This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Full-Scale, Ort-Road Study of the Effect of Automobile Shape on its Aerodynamic Characteristics, and Comparison with Small-Scale Wind Tunnel Results
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1985 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The design of passenger vehicles for improved aerodynamic characteristics will result in reduced fuel consumption and better road handling during high-speed driving. In this research, techniques were developed to measure the aerodynamic drag and lift forces acting on a full-scale vehicle under road conditions and then were compared with results obtained on reduced-scale models in a wind tunnel. A number of configurations which characterize common vehicle forms were investigated for their effect on aerodynamic efficiency and fuel consumption, Experimental speeds were between 70 and 110 km/h, these being representative of highway driving conditions.
A typical passenger vehicle of the three-box type was selected for the experiments, and its exterior form was altered by means of attaching various configurations to its front, rear, and underbody portions. These additions transformed the original vehicle into a “fast-back” and “station wagon,” and were used in combination with underbody alterations, such as front spoiler, side skirts, and smooth underbody. During road experiments, drag force was measured by means of a telemetric system receiving data on drive-shaft strains, whereas lift forces were measured by relative vertical displacements in the front and rear suspensions.
Statistical analyses showed that the different configurations had a significant effect on the aerodynamic forces. The change in configurations brought about a maximum reduction in drag coefficient (CD) of 51%, relative to the original vehicle. As a result, fuel consumption was reduced by 13% (at 110 km/h). Lift forces dropped by as much as 47%. The most effective components were a smooth underbody and a “fast-back” form for drag, and a smooth underbody and front spoiler for low lift. Results of the road experiments showed a reasonable correlation with those obtained using reduced-scale models in a wind tunnel.
CitationFanger-Vexler, S., Katz, J., and Foux, A., "Full-Scale, Ort-Road Study of the Effect of Automobile Shape on its Aerodynamic Characteristics, and Comparison with Small-Scale Wind Tunnel Results," SAE Technical Paper 850287, 1985, https://doi.org/10.4271/850287.
- Buchheim, R. Deutenbach, K. R. Luckoff, H. J. “Necessity and Premises for Reducing the Aerodynamic Drag of Future Passenger Cars,” SAE 81-0185 1981
- Janssen, L. J. Smmelmann, H. J. “Aerodynamic Improvements-A Great Potential for Better Fuel Economy,” SAE 78-0265 1978
- Hucho, W. H. Janssen, L. J. Emmelman, H. J. “The Optimization of Body Details-A Method for Reducing the Aerodynamic Drag of Road Vehicles,” SAE 76-0185 1976
- Losito, V. De Nicola, C. Albertoni, S. Berta, C. “Numerical Solutions of Potential and Viscous Flows Around Road Vehicles,” International Journal of Vehicle Design Technological Advances in Vehicle Design Series, SP3, Impact of Aerodynamics on Vehicle Design 1983 429 440
- Chometon, F. “Calculating Three-Dimensional Separated Flow Around Road Vehicles,” International Journal of Vehicle Design Technological Advances in Vehicle Design Series, SP3, Impact of Aerodynamics on Vehicle Design 1983 374 386
- Markatos, N. G. “The Theoretical Prediction of External Aerodynamics of Road Vehicles,” International Journal of Vehicle Design Technological Advances In Vehicle Design Series, SP3, Impact of Aerodynamics on Vehicle Design 1983 387 400
- Mason, W. T., Jr. Sovran, G. “Ground Plane Effects on the Aerodynamic Characteristics of Automobile Models-An Examination of Wind Tunnel Test Technique,” Advances in Road Vehicle Aerodynamics BHRA Fluid Engineering 1973 291 310
- Hucho, W. H. Janssen, L. J. Schwarz, G. “The Wind Tunnel's Ground Plane Boundary Layer-Its Interference with the Flow Underneath the Cars,” SAE 75-0066 February 1975
- Gross, D. S. Sekscienski, W. S. “Some Problems Concerning Wind Tunnel Testing of Automotive Vehicles,” SAE 66-0385 June 1966
- Beauvais, F. N. Tignor, S. C. Turner, T. R. “Problems of Ground Simulation in Automobile Aerodynamics,” SAE 68-0121 1968
- Roussillon, G. “Contribution to Accurate Measurement of Aerodynamic Drag on a Moving Vehicle From Coast-Down Tests and Determination of Actual Rolling Resistance,” Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics 9 1981 33 48
- Korst, H. H. White, R. A. “Evaluation of Vehicle Drag Parameters From Coast-Down Experiments Conducted Under Nonideal Environmental Conditions,” Journal of Fluids Engineering 103 March 1981 133 140
- Sovran, G. “The Effect of Ambient Wind on a Road Vehicle's Aerodynamic Work Requirement and Fuel Consumption,” SAE 84-0298 February 1984
- Duncan, D. B. “Multiple Range and Multiple F Tests,” Biometrics 11 1955 1 42
- Fanger-Vexler, S. “Experimental Study on the Effect of Vehicle Shape on Aerodynamic Drag and Lift Forces,” Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Technion, I.I.T. Haifa, Israel March 1984
- Hucho, W. H. “The Aerodynamic Drag of Cars, Current Understanding, Unresolved Problems and Future Prospects,” Symp. on Aerodynamic Drag Mechanisms of Bluff Bodies and Road Vehicles General Motors Warren, Michigan 1971 Plenum Press 1978 7 10
- Morel, T. “Aerodynamic Drag of Bluff Body Shapes Characteristic of Hatch-Back Cars,” SAE 78-0267 1978
- Ahmed, S. R. “Influence of Base Slant on the Wake Structure and Drag of Road Vehicles,” Journal of Fluids Engineering 105 December 1983 429 434
- Cogotti, A. Buchheim, R. Garrone, A. Kuhn, A. “Comparison Tests Between Some Full Scale European Automotive Wind Tunnels- Pininfarina Reference Car,” SAE 80-0139 February 1980
- Schenkel, F. K. “The Origins of Drag and Lift Reductions on Automobiles With Front and Rear Spoilers,” SAE 77-0389 1977
- Katz, J. “Evaluation of Small-Scale Automotive Wind Tunnel Testings,” J. of Technology 21 1984
- Corsiglia, V. R. Katz, J. Kroeger, R. A “Full-Scale Study of the Effect of Nacelle Shape on Cooling Drag,” Journal of Aircraft 18 2 1981 82 88
- Katz, J. Corsiglia, V. R. Barlow, P. R. “Cooling Air Inlet and Exit Geometries on Aircraft Engine Installations,” Journal of Aircraft 19 7 1982 525 530
- Morelli, J. “Aerodynamic Basic Bodies Suitable for Automobile Applications,” International Journal of Vehicle Design Technological Advances in Vehicle Design Series, SP3, Impact of Aerodynamic on Vehicle Design 1983 70 98
- Katz, J. “Effect of External Geometry on Automobile Aerodynamic Drag,” E.E.C. Report No. 132 Technion, I.I.T. Haifa, Israel 1982