This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Classical Combustion Diagnostics for Engine Research
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The use of engine diagnostic techniques in research on the reciprocating internal combustion engine has contributed substantially to engine progress over the years. Many of these techniques were developed before the advent of the laser, and most engine research still uses these classical methods. This paper provides historical snapshots of efforts to understand flame propagation and knock in homogeneous-charge engines, and fuel-air mixing and some of its ramifications in diesels. Such a review demonstrates the accomplishments facilitated by measurement of pressure, temperature, fluid motions, and chemistry within the cylinder. A critique of these classical diagnostics is then offered.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Amann, C., "Classical Combustion Diagnostics for Engine Research," SAE Technical Paper 850395, 1985, https://doi.org/10.4271/850395.Also In
References
- Amann, C. A. “A. Perspective of Re-ciprocating-Engine Diagnostics Without Lasers,” Prog. in Energy and Combust. Sci. 9 239 267 1983
- Clerk, D. “The Theory of the Gas-Engine,” Proc. Instn. of Civil Engrs. 69 220 250 1882
- Bryant, L. “The Origin of the Auto-mobile Engine,” Scientific American 216 102 110 1967
- Clerk, D. “Cylinder Actions in Gas and Gasoline Engines,” SAE Journal 8 523 539 1921
- Clerk, D. “On the Limits of Thermal Efficiency in Internal-Combustion Motors,” Proc. Instn. Civil Engrs. 169 121 152 1907
- Hopkinson, B. “The Effect of Mixture Strength and Scavenging upon Thermal Efficiency,” Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs. 417 453 1908
- Tizard H. T. Pye, D. R. “The Character of Various Fuels for Internal Combustion Engines -- The Influences of Specific Heat and Dissociation of the Working Fluid,” Empire Motor Fuels Committee Report, Instn. Automobile Engrs. 46 1 47 1923
- Ricardo, H. R. “Some Early Reminiscences,” SAE Trans. 63 620 627 1955
- Boyd, T. A. “Pathfinding in Fuels and Engines,” SAE Trans. 4 182 195 1950
- Marvin, C. F. Jr. “Combustion Time in the Engine Cylinder and Its Effect on Engine Performance,” NACA Report 276 1927
- MacKenzie D. Honaman, R. K. “The Velocity of Flame Propagation in Engine Cylinders,” SAE Trans. 15 299 317 1920
- Schnauffer, K. “Engine-Cylinder Flame-Propagation Studied by New Method,” SAE Journal (Trans.) 34 17 24 1934
- Withrow, L. Lovell W. G. Boyd, T. A. “Following Combustion by Chemical Means,” Ind. Eng. Chem. 22 945 951 1930
- Glyde, H. S. “Experiments to Determine Velocities of Flame Propagation in a Side Valve Petrol Engine,” J. Inst. Petroleum Technologists 16 756 776 1930
- Withrow L. Boyd, T. A. “Photographic Flame Studies in the Gasoline Engine,” Ind. Eng. Chem. 23 539 547 1931
- Marvin, C. F. Jr. Best, R. D. “Flame Movement and Pressure Development in an Engine Cylinder,” NACA Report 399 1931
- Withrow L. Rassweiler, G. M. “Slow Motion Shows Knocking and Non-Knocking Explosions,” SAE Journal (Trans.) 39 297 303 1936
- Rassweiler G. M. Withrow, L. “Motion Pictures of Engine Flames Correlated with Pressure Cards,” SAE Journal (Trans.) 42 185 204 1938
