This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Seat Belt Laws: Implications for Occupant Protection
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Laws requiring seat belt use have had some limited success in reducing occupant fatalities. However, fatality reductions have been considerably less than expected from the reported increases in belt use rates because belt use by those in crashes has not increased to the same extent. Occupants most likely to be in serious crashes are least likely to increase their use of belts in response to laws.
In addition, many involuntary belt users comply with belt use laws by wearing their belts incorrectly, in ways that greatly reduce their effectiveness, and many in front seats who wear belts in response to laws are susceptible to being impacted in crashes by unbelted rear seat occupants.
The incomplete success of belt use laws does not reduce their importance as a countermeasure, but does reinforce the importance of providing automatic (“passive”) protection to vehicle occupants as an alternative or supplementary countermeasure.
Authors
Topic
Citation
Williams, A. and O'Neill, B., "Seat Belt Laws: Implications for Occupant Protection," SAE Technical Paper 790683, 1979, https://doi.org/10.4271/790683.Also In
References
- Robertson L. S. “Automobile Seat Belt Use in Selected Countries, States and Provinces with and without Laws Requiring Belt Use.” Accid Anal & Prev 10 5 10 1978
- Livingston C. F. et al. “Task Force Report on Safety Belt Usage Laws National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, U.S. DOT June 1977 June 1978
- Ziegler P. N. “The Effect of Safety Belt Usage Laws Around the World,” J Safety Research 9 97 99 1977
- Nilsson L. “Swedish Government and Industry Studies of Belt Usage Law Effectiveness,” Saab-Scania, Sweden 1976
- Swedish National Central Bureau of Statistics, Stockholm 1978
- Nordentoft E. L. Kruse T. Nielsen H. V. Weeth R. “The Effect of Mandatory Seat Belt Legislation on Mortality and Morbidity in Denmark,” Proceedings of the American Association for Automotive Medicine 22nd Conference and the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine VII Conference Ann Arbor, Michigan 1978 181 191
- Royal Australasian College of Surgeons Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 1977
- Chodkiewicz J. P. Dubarry B. “Effects of Mandatory Seat Belt Legislation in France,” Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 1977 40 44
- Foldvary L. C. Lane J. C. “The Effectiveness of Compulsory Wearing of Seat Belts in Casualty Reduction,” Accid Anal & Prev 6 59 81 1974
- Robertson L. S. “Estimates of Motor Vehicle Seat Belt Effectiveness and Use: Implications for Occupant Crash Protection.” Am J Public Health 66 859 864 1976
- Boughton C. J. Present Situation of Australian Legislation covering Child Restraints. Paper presented at Royal Australasian College of Surgeons Seminar “Restraining the Child in a Car,” Melbourne, Australia 1978
- Boughton C. J. “Occupant Restraints in Motor Vehicles -- the Present Situation” Commonwealth Dept of Transport Melbourne, Australia 1978
- Opinion Research Corporation “Safety Belt Usage: Survey of Cars in the Traffic Population (November 1977-June 1978).” National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, U.S. DOT December 1978
- Robertson L. S. “The Seat Belt Use Law in Ontario: Effects on Actual Use,” Canadian J Public Health 69 154 157 1978
- Bliersbach G. Delten R. G. “Psychological Problems of Restraint Systems Such as Seat Belts and Air Bags in West Germany,” Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 1977 504 511
- Robertson L. S. Williams A. F. “Some International Comparisons of the Effects of Motor Vehicle Seat Belt Use and Child Restraint Laws,” Proceedings of Child Passenger Safety Conference, Transportation Center U. of Tennessee, Nashville 1978
- Hurst P. M. “Compulsory Seatbelt Use: Further Inferences.” Accid Anal & Prev 11 27 33 1979
- Dalgaard J. B. “Experiences With the New Seat-Belt Law on Fatal Lesions of Car Occupants in Denmark.” Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 56 69
- Voas R. B. “Future Directions for Vehicle Occupant Protection: Complex Problems Require Multifaceted, Systematic Solutions.” Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 529 533
- Andreassend D. C. “The Effects of Compulsory Seat Belt Wearing Legislation in Victoria,” In National Road Safety Symposium Canberra, Australia 1972
- Toomath J. B. “Compulsory Seat Belt Legislation in New Zealand,” Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 1977 21 39
- American Seat Belt Council “Seat Belt Use Abroad,” Washington, D. C. June 1978
- Bohlin N. “Fifteen Years with the Three-Point Safety Belt,” Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 1977 142 159
- Holt B. W. Vazey B. A. “In depth Study of Seriously Injured Seat Belt Wearers,” Traffic Accident Research Unit Dept. of Motor Transport New South Wales, Australia June 1977
- MacKay G. M. Gloyns P. F. Hayes H. R. M. Griffiths D. K. Rattenbury S. J. “Serious Trauma to Car Occupants Wearing Seat Belts,” Proceedings of 2nd International Conference Biomechanics of Serious Trauma Birmingham, England September 1975 20 29
- Robertson L. S. Kelley A. B. O'Neill B. Wixom C. W. Haddon, W. Jr. Eiswirth R. E. “A Controlled Study of the Effect of Television Messages on Safety Belt Use.” American J. Public Health 64 1071 1080 1974
- Kelley B. Robertson L. S. Statement Before the Subcommittee on Investigations and Review, House Committee on Public Works and Transportation, Hearings on Safety Belt Usage Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Washington, D.C. June 7 1978
- Williams A. F. “Restraint Use Legislation: Its Prospects for Increasing the Protection of Children in Cars,” Accid Anal & Prev, in press
- Williams A. F. “Evaluation of the Tennessee Child Restraint Law.” Am J Public Health 69 455 458 1979
- Haddon, W. Jr. “Research with Respect to Fatal Accident Causes: Implications for Vehicle Design.” SAE Paper 366A 1961 Highway Vehicle Safety SAE Papers 1961-1967 NY 1968 1 7
- Haddon, W. Jr. Goddard J. L. “An Analysis of Highway Safety Strategies.” Passenger Car Design and Highway Safety Association for the Aid of Crippled Children and Consumers Union of the U.S. New York 1962
- Haddon, W. Jr. “Strategies in Preventive Medicine: Passive vs. Active Approaches to Reducing Human Wastage” J Trauma 4 14 1974
- Haddon, W. Jr. Baker S. P. “Injury Control” Preventive Medicine Second Clark D. W. MacMahon Little Brown and Co. 1979
- Henderson J. M. Vazey B. A. Herbert D. C. Stott J. D. “The Effect of Seat Belt Design and Anchorage Geometry on Injury Patterns.” Proceedings of Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 1977 407 422
- MacKay G. M. “Belted Occupants in Frontal Crashes.” Proceedings of Sixth International Conference of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine Melbourne, Australia 1977 351 358
- Reidelbach W. Scholz H. “Advanced restraint system concepts.” SAE Paper 790321 Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pa. 1979