP” Proc. 33th Spring Mtg. Jap. Soc. Lub. Eng. 61 1989
- Mun U. Kimura Y. Okada K. “Wear test in degraded engine oil II” Proc. 33th Spring Mtg. Jap. Soc. Lub. Eng. 57 1989
- Mun U. Kimura Y. “Wear test in degraded engine oil: Effect of model degraded compound” Pcoc. 34th Spring Mtg. Jap. Soc. Lub. Eng. 585 1990