This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Simulation of Head/Neck Impact Responses for Helmeted and Unhelmeted Motorcyclists
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to assess, by use of computer simulations, the effectiveness of motorcycle helmets in reducing head and neck injuries in motorcyclist impacts. The computer model used was the MVMA Two-Dimensional Crash Victim Simulator. The study investigated a wide variety of impact conditions in order to establish a broad overall view of the effectiveness of helmets. It was found that helmet use invariably reduces dynamic responses which have a role in producing head injury and, in addition, almost always reduces the severity of neck response as well. For no configuration or condition does the helmet greatly increase the likelihood of neck injury. Thus, these simulations of a wide spectrum of motorcyclist impacts provide further evidence that helmet use significantly reduces the likelihood and severity of both head and neck injuries.
This study was supported by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Opinions, findings and conclusions expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.
MOTORCYCLE CRASH INVESTIGATION data show that the use of helmets results in substantially fewer head injuries and fatalities (1). Few would disagree that helmets reduce the likelihood and severity of sharp and blunt trauma to the head resulting from head impacts. The effects on neck response of the addition of the helmet weight to that of the head, however, are not well understood.
Many studies have indicated that the wearing of helmets does not increase the probability of sustaining neck injuries, but controversy on this point exists (2). It has been claimed that the mass of the helmet might cause increased loading of the neck structure during a crash event. Another view is simply that, apart from dynamic effects, if the head is protected, then greater energy must be absorbed by the neck. These views cannot be countered by epidemiological data at the present time because of both the difficulty in diagnosing neck injury in those cases where the cyclist survives and lack of well-defined neck autopsy protocol in those cases where the cyclist dies.
In the past few years, some opponents of mandatory helmet laws have used unsubstantiated claims of the adverse role of helmets in neck injury causation as partial justification for having the laws repealed. In a review article, Versace (2) stated that “while the evidence does not support the theory that the helmet is a causal factor in the incidence of neck injury, the state-of-the-art does not provide sufficient data at this time which would indicate that the helmet does not increase the incidence of neck injury.” It was the intended purpose of the study discussed by this paper to expand the state-of-the-art so that this question and others pertaining to helmet use can be answered *1
The research project described here had the following goals: 1) to address previously unanswered questions regarding neck response for helmeted and unhelmeted head impacts; 2) to model a range of cyclist impact situations accurately enough to provide useful quantitative measures of both head and neck responses; 3) to provide a basis for limited statements relating to helmet design; and finally, 4) to establish a broad overall view of the effectiveness of helmet use by investigating the potential of the helmet to both detrimentally and beneficially affect head and neck response.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Bowman, B., Schneider, L., Rohr, P., and Mohan, D., "Simulation of Head/Neck Impact Responses for Helmeted and Unhelmeted Motorcyclists," SAE Technical Paper 811029, 1981, https://doi.org/10.4271/811029.Also In
References
- Hurt Hugh H. Jr. “Motorcycle Accident Cause Factors and Identification of Countermeasures,” Preliminary Report to U.S. Department of Transportation National Highway Safety Administration, DOT HS-804-096 January 1980
- Versace S.V. “A Review of Conflicting Reports Concerning the Safety of Motorcycle Helmets.” Highway Safety Literature , HSL No. 77-6, 1977, U.S. Department of Transportation Washington, DC
- Bowman B.M. Bennett R.O. Robbins D.H. “MVMA Two-Dimensional Crash Victim Simulation, Version 3.” Final Report to Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association. UM-HSRI-Bl-74-1 3 Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan June 1974
- Bowman B.M. Robbins D.H. Bennett R.O. “MVMA 2-D Crash Victim Simulation: Tutorial System Self-Study Guide.” Final Report to Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association, UM-HSRI-77-18-1 Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan April 1977
- Bowman B.M. Bennett R.O. Robbins D.H. “MVMA Two-Dimensional Crash Victim Simulation, Version 4.” Final Report to Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association. UM-HSRI-79-5 3 Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan June 1979
- Schneider L.W. Bowman B.M. Snyder R.G. Peck L.S. “A Prediction of Response of the Head and Neck of the U.S. Adult Military Population to Dynamic Impact Acceleration from Selected Dynamic Test Subjects.” 12 Month Technical Report, NR-105-832, UM-HSRI-76-10 May 1976
- Alem N.M. Melvin J.W. Bowman B.M. Benson J.B. Whole Body Response Research Program . Sponsored by General Motors Research Laboratories Biomedical Science Department. Final Report, UM-HSRI-77-39-1 University of Michigan Highway Safety Research Institute April 1978
- Alem N.M. Bowman B.M. Melvin J.W. Benson J.B. “Whole-Body Human Surrogate Response to Three-Point Harness Restraint.” Proceedings of 22nd Stapp Car Crash Conference . Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA., SAE 780895 October 1978
- Snyder R.G. Foust D.R. Bowman B.M. “Study of Impact Tolerance Through Free-Fall Investigations.” Final Report to Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, UM-HSRI-77-8 Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan December 1977
- Foust D.R. Bowman B.M. Snyder R.G. “Study of Human Impact Tolerance Using Investigations and Simulations of Free Falls.” Proceedings of 21 st Stapp Car Crash Conference . Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA., SAE 770915 October 1977
- Mohan D. Bowman B.M. Snyder R.G. Foust D.R. “A Biomechanical Analysis of Head Impact Injuries to Children.” J. of Biomechanical Engineering 101 4 250 260 November 1979
- Bowman B.M. Schneider L.W. Simulation Analysis of Head/Neck Impact Response for Helmeted and Unhelmeted Motorcycliststs. Sponsored by Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Washington, D.C. Report No. UM-HSRI-80-26 Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan April 1980
- McElhaney J.H. Stalnaker R.L. Roberts V.L. “Biomechanical Aspects of Head Injury.” Human Impact Response , General Motors Research Laboratories Symposium October 1972 King W.F. Mertz H.J. Plenum Publishing Corporation New York 1973
- McElhaney J.H. Mate P.I. Roberts V.L. “A New Crash Test Device - ‘Repeatable Pete’” Proceedings of 7th Stapp Car Crash Conference . Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc New York SAE 730983 1973
- Messerer O. “Uber Elasticat and Festigkeit der Menschlichen Knochen.” Cotta J.G. Stuttgart 1880
- Lobdell T.E. Kroell C.K. Schneider D.C. Hering W.E. “Impact Response of the Human Thorax.” Human Impact Response , General Motors Research Laboratories Symposium October 1972 King W.F. Mertz H.J. Plenum Publishing Corporation New York 1973
- Mertz H.J. Patrick L.M. “Strength and Response of the Human Neck.” Proceedings of 15th Stapp Car Crash Conference . Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc Warrendale, PA SAE 710855, November 1971
- Ewing C.L. Thomas D.J. “Human Head and Neck Response to Impact Acceleration.” NAMRL Monograph 21, USAMRL 73-1 August 1972
- Kingsbury H.B. personal communication. Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering University of Delaware 1978
- Kingsbury H.B. Herrick W.C. Mohan D. “High and Low Rate Force-Deformation Characteristics of Motorcycle Helmets.” SAE Technical Paper Series, No. 790324. Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc Warrendale, PA February 1979
- Department of Transportation, NHTSA Docket No. 69-7; Notice 19, 37 FR 12393 Occupant Crash Protection Head Injury Criterion S6.2 of MVSS 208 June 1972