This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Motorcyclists' Visual Scanning Pattern in Comparison with Automobile Drivers'
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1979 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Motorcyclists' visual behavior was examined and compared with that of drivers' by an eye-marker method. The background of this research is as follows. From the accident statistics of Osaka prefecture, characteristics of motorcycle accidents and those of ordinary passenger cars were analysed and compared and it was revealed that collisions on turning right (in the United States, collisions on turning left) are most remarkable. In this case, collisions between motorcycles running straight ahead and automobiles turning right are most typical. The automobile drivers expected that the motorcyclists would give way. But, almost without braking, the motorcycles crashed into the automobiles turning right. Here, one of the problems is motorcyclists' unawareness of existence of automobiles turning right. We focused upon this.
Three males participated as subjects in these experiments with an eye-marker. Independent variables were type of vehicel and speed. The results are as follows. (1) The proportion of the road surface which was recorded on film through an eye-marker is much larger in riding motorcycles than in driving an automobile. Motorcyclists' head is tilted forward. It follows that they are apt to be looking at the closer road surface more frequently. (2) From the result of distribution of fixation points, it is suggested that motorcyclists are mainly acquiring information from the closer road surface, whereas, automobile drivers are mainly acquiring information from distant foreground. (3) In riding motorcycles, the vertical variance of visual field and fixation points is larger. This suggests that motorcyclists are trying to acquire information from both the closer road surface and the distant foreground. (4) Mean fixation duration of motorcyclists is shorter than that of automobile drivers. This suggests that they are acquiring and identifying information relatively superficially.
These findings would throw light on motorcyclists' failure to detect vehicles turning right, oncoming vehicles, crossing vehicles and pedestrians. We stress that education for road users should involve these findings and that more appropriate road conditions for stable riding should be realized.
|Technical Paper||Comparison of Eye Fixations of Operators of Motorcycles and Automobiles|
|Technical Paper||Motor Cycle Braking Methods|
|Technical Paper||Characteristics of Motorcycle Traffic Accidents in Japan|
CitationNagayama, Y., Morita, T., Miura, T., Watanabem, J. et al., "Motorcyclists' Visual Scanning Pattern in Comparison with Automobile Drivers'," SAE Technical Paper 790262, 1979, https://doi.org/10.4271/790262.
- Mourant R.R. Rockwell T.H. “Strategies of Visual Search by Novice and Experienced Drivers.” Human Factors 14 325 335 1972
- Kaluger N.A. Smith G.L. Jr. “Driver Eye-Movement Patterns under Conditions of Prolonged Driving and Sleep Deprivation.” Highway Research Record 336 92 106 1970
- Cohen A.S. 22 68 76 1976
- Mourant R.R. Rockwell T.H. Rackoff N.J. “Drivers' Eye-Movements and Visual Work Load.” Highway Research Record 292 1 10 1969
- Mourant R.R. Rockwell T.H. “Mapping Eye-Movement Patterns to the Visual Scene in Driving: An Exploratory Study.” Human Factors 12 81 87 1970
- Thomas E.L. “Movements of the Eye.” Scientific American 219 88 95 1968
- Murata T. Nakamura Y. “Fixation Points of Drivers.” Traffic Engineering 5 3 12 1970