This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Study of Human Impact Tolerance Using Investigations and Simulations of Free-Falls
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1977 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A study of free-fall accidents and resulting injuries was conducted to determine how useful these types of data could be in establishing human injury tolerance limits. “Tolerance” was examined primarily for children at two levels - reversible injury and threat to survival. The specific objectives were to investigate specific free-falls in sufficient depth to permit biomedical or mathematical reconstruction of the fall, simulate selected free-falls to estimate impact response, and compare predicted responses with observed injuries as a means of estimating human tolerance levels. From more than 2100 reported free-falls, 110 were investigated on-site. Seven head-first and three feet-first falls were then simulated using the MVMA 2-D Crash Victim Simulator. Newspaper reports of free-falls showed that males fell six times as often as females and most often while at work. Children fell from windows and balconies more often than from any other hazard. Case investigations showed that children were generally injured less severely than adults under similar fall circumstances, and tended to land on their heads a greater proportion of the time. The investigations also indicated that for impacts onto rigid surfaces: Both children and adults may be expected to suffer skull fractures in head-first falls of greater than 10 ft; adults are likely to incur lumbar spine fracture if they land in a sitting position after falling 10 ft; and adults will probably sustain pelvic fracture in feet-first falls of more than 30 ft. The head-first fall simulations predicted skull acceleration responses that were higher than previously considered survivable, although five of the six child subjects whose falls were simulated did survive. Analysis of simulation results indicated that, for some children under eight years old, peak accelerations of as high as 350 G, with a rate of onset of up to 200 000 G/s and a duration of up to 3 ms (approximate HIC = 1700-2800), would produce only moderate, reversible injury (as defined by AIS 2). For this same age group, the survival limit for head impacts - the level at which most people would sustain AIS 5 or greater injuries - was estimated to be as high as 600 G peak acceleration and 300 000 G/s for a duration of up to 3 ms (approximate HIC = up to 11 000). In feet-first simulations, the model predicted forces in the leg bones that correlated with observed injuries. The combination of in-depth on-site investigation and computer simulation of representative cases was found to be an effective method of studying impact injury tolerance.
This research was sponsored by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Washington, D.C.
CitationFoust, D., Bowman, B., and Snyder, R., "Study of Human Impact Tolerance Using Investigations and Simulations of Free-Falls," SAE Technical Paper 770915, 1977, https://doi.org/10.4271/770915.
- National Safety Council, “Accident Facts, 1976 Edition,” Chicago, 1976, pp.54, 57, 61, 84.
- “Abbreviated Injury Scale, 1976 Revision.” Prepared by Joint Committee for Injury Scaling (American Medical Association, Society of Automotive Engineers, American Association for Automotive Medicine); Morton Grove, Illinois: American Association for Automotive Medicine, 1976.
- DeHaven H., “Mechanical Analysis of Survival of Falls, from Heights of Fifty to One Hundred and Fifty Feet.” War Med. Vol.2, 1942.
- Snyder R. G., “Human Tolerances to Extreme Impacts in Free-Fall.” Aerospace Med. Vol.34(8), 1963.
- Snyder R. G., “Man's Survivability of Extreme Forces in Free-Fall Impact” AGARD Conference Proceedings No. 88 on Linear Acceleration of Impact Type, North Atlantic Treaty Organization, Publication AGARD-CP-88-71, 1971.
- Snyder R. G., “Human Tolerance Limits in Water Impact.” Aerospace Med, Vol.36(10), 1965.
- Snyder R. G., and Snow C. C., “Fatal Injuries Resulting from Extreme Water Impact.” Aerospace Med, Vol.38(8), 1967.
- Snyder R. G., “Terminal Velocity Impacts into Snow.” Military Med, Vol. 131 (10), 1966.
- El-Assal G., “A Study on Falling from Heights.” Alexandria Med J, Vol.IX(10) 1963.