- Miller, C. D. “Roles of Detonation Waves and Autoignition in Spark-Ignition Engine -- Knock as Shown by Photographs Taken at 40,000 and 200,000 Frames per Sec,” SAE Trans. 1 98 143 1947
- Curry, S. “The Relationship Between Flame Propagation and Pressure Development During Knocking Combustion,” SAE Paper 647B 1963
- Curry, S. “A Three-Dimensional Study of Flame Propagation in a Spark Ignition Engine,” SAE Trans. 71 628 646 1963
- Withrow L. Rassweiler, G. M. “Spectroscopic Studies of Engine Combustion,” Ind. Eng. Chem. 23 769 776 1931
- Rassweiler G. M. Withrow, L. “Emission Spectra of Engine Flames,” Ind. Eng. Chem 24 528 538 1932
- Withrow L. Rassweiler, G. M. “Absorption Spectra of Gaseous Charges in a Gasoline Engine,” Ind. Eng. Chem. 25 923 931 1933
- Rassweiler G. M. Withrow, L. “Spectrographic Detection of Formaldehyde in an Engine Prior to Knock,” Ind. Eng. Chem. 25 1359 1366 1933
- Withrow L. Rassweiler, G. M. “Formaldehyde Formation in Preflame Reactions in an Engine,” Ind. Eng. Chem. 26 1256 1262 1934
- Downs, D. Walsh A. D. Wheeler, R. W. “A Study of the Reactions that Lead to ‘Knock’ in the Spark-Ignition Engine,” Phil. Trans. of the Royal Soc. London Series A, 243 463 521 1951
- Midgley, T. Jr., “The Combustion of Fuels in the Internal-Combustion Engine,” SAE Journal 7 489 497 1920
- Cornelius W. Caplan, J. D. “Some Effects of Fuel Structure, Tetraethyl Lead, and Engine Deposits on Precombustion Reactions in a Firing Engine,” SAE Trans. 6 488 508 1952
- Rassweiler G. M. Withrow, L. “Flame Temperatures Vary with Knock and Combustion-Chamber Position,” SAE Journal (Trans.) 36 125 133 1935
- Hopkinson, B. “The Explosion of Gaseous Mixtures, and the Specific Heat of the Products,” Engineering London 71 777 778 1906
- Wakil, M. M. El Myers P. S. Uyehara, O. A. “An Instantaneous and Continuous Sodium-Line Reversal Pyrometer,” ASME Trans. 74 255 264 1952
- Millar, G. H. Winans, J. G. Uyehara, O. A. “A Fast, Electro-Optical, Hot-Gas Pyrometer,” J. Optical Society of America 43 609 617 1953
- Chen, S. K. Beck, N. J. Uyehara O. A. Myers, P. S. “Compression and End-Gas Temperatures from Iodine Absorption Spectra,” SAE Trans. 62 503 513 1954
- Burrows, M. C. Shimizu, S. Myers P. S. Uyehara, O. A. “The Measurement of Unburned Gas Temperatures in an Engine by an Infrared Radiation Pyrometer,” SAE Trans. 69 514 528 1961
- Agnew, W. G. “End Gas Temperature Measurement by a Two-Wavelength Infrared Radiation Measurement,” SAE Trans. 68 495 513 1960
- Livengood, J. C. Taylor C. F. Wu, P. C. “Measurement of Gas Temperature in an Engine by the Velocity of Sound Method,” SAE Trans. 66 683 695 1958
- Wlenke, H. J. Myers P. S. Uyehara, O. A. “A Resistance Thermometer for Engine Compression Temperatures,” SAE Paper 701A 1963
- Meyer W. E. DeCarolis, J. J. “Compression Temperatures in Diesel Engines Under Starting Conditions,” SAE Trans. 70 163 174 1962
- Tsao, K. C. Myers P. S. Uyehara, O. A. “Gas Temperatures During Compression in Motored and Fired Diesel Engines,” SAE Trans. 70 136 145 1962
- Horning, H. L. “Turbulence,” SAE Journal 8 579 587 1921
- Semenov, E. S. “Studies of Turbulent Gas Flow in Piston Engines,” Otdelenie Tekhnicheskikh Nauk 1958 (NASA Technical Translation F-97, 1963)
- Lancaster, D. R. “Effects of Engine Variables on Turbulence in a Spark-Ignition Engine,” SAE Trans. 85 671 688 760159 1976
