This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Methodology for Validating Vehicle Dynamics Simulations
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1990 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper presents a methodology for validating vehicle stability and control computer simulations. Validation is defined as showing that, within some specified operating range of the vehicle, a simulation's predictions of a vehicle's responses agree with the actual measured vehicle's responses to within some specified level of accuracy. The method uses repeated experimental runs at each test condition to generate sufficient data for statistical analyses. The acquisition and reduction of experimental data, and the processing path for simulation data, are described. The usefulness of time domain validation for steady state and slowly varying transients is discussed. The importance of frequency domain validation for thoroughly validating a simulation is shown. Both qualitative and quantitative methods for the comparison of the simulation predictions with the actual test measurements are developed.
To illustrate the validation methodology, experimental testing of four different vehicles was performed; with the results being compared with predictions made by two existing vehicle stability and control simulations. Constant steer, braking in a turn, straight line braking, double lane change, and sinusoidal sweep steering maneuvers of varying severity were performed to study simulation validity for a wide range of vehicle operating conditions. Comparisons between the actual test measurements and the simulation predictions are shown.
CitationHeydinger, G., Garrott, W., Chrstos, J., and Guenther, D., "A Methodology for Validating Vehicle Dynamics Simulations," SAE Technical Paper 900128, 1990, https://doi.org/10.4271/900128.
- SegalD.J., “Highway Vehicle-Object Simulation Model,” DOT FHWA-RD-76-165, Calspan Corporation, February 1976.
- BohnP.F., and KeenanR.J., “Hybrid Computer Vehicle Handling Program,” DOT HS-802-059, Applied Physics Laboratory, The Johns Hopkins University, July 1976.
- BohnP.F., and KeenanR.J., “Improved Hybrid Computer Vehicle Handling Program.” DOT HS-805-031, Applied Physics Laboratory, The Johns Hopkins University, October 1978.
- GarrottW.R., and ScottR.A., “Improvement of Mathematical Models for Simulation of Vehicle Handling - Volume 7: Technical Manual for the General Simulation,” DOT HS-805-370, The University of Michigan College of Engineering, March 1980.
- AllenR.W., RosenthalT.J., and SzostakH.T., “Steady State and Transient Analysis of Ground Vehicle Handling,” 1987 SAE International Congress and Exposition, Detroit, Michigan, February 1987.
- AllenR.W.et. al., “Test Methods and Computer Modeling for the Analysis of Ground Vehicle Handling,” SAE Technical Paper Series, West Coast International Meeting, Universal City, California, August 1986.
- DoebelinErnest O., “System Modeling and Response-Theoretical and Experimental Approaches,” John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1980.
- GarrottW.R., ChrstosJ.P., and MonkM.W., “Vehicle Inertial Parameters-Measured Values and Approximations,” SAE Paper 881767, 1988.
- EllisJ.R., BellS.C., GarrottW.R., and LiaoY.C., “Suspension Testing Using the Suspension Parameter Measurement Device,” SAE Paper 870577, 1987.
- WolaninW.J., and BaptistT.A., “Road Transducer - Objective Brake Balance Measurement Without Vehicle Instrumentation,” SAE Paper 870266, 1987.
- TapiaG.A., “Extended Tire Testing,” DOT 6871-V-1, Calspan Corporation, November 1983.
- SmithN.P., “Transient Control Response of Automobiles,” Proceedings of 5th VSD-2nd IUTAM Symposium, Technical University Vienna, Austria, September 19-23, 1977.
- SegelL., and MacAdamC., “The Influence of the Steering System on the Directional Response to Steering,” 10th IAVSD Symposium, Prague, Czechoslovakia, August 1987.
- DoebelinErnest O., “Control System -Principles and Design,” John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1985.
- NisongerR.L., and FancherP.S., “Transient Directional Response Test Procedures for Automobiles,” Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association Project 1149, UM-HSRI-81-36, July 1981.
- AllenR.W., RosenthalT.J., and SzostakH.T., “Analytical Modeling of Driver Response in Crash Avoidance Maneuvering, Volume I: Technical Background,” DOT HS-807-270, Systems Technology, Inc., April 1988.
- RogersL.C., and BrewerH.K., “Synthesis of Tire Equations for Use in Shimmy and Other Dynamic Studies,” Journal of Aircraft. Volume 8, No. 9, September 1971.
- WeberR., and PerschH.G., “Frequency Response of Tires-Slip Angle and Lateral Force,” SAE Paper 760030. Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition, Detroit, February 23-27, 1976.