This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Gasohol: Technical, Economic, or Political Panacea?
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published August 01, 1980 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Gasohol, a blend of 90 percent unleaded gasoline and 10 percent ethanol, has been represented as an alternative to pure gasoline which can reduce the nation’s crude oil dependence. However, a systems analysis of the gasohol production processes indicates that gasohol is increasing rather than decreasing the nation’s dependence on crude oil. Alternative uses of the petroleum and natural gas currently used to manufacture ethanol would reduce the nation’s demand for oil. At the present time, every gallon of crude oil “saved” by substituting ethanol for gasoline results in a need to import approximately two gallons of crude oil.
The federal government’s claim that gasohol can reduce the nation’s dependence on imported energy appears, to be based principally on political considerations, but also on the assumption that coal will eventually replace the petroleum and natural gas currently used in the gasohol production wherever possible. However, if one considers using the coal that would otherwise be consumed in gasohol production to make methanol or synthetic gasoline and diesel fuel, then, gasohol will not reduce our dependence on imported energy but it will result in higher energy costs. Although many different government subsidies are causing the true cost of gasohol to be hidden from customers, the hidden costs are being paid indirectly by the nation’s taxpayers.
Because the effect of gasohol on automobiles is highly dependent on engine design and calibration, there is a wide variety of data on how gasohol alters vehicle performance. Older, richly calibrated cars can exhibit improved fuel economy and lower exhaust emissions due to the mixture enleanment caused by the blending of ethanol into gasoline. However, late model automobiles experience reduced fuel economy and mixed exhaust emissions impacts when gasohol is used. The principal environmental impact of gasohol is the substantially increased evaporative emissions which are experienced by most vehicles.
The authors advocate reevaluation of the government’s commitment to gasohol and increased governmental support for using the nonrenewable resources needed for gasohol production on the production of synthetic gasoline and diesel fuel, and methanol, all of which are projected to be less expensive and more energy efficient fuels.
CitationAustin, T. and Rubenstein, G., "Gasohol: Technical, Economic, or Political Panacea?," SAE Technical Paper 800891, 1980, https://doi.org/10.4271/800891.
- Bossong, K. “A History of Alcohol Fuels” The Energy Consumer U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Consumer Affairs January 1980
- “The Report of the Alcohol Fuels Policy Review” U.S. Department of Energy June 1979
- ADM Gasohol News Archer Daniels Midland Co. July 8 1980
- “Analysis of Gasohol Fleet Data to Characterize the Impact of Gasohol on Tailpipe and Evaporative Emissions” Mobile Source Enforcement Division, U.S. EPA December 1978
- “Marketing of Gasohol to Continue” Environmental News EPA December 16 1978
- “Diamond Shamrock Announces Plans to Expand Gasohol Sales” Amarillo Globe-Tribune June 5 1980
- “Report Says Gasohol Could be Standard Fuel by 2000” The Cedar Rapids Gazette June 22 1980
- “Gasohol Proves Popular in Area and Nationwide” The Washington Post June 6 1980
- “Alcohols: A Technical Assessment of Their Application as Fuels” American Petroleum Institute July 1976
- Abu-Isa, I. “Effects of Mixture of Gasoline with Methanol and with Ethanol on Automotive Elastomers” General Motors October 31 1979
- ADM Gasohol News Archer Daniels Midland Co. May 1980
- “Identification of Probable Automotive Fuels Composition: 1985–2000” SWRI International May 1978
- Scheller W. Mohr, B. “Net Energy Analysis of Ethanol Production” paper presented at the 171st National Meeting of the American Chemical Society, New York April 1976
- Reilly, P. “Economics and Energy Requirements for Ethanol Production” Department of Chemical and Nuclear Engineering January 1978
- “Energy Balance” ACR Process Corporation April 1978
- Jenkins, D. McClure T. Reddy, T. “Net Energy Analysis of Alcohol Fuels” Battelle Columbus Laboratories April 1979
- Chambers et al. “Gasohol” Science November 16 1979
- Kant, F. et a1. “Feasibility Study of Alternative Fuels for Automotive Transportation” Exxon Research and Engineering Company June 1974
- Cart, E.N. et al. “Alternative Energy Sources for Non-Highway Transportation” Exxon Research and Engineering Company June 1974
- “Alcohol Fueled Automobiles: Performance-Emissions-Environment” Mechanical Engineering Department, University of Santa Clara October 1979
- “Toyota’s Comments on CARB Proposed Regulations on Gasohol” March 26 1980
- “Purdue Evaluates Gasohol” Department of Mechanical Engineering Technology, Purdue University School of Technology May 1979
- “Gasohol Test Results” California Department of General Services December 27 1979
- Brinkman, N.D. Gallopoulos, N.E. Jackson, M.W. “Exhaust Emissions, Fuel Economy, and Driveability of Vehicles Fueled with Alcohol-Gasoline Blends” SAE Paper No. 750120 February 1975
- Furey R.L. King, J.B. “Evaporative and Exhaust Emissions from Cars Fueled with Gasoline Containing Ethanol or Methyl Tert-Butyl Ether” SAE Paper No. 800261 February 1980
- “Comparison of Emissions of Four 1980 Automobiles: Gasoline Versus Gasohol” Mobile Source Control Division, California Air Resources Board February 1980
- “Testing of Three Caltrans Gasohol Fueled Vehicles” Mobile Source Control Division, California Air Resources Board May 1980
- Lawrence Richard “Gasohol Test Program” Technology Assessment and Evaluation Branch, U.S. EPA December 1979
- “Testimony of M. Suematsu representing Nissan Motor Company, Ltd., before the California Air Resources Board” March 26 1980
- “Gasoline Vapor Recovery Rules” California Air Resources Board May 20 1976
- Perry R. Simeroth, Dean Engineering Evaluation Branch, California Air Resources Board
- “Procedure and Basis for Estimating On-Road Motor Vehicle Emissions” Technical Services Division, California Air Resources Board January 1980
- Holmes, J. Ph.D. Research Division, California Air Resources Board