- Lancaster, D. R. Krieger, R. B. Sorenson S. C. Hull, W. L. “Effects of Turbulence on Spark-Ignition Engine Combustion,” SAE Trans. 85 689 710 760160 1976
- Groff E. G. Matekunas, F. A. “The Nature of Turbulent Flame Propagation in a Homogeneous Spark-Ignited Engine,” SAE Trans. 89 740 764 800133 1980
- Blizard N. C. Keck, J. C. “Experimental and Theoretical Investigation of Turbulent Burning Model for Internal Combustion Engines,” SAE Trans. 83 846 863 740191 1974
- Arrigoni, V. Cornetti, G. M. Gerbaz, G. P. Giavazzi F. Pozzi, U. “Chemi-Ionization and Carbon in a Spark Ignition Engine,” SAE Trans. 83 865 884 740192 1974
- Ricardo, H. R. “Diesel Engines,” Howard Lecture to the Royal Society of Arts London 23
- Eisele, E. “Daimler-Benz Passenger Car Diesel Engines — Highlights of 30 Years of Development,” SAE Paper 680089 1968
- Hofbauer P. Sator, K. “Advanced Automotive Power Systems, Part 2: A Diesel for Subcompact Cars,” SAE Trans. 86 400 445 770113 1977
- Jones, J. H. Kingsbury, W. L. Lyon, H. H. Mutty P. R. Thurston, K. W. “Development of a 5.7 Litre V8 Automotive Diesel Engine,” SAE Trans. 87 1930 1946 780412 1978
- Ephraim, M. Jr. Kotlin J. J. Williams, H. A. Jr. “A Versatile Two-Cycle Diesel Engine — The EMD Model 645 Series,” ASME Paper 76-DGP-5 1976
- Cichocki R. Cartellieri, W. “The Passenger Car Direct Injection Diesel — A Performance and Emissions Update,” SAE Paper 310480 1981
- Neitz, A. “The M.A.N. Combustion System in the Passenger Car Diesel Engine,” SAE Paper 770434 1977
- Rothrock A. M. Waldron, C. D. “Some Effects of Injection Advance Angle, Engine-Jacket Temperature, and Speed on Combustion in a Compression-Ignition Engine,” NACA Technical Report No. 525 1935
- Ricardo, H. R. “Combustion in Diesel Engines,” Proc. Instn. Automobile Engrs. 24 645 665 1930
- Nagao F. Kakimoto, H. “Swirl and Combustion in Divided Combustion Chamber Type Diesel Engines,” SAE Trans. 70 680 696 1962
- Alcock J. Scott, W. “Some More Light on Diesel Combustion,” Proc. instn. Mech. Eng. 179 191 1962
- Scott, W. M. “Looking in on Diesel Combustion,” SAE Trans. 78 33 48 690002 1969
- Lyn W. T. Valdmanis, E. “The Application of High-Speed Schlieren Photography to Diesel Combustion Research,” J. of Photo. Sci. 10 74 82 1962
- Ohigashi, S. Hamamoto Y. Tanabe, S. “Swirl — Its Measurement and Effect on Combustion in a Diesel Engine,” Paper C134/71, Instn. Mech. Eng. Conference on Air Pollution Control in Transport Engines 1971
- Ahmad, T. Groff E. G. Myers, J. P. “A Spark-Discharge Probe for Velocity Measurements In Engines,” presented at ASME Winter Annual Meeting New Orleans 1984
- Ahmad, T. Myers J. P. Groff, E. G. “Velocity Measurements in a Diesel Prechamber Using Spark-Discharge Velocity Probes,” presented at ASME Winter Annual Meeting New Orleans 1984
- Hiroyasu, H. Kato, T. Takahashi N. Takahashi, M. “Measurement of Air Swirl in Combustion Chamber Using Electric Discharge,” Bull. JSAE 2 41 50 1970
- Maly, R. Meinel H. Wagner, E. “Novel Method for Determining General Flow Parameters from Conventional Spark Discharges,” Instn, of Mech. Eng. Paper C67/83, Combustion in Engineering 1 27 32 1983
- Chen, L. L. Myers P. S. Uyehara, O. A. “Air Velocity Measurements in Engines by Vortex Shedding,” SAE Trans. 83 3297 3317 741057 1974
