This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Adverse Effects of Seat Belts and Causes of Belt Failures in Severe Car Accidents in Switzerland During 1976
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Results of a one year field study initiated by the Swiss Federal Police Department in connection with a mandatory seat belt law effective January 1, 1976 are presented. 304 accidents with 153 killed and 257 severely injured (OAIS ≧ 2) belted occupants were analysed during this program. As belt effectiveness has previously been demonstrated in field investigations the following specific problems are discussed:
- Frequency and statistical significance of cases in which, with a high degree of probability, the belt had an adverse effect
- Relevant injury patterns
- Frequency and causes of belt failures including releasing difficulties after a crash
- Possible improvements.
Furthermore, the applicability of Calspan's SMAC method is demonstrated and discussed. In case of car to car collisions the mass ratio is shown to be of importance. A correlation analysis between the velocity change during the collision phase (Δv) and the injury severity is performed. Special attention is given to frontal crashes with no or minimal passenger compartment intrusion. Severe injuries in such cases can usually be attributed to one or more of the following reasons: submarining, excessive slack, inadequate mechanical compatibility between belt system compliance and mechanical properties of the chest (e.g., old age), overloading due to backseat passenger.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Niederer, P., Walz, F., and Zollinger, U., "Adverse Effects of Seat Belts and Causes of Belt Failures in Severe Car Accidents in Switzerland During 1976," SAE Technical Paper 770916, 1977, https://doi.org/10.4271/770916.Also In
References
- Scott R.E. Flora J.D. Marsh J.C. “An Evaluation of the 1974 and 1975 Restraint Systems” Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan 1976
- Huelke D.F. “The Effectiveness of Belt Systems in Frontal and Rollover Crashes.” SAE Paper No. 770148 1977
- Langwieder K. 1975
- Walz F. “Der Einfluss von Sitzgurten und Kopfstützen auf die Verletzungen von Autoinsassen.” University of Zurich 1972
- Bohlin N. “A Statistical Analysis of 28'000 Accident Cases with Emphasis on Occupant Restraint Value.” SAE Paper No. 670925 , Proc. of the 11th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 1967
- Petty P.G. “The Influence of Seat Belt Wearing on the Incidence of Severe Head Injury.” Proc. of the 6th IAATM Conf. Melbourne 1977
- Sabey B.E. “Alleviation of Injuries by Use of Seat Belts.” Proc. of the 6th IAATM Conf. Melbourne 1977
- Mackay G.M. “Belted Occupants in Frontal Crashes.” Proc. of the 6th IAATM Conf. Melbourne 1977
- Kahane C.J. “Usage and Effectiveness of Seat and Shoulder Belts in Rural Pennsylvania Accidents.” NHTSA Technical Note N43-31-5 1974
- Bern 1976
- McHenry R. “Computer Aids for Accident Investigation.” SAE SP-412 85 96 1976
- The Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) Joint Committee of AMA, SAE, AAAM 1976
- Robertson L.S. “Estimates of Motor Vehicle Seat Belt Effectiveness and Use: Implication for Occupant Crash Protection.” AJPH 66 859 1976
- Walz F. Niederer P. Zollinger U. Renfer A. “Belted Passengers in Lateral and Oblique Collision.” Proc. of the IIId. IRCOBI Berlin 1977
- Niederer P. Walz F. “Reconstruction and Analysis of Lateral Collisions.” Proc. of the IIId. IRCOBI Berlin 1977
- Walz F. Zollinger U. Renfer A. Wegmann R. Meier M. Niederer P. Rudin H. Bern 1977
- Walz F. Niederer P. Zollinger U. Renfer A. “Analysis of 115 Killed and 205 Severely Injured Seat Belt Users.” Proc. of the 6th IAATM Conf. Melbourne 1977
- Vazey B.A. Holt B.W. “In Depth Analysis of Fatalities to Wearers of Seat Belts.” Dept. of Motor Trsp. N.S.W. Australia
- Baker S.P. et al. “The Injury Severity Score: Development and Potential Usefulness.” AAAM Proceedings 59 74 1974
- Armitage P. “Statistical Methods in Medical Research.” Blaisdell Scientific Publications London 1974
- Collision Deformation Classification SAE Technical Report J224a 1972
- Appel H. 1973
- Kossar “Compatibility Between Big and Little Cars.” SAE Paper No. 750114 1975
- Grime G. Hutchinson T.P. “Two Vehicle Collisions: The Influence of Mass Ratio on the Risk of Injuries to Drivers.” University College London 1976
- Cameron M.H. Nelson P.G. “Injury Pattern With and Without Seat Belts.” Proc. of the 6th IAATM Conf. Melbourne 1977
- Christian M.S. “Non Fatal Injuries Sustained by Seat Belt Wearers: A Comparative Study.” Brit. Med. J. 1310 November 1976
- Huelke D.F. “The Hazard of the Unrestrained Occupant.” J. of Trauma 16 383 1976
- Patrick L.M. Bohlin N.I. Anderson A. “3 Points Harness Accident and Laboratory Data Comparison.” SAE Paper No. 741181 , Proc. of the 18th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 1974
- Walz F. Beiheft
- Hamburg 1975
- Niederer P. 61 1977
- Niederer P. Walz F. “Stability Considerations in the Mathematical Reconstruction of Traffic Accidents.” SAE Paper No. 760775 1976
- Beier G. et al. München 1975
- Lehmann E.L. “Non Parametrics: Statistical Methods Based on Ranks.” McGraw-Hill 1973