- Grech P., “Falls from Coconut Trees.” East African Med J, Vol. 41(2), 1964.
- Lewis W. S., Lee A. B.Jr., and Granthan A. A., “Jumpers Syndrome: The Trauma of High Free-Fall as Seen at Harlem Hospital.” J. of Trauma, Vol. 5(6), 1965.
- Lane J. C., Penfold M. F., Laing J., Bailey J. B., and Tonge J. I., “Human Tolerance to Abrupt Deceleration in Water: An Analysis of Free Falls from Two Bridges.” Proceedings, International Conference on the Bio-kinetics of Impacts, Amsterdam, June 1973.
- Snyder R. G., “Impact Injury Tolerances of Infants and Children in Free-Fall.” Proceedings, American Association of Automotive Medicine, The University of Minnesota. Published by Highway Safety Research Institute, The University of Michigan, May 1970.
- Smith M. D., “Injuries in Children Sustained in Free-Falls: An Analysis of 66 Cases.” Trauma, 15(11), 1975.
- Robbins D. H., Bowman B. M., and Bennett R. O., “The MVMA Two-Dimensional Crash Victim Simulation.” SAE 741195, Proceedings, 18th Stapp Car Crash Conference, Warrendale, Pa: Society of Automotive Engineers, 1974.
- Bowman B. M., Bennett R. O., and Robbins D. H., “MVMA Two-Dimensional Crash Victim Simulation, Version 3.” Final Report to Motor Vehicle Manufacturer's Association, UM-HSRI-BI-74-1, 3 Volumes, Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan, June 1974.
- Bowman B. M., Robbins D. H., and Bennett R. O., “MVMA Two-Dimensional Crash Victim Simulator: Self-Study Guide.” UM-HSRI-77-18-1, Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan, April 1977.
- McElhaney J. H., Mate P. I., and Roberts V. L., “A New Crash Test Device-- ‘Repeatable Pete’.” SAE 730983, Proceedings, Seventeenth Stapp Car Crash Conference, New York: Society of Automotive Engineers, 1973.
- Snyder R. G., Foust D. R., and Bowman B. M., “Study of Impact Tolerance Through Free-Fall Investigations.” Final Report to Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, UM-HSRI-77-8, Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan, August 1977.
- Baker S. P., O'Neill B., Haddon W. Jr., and Long W. B., “Injury Severity Score: A Method for Describing Patients with Multiple Injuries and Evaluating Emergency Care.” J of Trauma, Vol.14, 1974.
- Baker S. P. and O'Neill B., “The Injury Severity Score: An Update.” J of Trauma, Vol.16, 1976.
- Snyder R. G., “State-of-the-Art: Human Impact Tolerance.” SAE 700398, International Automotive Safety Conference Compendium, New York: Society of Automotive Engineers, May 1970.
- Snyder R. G., “Impact.” Chapter 6 in Bioastronautics Data Book, Second Edition (Parker J. F. Jr., and West V. R., eds), Washington, D. C.: National Aeronautics and Space Administration NASA SP-3006, 1973.
- Roth E. M., “Impact.” Compendium of Human Responses to the Aerospace Environment, Vol.11, Section 7, NASA CR-1205 (II), 1967.
- Department U.S. of Transportation “Occupant Crash Protection Head Injury Criterion.” DOT 49 CFR, Part 571, Docket No. 69-7, Notice 17, 1969.
- Fayon A., Tarrière C., Walfisch G., Got C., and Patel A., “Contribution to Defining a Tolerance Level for a Laterally Impacted Human Head.” Laboratory of Physiology and Biomechanics, Association Peugeot-Renault (France), 1976.
- Melvin J. W., and Stalnaker R. L., “Tolerance and Response of the Knee-FemurPelvis Complex to Axial Impact.” Final Report to Motor Vehicle Mfgrs. Assn., UM-HSRI-76-33, Highway Safety Research Institute, The University of Michigan, October 1976.