- Elkotb, M. M. Ellail M. M. M. Abou Salem, I. “Influence of Swirl Chamber Geometry on Turbulence in Multifuel Engines,” Instn. of Mech. Eng. Paper C55/83, Combustion in Engineering 1 101 112 1983
- Jessel A. J. Borman, G. L. “A Tracer Technique for Measuring Gas Motion in a Fired Diesel Engine Cylinder,” SAE Paper 800134 1980
- Sinnamon, J. F. Lancaster D. R. Steiner, J. C. “An Experimental and Analytical Study of Engine Fuel-Spray Trajectories,” SAE Trans. 89 765 785 800135 1980
- Matekunas, F. A. “A Schlieren Study of Combustion in a Rapid Compression Machine Simulating the Spark Ignition Engine,” 17th Symp. (International) on Combustion 1283 1293 1979
- Elkotb, M. M. “Fuel Atomization for Spray Modeling,” Prog. in Energy and Combust. Sci. 8 61 91 1982
- Urlaub A. Muller, E. “Experimental and Theoretical Investigations into the Question of the Exhaust Gas Quality of M-Diesel Engines,” Proceedings of CIMAC 457 483 1973
- Klanner, W. “Experimentelle und theoretische Untersuchung der Kraftstoffilmverdampfung im Dieselmotor,” doctoral thesis, Technical University of Munich 1971
- Uyehara, O. A. Myers, P. S. Watson K. M. Wilson, L. A. “Flame-Temperature Measurements in Internal Combustion Engines,” ASME Trans. 68 17 28 1946
- Matsui, Y. Kamimoto T. Matsuoka, S. “A Study of the Application of the Two-Color Method to the Measurement of Flame Temperature and Soot Concentration in Diesel Engines,” SAE Trans. 89 3043 3055 800970 1980
- Ogasawara M. Sami, H. “A Study on the Behavior of a Fuel Droplet Injected into a Combustion Chamber of a Diesel Engine,” SAE Trans. 76 1690 1707 670468 1967
- Harrington, D. L. “Interactions of Direct-Injection Fuel Sprays with In-Cylinder Air Motions,” SAE Paper 831728 1983
- Peterson R. C. Alkidas, A. C. “A Visual Study of Divided-Chamber Diesel Combustion Using a Rapid Compression Machine,” Comb. and Flame 53 65 81 1983
- Nightingale, D. R. “A Fundamental Investigation into the Problem of NO Formation in Diesel Engines,” SAE Trans. 84 2196 2212 750848 1975
- Bennethum, J. E. Mattavi J. N. Toepel, R. R. “Combustion Chamber Sampling-Hardware Procedures and Data Interpretation,” SAE Trans. 84 2213 2238 750849 1975
- Duggal, V. K. Priede T. Khan, I. M. “A Study of Pollutant Formation within the Combustion Space of a Diesel Engine,” SAE Trans. 87 987 1014 780227 1978
- Voiculescu I. A. Borman, G. L. “An Experimental Study of Diuesel Engine Cylinder -- Averaged NOx Histories,” SAE Trans. 87 1001 1014 780228 1978
- Liu X. Kittelson, D. B. “Total Cylinder Sampling from a Diesel Engine (Part II),” SAE Paper 820360 1982
- Ahmad T. Plee, S. L. “Using a Tracer-Gas Technique to Study Combustion and Mixing in a Diesel Engine,” presented at meeting of The Combustion Inst./Central States Section 1984
- Krieger R. B. Borman, G. L. “The Computation of Apparent Heat Release for Internal Combustion Engines,” ASME Paper 66-WA/DGP-4 1966
- Kerley R. V. Thurston, K. W. “The Indicated Performance of Otto-Cycle Engines,” SAE Trans. 70 5 30 1962
- Tuttle J. H. Toepel, R. R. “Increased Burning Rates Offer Improved Fuel Economy-NOx Emissions Trade-Offs in Spark-Ignition Engines,” SAE Trans. 88 1400 1412 790388 1979
- Wade W. R. Jones, C. R. “Current and Future Light Duty Diesel Engines and Their Fuels,” SAE Paper 840105 1984
- Midgley, T. Jr., “High-Speed Indicators,” SAE Trans. 15 317 326 1920
- Gish, R. E. McCullogh, J. D. Retzloff J. B. Mueller, H. T. “Determination of True Engine Friction,” SAE Trans. 66 649 661 1958
- Brown, W. L. “Methods for Evaluating Requirements and Errors in Cylinder Pressure Measurement,” SAE Trans. 76 50 71 1967
- Draper C. S. Li, Y. T. “New High-Speed Indicator of Strain-Gage Type,” J. Aero. Sci. 16 593 610 1949
- Lancaster, D. R. Krieger R. B. Lienesch, J. H. “Measurement and Analysis of Engine Pressure Date,” SAE Trans. 84 155 169 750026 1975
- Millar, G. H. Uyehara O. A. Myers, P. S. “Practical Application of Flame Temperature Measurements,” SAE Trans. 62 514 524 1954
- Lienesch J. H. Krage, M. K. “Using Microwaves to Phase Cylinder Pressure to Crankshaft Position,” SAE Trans. 88 410 418 790103 1979
- D’Alleva B. A. Lovell, W. G. “Relation of Exhaust Gas Composition to Air-Fuel Ratio,” SAE Trans. 38 90 96 1936
- Papa, L. J. “Gas Chromatography --Measuring Exhaust Hydrocarbons Down to Parts per Billion,” SAE Trans. 76 1797 1815 670494 1967
- Spanogle J. A. Buckley, E. C. “The N.A.C.A. Combustion Chamber Gas-Sampling Valve and Some Preliminary Test Results,” NACA Tech. Note No. 454, 1933
- LoRusso, J. A. Lavoie G. A. Kaiser, E. W. “An Electrohydraulic Gas Sampling Valve with Application to Hydrocarbon Emissions Studies,” SAE Trans. 89 304 323 800045 1980
- Henningsen S. Qvale, B. “Experimental Determination of the Flame Quenching Distance in a Spark-Ignition Engine,” SAE Paper 800104 1980
- Rhee, K. T. Borman, G. L. Uyehara O. A. Myers, P. S. “A Continuous-Flow Gas Sampling System for Engines,” Comb. Sci. Tech. 12 105 109 1976
- Rhee, K. T. Myers P. S. Uyehara, O. A. “Time- and Space-Resolved Species Determination in Diesel Combustion Using Continuous Flow Sampling,” SAE Trans. 87 959 986 780226 1978
- Turns S. R. Borman, G. L. “An Estimation of Quench-Gas Bias in Internal Combustion Engine In-Cylinder Sampling.” Comb. and Flame 39 97 109 1980
- Johnston S. C. Green, R. M. “Engine Hydrocarbon Concentration Measurements: A Comparison Between a Sampling Probe and Raman Spectroscopy,” SAE Paper 820499 1982
- Bowditch, F. W. “A New Tool for Combustion Research -- A Quartz Piston Engine,” SAE Trans. 69 17 23 1961
- Groff E. G. Sinnamon, J. F. “The Effects of Ignition Location in a Swirl Field on Homogeneous-Charge Combustion,” SAE Trans. 91 3838 3855 821221 1982
- Johnston, S. C. Robinson, C. W. Rorke, W. S. Smith J. R. Witze, P.O. “Application of Laser Diagnostics to an Injected Engine,” SAE Trans. 88 353 370 790092 1979
- Steinberger, R. L. Marden W. W. Bracco, F. V. “A Pulsed-Illumination, Closed-Circuit Television System for Real-Time Viewing of Engine Combustion and Observed Cyclic Variation,” SAE Paper 790093 1979
- Namazian, N. Hansen, S. Lyford-Pike, E. Sanches-Barsse, S. Heywood J. Rife, J. “Schlieren Visualization of the Flow and Density Fields in the Cylinder of a Spark-Ignition Engine,” SAE Trans. 89 276 303 800044 1980
- Werlberger P. Cartellieri, W. “High Speed Combustion Photography in Actual Diesel Engines -- A New Approach,” ISATA 83 Proceedings 1 143 160 1983
- Dyer, T. M. “New Experimental Techniques for In-Cylinder Engine Studies,” SAE Paper 850396 1985